r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/kasai_usagi • Feb 26 '25
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/ScarlettMatt • Apr 10 '25
Xander sucked
Okay, new here so don't hate, but I am rewatching Buffy and Xander really was a jerk the whole time. He was more a villain than most of the villains they faced.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/dustman2745 • Mar 29 '25
Write Xander off
I'm in S03 of the show and Xander's character is so awful it almost makes the series unwatchable.
He's so unhelpful, annoying and selfish, I can't name a single redeeming quality!
Had to rant for a second, I'm just so over him
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/HoemanRainbow • Dec 05 '25
Imagining the cast for an all-black Buffy reboot
Why? Why not. I'm thinking Willow Smith as Buffy, Ayo Edebiri as Willow, and Ncuti Gatwa as Xander. Maybe Michael B.Jordan as Angel and Idris Elba as Giles? What do you think?
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Evrey10000 • Jun 10 '26
Angel, don't blame yourself
When i heard them saying Angel i knew i had to do it with my favourite episode. Spoilers to Amends
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Meta76 • Oct 23 '25
Buffy reboot?
I want to know your thoughts? So Sara Michelle Gellar got interviewed this week about Buffy reboot...in my opinion it's not a reboot it's a continuation she mention the new slayer name Nova is her name like passing the torch(stake) to the new slayer. Now I think they said it's a new Sunnydale now? At the series Giles says Cleveland has Hellmouth.Well I think they should do one another country Hellmouth how Japan? Japan artifacts cursed by demonic relics of Japan.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Dramatic-Maybe3294 • Feb 12 '25
What is the consensus on Zander? I personally don’t like him and think he drags down the show lwky??
Idk if he has his little followers but feel free to give me your best take and opinion.
Edit: Sorry for spelling his name wrong yall Im only through season 2.
Anywho thanks for the feedback I’ll def keep an open mind and also see how Wedon negatively might have influenced him.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/That_Juggernaut4820 • May 29 '25
Would you have liked Tarantino to direct an episode of Buffy or Angel?
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/trvxzen • Mar 14 '26
Everyone, we should spam Netflix to pick up the New Sunnydale series revival
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/[deleted] • Feb 06 '25
Buffy slayed because her flaws made her vulnerable and relatable. The 'modern' reboot will just be a slayer 'girl boss' who is never wrong and doesn't need any help.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Amber_Flowers_133 • Dec 24 '25
Did you know that Season 5 of Buffy was originally going to be the Series Finale?
S5 should’ve been the series finale
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/[deleted] • Oct 22 '24
Christianity in the buffy verse
Why isn't Buffy or any or the scoobie an open christian? They have enough proof that it's real considering crosses and holy water work on literal demons haha. It atleast has to be one of the possible heaven dimensions that exist in Buffy.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/deer_bones23 • Jul 28 '26
Does anyone else remember a different actress playing Cordelia in the pilot episode?
After scouring the internet I'm giving up and turning to this sub for, I don't even know, something.
I'll preface this by saying my friend and I got into the show a few months ago now, and are both in early s3 (not relevant to my question, but want to put it out there so there's no spoilers hopefully). Many weeks ago we had a conversation about the show, and talked about how we were both sad to see that Cordelia had been recast after the pilot, and how her original actress had played her differently and made her a bit more interesting as a character.
I'm rewatching the pilot as background noise while I work on some things on my phone, and I looked up because I heard a familiar voice. Cordelia is the same as always, no other pilot actress that both I and my friend remember! I asked him to clarify that that conversation did in fact take place, and sent him a video. We're both incredibly confused! Scoured the internet and can't find a single thing about it.
If it was just me I'd brush it off as me misremembering, but we both remember it. No power of suggestion or anything, we brought it up at the same time!
The only conclusion that we've come to is that it's either a mandela effect, or we just jumped timelines :/ (I'm joking I'm joking, but I am curious to hear what other people have to say!)
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Amber_Flowers_133 • Dec 27 '25
How will they write off Dawn in Buffy New Sunnydale?
There would be no need to include her.
The Dawn character was created as part of an extended storyline in the fifth season and the audience was supposed to “just go with” the fact that Buffy now had a younger sister, had seemingly had one the whole time and that no one else recognized the incongruity of that, including Buffy’s mother and Buffy herself. What transpired later to explain the sudden appearance of Dawn is related to THAT Buffyverse and certainly wouldn’t need to be revisited in any new attempt to revise the series.
An example of this was the fact that other humans existed in the Battlestar Galactica universe of 1978 and that the colonials encountered them on their journey toward Earth.
The 2003 reboot decided to eschew that by showing that other than Pegasus and the civilians that they impressed into their crew, the human race was mostly destroyed when the colonies were attacked. The former storyline was “abandoned” by the reboot, even though it could have added additional depth to the program.
Dawn was a creation by the earlier series and may (or may not) exist in a new series despite the recent and tragic death of her performer, Michelle Trachtenberg.
RIP Michelle Trachtenberg 1985–2025
Any number of ways.
They might not have any references to her at all or they might place her somewhere else, never to be seen in the new show.
They might invent a death for her that happened over the intervening two decades.
They can also cast a different actress who bears a slight resemblance to Michelle Trachtenberg and is 20ish years older than when we last saw Dawn
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Horror_Stress9849 • Oct 19 '25
When Buffy died closing the gate to save Dawn, why wasn’t another Slayer dispatched? In S1 another slayer was dispatched immediately after Buffy’s temporary death. And then there was the other slayer. But none when Buffy died again?
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Amber_Flowers_133 • Dec 17 '25
Why do people like Spike more than Angel?
Spike appeals to many more strongly than Angel because his characterization, arc, and pop-cultural presentation deliver sharper emotional contrasts, clearer growth, and greater moral complexity in a package that’s more charismatic, amusing, and narratively adaptable than Angel’s brooding, often static, noble-savior persona. Why Spike resonates more — key points
Clear, vivid personality
Spike is outspoken, witty, self-aware, mischievous. His dialogue and swagger make him immediately entertaining and quotable.
Angel is earnest, brooding, guilt-driven. That intensity can feel heavy and less accessible over long arcs.
Dramatic moral tension and change
Spike’s arc (villain → reluctant ally → lover → seeking redemption) shows visible, sometimes messy transformation. Audiences enjoy watching a character visibly evolve and make morally ambiguous choices.
Angel’s core conflict—redemption through suffering—stays more consistent; his trajectory is inward and solemn, which can seem static compared with Spike’s swings.
Emotional complexity delivered with levity
Spike pairs depth with humor and self-parody; even when he’s suffering he often frames it with irony, making him easier to empathize with.
Angel’s path foregrounds melancholy and responsibility; empathy requires more patience and investment.
Romantic chemistry and narrative stakes
Spike’s relationship with Buffy is volatile, transgressive, and erotically charged: obsession, rivalry, toxicity, growth. That roller-coaster creates high drama and fan engagement.
Angel’s romance with Buffy is tragic and idealized; its seriousness produces a different, often less titillating, fan response.
Antihero archetype popularity
Contemporary audiences are drawn to antiheroes who break rules and challenge institutions. Spike’s rule-breaking charisma fits modern tastes.
Angel represents the tragic hero—admired but less fashionable in many fan subcultures.
Performer and presentation
James Marsters gave Spike flamboyant physicality, comedic timing, and a rock-star persona that made the character a scene-stealer.
David Boreanaz played Angel with reserved gravity necessary to his role; that restraint reduced moments of surprise or comic relief.
Versatility for storytelling and fandom
Spike comfortably moves between comic episodes, noir, horror, romance, and action, letting writers showcase him in varied tones.
Angel’s tonal consistency binds him to certain story types (redemption drama, moral dilemmas), which narrows the kinds of scenes that spotlight him. Typical examples fans cite
Spike’s witty one-liners and scenes (e.g., sarcastic commentary, self-mocking confessions) that make him loveable even when he does awful things.
The “redemption through love” storyline giving visible, dramatic milestones (chip, soul, small acts of sacrifice) that show measurable change.
Angel’s long, brooding monologues and moral dilemmas that reward patience but don’t produce the same immediate fan gratification. Context and caveats
Preference is subjective: many viewers prefer Angel’s nobility, restraint, and tragic romanticism.
Different fan communities value different traits: Spike dominates in fandom that prizes edge, humor, and antihero complexity; Angel retains strength among fans who prize classic tragic heroism and moral seriousness.
Preferences shift over time: cultural tastes for antiheroes and ironic detachment grew since Buffy’s 1990s/2000s run, benefiting Spike’s reception in retrospect. Conclusion, Spike’s blend of charisma, humor, visible moral change, and flexible storytelling makes him more instantly engaging to broader audiences, while Angel’s solemn, tragic heroism commands admiration but less immediate emotional magnetism. Both succeed for different reasons; Spike’s advantages explain why he’s the more commonly loved figure.
Personally I liked Angel, but he is a bit vanilla. That’s ok to eat on your apple pie, but sometimes you need something more exciting to be the main attraction. When Angel was first introduced he was more mysterious and, let’s face it, very pleasing on the eye. He seemed to have edge. The more we got to know him though he turned out to be a bit of a dork.
That was quite appealing but he lost that edginess. I went from sitting at the edge of my seat wondering what he’d do next, to sitting back and going ‘Aw! He’s adorable!’ It was a slow build up as he was in the background seemingly guiding Buffy. It was like the best horror films with the tension and anticipation—and then the monster was entirely unscary.
And that was kinda ok. Angel was a great contrast with Angelus. Having him be so dorky at times was completely the flip side of the coin to confident, competent, evil Angelus. If Angel had been the mean, moody, uncaring guy we first thought he was it wouldn’t have so shocking to meet Angelus. I did rather miss him and all the speculation about who he was though.
Spike was spiky from the get go, had such a great sense of humour and got some of the best lines. His black humour and wit really appeals to Brits and that crosses to other countries. He’s pretty complex and, as I seem to enjoy contrast, entirely different from the poetry reading idiot he’d been before turning. Didn’t hurt he’s English and has style. And who doesn’t love a bad boy!?!
I know the question didn’t ask this but thought it might shed some light. I was rooting for Angel to stay with Buffy and not Spike. Spike did not bring out the best in her and he wasn’t always his best self with her either. Going back to ice cream flavours, the choices aren’t between vanilla and a dessert laced with ground glass and a touch of arsenic! Maybe a nice raspberry ripple as a transition… Oh, she did that, my bad.
Anyway, it was clever to have Angel revert to Angelus when he experienced pure bliss. Their relationship would have been boring to many viewers and losing Angel made Buffy more vulnerable and added excitement and unpredictability to the series. I think that a lot of people found her relationship with Spike much more appealing as it wasn’t ‘safe’ and definitely not boring.
Hope that answered your question while not necessarily agreeing with which I ‘like’ more. Let’s say that on balance I ‘prefer’ Spike though.
Spike had the bad boy edge. He loved Buffy before he had a soul and that was a unique deal, plus he had a slightly more rounded personality than Angel did before the show ANGEL
Spike is more interesting. I find him a lot more complex than Angel. He’s also not a good guy for a lot of his arc, and when he is, he’s not a traditional good guy. Spike stays pretty much the same throughout in a lot of ways, but there’s more development for him than there is for Angel. Spike is more fun to watch as well.
Angel is pretty predictable, but Spike really isn’t. Spike’s impulsiveness made it hard to guess what he was going to do, and that’s always much more fun than to see it coming a mile away.
There’s also the fact that I generally prefer Buffy as a show over Angel as a show, so I’ve rewatched Buffy far more than Angel. So I’m getting a lot more of Spike as Angel is only in 3 seasons of Buffy plus a few guest spots. Spike is the main villain in season 2, a guest spot in season 3, then in it from season 4 straight through to the end.
When choosing between Spike and Angel, Spike wins for me, hands down. The difficulty comes when choosing between Spike and Angelus, as I truly do love Angelus, he’s an extremely interesting and compelling villain and I was always disappointed that we got so little of him during the two shows.
Because Angel, without a soul, hurts Buffy with a cruelty unmatched by anyone else. Spike, without a soul, still retains some humanity. Angel becomes Angelus and loses all humanity.
Originally, I think it was because Angel had a anti-redemptive arc, and Buffy was in love with him, while Spike was just evil. Once Angel came back….he was sort of one note. (Buffy’s ex, still hot)
Over time, and with better writing, Spike became more complex, and I think people appreciated the character more. Plus, he was a LOT funnier than Angel.
I don’t think there’s a right or wrong here. Angel is pure (either pure evil or pure good), Spike is mostly bad with an occasional diversion into being a hero.
What’s better is up to the viewer.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Ok_Road_7999 • Jan 15 '25
Does Dawn stick around?
I'm doing a first time watch of Buffy and I'm on season 5. Buffy suddenly has this sister named Dawn who was never in the show before - I'm sure there's some magic explanation but they haven't explained it yet. Without spoiling specifically what happens, can someone let me know if she sticks around for the rest of the show? I'm hoping she doesn't because she's unbearably annoying.
As a younger sister myself I feel like I should be in a position to empathize with her more than the average viewer (who may not be a younger sister themself) but she's like every annoying stereotype of little siblings rolled into one. She's obnoxious, she's incapable but constantly complains about not being allowed to do anything, she messes things up for people but never really gets in trouble, and has no understanding of what Buffy sacrifices.
I'm on S5 E5 and she just annoyed the crap out of me twice in a row by (a) taking credit for the breakfast Buffy made for Joyce and (b) telling Riley in front of everyone that Buffy basically called him a weakling she needs to protect, and that she doesn't want him to go patrolling. And then she says, "welcome to the club, she'll never let me go either". Like yes, Dawn, because you'd immediately be killed because you're a random 14 year old with no skills or magic powers.
Please, please, tell me this is a short lived thing like that alternate universe where everyone thought Jonathan was really cool. At least that was funny.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/kasterborous903 • Sep 02 '25
“The Pack” discussion
Idk how Buffy got over what Xander did to her in “The Pack” it was so early in their friendship and I know he was possessed but I would have not been able to get over that for a long time. Like he literally sexually assaulted and attempted to r*pe her. I know it’s a tv show so yeah obviously they aren’t gonna cut Xan but my god I would have not been able to LOOK at him without feeling sick! Hes a great guy but Jesus Christ 😭
EDIT: if yall are gonna take my post out of context and say “oh Xander didn’t know poor him” literally stop and delete your comment I don’t care. Yes I understand Xander didn’t do it on purpose. Yes I understand he was possessed. I don’t think Xander is a bad guy (for this 😒). But you’re genuinely an incel if you think that my opinion on not wanting to be friends with someone who almost raped you is wrong in anyway.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/LiquorRich • Mar 23 '26
Hulu Feedback page - it worked for Lucifer..
Hulu have a feedback form, and you can request a movie or show. This apparently worked on the Lucifer show and got it additional episodes or season(s) just through sheer fandom.
It's not like this hasn't worked before - we got the film Serenity because of the Firefly fandom.
I don't want to break any rules, so I've removed the . from the link below just in case of auto-mod or actual Mod.
I came straight here from the Facebook post that is rallying the fans there. Fingers crossed, we can be back in Sunnydale before you know it.
help.hulu com/feedback?type=request-a-movie-or-show
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/CharlieOak86868686 • Sep 17 '18
Why do people put up with Cordelia being a massive cunt?
She doesn't even understand Buffy has to fight monsters and will probably get killed. Buffy saves her so many times and Cordelia still blames her for problems. Is it supposed to be funny? She goes out of her way to insult Buffy and her friends.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/Adorable-Taro6117 • Dec 23 '25
Where do the slayers go when they die?
I recently watched a video that left me a little doubtful about the idea that when female killers die they go to hell. Honestly, I stopped at season 7 of Buffy the Vampire Slayer, so I haven't read the comics, but I'd like to know if this fact is mentioned in the story.
r/BuffyTheVampireSlayer • u/[deleted] • Sep 06 '25
Season 6 (Yes I hated it…)
Season 6 is one of Buffy’s most polarizing seasons of the television show to date. I myself finished it a couple of years ago, and after a number of rewatches, I don’t ever think you can slam the can of worms shut.
The first and most egregious act of the season is centered around Spikes character. I’ve found numerous accounts online where Joss threatens James to do the r*pe scene, where writer Marti Noxon tries to use the scene cathartically to deal with a bad break up, to all other explanations and the reality is, Spike would have gone to get his soul if it meant he got with Buffy. There was no sexual predation needed in order to set this in order. All the change that Spike had been through in the last 3 seasons leading up to this had been so that the romance subplot between spike and Buffy could be justified. Instead we just watch Buffy mistreat spike because she can’t deal with the fact she fell for another vampire. It makes no sense.
Let’s also acknowledge all the mistreatment for Anya in both seasons 6 and 7. Why?? She’s a literal baby. One of the roses of season 6 was watching the dissolution of the wedding between Anya and Xander. I think it’s fair that someone who came from a dysfunctional family did not want to perpetuate the same behavior onto their partner who had only been a human for about 2/3 years. Though heart breaking it still makes me emotional watching Anya in her perfect dress not accept Xander not marrying her.
So when did willow become a drug addict? I think magic in the Buffy verse was incredibly balanced. Magic happened, there was a source and consequences. But Willow essentially being a magic-addict is only a byproduct of how much she had to do for Buffy against Glory. Moreover, she also had to find a way to get her Partner’s personality back from glory, so that should also be taken into account.
Just some thoughts, what do you guys think?