r/CHICubs • • 17d ago

Is bringing a player who struck out over 200+ times this season and not showing up in the playoffs when it mattered most worth paying $22.5 mill and bringing back for 2027? cause I don’t think so.

Post image
32 Upvotes

I love Happer I really do but going completely invisible not showing up when it mattered the most in the big moments in the playoffs makes you not want to bring him back but it wasn’t just playoffs it was also the regular season as well where he underperformed or was up and down in a way I would put it and setting his season record of strikeouts after breaking his last record 2 years ago is not worth keeping / bringing back at all especially at $22.5 mill as well we have other options in the outfield that we have to play in the outfield like Alcantara ( in which I forgot about lol ), Shaw, Ramirez, ( Soon Hartshorn ), just need to head in a different direction in terms of future long term in the outfield, I love Happer and all he’s done for the team and city but I think it’s time to move on from him.


r/CHICubs • • Oct 12 '25

GO DODGERS!!!

Post image
226 Upvotes

r/CHICubs • • Jan 24 '24

Cubs and luxury tax implications

1 Upvotes

Cubs got 40 million to spend to stay under the luxury tax.

They got 60 million to spend to pay the first penalty which would only be 4 million dollars

SPEND THE FUCKING MONEY RICKETTS YOU CHEAP BASTARD

Thats all


r/CHICubs • • Jul 27 '22

I am 100% happy the Cubs did not sign Bryant, Rizzo, Baez, Schwarber, and probably Contreras & Happ to long-term contracts.

0 Upvotes

The Bryzzo, Baez, Schwarber quartet have woefully underperformed since leaving the Cubs. They were all 4 underperforming on the Cubs.

Contreras is at a place in his career where he will likely only decline. Happ, at best, is an average big league outfielder who lacks any sort of consistency in production.

None of those 6 players have earned a long-term contract with the Cubs or any other organization. I'm grateful for their contributions to the 2016 World Series, and I'll jump at the chance to buy any of them a beer should I ever encounter them out and about in Chicago.

But, that being said, thanks for the memories boys. On to the next core!


r/CHICubs • • Oct 13 '25

Predict the Cubs’ 2026 Opening Day lineup vs Washington Nationals at Wrigley

Post image
0 Upvotes

Let’s see who can call the Opening Day lineup right now.

Drop your 1–9 and starting pitcher in the comments. Feel free to add your batting order too if you’re feeling confident.

I’ll bump this post at the end of March to see if anyone nailed it.

Have fun!


r/CHICubs • • Dec 12 '24

Kyle Tucker...

0 Upvotes
  1. Is not going to sign an extension because of Boras and his affinity for making his clients test free agency. of reports indicating he will not.

  2. Will go to a team that:

  • Can afford to over pay for a one year rental.

  • is close to winning the World Series.

The Cubs are not that team and should not bet the farm and two solid players for a one year rental when he will most likely not re-sign after being on an (most likely) underperforming 2025 Cubs team. I'm not saying I have all the answers, but this deal ain't it. Just seems like Jed is gonna bet the farm to save his job at the expense of the franchise long term.

Also if we're in on Roki Sasaki how the hell is dangling Suzuki out there a good look?


r/CHICubs • • Dec 31 '24

I GM'd the Cubs through a 2024-25 offseason simulation. How did I do?

1 Upvotes

Hi Cubs fans,

Every year, about 3 dozen other baseball nerds, including myself, gather together after the World Series and run a simulated version of the MLB offseason. This was my first year as the Cubs GM, and after gaining an understanding of what Cubs fans want (a roster that wins more than 83 games every year), I aimed to make the Chicago Cubs the best team in the NL Central.

It's worth keeping in mind that every move I made was done by conversing with real people--other GMs, agents, commissioners, etc. so it's practically impossible to do some things, much like in real life. I can't simply trade for Shohei Ohtani, or sign Juan Soto to a bajillion-dollar contract (not that I didn't try). For the sake of realism, you've got to give something to get something, and moves that don't make sense from a team perspective will be vetoed.

Without further ado:

Budget - $205M

Nontenders

Patrick Wisdom, Nick Madrigal, Colten Brewer, Jimmy Herget, Adbert Alzolay, Yency Almonte

26-man roster (italics indicate roster addition)

C - Travis D'Arnaud

C - Miguel Amaya

1B - Michael Busch

2B - Nico Hoerner

3B - Isaac Paredes

SS - Dansby Swanson

IF - Kyle Farmer

LF - Ian Happ

CF - Pete Crow-Armstrong

RF - Lars Nootbaar

OF - Alexander Canario

OF - Mike Tauchman

DH - Seiya Suzuki

SPs - Blake Snell, Justin Steele, Shota Imanaga, Erick Fedde, Jameson Taillon

RPs - Keegan Thompson, Jordan Wicks, Ben Brown, Hoby Milner, Tyson Miller, Dennis Santana, Porter Hodge, David Robertson

FA Signings

It should be noted that Cody Bellinger's agent opted him out of his contract at the beginning of the sim, which was a real blessing, given he was making something like $27m and the real-life Cubs ended up dumping his contract anyway. This gave me a fair amount of space to make some deals in free agency and have enough left over to add some much-needed pieces in the trade market.

Blake Snell - 4/$120M

Not much to say here--Snell is in that top tier of the free agent pitching market, along with Burnes and Fried, and I got him for a pretty reasonable deal! He had a slow start with the Giants, but after some mid-season tweaks he was the best pitcher in the second half of the season (1.23 ERA, 1.77 FIP from July onward)--all this after an incredible contract year with the Padres and prior Cy Young success.

David Robertson - 1/$10M

Usually not a fan of paying relievers, but Robertson has thrown 60+ IP in each of the past three seasons at a combined 2.82 ERA/3.24 FIP, and he's somehow throwing at a higher velo than ever nearing his age-40 season. He's beating father time, and this is a pretty easy bet to make to bolster the bullpen at a relatively low price.

Kyle Farmer - 1/$2.5M

Hardly an interesting deal, but Farmer's a fantastic defender all over the infield and hits at a slightly below-average clip. I signed him as a placeholder for the inevitable call-ups of Matt Shaw, Owen Caissie, and the rest of that bunch.

Penn Murfee, Payton Henry, Jose Peroza, Kendall Simmons - MiLB deals ($200k)

Not really going to bother talking about these, since they're boring, but a Penn Murfee return would be cool to see.

Trades

Ty Southisene for Dennis Santana

One of the more pressing needs for Chicago, as I'm sure you guys are aware, is to fix the bullpen. Santana found his footing in his age-28 season with the Pirates, posting a 2.44 ERA, 4.55 K/BB, and 1.1 WAR in 44.1 innings after getting waived by the Yankees earlier that year and changing up his pitch mix. He placed in the 98th percentile in chase rate, 95th in average exit velo, 92nd in barrel and hard-hit%, and 82nd in xERA. In the final two months of the season hitters batted with a .404 OPS against him. Small sample size, sure, but Southisene (cubs' fourth round pick this year) seemed like a relatively small price to pay for three years of one of the most improved relievers of the past season.

Christian Bethancourt, Luis Vazquez for Travis D’Arnaud

Amaya had a solid second half, but D'Arnaud should make for the perfect stopgap as the Cubs hope to contend in 2025 and hopefully transition Ballesteros to the bigs. Bethancourt was fine, but D'Arnaud is safely a starting-caliber catcher, and I’m betting on Vazquez panning out as a back-end 40-man sort of guy.

Cam Smith, Jefferson Rojas, and Derniche Valdez for Erick Fedde and Lars Nootbaar

This move clears up two needs for the Cubs: adding pitching depth to an already-stacked rotation (Snell/Steele/Imanaga/Fedde/Taillon!!!) and adds a starting RF after the loss of Bellinger. Fedde turned in a borderline all-star performance (3.30 ERA, 3.4 fWAR in 177 IP) this past season after figuring himself out overseas, and we also nab Nootbaar, who has been one of the most consistent hitters of the last few seasons and will immediately slot in to the middle of the lineup. The Cards get a top-100 guy in return, along with our recent 1st-rounder and a lotto ticket in Valdez. We have a glut of valuable infielders in our farm, so parting with them made the most sense for Chicago. NOTE: yes I am aware that this would never happen in real life--sorry!

Riley Thompson for Hoby Milner

Milner is a junkballing sidearm lefty who touches 88 on his fastball and thrives on soft contact. He posted a 4.73 ERA this season, but there's little to suggest he actually pitched any worse than he was last season, where he posted a 1.82 ERA. The peripherals are roughly the same: his K%, BB%, xWOBA and xERA have hardly changed over the last three years, and they all say that Milner is pretty good! His remarkable consistency lead me to believe that he'll be a very valuable middle reliever for Chicago, especially with the defensive force we've got in the middle infield.

Enoli Paredes, Christian Franklin for Nate Nankil

This deal was to offload Paredes, who was out of minor league options. I had run out of time to cut him by the deadline. This is almost certainly my most minor deal--Franklin is a likely platoon bat if he ever sees big league time, and Nankil was Oakland's 7th round pick in '23 and posted some fantastic numbers in A-ball.

Notes/Conclusion

You may be wondering where guys like Wesneski or Assad are. Don't worry: they've got options! If our roster is healthy come opening day, they will probably not make the roster. I don't believe Assad will replicate the same success he had in '24 with his shoddy peripherals, but he's still valuable as an emergency starter; after all, you've got to plan for what happens if your pitchers are going down nowadays. Matt Shaw (and the other prospects) is also not expected to make the opening day roster unless he's just ridiculously good in spring training, but I would expect to have him called up at some point during the course of the season.

I'm very happy with the sort of squad we've got here. We've effectively replaced Hendricks, Bellinger, and Bethancourt's roles with Snell, Nootbaar, and D'Arnaud, and made significant upgrades without breaking the bank or giving up the entire farm. We also have an abundance of MLB-caliber guys in the minors (see: Assad, Wesneski, Palencia) along with top prospects just waiting to get the call up to the bigs (Shaw, Caissie, Triantos, Horton, etc.), so depth should be no issue here.

I'd love to know what you guys think of my performance as Jed Hoyer. Please feel free to provide feedback. Go Cubs!


r/CHICubs • • Jan 23 '18

Cubs In Active Talks With Yu Darvish According To AP Source

Thumbnail
sportsmockery.com
0 Upvotes

r/CHICubs • • Jun 10 '26

Craig’s gotta go.

0 Upvotes

I’m convinced he’s a double agent. Something isn’t working here. Start at the head. Get him out. Seasons over.


r/CHICubs • • Jan 21 '18

In memory of a legend

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1 Upvotes

r/CHICubs • • Jan 17 '25

[ESPN] Dodgers Sign Sasaki

Thumbnail
espn.com
0 Upvotes

I wish the Cubs wanted to win as bad.


r/CHICubs • • Oct 03 '26

Small Ball

0 Upvotes

The Cubs had a huge problem playing small ball during the regular season. And attempted steals were also down. So I wasn't surprised the the Cubs put themselves in a position to be swept by the Padres.

Not batting Hoerner behind PCA was a huge mistake IMO. The Cubs need to be a lot more aggressive on the bases next year!


r/CHICubs • • Jan 05 '24

A little better photo of the Cubs king of the outfield, Cody Bellinger. hope you guys resign him coming from a Rays fan :)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/CHICubs • • Oct 29 '16

game 4

4 Upvotes

start heyward. enough already with this fucking about. we've missed his glove on a couple key plays, and his hustle shits anything soler or goddamn coghlan brings to the table. and neither one of them are hitting worth a shit either.

javy needs to calm the fuck down. his nlcs performance went straight to his head, and he's back to his old bullshit ways of swinging at pitches over his head. not loving the flashy bare-handed dipsy-do in the field, either. OR the fact that he seems to be best fucking friends with every other indian who makes it to second base, and spends 30 seconds playing grabass with them.

calm down, everybody. make them throw strikes and lay off the offspeed shit. jesus, it's baseball 101 and how the fuck does a 103-win team forget all the things they did to get here?

fuck kluber. we hit him long and hard in game 1, the balls just ended up in gloves instead of in the gap. if the wind is blowing tonight we hit 3 dongs, bet.

enough already with the schwarber strokefest. he choked like a dog last night and joe prob shouldn't have hit him in that situation anyway. i love the kid and his jersey will be the next one i buy, but he isn't gonna single-handedly win this series, esp. when our MVP 3rd baseman swings at pitches that are practically fucking BOUNCING IN THE DIRT!!!!!! godDAMMIT!!!!!!!

sigh. only down 2-1. we win tonight and it's a new series everybody. lackey is half-insane and we need that intensity tonight. as much as i love hendricks, his mopey stare at the ground shit gets old. i want my starter to fist pump and scream "let's fucking go you stupid sumbitches!" after every strikeout and act like a pissed off teenager if joe takes him out too soon.

LET'S GO!!! ONE IN MY LIFETIME! FUUUUUUUUCK!!!!!


r/CHICubs • • Dec 17 '23

The Cubs Should Re-Sign Cody Bellinger

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Is he worth the money? I think so. We need to show future free agents we reward good play. And I think his contact skills will play well going forward. What do you think?


r/CHICubs • • Jul 19 '25

Anyone else see this and now worried about not making good trades we need?

Post image
2 Upvotes

I am a big cubs fan and have been following this team since 2018. I have closely this season been watching all the games and consistently keeping my eye on trade rumors on different sites. I saw this earlier and it kinda worried me tbh. I initially had the idea that cubs were going to be buyers but active and big buyers at that, especially with them saying no prospect is untouchable and they are going to go big. However, and maybe it’s just me, but this remark from Hawkins to me sounds like they are pretty satisfied with the team and may not be going as big as I thought. I hope I’m wrong because I do believe this team is special and can win it all BUT there are holes that need to be patched. What’s everyone else’s thoughts ?


r/CHICubs • • Aug 03 '23

The whoop there it is song immediately makes cubs hitting a homer lame af

0 Upvotes

It would be so much cooler to just let it be the sound of the roaring crowd. It's such a lame song choice too. Basic af.


r/CHICubs • • Sep 22 '25

Is Matt Shaw okay?

Post image
0 Upvotes

First and foremost, thoughts and prayers for whatever he is going through.

With that said, the season is not over and whatever is taking his bat out of the lineup surely can’t be more important than missing a game for what seems like no reason.

Hopefully this lack of being a team player isn’t something that is normalized. If so, I believe we might want to consider someone who is more of a team player to replace him.

Curious of your thoughts. Go Cubs!


r/CHICubs • • Aug 22 '25

What is the most amount of money the Cubs should realistically pay for Tucker, who might (likely) not even hit 25 home runs?

0 Upvotes

I've seen $600-million reports, but honestly, $400 should be out the door at this point. Would any of you even spend $300, $30-million per year? I wouldn't. I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on max Cubs should spend on Tucker. Say what you want about his hand but I'd rather watch 750k Cassie out there full time next season.


r/CHICubs • • Apr 11 '26

Busch and PCA

0 Upvotes

Counsell needs to stop trying to make PCA a slugger and stop trying to make Busch a table setter.

PCA had his greatest success in the minors at the top of the lineup and also in the majors when he was allowed to do so. PCA should be batting behind Hoerner so that he can use all of his skills to help produce runs for the Cubs.

Batting Busch sixth in the line up would allow him to relax and drive in a lot more runs!


r/CHICubs • • Jul 24 '23

Cubs Should Be Buyers Right Now

18 Upvotes

I do not want to see this Cubs team sell.

They have a solid core: Steele, Happ, Horner, Suzuki, Swanson.

They can pitch: Hendricks is solid. Taillon seems to be moving in the right direction. Alzolay has been solid out of the 'pen.

They can hit: Morel and Wisdom can get hot and are both above-average hitters; Happ and Swanson are solid middle of the order bats; I know we're all waiting on Suzuki to make some noise, but he's been league average too; Horner has been solid.

All that before noting that Bellinger and Stroman are two of the best players in the NL right now. This team is solid. They are arguably the 4th best team in the NL. The division is still very much up for grabs. It is not unthinkable that the Cubs can win this division. If they added another solid bat and another arm or two out of the 'pen, then they would have a very playable roster.

They would be competitive in the playoffs. They can pitch, they can hit and with another arm or two out of the 'pen, they'd be able to close games out too. The playoffs is a crap shoot.

I think the most important part is that even competing for a division title would be worth the cost of losing bellinger and stroman for nothing.


r/CHICubs • • Nov 24 '23

2024 Cubs Lineup

1 Upvotes
  1. PCA - CF

  2. Nico - 2B

  3. Bichette - 3B

  4. Ohtani - DH

  5. Suzuki - RF

  6. Happ -LF

  7. Swanson - SS

  8. Insert Journeyman Here - 1B

  9. Gomes/Amaya - C

So we can dream right?

How do you change it?

Flip Nico and PCA? Drop PCA till he proves himself?

That’s a lot of speed at top of lineup.


r/CHICubs • • Sep 23 '24

Was passing on Chapman the biggest blunder by Hoyer?

0 Upvotes

Was Jedd Hoyer passing on Matt Chapman the biggest blunder he made this winter???

Chapman is 31 years old and has hit 26 home runs with 75 rbi and a .786 OPS. His fabulous glove at 3rd base when combined with his bat, has given him a WAR of 6.9 according to Baseball Reference. The players who have played 3rd base for the Cubs this season have accumulated a WAR of -3. Thus, the Cubs would have gained roughly 10 more wins, according to WAR, if Chapman had played 3rd for the Cubs this season.

When added to the Cubs current win total, the Cubs would have 90 wins which would be five games better than the current 85 wins for the Mets and Arizona who are holding down the 2nd and 3rd wild card slots.


r/CHICubs • • May 07 '24

The Bleacher Bums are an Allegory for American Politics

0 Upvotes

Let me explain.

Every game, the Bleacher Bums pick a side to sit on, left field, right field, or center field. At the end of the day, they’re all Cubs fans and hold some sense of camaraderie and pride for their team. However, at some point during games, tensions will usually rise. Cub fan will turn on Cub fan and chant “Left Field Sucks” or “Right Field Sucks” with their side of the bleachers. All while the center field bleachers sit above the chaos and watch as nobody looks towards them.

Every day, the Americans pick a side to vote on, the left, or the right. At the end of the day, they’re all Americans, and hold some sense of camaraderie and pride for their nation. However, at some point during their lives, tensions will usually rise. American will turn on American and yell “the left is radical” or “the right is unhinged” with their side of the aisle. All while the aristocrats sit in their ivory tower above the chaos and watch as nobody looks towards them.

This was all I was thinking about at the game yesterday.