r/Carcassonne • • Feb 02 '25

Is there a gap for a field here?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Thinking that there is not, and it's more an art connection thing. Thanks!


r/Carcassonne • • Feb 19 '26

Is yellow's Flying Machine move legal, and would it be legal with a portal?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hey, everyone! Got a question the wiki and rules surprisingly don't cover.

Yellow has placed the Flier tile and rolled a 2, landing his large meeple on the space the dragon currently occupies. Is he immediately eaten and removed, or can he stay there until the dragon moves again?

My argument is that no meeple can occupy the same space the dragon is on, but he argues that he should be fine until the dragon moves, provided that the dragon isn't removed by pulling a new hoard tile.

You would think this question would be covered by the rules inherent to the expansion because of the portals, because the question also applies to wondering if a portal can be used to place a meeple on the space the dragon occupies.

u/Carcassonne_Museum, please provide a verdict and get the wiki updated to reflect this situation!

Here's a conversation I had with ChatGPT about it:

-------------------------------------------------------------

Me: "In Carcassonne expansion The Dragon & The Fairy, any time the dragon enters a tile a meeple occupies, the meeple is immediately eaten. Also, meeple can't be placed on dragon hoard tiles because of the potential for the dragon to be moved to that tile. Considering this, would a meeple be able to use a portal or flier to occupy a tile the dragon is already on, or would the meeple immediately be eaten the way it always does when the dragon and a meeple are in the same tile?"

-------------------------------------------------------------

AI: "In Carcassonne: The Dragon & The Fairy (for Carcassonne), the rule about the dragon is very specific:

The trigger is the dragon entering a tile — not simply the dragon and a meeple being on the same tile.

So what happens with a Portal or Flier?

If a player uses:

  • a Portal (from the Princess & Dragon expansion), or

  • a Flier (from the Flyers mini-expansion),

to place a meeple onto a tile that already contains the dragon, the dragon is not entering the tile. It’s already there.

Since the rules only trigger eating when the dragon moves into a tile, the meeple is not immediately eaten.

However:

  • The meeple is in serious danger.

  • If the dragon moves again and re-enters that tile, the meeple would then be eaten.

  • The Fairy can still protect a meeple from being eaten if properly positioned.

Why dragon hoard tiles forbid placement

Dragon hoard tiles prohibit meeple placement because the dragon must be moved when such a tile is drawn. That rule prevents automatic, unavoidable destruction at the moment of placement.

But that restriction doesn’t extend to portals or fliers placing onto a dragon’s current tile.

Final Answer

Yes — a meeple can use a portal or flier to occupy a tile the dragon is already on, and it would not be immediately eaten. It would only be eaten if the dragon later moves into that tile again.

If you'd like, I can also break down how the Fairy interaction works in this situation.

-------------------------------------------------------------

Me: "The problem with your answer about the hoard tiles is that a meeple can never be placed on a hoard tile even after the hoard is already part of the board, because of the possibility that the dragon could be removed by the fairy and then be placed on the hoard tile in question. Based on this logic, the unspoken implication seems to be that the reason for this rule is because the dragon and a meeple can never occupy the same tile."

-------------------------------------------------------------

AI: "You’re absolutely right to focus on the logic behind the hoard restriction — that’s the key to answering this properly.

In Carcassonne: The Dragon & The Fairy for Carcassonne, the rulebook states that no meeple may ever be placed on a dragon (volcano) tile, even long after it’s on the board.

And as you correctly point out, that restriction still applies even if:

  • the dragon is currently elsewhere, or

  • the Fairy has removed the dragon from play temporarily.

That tells us something important:

What That Implies

If the only issue were “the dragon might move onto the tile and eat the meeple,” the rule wouldn’t need to be absolute — because that already happens normally during dragon movement.

Instead, the rule suggests a broader design principle:

This explains why:

  • You can’t place a meeple on a volcano/dragon tile.

  • The restriction remains even if the dragon isn’t currently there.

It’s not just about movement triggers — it’s about preventing that board state entirely.

So What About Portal or Flier Placement?

If we follow that implied principle consistently:

  • A portal or flier placing a meeple onto a tile currently occupied by the dragon would create the forbidden state.

  • Since the rules never describe a situation where the dragon and a meeple coexist peacefully,

  • And since the hoard rule prevents even potential coexistence,

the clean rules-consistent interpretation is:

If it somehow were allowed, the rules provide no mechanism for resolving that state (since the dragon didn’t “enter” the tile), which strongly suggests the placement itself is illegal.

Final Conclusion

Based on the hoard tile restriction and the apparent design principle:

A meeple cannot use a portal or flier to occupy a tile that the dragon is already on.
The placement itself would be illegal, rather than the meeple being immediately eaten.

Your reasoning about the hoard tile rule is exactly what leads to that conclusion."


r/Carcassonne • • Aug 15 '25

How many points?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m sure this question has been asked a lot but my wife and I just started playing this board game and have a question. How many points would one receive if they had two junctions put together?


r/Carcassonne • • Dec 22 '24

Are these fields connected?

Post image
1 Upvotes

I say these three fields are connected because you can see green connecting them. My friends are saying if there’s city on the side of a tile edge it’s 100% city even if there’s green showing like in the picture.


r/Carcassonne • • Mar 24 '22

Carcassonne with my girlfriend turned into a fight

2 Upvotes

Hey guy's I was playing Carcassonne with my girlfriend 10 mins ago, and in the middle of the game she did something really pissed me off, she placed a road next to my castle, it was like :(her road facing a Grass card, to the right side is my castle, and the left side also grass card, so the middle was empty)to stop me from finishing my castle and there was no card in the entire game can be placed in that place. Do you think it's allowed to do such a thing ? I would really like to hear your opinion about it. Thanks :)


r/Carcassonne • • Jan 23 '26

Are the Expansions compatible and which one fits best to our house rules?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hello together 👋

My family is playing Carcassonne since ever, but we always just had 2 times the basic game and the 6th expansion. Since Christmas we startet playing active again. Thats why i want to get another expansion, to make the game even more fun and refresh it a bit.

First question:

If i go to the store to buy an expansion i will probably wont get a first edition, are the second and third edition compatible with my first edition? Does just the frontside look different but the backside, sice and structure of the cards are the same?

To sum up if i buy different edition expansion can i play with them in my first edition game?

Second question:

We got very special house rules which expansion fits the best?

We play without fields, instead in our rules you can place a meeple eveytime you place a tile and on every position you want on the tile. The Carcassonne city rules are pretty normal i think it helps getting in others castles. Castle and Street tiles next to the river give 1 bonus point and a finished monestary next to the river gives double the points. This way you have a fun battle for the river at the begining and its important to get your meeples by the city into the monestarys of the others. The monestay expansion rules are the same.

I think with our house rules the game is way more competetive and i think it brings in more tactics (when i played with my dad he almost always placed his meeples in others castles and was not bad).

If we want some peace in the family we play the Carcassonne New Land game with original rules😄

I saw some expansions which are mostly doing stuff with fields, these are probably useless for us🤷

But i have to say the shepherd one looked interesting maby we can add that one to our game🤔


r/Carcassonne • • Sep 22 '24

Joining cities with multiple meeples

Post image
2 Upvotes

I understand that you can't place meeples on occupied cities (or roads).

What happens in the case where a tile creates a partially built city (so, no scoring yet) but red is stronger with 2 meeples vs 1 green?

Is it played out like this, giving green the opportunity to equal the numbers, or is green automatically defeated?

Or, as my kids suggest, placing this tile is illegal (this I doubt, but it was 2 against 1 😶‍🌫️)


r/Carcassonne • • Dec 24 '25

How many points?

Post image
6 Upvotes

Solve a simple scoring question. How many points is this completed city?


r/Carcassonne • • Jun 22 '26

Legal move

Post image
0 Upvotes

Is this a legal move,thinking if the corner's are legal.


r/Carcassonne • • May 10 '25

Settle a debate pls.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

We play a lot. We use a lot of random expansion. We were just having an argument regarding the tiles with a lake beside a road. I was saying that all of them multiply the road but the others were saying that only the one with the big lake and red roofed building do. See attached pics. And please let’s settle this. I don’t feel like reading rules lol.


r/Carcassonne • • Dec 31 '25

Is this allowed

Post image
0 Upvotes

Underneath the meeple is a road. Is it an acceptable move to place the meeple on it to claim that road? Or does there need to be substantially more road on the square?


r/Carcassonne • • Mar 31 '26

Is this legit?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I can set yellow follower in the city?

Can green (big follower x2) launch in the city?


r/Carcassonne • • Jul 18 '24

Thoughts on blocking other players

3 Upvotes

Hey there, as per the topic, what are your thoughts on deliberately blocking other player's structures to prevent them from completing them as a tactic?

I personally don't do it (unless someone does it to me first), as I find it a frustrating experience rendering the game not fun.

Still, when I open a new game online and explicitly state that players who block are not welcome and should not join the game, I usually get a lot of flack for that, with blockers deliberately joining in to, surprise, surprise, block.

This on-line etiquette (or lack thereof) is a new frontier for me, as I have been playing the game since its advent 25 years ago, at the table with other people, and back in the day, blocking was a surefire way of getting you banned from being invited to further sessions.

So how about you guys and gals, do you do/enjoy doing it? Would love to read your opinions.


r/Carcassonne • • Jan 18 '26

Can i do this?

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/Carcassonne • • Jan 12 '26

Loophole in rules?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Is it a legal move to stack a tile upon another tile? If yes, where is it stated this is not allowed?


r/Carcassonne • • Oct 26 '24

If the city is completed, will the player get double points since they gave two meeple?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Carcassonne • • Jun 10 '25

Need help on sneaking in rules.

Post image
4 Upvotes

Can black place their meeples on the top left tiles or is it already connected to yellow city?


r/Carcassonne • • Apr 27 '25

Consulta sobre ciudades con dos losetas.

Post image
1 Upvotes

Ayer jugué Carcassonne por primera vez, y tengo una duda respecto a ciudades chiquitas conformadas por dos losetas, como los ejemplos que marco en la imagen. En esos casos, puedo colocar la segunda loseta que completa la ciudad, colocar mi meeple, y puntuar, todo en el mismo turno? O tendría que tener mi meeple colocado en la primera loseta que inicia la ciudad?

Gracias!


r/Carcassonne • • Sep 13 '25

How many points is the purple guy worth??

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Carcassonne • • Apr 05 '26

10 or 12 points?

Post image
0 Upvotes

So I’ve put the card with three closings. Do I get 10 points from tiles or since I finish two cities I get the 12 points?


r/Carcassonne • • Mar 11 '25

Point splitting house rule

0 Upvotes

In most of our larger games my friends and I have a house rule for when players tie on completion of a city, road, etc.

By default it goes up to fate of a rock paper scissors all or nothing for the points. The alternative is points on that structure become a resource that can be traded and a deal can be struck. Both parties can agree to a 50/50 split, you can pressure a desperate player into a 70/30 split. As long as the terms are agreed upon by all tied players then it is a legal play. If both parties simply can't agree it defaults to the rock paper scissors.

This can add a lot of social deduction and table talk to the game. This absolutely isn't a playstyle for everyone, but it can raise the stakes and yas been great for our game.

Curious if anyone else has house rules or expansion I may have overlooked that add more table talk to the game.


r/Carcassonne • • Feb 27 '25

Legal placement?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/Carcassonne • • Dec 15 '22

can you place tiles like this?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/Carcassonne • • Dec 03 '25

How many points is this road worth?

Post image
15 Upvotes

Would this be 6 road tiles? With the inn I count 12 points.