r/CPTSDNextSteps • u/thewayofxen • 5h ago
Sharing actionable insight (Rule2) I have terrible news: The "forgiveness" people are right.
Straight away, let me define what forgiveness isn't:
It is not reconciliation.
It is not suppressing anger.
It is not pretending nothing bad ever happened.
It is not allowing unsafe people into your life.
Forgiveness is the letting go of anger, rage, and betrayal, and instead seeing through to the root cause of the offense by way of better understanding the offender, and ultimately feeling disappointment and grief for the way the world is compared to what it could be. Important: Forgiveness is difficult and unpleasant, but ultimately relieving and liberating. I'll explain how later in the post.
So which "forgiveness people" am I talking about? Not the enablers, not the minimizers, not the abusers themselves demanding you let them back into your life. These people are wrong. The people who are right are the ones that you're surprised suggest forgiveness.
One of my favorite books on relationship dynamics is The Dance of Anger by Harriet Lerner, which I highly recommend to the people in this community (the book is written to women, but as a man, this didn't affect its usefulness).
But I always had a problem with this book, which is her conclusion towards the end. She says you shouldn't cut out family members from your life, because the tension you carry from that separation will bleed into your life and negatively affect you in a myriad of ways. I always thought, this woman has never met someone like my mother. The tension is worth keeping her out. And I haven't really changed my mind that I shouldn't have her in my life, but I also am realizing that I do carry tension and it does affect me. A lot.
That tension is that I still haven't forgiven her, so I carry anger and resentment, and it does indeed spill everywhere, most of all onto myself.
I'm reminded of another "forgiveness person," a therapist in the movie Ordinary People, who says to a young man whose mother treats him with distance and neglect, "Don't blame her for not loving you more than she's able." I love this movie, even though it broke me the first time I saw it. But every time I rewatch it, this scene bothers me. The main character's arc turns on a decision to forgive his awful mother even though she hasn't changed in the slightest. But it's necessary for him to move forward, because in forgiving his mother, he also forgives himself for a suicide attempt (as well as a very big spoilery thing), a thing he's very hard on himself for. To forgive himself for his attempt, he has to forgive his mother, because both of their sins stem from their own limitations.
That's the fundamental problem here: In order to forgive yourself for your own limitations, you have to accept that we all have limitations, which means also forgiving the people who hurt you. You won't let up on yourself until you let up on them, too. It's fruit born from the same tree.
I lived (and most days still live) in the refusal to eat that fruit. I have chosen to inflict misery on myself through all kinds of self-sabotage and depressive behaviors so I could hold the line against my family. But now after 10+ years of recovery work, I can finally sit and reflect and find that forgiveness. And when I apply it to them, it applies effortlessly to myself as well. I feel relief, I feel at ease, I feel liberated. No more self-punishment.
There's been a growing tension in my therapy that comes down to the question, "Why won't this end? Surely my suffering can't go on forever. Surely I can't feel this bad for the rest of my life." And the news is bad, my friends, because the thing that finally showed me the end of that suffering is blanket forgiveness.
Please allow yourself a minimum of one decade to mull this over. I think I'll still be wrestling with it for years. They make religions out of this stuff for a reason; it's as powerful as it is difficult. Just keep the level of nuance high. I will never allow my mother to stomp back into my life and demand that I lie about her transgressions, hide who I am and what I'm going through, and cater to her every emotional whim. Nor, however, can I blame her for doing all of that. I know enough about her life to know this isn't what she chose. I can't tolerate it, but I can forgive it. I have to do it, for myself.
And one day, so will you, if you're lucky.
Don't shoot the messenger!