r/Boxing • u/KingBumiOfOmashu Moses Itauma > Every Current HW • 8d ago
Fantasy LHW Tournament - Round 1: (2013) Bernard Hopkins vs (2025) David Benavidez
Thanks to moderator u/ _Sarcasmic_ for giving me the greenlight in starting this fantasy tournament up: (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/wKpd93kEcC)
I will be conducting a tournament containing some of the best LHWs of recent years. I purposely did not add any fighters in from before the 80s due to limited footage.
Two fights will be posted daily and the winners will move on until we have a champion.
Lastly, the fighters were not manually matched. All names were put into a randomizer and refreshed 3 times, then the bracket was made from where they were set after the third shake.
----------------------------------
#RULES
• Due to there being no poll option, winner will be decided through reasonable comments. Just simply commenting “___ wins” will not suffice and answers will have to be somewhat detailed (atleast 2 sentences).
• If there is a tie between voting comments for both competing fighters, the very most upvoted comment will be the deciding factor on which fighter moves on.
• Voting is concluded after 24 hours
• Each fighter has a year attached to their name. The year is only a suggestion for when you should consider them at their best. If you believe the mentioned fighter has a different peak, you may debate in their favor using a different time period, but it has to be when they were at Light Heeavyweight.
• The fighters are only credited with wins they have at LHW and any weight class they competed at before moving up to LHW. Any fights from a higher weight class should not be taken into consideration.
• All fighters will be at their absolute peaks for their time periods so there will be no illness/sickness, weight draining problems, or disqualifications.
----------------------------------
#Notable Wins
Bernard Hopkins: Antonio Tarver, Kelly Pavlik, Jean Pascal
David Benavidez: Oleksandr Gvozdyk, David Morrell, Anthony Yarde
----------------------------------
Tournament Bracket (https://challonge.com/dhh2vlaf)
----------------------------------
Previous Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/tSK2PYWKsq)
Next Post (https://www.reddit.com/r/Boxing/s/oKENt3BNbB)
4
u/Ruainari 50-0 in these comments sections 8d ago
Benavidez ✊✊👹👹🚩🚩👹👹
1
u/KingBumiOfOmashu Moses Itauma > Every Current HW 8d ago
Any reasoning?
3
u/Ruainari 50-0 in these comments sections 8d ago
Hand speed, look how much trouble Calzaghes gave him
2
u/RRR04_ 8d ago
2013 Hopkins was old lol. Still a competent fighter I guess but he lost to Kovalev a year later and just lost to Chad Dawson. Benavidez takes this version of B-Hop.
1
u/KingBumiOfOmashu Moses Itauma > Every Current HW 8d ago
Per the rules in the post, if you think the fighter had a different peak year, then you may argue in that favor, but it has to be at LHW.
4
u/VacuousWastrel 8d ago
Old Hopkins was good and had a lot of success and shjouldn't be written off. But Benavidez is a bad matchup: pressure, size (Benavidez, who is talking abhout HW soon, is massively bigger than Hopkins) and hand speed aren't a good combination to face when you're old. But then why are we talking about 2013 Hopkins anyway? How about 2007 Hopkins? Wins over Tarver and Wright, and about to dismantle Pavlik? Still smart, but much less.old. The loss to Calzaghe shows he's still beatable... But Calzaghe was cagier and smarter than Benavidez, and he had faster hands, and it was still a competitive fight. And Calzaghe had the chin to bounce back up when Hopkins dropped him. On the other hand the Plant fight shows that Benavidez isn't unstoppabnle against a smart stylist... And Hopkins wouldn't gas out. I think I'd probably take 2007 Hopkins over Benavidez. Hopkins has also proven his adapability and ability to make changes during a fight against a much larger, better and more diverse set of opponents than Benavidez has faced.
2
u/WORD_Boxing Don't push the horses 8d ago
The Calzaghe fight is a good analogy in terms of a guy whjo throws a lot of punches vs Bhop. Benavidez won't be slapping though.
3
2
u/ThurstonTheMagician 8d ago
B-Hop at 175 was more than willing to stink up the joint but that’s why I would expect him to lose to Benavidez. Getting anywhere in a clinch near David is a one ticket to getting your face blended. If they were at 160 different story I’d expect Hopkins to bury David with body shots.
1
u/WORD_Boxing Don't push the horses 8d ago
Hopkins was too old at LHW.
I wouldn't bother including him in a tounrament like this unless it's for Middleweights to be honest.
7
u/MiddleweightMonster I’ll pour honey on my GOAT, if the occasion calls for it. 8d ago
Gotta be Benavidez. 2005 B-Hop takes this, but in 2013 he was having a lot of trouble old-manning guys