First of all, I know this may be an unpopular rant.. but here I go. As someone who loves cdramas, I really find it difficult to continue watching them. Here are my critiques, which apply to most of the historical cdramas I've seen:
1.) The inclusion of characters that literally have no purpose other than be the Fl/ML wingman/woman
2.) Uncreative dialogue that mostly consists of the characters swooning over their love or crying over their lost love , Also, the ML is not allowed to love anyone other than the FL even after they break up-- the truth is almost always the same for FML. They have to long for each other then get back together. The worst case of this was in "The Wolf." I literally stopped watching it cus the FL was crying in EVERY episode about how the ML changed and how she missed the 'past him'--drove me crazy lol.
3.) Once the ML falls in love he becomes a simp or loses rationality. Mopes around when the FL leaves him, loses his personality (cough cough ML from LYF cough)
4.) Unnecessary 2nd and 3rd couples that literally only exist for filler
5.) The reusage of sets used in past dramas
6.) the fact that nearly all historical dramas are shooting in hengdian world studios.. sick of seeing the same backdrop every drama lol
7.) censorship
8.) Constant blood spitting to show character is ill/near death.
9.) The obsession with the lead characters having to look polished/ beautiful in every shot (TTEOTM)
10.) Extravagant outfits in settings that dont make sense. Why are you sneaking out decked in a gorgeous hanfu? I thought you were trying to evade attention.. Also, why are you going to sleep in full makeup and a headpiece???
11.) Actors tend to spoil a lot of elements of the show in livestreams/other promotional events (EX: will the show have a HE or BE?)
12.) There is always food in the scenes, but its almost never touched
13.) When people DO eat, they take mouse-sized bites???
14.) Second leads in love w/ the ML that are annoying asf. This is also a faucet for sexism- I feel the SFLs are almost always depicted as catty / one dimensional, as opposed to SMLs that tend to be morally gray or upright.
15.) Literally the tropes. It's hard to find something new. Also, the obsession with love. I like romance, but some of these dramas overdo it
16.) The dubbing really bothers me.. I want to hear the raw emotions from the actors WHILE they acted that part out.. it make the drama less immersive if I cant hear their ACTUAL voices. Really appreciate Zhang Wan Yi and Yang zi for their amazing enunciation and tone when delivering lines in LYF.
17.) Show not tell: Cdramas tend to rely a lot on dialogue rather than putting in the extra work for the fine details. For instance, rather than showing you a proper battle, they might just narrate something over the image of a battlefield... or animate the battle?? ( The Longest Ballad). It feels lazy but I can understand because of financial restraints.
18.) The lack of logic. I remember watching a scene in The Pillow book drama w/ Dilreba, the FL concluded someone was lurking around in her room because the paper she found on the ground was crumpled differently from how she crumpled paper.. huh?????
19.) There's simply too many episodes
This list is NOT exhaustive, feel free to add your reasons.
Listen, I love cdramas and c-ent has SO much potential and rich history and I feel that the quality of cdramas are also impacted by the fact they are mass produced . I recently have been watching House of the Dragon/Shogun and I couldn't help but compare it w/ chinese historical dramas. At the very least, I do appreciate the great acting skills and the fact that cdramas are def more family-friendly in comparison to other media. Some of the dramas that I truly appreciate are: Love Like the Galaxy and The Rise of Phoenixes. I also adore Lost You Forever, but am disappointed w/ the characterization of 9 tailed fox and the constant *almost confessing* of CX lol. Tough love there!