Let's see if I get banned here for pointing out facts.
Video: Canada Post financials explained
TLDR: Canada Post has traditionally relied on it's letter mail monopoly and generated considerable profits in-exchange for providing mail service 5 days a week to every address in Canada. In the past the monopoly was lucrative enough to offer generous wages and benefits to jobs in a courier company. However since 2017 Canada Post has been losing money annually and it's significant. Even if the union wins, short of being bailed out by every Canadian taxpayer where is the money coming from?
FYI *Canada Post, while a crown Corp is forbidden by its own charter from taking taxpayer money, it has historically often paid profits to government, and this is part of why it needs to reform since it needs to be profitable.
However, with the expansion of digital communication, the volume of letter mail has declined from 5.5billion letters annually in 2006 to 2.2billion letters annually in 2023. It's simply easier and cheaper to send an email or Facebook post than to cut down a tree, process it, print it, then deliver it. This is also true for mailed adverts.
While the expansion of ecommerce was initially good for Canada Post which controlled 62% of parcel deliveries which accounted for over half of it's income, the explosion of demand during the pandemic along with a bunch of low-cost and flexible gig-worker couriers made it significant enough for companies to find cheaper and more flexible solutions. So this source of revenue is in decline and the union opposes hiring gig workers to compete while existing full-time and benefits workers are too expensive for customers.*
*Some of it did go to Purolator, which is profitable and it suggests that the current structure of CP is very-inefficient.
You can find the latest CUPW demands here (obviously subject to change). Now I won't go through them all but I do want to cite my sources and focus on some key aspects.
Labour, the vast majority of which are to the workers account for 53% of costs (not including benefits and pensions), how can they possibly add 20% to that in the near future while the corporation is also losing about 2-5 cents on every dollar spent? It's not like the workers will be 20% more productive, nor are the workers open to automating/subcontracting, nor will Canada go back to more letter mail/CP for parcels.
One can find the 2023 annual report here.
To put things in context a wage increase of 20% is on top of the existing CP median wage of 28$/hr which is already 6$ above the industry average for couriers and higher than half of all Canadians for doing a job that requires legs, reading, and driving.
Improved protections against technological change.
Probably the most damning demand, while the likes of Walmart and Amazon are automating more and more the CUPW wants to keep inefficient and labour intensive processes for sorting, tracking, and packing. While it does protect union jobs, it also means that Canada Post would be forced to neglect productive investments, become less and less competitive over time, and be forced to charge increasing more for the same service relative to competitors.
Minimum 20-hour schedule for all part-time employees (effectively no gig-workers)
No contracting out of bargaining unit work
Gig work is now the industry standard and a major aspect of being competitive. No one is forcing people to engage in gig work, while Canadians may not like it they did speak with their wallets and consistently chose delivery services that employed more and more gig workers. It's hard to see why Canadians would pay more shipping to subsidize CUPW workers at much higher wages.
Some common points I see:
Executives are being paid hundreds of thousands in bonuses- Yes, its in their contract just as the CUPW's contracts and judging by average C-suite salaries for 55,000 employee organizations it's below-average and at 15 million a year a drop in the bucket vs a wage budget of 3.4billion. If they were to somehow run the company without C-suites the average CUPW worker would get 180$ more per year, a far cry from the 20% they are asking for.
Executives have mismanaged the company- perhaps, regardless this is the situation now and drastic measures are needed none of which the union is open to. The union doesn't seem to realize that even if they got all their demands, CP is set towards a debt-spiral and insolvency within a year or so.
The cost of living is rising, the demands are just- the cost of living is rising for everyone, except the majority of Canadians are seeing a 1%-2% annual decline in their income in addition to inflation while the union is asking for a 20% increase. More importantly, people are paid for useful work, that's free exchange and there's no good reason that a person with a package should pay more for less flexible Canada Post shipping than a courier except for the coverage.
A rising tide raises all boats, increased CUPW wages will translate to higher wages for everyone- No it hasn't, the average CUPW wage is at the median Canadian wage and there has been no effect. And a simple bit of economic thinking would deduce that if all wages increase while the amount of goods and services stay the same then all we've effectively done is double all of our prices and started dramatic inflation.