Feeling very underwhelmed with honestly every state apart from Minnesota. I loved to see everyone pop out to support Renee Good and her family. As someone born and raised in Minnesota and knowing how much they love to rally I wish I could see more done in Montana and specifically bozeman. I want to do more and I’m wondering what I can do here to stir the pot and make some fucking noise for our rightful america who have been run and always will be by immigrants. can’t be illegal on stolen land. we have rights for now and i want to exercise those rights until they’re completely taken away from us. only people i see making noise are in chicago and minneapolis. we should change that.
Is it fun/motivating to go to protests? It seems really stressful and kind of negative so I have never really wanted to go. I guess that I maybe just don't understand it. It doesn't seem to change anything and we don't get to vote on anything until November so I'm trying to figure out what the point is. I also don't like to see all the waste in materials used for signs and chemicals in the printed materials that are destroying our planet.
I have asked a lot of the same questions you do. I don’t have answers but what I do know is that when I went to the No Kings Day protest over the summer I was moved to tears. I think that kind of energy matters in a time where hopelessness is being capitalized on.
There’s not many (big) protests because many Montanans are still okay with what’s happening even though it’s egregious ( i.e these comments ). I’ve notice the only large ones have been ones put on by national chapters like no kings day, and I could tell people traveled. I would love some serious care for organizing around here but I don’t see any marketing for that happening anytime soon. Unfortunately. Unless it starts to get serious I guess
i run the marchonbozeman26 page i post as many protests i hear about locally. if you ever want to put one on reach out to me on there and i will promote it. if you organize people will come, but we dont have trained organizers here (indivisible eh) so its up to individuals. if you need advice ive put on many.
This is a fairly illuminating thread about what's going around the MAGERNET. It has the intellectual engagement of a kindergartener, but it's still interesting
Stir the pot … gotcha … if you want and feel bad about what’s going on in Minnesota, then why not drive there and do something ?? Protesting a local government over an issue in another state is asinine
This isn’t just a Minnesota issue, this is a national crisis. What happened to Renee Good was only nationally broadcasted because she was a white woman. Deadly interaction with ice have been happening everywhere but no one talks about it because they’re people of color.
There are probably a lot of other people who feel the same you do: Passionate but feeling isolated due to where they live. It would take a lot of courage to do this, but finding a public space and doing a demonstration by yourself might encourage others to also share their views. I've seen a lot of videos like this on tiktok of people being brave in red states/areas and I think this takes more balls than going to a protest with a bunch of people.
Montana girl here, my ancestors came here to get away from big government over 160 yrs ago. My family is full of Libertarians, Republicans and Democrats. My grandfather, received purple hearts, told my Dad so we could have the freedom of voting or not, protesting, and having the voice to speak out. Most of Libertarians and Republicans in my family are very disturbed by what’s going on. SMALLER government You should be too!
Just when you think “only someplace else” some woketard comes in and tries to make a wonderful place into the same shithole they came from! Fuck off and go back!
They are neither law enforcement NOR are they actually upholding any laws. They're arresting US citizens. Take your little hate party somewhere else...
It’s so ironic how the party that was celebrating getting vaxxed for a flu 4 times, calling the police on their neighbors for going to churches and beaches, and filling skateparks with truck loads of sand is now calling the other side bootlickers lmao.
I mean- yall were GLEEFULLY cheering for people to lose their jobs, be ostracized, harassed, discriminated against (vaccine passports/cards) for refusing the tax.
Yall were foaming at the mouth for mandatory lock downs.
But hey.
None of that really is relevant.
What happened happened because she rammed her car into an ICE agent.
The exact same thing would happen to me if I decided to go obstruct your local police department and ram my car into a local cop.
First responder here. Disregarding your gross misinterpretation of what happened in the video, literally every single one of us has been trained not to stand in front of running vehicles. We went over that day 1 of EMT. With any trained professional that situation would've never happened in the first place.
Everywhere ive worked with police they are trained never to shoot at a vehicle like that because it goes out of controll once the driver dies.
No first responder would ever let a scene degrade like that. Especially conisdering that they had her on camera and her liscense plate. It was entirely caused by ice being incompetent.
The situation would've never happened with actual first responders.
Oh please for the love of god tell me what about the video im "misinterpreting". Like what specifically.
Funny thing is he wasnt even really standing in front of her vehicle until she did a 3 point turn and decided to drive straight into him.
And even if he "wasnt supposed to be standing there"- that doesnt mean his right to not be rammed into with a car is suddenly forfeit.
An attractive woman arguably shouldnt be walking alone at night through back alleys but if someone put her in a bad situation and she ended up having to defend herself I wouldnt be saying "oh, sorry hun youre going to jail. You shouldn't have been there".
I highly doubt youre a first responder.
And if you are, I have even more doubt its anything to do with law enforcement.
As for "letting the scene degrade". Are you high? The FUCK do you think they should have done?
Oh they should have had a crystal ball and known shed crashout like that?
In what clownworld do THEY bear responsibility for her actions but she doesnt.
I mean watch the video again. She was talking to the ICE dude who was trying to open the door. Another one was telling her to move the car. And a third walking in front of the car while she was distracted and being told to move. She turned the car away from him, clipped him lightly enough that while standing on ice he stayed on his feet and held onto his phone he was filming with.
He then caps her and she falls on the accelerator. The way she accelerates would have killed him if thay was her goal.
The shooter doesnt bear responsibility for her actions he bears responsibility for his own.
As for whether or not you belive im a first responder, I could really care less. Doesn't change anything for me.
You make it out like she was being downright friendly and compliant when that isnt the case. At all.
She parked her car sideways in the road to block them.
She was initially told to move. She didnt. They tried to yank her out of the car.
See heres the thing. You can protest all you want. What you dont get to do is deliberately try to prevent law enforcement from doing their jobs.
See let's say the DEA decided to crack down on dispensaries around here right?
And i didnt like that. I considered it a violation of state sovereignty and an oppressive affront to individual liberty.
I can hold my little signs. I can yell things. I can call them names on social media. What I certainly cant do though is park my car sideways in the road in front of them when theyre trying to conduct official business.
And if they try to apprehend me for deliberately obstructing them, I certainly dont get to ram my car into them.
She does a 3 point turn as her wife yells "drive baby, drive!".
Agent didn't even draw his gun let alone fire until she accelerated into him-
Its not like she just got domed and her dead weight foot just happened to land on the accelerator.
And if you want to argue about this we can hold hands and watch the video together frame by frame.
As for officer's injuries-
He was hit hard enough to have internal bleeding. He was almost knocked off his feet.
Something you dont seem to understand about deadly force law is how much injury you actually receive isnt the deciding factor.
What matters is, in the totality of the circumstances, a reasonable fear of death or grave bodily harm.
You can be in reasonable fear of death or grave bodily harm, and not suffer a scratch, and still be justified. Examples:
A bad guy kicks down your door waving a knife around threatening to kill you. You shoot him in the face, he drops dead, youre untouched.
Someone is shooting at you, but they miss repeatedly. You fire back in self defense and dont miss.
Someone knocks you to the ground, gets on top of you, and starts beating you. You cant adequately defend yourself or fight back at least not with fists. You cant escape either. You shoot them and "only" get some minor injuries.
Someone commits armed robbery. Waving a gun around in people's faces. Someone, maybe a concealed carry permit holder maybe an off duty cop, shoots them.
Hell maybe on top of not actually "hurting" anyone, the gun turns out to be fake.
In every example I just gave, a reasonably prudent person in their shoes, knowing what they knew at the time, would be in reasonable fear of death or grave bodily harm.
Theres plenty of established case law/legal precedent for every scenario i just mentioned.
A vehicle absolutely meets the threshold. Yeah. Someone MIGHT get lucky and walk away from getting hit by a car or they might not. Its still freaking dangerous.
As for you not being a first responder.
First of all its one thing to be uninformed but its another to be a liar.
And yeah, I think youre a liar.
I think at BEST you might be.. some kind of first responder. And rather than be honest about what that entails youre leaving it vague on purpose to imply you have more credibility than you actually do. An EMT (for example) wouldnt inherently know any more about the judicious use of deadly force than a cashier at Burger king.
And at "worst" you arent one period. At all. Not medical not fire not law enforcement. Nothing.
"yall"? you mean the loudest 1 % of the internet? i never celebrated anyone losing their job. No one i know did. It was just obnoxious people on social who did that cuz theyre crazy or rage baiting viral trends. your generalization of the left is about as poorly formed as those dumb cartoons you think are pwning the libs.
And regardless, there was a big movement that did the same thing happened to anyone hinting at anything other than grief about charlie kirk. The lat night host even got briefly canceled since trump sues any media who feels hurt by. you have no leg to stand on
Basically every lefty state government yall could get away with it.
Lefty media.
Social media/reddit as a matter of policy.
Its as disingenuous as it is stupid to sit here and pretend you dont know what a generalization is or that "oh gee there was only like one person ever who fits what im talking about".
You can stand on my third leg how about that? Both inches of it.
If you cant even be intellectually honest give me one good reason its worth taking you seriously
But why are you making me answer for them? Just because we agree that Renee Goode shouldn’t have been shot?
You’re having a conversation with me, not celebrities or the Biden administration. It’s about bozeman and whether we should support community organization and engagement through protest. Not about left vs right nationally. Thats the type of psyop divisiveness that authoritarians love to instill in the public. That your neighbors are the same people they flout on tv
I have no problem with generalizing, but I do have a problem with trying to make me answer for people I don’t associate or agree with.
whats even more ironic is the people calling us bootlickers are the same people who think we need a ministry of truth to decide what speech is or isnt allowed.
Conspiracy theories are simplistic at the core, which is why MAGA clings to them so readily. Science and the truth are often more complex and require a level of logic and education.
Organisations across the country are calling on people across the country to join a nationwide day of action against ICE terror on January 20, to walk out and show up on the streets. More info here: https://www.freeameri.ca/
The ICE mass deportation efforts and all of the violence and scare tactics are being pushed out by potus, admin officials, and on official social media accounts. It’s state policy, they are bragging about it and showing off. But maybe someone just hacked all their accounts for the last year? Hmmmmm
Being butthurt about ICE operations doesnt mean Renee had the right to deliberately obstruct an active ICE operation.
If the feds decided to crack down on state-legal Marijuana dispensaries I wouldnt approve of that, but that wouldnt give me the right to go fuck with the DEA either.
And it certainly didnt give her the right to ram her car into an agent.
Omg you are arguing the dumbest semantics. Do you really want to throw shade on protestors because it sounds like that’s what this is about? Why does that matter? Take your own advice and don’t make assumptions about the post and just respond to the verifiable content in it. Maybe you’ll understand if I put it this way: your assumptions ≠ facts
Honestly it just sounds like you like being a wet blanket
And besides, if you want clear, verifiable answers, that’s even MORE reason to protest. The govt is completely shutting out all normal procedures for investigations, and shut out local law enforcement investigators. Why have the 3 top fed ags in Minnesota resigned? Because of how badly they are bungling the investigation. Theres no way we will ever get a full, honest understanding of what happened UNLESS we make noise.
Maybe you are just really behind. The shit being protested is literally the stuff the government is bragging about now and then make dumb memes on ai and post on official government accounts.
Should I wait for an investigation to find out if all of that was real and it wasn’t just a mistake or something?
Do you think people want to rally because Renee Goode? No one has even mentioned her name in this entire thread, and this is a conversation I’ve seen crop up on this sub every couple weeks long before that happened.
Maybe you just have a bunch of assumptions about the protesters that aren’t true. You sound like your conception of the protestors is whatever your algorithms are telling you
Just a heads up the Cats Victory parade starts at 10am Saturday from the stadium, down 11th, down main, up highland, back down Kagy to the stadium. Saying this because I would hate for the effort to be overshadowed by the parade!
It will. I know it. You disintegrate your own movement from the inside, every single time, and you'll do it again. The many lonely people who want to help? You'll scare them away again. And that's why your protest will fail.
In the end, what destroys you won't be Trump, or ICE, or billionaires, but your own hand.
Say why I'm wrong. You can't. Because you know it's the truth. And that's what makes your movement the most pathetic movement ever. You started with a good cause, but you have been overcome by your own thirst for others' pain.
Oh my lord you are truly miserable, touch some grass and get some actual mental help. Reddit’s not the place. CHP has a sliding scale you can check out if you can’t afford it.
I wouldn't necessarily blame the migrants for you losing your job. It's the owners who want to pay less and not pay taxes. But, good you are wanting and able to protest. Thank you
You need to file an osha report for an unsafe work environment and a complaint with the secretary of state's office over the illegal operation of that business if thats the case. If more people started doing that it'd start bringing whats happened to you to a stop.
15
u/makingmagic2023 Jan 15 '26
Protest by yourself! That's what I've been doing in Pierre, South Dakota!