r/BookPromotion • • Sep 14 '26

Book4Book

I am proposing to help and support of others who are in need of getting their name out there in the world. I buy a copy of your book and you buy a copy of one of my books and both of us leave honest reviews on Amazon. Serious inquire. I would love this kind of feedback and ability to support other authors.

https://a.co/d/0hky3qnB

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

6

u/ArcReaderHub Sep 14 '26

This would be a review swap, Amazon will delete the review and could create problem for you so be careful

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

Even if it’s an honest review after I read their book?

2

u/dragonsandvamps Sep 14 '26

It isn't an honest review if it's a review swap. Tell me, are you really planning to leave a 1-star of someone you know is reading your book and may 1-star you in return if they don't like your rating? Of course you aren't! These swaps always result in everyone 5-starring each other, and Amazon knows it. You will both get your reviews deleted and your accounts flagged. Don't do this.

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

I absolutely would give a one star for a book if I believed it wasn’t written well or didn’t end good enough etc. There are real published authors like Holly Jackson whose work I believe is quite awful. By honest, that is what I mean and what I want. I am not asking for five stars either. If someone doesn’t like my work, I want to know why so I could use that to improve. I actually value negative feedback more.

1

u/dragonsandvamps Sep 14 '26

As long as the ratings you are receiving are balanced i.e. you are receiving 1s, 2s, 3s and not just 4s and 5s, maybe you get away with it.

If you are getting all 4s and 5s and the rare 3, no, Amz isn't going to consider these "honest" reviews. The biggest authors on their site get 1s 2s and 3s so they are expecting no name self publishers to get those ratings, too. When you're only getting 4s and 5s, it flags their system, and they take a closer look. That's why sometimes you see people say their cousin reviewed or whatever and they didn't get caught. They may not have had enough reviews to get noticed. If you get enough positive reviews, and aren't getting negative reviews, the math doesn't math for amazon, and eventually they look closer.

2

u/ArcReaderHub Sep 14 '26

Amazon Algo will only check if review exchange has happened and delete it. Algo does not care if it's honest or anything. If it happens multiple times they also ban the account so it's safe to not do it.

2

u/South-Knee-9601 Sep 14 '26

Yeah that sucks.

I had to explain to a friend this who wanted to leave a review.

The only way you can realistically get around that is a proxy purchase.

So one of his friends that I do not know at all or work colleague buys it for him. And then gives it to my friend who writes the review and then gives the review to his friend to paste into Amazon a month later.

It's janky and a pain but that way isn't traceable

2

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

That is absurd… the system thinks its unacceptable if a friend purchases, reads and reviews? I guess I have to rely on strangers and get nowhere 🤷‍♀️🤦🏼‍♀️ thank you for letting me know this. Was unaware of how janky technology has gotten.

1

u/dragonsandvamps Sep 14 '26

Friends are not "honest reviews." Your mom will not leave an "honest review." Come now. Do you really expect your mom to leave you a 1-star and tell you that your pacing sucks and your book was boring so she dnf'ed? Of course not. She's going to leave you a 5-star even if the book is terrible. All family and friend reviews are fake. So are reviews swaps. That's why Amz doesn't allow this. If you need reviews, work on sales, or if the book isn't live yet, put it up for ARC reviews.

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

Dude if I could get my mom to read any of my books then that would be a plus. She actually did read my third and complained it wasn’t executed properly and I valued that feedback very much.

1

u/South-Knee-9601 Sep 14 '26

Yeah like if they order the book at your house

WiFi or not there's like a geocache thing when the purchase is made so they know your in the same address or that the author is at.

It's proper anal stuff

2

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

Wow really? I am so behind on technology these days. I grew up very poor and never conformed to new things well. Im 32 but might as well have been born in the 50s… that is just so discouraging. I can understand the logic to an extent but seems extremely excessive in preventing people from success. Especially when we are all just struggling to survive. I don’t need to become the next Frieda McFadden. I just like know my work is enjoyed by others and finding other people to support in exchange. There is a lot of work out there unseen that deserves proper recognition. Thank you for your input.

1

u/South-Knee-9601 Sep 14 '26

Maybe consider Ingram spark or a traditional publishing house

Neither are that worried about it compared to Amazon

1

u/Simple-Ring2073 Sep 14 '26

Amazon knows everything,. If there is any sort of exchange for a review then Amazon is in violation of the Federal trade commission. So they're extra cautious and will delete you. 

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

That is very disheartening.. My intentions are to help support other self published authors not play the system..thanks for sharing.

1

u/Simple-Ring2073 Sep 14 '26

I had One removed because I'm friends on social media with them

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

That is ridiculous.. thank you for letting me know this.

1

u/The-CarlBanatte Sep 14 '26

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

I added The Weight of Iron to my cart. As soon as I have another interested person I will place the order. (I don’t have Prime right now and need to add more to cart for free shipping). Excited to read it!

1

u/QuirkyQuills13 Sep 14 '26

I want to join but shipping is too costly :(
You're doing a good thing!

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

I understand. By any chance can you tell me which state you are located in? I have been on a mission to have my books across the country and have mailed out some complimentary copies to people who have placed my books in LFLs local to their area. I am currently in 31 states! If you’re in a state I haven’t reached yet maybe I can send you a copy or two.

1

u/QuirkyQuills13 Sep 14 '26 • Heartwarming

I'm in southern asia...don't go through too much trouble though

2

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

Love that you have an interest from so far away!

1

u/xemeraldxinxthexskyx Sep 14 '26

Your book actually has a bit of a similar premise to mine! DM me?

1

u/KrookedBlue Sep 14 '26

Hi! I am not able to message you for some reason it brings me to a NSFW page.

1

u/rocks1976 Sep 15 '26

My sister bought a copy of my book and wanted to leave a review. I told her not to. I wasn’t thinking about Amazon spotting the same last name. I was thinking potential readers would see it in the reviews.

1

u/indieauthor13 Sep 16 '26

Review swaps are against Amazon's TOS