r/Boxing • Moses Itauma > Every Current HW • 8d ago

Fantasy LHW Tournament - Round 1: (2017) Adonis Stevenson vs (1981) Matthew Saad Muhammad

Thanks to moderator u/_Sarcasmic_ for giving me the greenlight in starting this fantasy tournament up: (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/wKpd93kEcC)

I will be conducting a tournament containing some of the best LHWs of recent years. I purposely did not add any fighters in from before the 80s due to limited footage.

Two fights will be posted daily and the winners will move on until we have a champion.

Lastly, the fighters were not manually matched. All names were put into a randomizer and refreshed 3 times, then the bracket was made from where they were set after the third shake.

----------------------------------

#RULES

• Due to there being no poll option, winner will be decided through reasonable comments. Just simply commenting “___ wins” will not suffice and answers will have to be somewhat detailed (atleast 2 sentences).

• If there is a tie between voting comments for both competing fighters, the very most upvoted comment will be the deciding factor on which fighter moves on.

• Voting is concluded after 24 hours

• Each fighter has a year attached to their name. The year is only a suggestion for when you should consider them at their best. If you believe the mentioned fighter has a different peak, you may debate in their favor using a different time period, but it has to be when they were at Light Heeavyweight.

• The fighters are only credited with wins they have at LHW and any weight class they competed at before moving up to LHW. Any fights from a higher weight class should not be taken into consideration.

• All fighters will be at their absolute peaks for their time periods so there will be no illness/sickness, weight draining problems, or disqualifications.

----------------------------------

#Notable Wins

Adonis Stevenson: Chad Dawson, Tavoris Cloud, Tony Bellew

Matthew Saad Muhammad: Marvin Johnson, Yaqui Lopez, Murray Sutherland

----------------------------------

Tournament Bracket (https://challonge.com/dhh2vlaf)

----------------------------------

Next Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/osn6iFbnYW)

8 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/MiddleweightMonster I’ll pour honey on my GOAT, if the occasion calls for it. 8d ago

MSM was a dog, but my instinct cat is Adonis Stevenson, as I think his resume is just consistently at a higher level. Stevenson by points

3

u/KingBumiOfOmashu Moses Itauma > Every Current HW 8d ago

Do you think Stevenson’s kind of average footwork helps him last the whole 12 against MSM’s famous left hook?

1

u/MiddleweightMonster I’ll pour honey on my GOAT, if the occasion calls for it. 8d ago

Not necessarily, but I think Stevenson has other defensive answers to the hook. I think it would be a very boring “big puncher vs boxer” fight

6

u/VacuousWastrel 8d ago

Don't know if I'd agree on the resume. MSM had to run a gauntlet. He debuted in the annual rankings in 1978 at #2; by that time he had already beaten the #4 (Yaqui Lopez), the #5 (Marvin Johnson, future champion), and the #6 (Mate Parlov, future champion), as well as Richie Kates, who had been #5 a year earlier (and #3 the year before that). He would also go on to beat the #3 (John Conteh, former champion) and the #9 (vonzell johnson), giving him half the rankings as his victims. He would also go on to beat ranked opponents Lotte Mwale, Jerry Martin and Murray Sutherland. All in just five years! Stevenson, by contrast, certainly has better headliners on his resume: Dawson and Cloud. But there's not a lot else. Bellew and Fonfara are his only other ranked wins, and both were only #7, and only very briefly ranked in that division. Doesn't mean Stevenson was worse than Muhammad, but his resume is less "consistently" high level in my opinion.

4

u/Complete_Dare_4201 8d ago

Stevenson starts fast, hurts Saad Muhammad. Saad Muhammad endures the early onslaught and gets him by the mid rounds to late rounds. I don't see how Stevenson keeps Matthew off him as he slows down and his left hand becomes more and more predictable.

It would be kind of a replay of Saad Muhammad vs. Marvin Johnson

3

u/_Sarcasmic_ No Carty No Divey 8d ago

❤️

2

u/Formal-Cherry6078 8d ago

I’m gonna say Stevenson 52/48 he nacks the early rounds and wins a couple of late ones to get a decision

I think Stevenson would hurt him early with the straights to keep him at bay but would have some scares in the later rounds but pull through and get a decision