r/Canning • • May 26 '26

Announcement Why We Don't Recommend Electric Canners (Mod Post)

316 Upvotes
  1. Electric pressure canners have not been verified safely by third party testing. What has been performed is only, “We are safe because we say we are safe,” type testing. The manufacturers claim to match USDA specs but no one has verified that information externally and the manufacturers will not release their results to anyone externally. The USDA symbol used in some promotional materials is not an actual USDA seal and does not indicate USDA approval. The equipment that's been used in the past by the USDA and NCHFP to determine the thermal profile inside canners doesn't even fit inside existing electric canners on the market. A new design would be needed, and currently there is no funding for developing this equipment.

  2. The users of electric pressure canners do not have the physical signs of the device coming to pressure (like a jiggling weight or a rising analog dial to ensure that the food is processing at the correct pressure.) The user must rely on an electronic display for accuracy. Even if a type of electric canner has an analog feature, there is no way of getting the electric canner device tested or calibrated to ensure it is accurate or working correctly. (We should mention that electric WATER BATH canners are fine to use because the user can physically see the water coming to a boil.)

  3. Perhaps most importantly, all current approved pressure canning recipes rely on the heat up and cool down times relative to stove top pressure canners loaded with a minimum of two quarts of product. These heat up and cool down times are factored into the safety of all current safe recipes. Changing and/or reducing these times can affect the safety of your finished product.

Until ALL THREE of these reasons can be appropriately addressed, we as a sub do not endorse or condone the use of electric pressure canners.


r/Canning • • Oct 19 '25

Announcement Why don't we recommend pH testing for home canning? [Mod Post]

72 Upvotes

Hello Everyone!

As a mod team we've noticed a lot of questions and confusion about pH testing home canned foods recently so we're here today to give a more in depth explanation of why it's not recommended.

As I'm sure you all know, there are tons and tons of misconceptions about home canning and what we can and cannot do safely. One of the most common misconceptions is that if we pH test a food and it shows a pH below 4.6 it can be canned as a high acid food. There are two reasons why this isn't true.

  1. pH is not the only safety factor for home canning

  2. The options for pH testing at home are not necessarily the same as what's available in a lab setting.

Although pH is an important factor in home canning safely it is not the only factor. Characteristics like heat penetration, density, and homogeneity also play a role.

There are two types of pH test equipment; pH test strips and pH meters. pH test strips are not very accurate most of the time, they're just strips of paper with a chemical that changes color based on pH imbued in it. These strips expire over time and the color change is the only indicator which makes reading them rather subjective and likely inaccurate.

There are two levels of pH meters; home pH meters and laboratory grade pH meters. Home pH meters aren’t particularly expensive but they are often not accurate or precise at that price point. Laboratory grade pH meters are expensive, think hundreds to thousands of dollars for a good one. Many pH meters on sites like Amazon will claim that they are “laboratory grade” but they really aren’t. pH meters also need to be properly maintained and calibrated to ensure accuracy using calibration solutions which are also expensive. 

The bottom line is that most people do not have access to the lab grade equipment and training that would be required to make sure that something is safe so the blanket recommendation is that pH testing not be used in home canning applications.

Recipes that have undergone laboratory testing (what we generally refer to as "tested recipes" on this subreddit) have been tested to ensure that the acidity level is appropriate for the canning method listed in the recipe. pH testing does not enhance the safety of an already tested recipe.

Because pH testing is not recommended for home use we do not allow recommendations for it on our subreddit.

Sources:
https://ucanr.edu/blog/preservation-notes-san-joaquin-master-food-preservers/article/help-desk-question-home-ph

https://extension.okstate.edu/programs/oklahoma-gardening/recipes/ph-and-home-canning.html


r/Canning • • 7h ago

General Discussion Atmospheric steam canners: I'm a convert

Post image
125 Upvotes

So glad atmospheric steam canners were proven safe to use.

The first time I used one, I was convinced. Better than hot bath canning. The second time I used it, today, I'm converted. I don't think I want to use hot bath canning again in a hurry.

For me, there are several advantages. First, it comes to temperature so much faster. It took less than 20 minutes to reach temperature, whereas it can take up to an hour or more in a hot bath can.

Second, it's a lot easier to handle. Not as heavy.

Third, I can do one jar, or whole load of jars.

Fourth, because I tend to do smaller jars, things are always falling through the holes in the rack and the hot bath.

I made pickled beets today. I was done with two batches in less time than it would've taken to do one batch in a hot bath.

(Using NCHFP safe recipe for pickled beets, but I skipped the spices.)


r/Canning • • 1h ago

Safe Recipe Request Pomegranate Apple Jam- check recipe for safety

2 Upvotes

Hi! I’ve gone down quite the deep rabbit hole to try to find a pomegranate apple jam recipe. I found this recipe that looks pretty spot-on for what I’m looking for, but… it’s from one of the sites that’s deemed “unsafe”. 😵

Here’s the recipe: https://canningdiva.com/recipes/pomegranate-apple-jam-canning-recipe/

I’m wondering, could this recipe be tweaked and made safe? (Eg. swap out bottled lemon juice for the fresh lemon juice that the recipe calls for, etc.). OR if anyone knows of another pomegranate-apple jam recipe that’s safe, that would be really cool.

I have a ton of pomegranates and apples that I’d like to use up, and I really like the consistency of jam over jelly.

Thanks so much! ☺️


r/Canning • • 15h ago

Is this safe to eat? First time pressure canning

Post image
25 Upvotes

I attempted to can bone broth yesterday from a turkey carcass. I boiled/simmered for 5 hours yesterday. Prepped my jars and canner by warming them. I set aside the broth to cool slightly so I could skim fat off the top without refrigerating. I skimmed fat off the top using a ladle. Then I held a strainer directly over the hot jars. I used a measuring cup to dip into the hot broth and pour into jars. I put lids and bands on jars and then realized I forgot to wipe the rims so I took off, wiped with vinegar, & then put back on. I processed at 12-13 PSI for 25 minutes for quarts. Is it fine to have skipped the refrigerating step if I still skimmed from the top? And the broth wasn’t technically boiling when I filled jars, just very hot. Is that a deal breaker? Pic of jars this morning included!


r/Canning • • 2h ago

Is this safe to eat? Are my jars safe?

1 Upvotes

I pressure canned for the first time and now I’m wondering if I messed up. I used the Ball recipe for raw packed chicken (10lbs for 90minutes).
I vented for 10 minutes, put the regulator on and was waiting for the air vent/cover lock to pop up. It was taking a while and a lot of water was sputtering from the air vent/cover lock. So much so that there was a puddle around it. The troubleshooting guide in my manual (presto) said the lid might not be lined up correctly if a lot of leakage is happening and preventing the lock from popping up. So I turned off the heat, opened the lid and closed it again, making sure to line it up correctly. I started again and let it vent a bit before starting the 10 minute timer again but once I started my timer for venting, the lock popped up shortly after that. I didn’t know what to do. It didn’t look like anymore steam was coming out and I was concerned about venting it too much so I went ahead and put the regulator on and continued the process. The pressure built up and I finished the process following the recipe. Should I have let it vent the full 10 minutes again, even though the lock popped up early?


r/Canning • • 15h ago

Prep Help Canning frozen tomatoes

Post image
11 Upvotes

Good morning,

Today I’m canning my frozen tomatoes and wanted to ask for help on one part of the process. I’ll be using balls crushed tomato recipe (https://www.ballmasonjars.com/blog?cid=crushed-tomatoes).

Question: tomatoes are defrosted and sitting in separated water, do I need to reincorporate this water equally into the tomatoes as I cook them in the saucepan or just discard?

Thanks so much everyone! Photo included is the last batch of stragglers that ripened this week, the green ones have been sacrificed to chickens.


r/Canning • • 2h ago

Is this safe to eat? Weird jar

1 Upvotes

I just canned black beans using the Ball recipe. I let the canner depressurize naturally. Waited 5 minutes for lid, another 10 to remove jars. When I picked one jar up bean juice spurted out. I left in canner and now it’s sealed. - I’m going to put in the fridge once it cools down but what the heck happened?


r/Canning • • 12h ago

Pressure Canning Processing Help Pressure dipped to 10, do I need to restart timer when I get it back to 11?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Chicken thighs. I'm trying to get the pressure back up without cranking the heat too much. Finding this heat/temperature/pressure balance has been challenging.

Don't mind the cracked plaster wall in the background. It's only coming up on 100 years old...


r/Canning • • 6h ago

General Discussion Canning with dietary restrictions

1 Upvotes

Hello. I have a sliding hernia and IBS, have a list of ingredients I cant eat.

no onions, no garlic, no leeks, chives, lemongrass, no soy, no coconut, no tomatoes, no oats, (not to much dairy). Not to much citrus

I want to get into pressure canning, given this list how possible is this? I love the idea of heading to a relatives and throwing a few meals in a bag.

Im a great cook, and have a massive inventory of recipes I cook, but as I understand it I cant just pressure can anything, it needs a specific recipe.

Or is this an online safety myth….?

Would love book recommendations etc, and if this is even something I should consider. I adapt basically every recipe I ever see, so canning specific recipes seems impossible.

Thanks so much!


r/Canning • • 1d ago

General Discussion Deformed Canner

Post image
50 Upvotes

When canning meat in quart jars. I had a problem in the last 5 minutes of pressure canning. It started losing pressure, so I turned up the heat on the propane burners. This was enough to keep the pressure cooker around 10 lbs. Everything worked out. The meat was good.
This year we pulled out the canner and saw this deformed canner.


r/Canning • • 10h ago

Prep Help Open pectin sealed in the fridge.

2 Upvotes

I have some liquid pectin that's been in the fridge (Certo) it says to use it within 14 days, but it's been there for a few months. Looks fine.

Is there a food safety issue or is it just a performance issue if i use it?

Anyone keep bottles of open liquid pectin in the fridge and use? Does it work ok?


r/Canning • • 13h ago

Understanding Recipe Help Cranberry Juice Recipe Help

3 Upvotes

Hey guys. In the Ball Complete Book of Home Preserving book on page 189 is a recipe for cranberry juice I am attempting to follow. The verbiage is confusing me though. Calls for 2 1/2 lbs of cranberries and 8 cups of water. Step one says, "in a large deep stainless steel saucepan, combine an equal measure of cranberries and water". Then it never mentioned the specific "8 cups of water", is this the 8 cups? Why is it saying "equal measure"?


r/Canning • • 8h ago

General Discussion Ball onion soup onion peel stock

0 Upvotes

I simmered the onion peels and skins in some water with some carrot scraps. Is this stock I can pressure can?


r/Canning • • 15h ago

General Discussion Canning water

1 Upvotes

Good morning,

I was wondering if anyone has any advice on storing water in old jars? I have a bunch of empty jars that I've saved (sauce & pickle) & was thinking about putting water in them for emergencies. I won't fill them to the brim but just below the top so it's not touching the lid. I appreciate any advice!!! Thanks !


r/Canning • • 7h ago

*** UNSAFE CANNING PRACTICE *** Cowboy Candy - Careful with Google Chat

0 Upvotes

I asked Google to generate a double batch recipe for Cowboy Candy based on the original Ball recipe.

https://www.ballmasonjars.com/blog?cid=candied-jalapenos

It calls for:
4 pounds jalapenos
4 cups sugar
3 cups apple cider vinegar

So what does Google give me?:
8 pounds of jalapenos, stemmed and cut into rings
12 cups sugar
4 cups apple cider vinegar

Both say to process pint jars at 15 minutes.

Then I ask Google if this recipe is shelf stable, and it says yes, because of the sugar content. I correct it with the Ball measurements and it says no, it is not shelf stable because it needs more vinegar. I need to refrigerate it.

Stupid me, I already processed two batches. I am just outside the 24 hour window to reprocess the batches.

Should I ditch these or refrigerate them?


r/Canning • • 1d ago

Pressure Canning Processing Help Chicken thighs fresh out of the pressure canner

Post image
12 Upvotes

Well, here it is. Fresh out of the canner. Pint jars with 1 and 1/2 raw boneless chicken thighs. Directions said loose packed with 1.25" headspace. I had about 1.5". When I pulled them out, a few of them are still boiling in the jar and a couple of them are not. Are these expected results? I have more to do, so I want to get it at least close to right!


r/Canning • • 1d ago

Waterbath Canning Processing Help Apple sauce siphoning?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I just water bathed four pints of apple sauce. Left 1/2 inch headspace, but:

- I could see floaters in the water

- The jars haven’t popped yet but they look concave (came out seeming suctioned)

- Sauce was leaking down the side of two jars when I removed them from the waterbath

- seems very bubbly still

I’ve read to leave them for at least ten minutes (instead of my electric canners 5 minute cooldown), but too late for that.

Do we think they’ll seal? Is it weird I never heard a pop and they came out looking sealed? Will they be good even though they leaked? 🍎 😢


r/Canning • • 1d ago

General Discussion Reusing Ball or Azure lids

0 Upvotes

I'm about to take the leap and but a pressure canner. I've used canning jars for dry ingredients, using a vacuum sealer. I know not to reuse pressure canned lids, but can I use them if they've not been heated, but have just been vacuum sealed once.


r/Canning • • 1d ago

Pressure Canning Processing Help Raw pack boneless chicken thighs, pressure canning

6 Upvotes

Chicken is in the refrigerator; jars are room temperature. In the Presto 23qt book and the USDA guide, it says pack loosely in hot jars. Everything I see online has people doing it in room temperature jars. Do I need to warm the jars somehow first?

I have searched 'til I can search no more. Yes, I'm a noob and these little details make it intimidating and overwhelming.


r/Canning • • 1d ago

Waterbath Canning Processing Help Jars sealed before processing?

3 Upvotes

I’m processing tomato juice today per the Ball Blue Book. I started packing my jars of juice, then was interrupted for a few minutes when my kids came in after falling in the mud. While I was assisting my kids, I heard a few of my jars give the pop, even though I hadn’t even started the water bath yet.

I’ve gone ahead and put them in the water bath canner for 35 minutes as per the book, bc I’m assuming they would still be safe but was wondering if anyone had any insight or had this happen to them before. Thank you!


r/Canning • • 1d ago

General Discussion Buying a new pressure canner

7 Upvotes

Hi all. I have not canned in a very long time and want to start again next season. To do so I'll need a new pressure canner. The last one I used was a Presto. I would like to try a canner without a gasket needed. What is the best one out there? While money is tight this is a situation where spending for quality is a good investment and this is something my family can use for a long time.


r/Canning • • 1d ago

Safe Recipe Request Substitute vinegar for lemon juice

0 Upvotes

I am canning a huge amount of elderberry jam tomorrow. The recipe in my book calls for vinegar, but elderberry jam is traditionally made with lemon juice. I know it’s not a simple substitution. What are your suggestions?


r/Canning • • 1d ago

Equipment/Tools Help Band Recommendation

2 Upvotes

Edit: Just wanted to thank those who suggested hand drying the bands. I do that about half the time and yes it does seem to help. I still need recommendations for band brands though, because I am almost out of my old bands and will need to buy some soon.

Hello everyone! I have been canning for years, but it's been a long long time since I bought bands. Many years ago, I bought a big box of brand new bands second hand, and I've been working my way through them. The bands weren't in packages so I don't know what brand they were, but as they also had a couple of boxes of Ball lids, I figure they were Ball bands.

They will last a few trips through the canner and then be too rusty to be used again. To be clear, I take the bands off after the 12-24 hour window, wash, and hang to dry. Once dry, I put in an air tight container because I live in a humid region. If I'm feeling ambitious, I wall wipe down with vinegar and air dry before putting them in a container. They don't get rusty in storage, it's the trip through the canner that seems to make them rusty. And once rusty, I can't feel if they're being tightened properly anymore.

So I am curious if anyone has any recommendations for a good brand of canning bands. I have used and like Superb lids, and they're easily available to me as I live in Amish country.

Something I have experimented with and am considering expanding is using aluminum bands that I found on Amazon. I bought a dozen and have been experimenting with them, and they have worked well in for me the few times I've tried them. I'm wondering if there is a safety reason for not using these?

I'm also open to suggestions on how to make my rusty bands work better! Thank you everyone!