r/CSEducation • • Apr 14 '17

What Is Array

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6tjYC86iV5E
0 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '17

Hey there, I am not sure if you made this video, but I'd like to give you some criticism just in case. Especially seeing that nobody else commented on it so far.

First of all, I like that you put the effort into making short educational videos that are also visually a little different, I like that you placed some computer related items in the corners.

I know that a lot of languages do not use articles as excessive as the Germanic ones (e.g. English), but you need it in this case. "What is an array?" This goes also for the other sentences you are saying in the video, don't forget the articles. Write a transcript (you're probably doing this already) and let someone proof-read it.

Then secondly, explaining that accessing an element in an array only takes constant complexity is a little moot if people don't know what that means. However, explaining complexities is a whole other can of worms.

Then again, as mentioned, the length of the video is good. It can be a little longer, but keeping it short makes sure they are easily digestible.

I hope that helped :D

1

u/shargath Apr 14 '17

Yes, I made it! :) Articles - I'll keep it in mind next time. Complexity - I made also video(it was my 2nd) about Big O notation, to which I link at the time I mentioned complexity. But I should probably put it into description.

That was great feedback! Thank you :)

1

u/cdsmith Apr 16 '17

Your choice to teach asymptotic complexity first, and then mention arrays later, is definitely unconventional. Is it deliberate?

I think you can get away with mentioning that you can do it "in a fixed amount of time" or "without walking through the rest of the structure", and not get into the formalism of asymptotics yet.

2

u/shargath Apr 17 '17

I don't follow any curriculum nor do I have any plan of topics in specific order. I just have some backlog of topics, to which I sometimes add a new one, when something good crosses my mind or I got some suggestion from viewers.

With this video and other ones like sorting algorithms, it works well since I can always link back to my Big O notation video.

1

u/Edg-R Apr 15 '17

I was going to mention this too but I saw someone else already mentioned it. The proper phrase is "What is an array?".

Great video though, I love the visuals. You should redo this one and re-upload it.

1

u/shargath Apr 15 '17

Thank you! Reuploading seems too radical. I will change title and thumbnail at least.

3

u/Edg-R Apr 15 '17

The title 🙂

1

u/shargath Apr 15 '17

Damned! 😄

1

u/imforit Apr 15 '17

This also isn't research on education theory or practice, which is technically outside the scope of the sub. But it does give you access to CS ed researchers and practitioners!

0

u/[deleted] Apr 20 '17

[deleted]

2

u/shargath Apr 20 '17

Happy to hear that :) Thanks for watching!