Warning: long post ahead read at your own risk.
Kept anonymity to avoid an unnecessary escalation for them.
A friend of mine recently went through something during his final placements at one of India’s top B-schools, and the more I got to know about the incident, the more I started questioning how much power placement committees at these institutes actually have over students’ careers. I understand that managing placements for hundreds of students and maintaining relationships with recruiters is not an easy job, but what happened with him genuinely made me wonder whether, somewhere in this process, the interests of the students themselves have started taking a back seat.
For some context, this guy graduated from one of the top IITs, had a 9/9/8 academic profile, was on the academic merit list at his B-school and had a pretty strong overall profile for consulting. During his summer internship, he worked with a boutique consulting firm based in the Middle East, where seven students from two of India’s top B-schools had interned. Of these seven, he was the only one to receive a PPO, with a compensation package of over ₹80 LPA. However, after spending considerable time outside India, including an exchange term during his MBA, he realised that he did not really want to spend the next few years working abroad. The money was obviously great, but he wanted to build his career in India, and after thinking it through, he decided to reject the PPO and take his chances during final placements instead. Given his profile and previous consulting experience, he was fairly confident about his chances at MBB and other top consulting firms.
Now, rejecting a PPO at these institutes is already a significant risk because there are restrictions on the number of top-tier companies you can apply to during final placements. In his case, he could apply to only six such firms, which he was planning to use for MBB and a few other consulting companies. He had communicated his decision to reject the PPO to the placement committee and had started preparing for finals. Around the same time, he also wrote a LinkedIn post reflecting on his exchange experience, where he spoke about how living abroad had changed his perspective on a few things, including his decision to stay in India rather than pursue the international offer. It was a fairly normal post about his personal experience, without any criticism of the company or the institute, and he probably did not imagine that mentioning his PPO rejection publicly could create a problem.
Apparently, the company came across the post and raised an issue with the placement committee because, according to what my friend was told, it had learnt about the rejection through LinkedIn rather than through the official communication process. My friend was subsequently called in and informed that there might be some consequences for what had happened. Now, I can understand why a company might not appreciate learning about a PPO rejection through social media, especially when there are formal communication protocols in place. But what I find strange is that the student had already informed the placement committee of his decision, and if there was a specific rule about when he could publicly mention it, surely that could have been addressed without putting his entire placement process at risk. Anyway, after this discussion, nothing was communicated to him for the next ten days, and he assumed that the matter had been settled.
This is where things took a rather unexpected turn. Just one day before the shortlists for the top consulting firms were supposed to come out, he got to know from someone working at one of these firms that he had apparently been debarred from applying to them. He had received no official communication about any such penalty from his own institute. He then started reaching out to seniors and contacts at these companies to understand what was happening, only to learn that recruiters had apparently already been informed about his ineligibility. Imagine being in that situation, where you have spent months preparing for one of the most important placement processes of your career, and you get to know from an employee of an external company that your own institute has restricted your applications, while nobody responsible for the decision has formally told you anything.
It was only at around 4 AM that he finally received an official email informing him that his first six applications, essentially the six most important applications he had for final placements, had been disallowed. This was happening barely a day before the shortlists were scheduled to be released. For someone who had already rejected an ₹80+ LPA international offer because he wanted to work in India, finding out at the very last moment that he might not even get the opportunity to interview with the companies he had been targeting was understandably quite difficult. And what made the situation worse was that he wasn’t being rejected by these firms based on his profile or performance. He was being prevented from participating in the process in the first place, over an issue that had originated from a LinkedIn post.
What followed was three to four days of constant back and forth with different authorities at the institute, trying to understand the rationale behind the decision, explaining his side of the story and requesting that the penalty be reconsidered. Meanwhile, the placement process was continuing, shortlists were being released, and his name was missing from the initial lists. This was someone who was considered among the stronger profiles in his batch, had a good academic record and had already demonstrated his ability to secure a consulting PPO, but instead of focusing on interview preparation, he was spending those crucial days running between people trying to get permission to participate in placements. I can only imagine how helpless it must feel when the people responsible for facilitating your placements are also the ones whose decision you are trying to challenge, especially when every passing day could mean another missed opportunity.
Eventually, after repeated discussions and escalations, he was allowed to use four of his original six applications, and he also managed to get extended shortlists from some of the top consulting firms. Thankfully, things did work out for him to some extent, but I don’t think that takes away from what happened during those few days. If four applications could eventually be restored, it makes me wonder why such a severe penalty was imposed so close to the shortlist dates in the first place, and more importantly, why the student apparently had to learn about it from recruiters before receiving any formal communication from the placement committee. Even if the original penalty was justified under some placement rule, was there really no way to communicate it earlier and give him a fair opportunity to explain his position?
I am not suggesting that placement committees should not have rules or that students should be exempt from consequences when they violate them. I understand that recruiter relationships matter, and companies committing time and resources to campus placements expect a certain level of professionalism from the institute. But there has to be some proportionality between the mistake and the punishment, and some basic transparency in how such decisions are taken. A communication issue involving one company should not automatically put a student’s opportunities with several unrelated companies at risk, particularly when the student has already rejected an existing offer and is relying on the institute’s placement process to find a job.
What bothers me the most about the entire incident is the imbalance of power. A student who has spent two years and a considerable amount of money pursuing an MBA is in a position where questioning a placement-related decision could itself become risky, because the same people he is challenging have significant influence over the opportunities available to him. In this case, my friend had a strong profile, a decent network of seniors and contacts at consulting firms, and was willing to keep escalating the matter until someone reconsidered the decision. But I genuinely wonder what would have happened to someone with an average profile, no contacts outside the institute and no idea whom to approach. Would that person have simply accepted the penalty and moved on, even if it meant losing out on some of the biggest opportunities of their career?
I would really like to understand how others see this, especially people who have studied at top B-schools, served on placement committees or been involved in campus recruitment. Is there something about how recruiter relationships work that justifies such strict penalties, or have we normalised giving student-run placement bodies far too much discretion over decisions that can significantly affect someone’s career? And shouldn’t there be a transparent appeal mechanism where students can challenge such decisions without worrying about the impact on their placements?
Because irrespective of whether my friend made a mistake by mentioning his PPO rejection publicly, I find it difficult to understand how a situation like this was allowed to reach a point where his placement opportunities were at stake before he had even received an official explanation.