r/ButtSharpies • u/itsFuntosayTitties • Sep 03 '17
I asked my girlfriend if I could fill her ass, she said yes.. 7 is a great start! NSFW
4.7k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Lunasunshine420 • Aug 20 '21
Buried the whole 14 pack! Purchased 16 more tonight for science. NSFW
4.3k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/wupeachyblue • Aug 29 '20
Day 29! This is the last day I can manage, thank you all [f]or your love, support and encouragement ❤️[OC] NSFW
3.1k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/moonbeamgirl69 • Jan 04 '25
[OC] I’m new to this, be gentle please 🥺 NSFW
3.0k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/wupeachyblue • Aug 16 '20
Day 16/31 Who is having as much [f]un as me with Anal August? [OC] NSFW
3.0k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/sweetpeachmagic • Jan 01 '25
[self] new year new personal sharpie record 🍑 NSFW
2.7k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Cptbrd8008 • Jan 09 '25
21! Finally beat my own record 🎉 NSFW
2.7k
Upvotes
Are you proud of me? ☺️
r/ButtSharpies • u/moonbeamgirl69 • Jan 05 '25
[OC] Here is the much requested video NSFW
2.6k
Upvotes
Hope you all enjoy my video as much as I enjoyed making it for all of you. I really appreciate all of the support that this subreddit has given me, it really makes me feel like a naughty little slut🖤
r/ButtSharpies • u/BunniizCultx • Nov 09 '21
Since I’m not allowed to post these on that one website anymore 😔 NSFW
2.6k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/EmieCZ • Dec 23 '24
Merry Christmas, guys! I really pushed myself, stretched my hole to its agonizing limit tonight to give you a 20. 🩷 NSFW
2.5k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/feetonadya • Aug 19 '24
I think I can stick all 12 in my asshole NSFW
2.4k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/SweetCollegeDropOut • Jul 29 '26
I didn’t know if i could manage one in my butt but i’m glad i tried!! NSFW
2.3k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/nekokitty18 • Feb 11 '20
(OC) my first time! My ass is so tight . Ended up fitting 8! NSFW
2.3k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Plzplaywithme • Sep 25 '18
I could only find one which is boring but the angle looks great! NSFW
2.1k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/generic_username_4me • Sep 26 '26
Repost because the first was taken down NSFW
2.1k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/wupeachyblue • Aug 28 '20
Day 27/31 [f] I think this is the last day I can handle! [OC] NSFW
2.0k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/wupeachyblue • Aug 29 '20
Day 28/31 Accidentally did 28 yesterday, [f]igured I could do it again today 🥰 [OC] NSFW
2.0k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/His_phantasmagoria • Apr 22 '26
After playing and stretching myself I think I hit my max, what do y`all think? [OC] NSFW
2.0k
Upvotes
Some of y`all were close, great guesses on my original post, sadly it got removed 😋👏
r/ButtSharpies • u/moonbeamgirl69 • Jan 05 '25
[OC] Couldn’t help coming back for more 🤤 NSFW
1.9k
Upvotes
Maybe if I’m in the mood later I’ll post the video of me pushing them out of my tight ass 😈