r/Bogleheads • • Apr 18 '22

Investment Theory A good argument for having bonds in a retirement portfolio

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Bogleheads • • Feb 16 '24

Man, this Roth IRA compound interest thing works really quick

0 Upvotes

Just a month ago in early January I opened up a Roth IRA retirement account (VFIFX) and maxed out 2023/2024. Already in 1 month time I check the balance on Vanguard and I already have $200 more than when I started. I know it can go up or down, but I already got $200 "for free" in 1 month time.

I can't imagine what it'll grow after a full year and of course I intend to max out my Roth every year once 2025 becomes available and onward.


r/Bogleheads • • Sep 26 '22

The Case AGAINST International Indexing

7 Upvotes

International diversification has been thrown around a lot as it's an obvious choice. I don't think it is.

Firstly, John C. Bogle was firmly against it. And he is literally the one who invented international index funds in the first place. He mentioned them being more risky, the added currency risks, and some country specific weaknesses. While the U.S. economy is already well diversified, the most entrepreneurial, and already very international. He also mentioned the stability in the past of the U.S. government, the USD, and financial governance. (Ref: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y2A_lAHcozM and https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P54trh0Rre8).

Then, the devil is in the details. Nowadays, the most valuable ex-US stocks are Saudi (or French-Saudi-related) oil companies and Chinese companies. Outside of obvious moral considerations, both governments (a Royalty and a Communist regime) are authoritarian enough to take back full ownership of these companies at any political whim. They don't have the legal guarantees for you or Vanguard to secure foreign share ownerships.

Outside of these, whatever international pie left is small. Promising EU and ex-US companies are unfortunately rare. And, anyway, it doesn't even mean US funds will be missing out on them. Their founders will be either moving to the U.S. (like Elon Musk did), get acquired by U.S. companies, or be so much intertwined in the U.S. economy that the exposure is already there.

Finally, foreign capital is way more home-country captive than U.S. capital. Taxes, regulations, and just market offerings make it way more complicated to buy U.S. stocks from France than the reverse. So, we can assume foreign stock markets are inflated compared to what it will be in a free economy.

My point is this subreddit shouldn't advise international exposure as an automated advice. But, should stick to Bogle advices, VTSAX/VFIAX and some VBTLX. Ex-US dividends chasings seem very short sighted.


r/Bogleheads • • Oct 10 '25

Investing Questions Twenty Years Ago, our family should have followed a logical Bogleheads approach and invested our inheritance (It cost us nearly 2 Million Dollars!)

0 Upvotes

Most people, when they a given an unexpected lump sum of money, will squander it in a very short period of time. Our family did twenty years ago, and to this day, I still feel sad about it.

In 2005, my Aunt died and left lots of money to a large number of friends and relatives in her will. I got about $250,000. Other relatives got over a million. My Aunt was very rich. (No living husband, children, or siblings a the time of her death)

When the check for the money arrived, I was a family man with a wife and teenage children. We were living an upper-middle-class lifestyle and were living a good life with money left over after all the bills were paid. But my wife suddenly went wild and was like a kid in a candy store. The kids spent hours finding things they wanted to buy and places they wanted to travel to. My wife put together a list of vacation destinations all over the world and insisted we travel first class at 5 Star Hotels. She bought lots of stuff, including lots of furniture and a completely new wardrobe. In two years, the money was gone.

Those two years were the most exciting time we ever had in the family. What an experience!

If we had saved the money and invested it in the S&P 500, that $250K would now be worth almost 2 million Dollars. I asked our two sons, now in their 30s, if it would have been better if we saved and invested the the $250K so they could inherit the 2 Million + when we die. Now in their 30s, they are more mature with Mom and Dad's money, and they now say we should have saved and invested most of the money from Aunt Gert. They don't remember much about those two years.

I am now retired with a million in my IRAs and a nice pension. But we could have had lots more $$.

How much of the $250K inheritance should we have saved and invested?


r/Bogleheads • • Feb 21 '26

The Math Against the Adding Bonds the Five Years Before Retirement Idea

0 Upvotes

Lately, I've seen a fair number of posts regarding adding bonds to an investment porfolio five years before retirement. The move is to theorietically get ahead of the curve before retirement to build up a bond balance, so that if the market dives right before you are ready to retire, you are still set.

It sounds good in practice. Reality is different.

Let's get the disclaimer out of the way. I am a 100% stock person. I do not believe individuals, particularly in the accumulation phase, should own bonds, because there is no value to owning 5% assets when you can own the 10% assets. I have heard all of the reasons why people hold bonds, and find those reasons lacking.

In retirement, individuals should hold mostly stocks with some cash equivalents to cover potential market downturns. That idea I originally read in columns by Jonathan Clements (RIP) in the WSJ about 25 years ago. In 2013, Warren Buffett stated his wife's estate would be 90% in an index fund (like the 500) and the other 10% in cash equivalents. In 2016 Professor Javier Estrada did research to validate this approach. The Cederburg study in 2025 validates a 100% stock approach, with an exception for those who follow the 4% rule and increase the amount by inflation; that exception carves out an amount of cash equivalents starting at age 65 and phased out by 70.

To accompany this post, I created this google sheet that models the idea of adding bonds (or any fixed investment) to a 100% stock portfolio. For purposes of this illustration, I assumed the stocks to return 10% and the other (bonds and/or cash) to return 4%.

If you wish to use it, you can change three variables; the percentage of bonds, the starting investment, and the Fire Goal. Those three are in gray. The rest is all formula driven. It all assumes no reinvestment. Each pot of money is calculated independently.

I chose $2 MM as the starting point with a $4 MM goal because I saw a post on a FIRE board asking whether the poster should start adding to bonds (targeting 20%) with a 7 to 10 year FIRE target. My answer was no, for essentially two reasons. One, doing so means less in retirement, and second, if the market drops at your planned retirement date, you aren't retiring anyway, because you won't be at your FIRE goal, and the bonds aren't going to save you.

The google sheet proves that point. Here is the absolute truth in today's DIY retirement world. You cannot build a retirement portfolio in 2026 without relying on stocks, assuming you are starting from scratch. Bonds have a little over a 1% real return, so one cannot invest enough to build a retirement nest egg. Like it or not, the only path to a secure retirement portfolio through financial assets is to own stocks.

The worksheet has a 10 year projection, using the assumed average returns. Yes, I know in reality it's a roller coaster and not a straight line, but over longer periods the averages work out. Every year after the first, the difference between the 100% stock and the stock/bond blend grows in dollars and as a percentage. That is the nature of compound returns.

As that difference grows, so does the breakeven market decline percentage. Column K shows the breakeven point for a stock market decline so that the 100% stock and the stock/bond blends are the same. For example, in cell K20, the breakeven point after year 5 is -24.46%; that is, for any decline less than 24.46% the 100% stock portfolio does better, and vice versa. Any decline greater than 24.46% the mixed portfolio does better. You can see the numbers by year. By year ten, with the 80/20 mix, the decline breakeven point is -42.93%.

Again, these are the breakeven points. Any declines LESS than those, the 100% portfolio does better.

And therein lies the rub. The investor wants to protect against a market downturn at the end, and buys their chosen level or bonds (or cash) in advance to protect against that. However, at the levels of market declines needed to hit the breakeven point, the individual CANNOT retire, because they are far short of their FIRE goal. The investor who bought bonds to protect against that almost 43% downturn at the end is still $1 MM short of their goal. The bonds did not save them because the math does not work.

That investor can only FIRE when the market rebounds, and the 100% investors rebound will be greater than the blend. And for any declines less than the breakeven level, the 100% investor is always better off. because they have a greater asset balance.

Individuals have zero control over future stock market returns. None. You can do all the Monte Carlo testing you like but there is only one (unknown) result and the investor has no control over it. But we know from results of the last fifty years in bonds they cannot build wealth, and only stocks can (amongst financial investment assets). To use the poker term, an investor is "pot committed" to stocks. As such, the best course of action--like the Cederburg study clearly shows, or a simple model like this one I built--is to own 100% stocks in the accumulation phase (and those should be large market index funds, IMO).

Make a copy of the sheet, play with it yourself. Change the three inputs, and see where you stand. Note, I could have screwed things up, but I think I got it right. But the conclusion is clear; if you want your five years in bonds or cash or any combination, there is really no value doing it five years out.


r/Bogleheads • • Dec 03 '24 Take My Silver

Investing Questions Downvoted on r/investing for mentioning VOO

0 Upvotes

I am a new college grad who is getting into investing. From my research , broad market index funds seem like a generally good investment long term.

I commented something on the sub where I said "I'm a new grad and only focusing on VOO for now" and got like 90 downvotes , so I ended up deleting the comment.

Does anyone have any idea why this happened? Do Index Funds have a bad reputation now?


r/Bogleheads • • 19d ago

Caution - Fidelity horror story

52 Upvotes

I have been a loyal Fidelity customer for more than 20 years and have always trusted them recommended them to people looking for a safe place to keep their money. Unfortunately, that all ended today.

Background: In Sept 2025 I established a 72t SEPP automatic withdrawal plan for my IRA. I wanted them to automatically process only the first year's withdrawal, and I would manually process all subsequent withdrawals. The 2025 withdrawal went fine. I then manually processed my 2026 withdrawal in Feb. When I logged onto my account a few weeks ago they had taken a second full withdrawal, which breaks my 72t and exposes me to roughly $26K in IRS penalties.

Relevant facts: I was unsure how to fill out their automatic withdrawal form to accomplish my goals so I contacted my Fidelity Private Client advisor. I asked him in writing: "I set the start date as 9/17/25 and left end date blank, so this year fidelity will process the withdrawal and I will manually withdraw all future years. Just confirming that's how you guys will handle it."

My advisor responded: "Regarding the start and end date, I confirmed that this is correct, and you can adjust or stop the auto plan and switch to manual."

I subsequently went to a Fidelity branch office to fax the form, and a rep there went through the entire form with me to confirm it was filled out correctly. She also incorrectly confirmed that the way I filled it out would accomplish what I wanted.

Fidelity has since refused to reverse the transaction despite their representative advising me to complete the form incorrectly.

I have filed complaints with FINRA and the SEC, and will be filing for FINRA arbitration. I will also be closing my accounts, my wife's accounts, and my family accounts and transferring the assets to a reliable broker.

For anyone considering trusting your money to Fidelity, I'd highly advise you to reconsider. If this can happen to a HNW client, it can certainly happen to you.


r/Bogleheads • • May 12 '26

HSA receipt banking doesnt seem worth it, ever. Nor does just holding it forever.

0 Upvotes

Say you have enough money that you genuinely have the option to decide whether or not to pay out of pocket with current dollars or use an HSA.

This means that functionally, you are deciding whether or not to keep the HSA funds entirely invested pre-tax, or converting the HSA expenses into a post tax investment. Because thats the difference for someone who can choose to fund medical expenses in current dollars.

Banking receipts does mean you get to withdraw the nominal value of the expense, but only the nominal value so that nominal value declines over time with inflation and you redeem that declined real value later. If you had invested the nominal value of the expense, it would grow invested, despite being in a post tax brokerage account.

And also, non spouse beneficiaries inherit the HSA as ordinary income all at once. Maybe that could change in the future, but if you consider the primary account and all inheritors, its financially worse to have the HSA inherited versus the stepped up basis of a brokerage inherited.

EDIT: It seems like people are not understanding the point.

In this thought experiment, a person has the choice to use the HSA for expenses or to bank receipts for later reimbursement, or to not use the HSA at all until elderly care needs. To simplify, the first choice is A, the second choice is B, and the third choice is C.

This person, in this experiment, will always max out their HSA. So they will always get the pre tax deduction, the first of the tax advantages. They also have enough money to cover all their medical expenses out of pocket regardless of the HSA. The reason for this is because the arguments for delaying the use of the HSA hinge on being able to pay out of pocket for expenses rather than use the HSA. And necessarily, that means they have current dollars available to invest.

So scenario A, they use the HSA as needed. Because they have the funds necessary to pay out of pocket, they can choose to invest the amount of their medical expenses into a brokerage account each time they use the HSA. Money is fungible, so utilizing for expenses is essentially the same as making a tax free withdrawal from the HSA. This person will have a brokerage account that, for our experiment, is invested the exact same as the HSA. So the HSA grows and also the brokerage account grows.

In scenario B, they pay out of pocket using current dollars and bank receipts. This means down the line, the HSA will have grown pre-tax, and they will reimburse for the nominal value of their receipts. This matters because 100 dollars today is worth a lot more than 100 dollars in 40 years, but in 40 years they can only reimburse the 100 dollars nominally. They have no brokerage account because the point is to compare using the HSA vs not using it. They end up with a pile of cash equal to the nominal value of medical expenses from the banking of receipts, which they could invest or do whatever with.

In scenario C, they just never reimburse, and only plan on using the HSA later in life. So its just pre-tax growth until it is utilized later. Who knows when they use it.

The calculation has to be done with the same numbers for inflation, asset price growth, and medical expenses.

And on top of this all, inheritance. Brokerage accounts are inherited with stepped up basis. HSAs are inherited as ordinary income all at once. So the heirs actually face potentially very high tax bills upon inheritance. They can afford to pay it, but they wouldn't actually be paying anything if the total inheritance is less than the estate tax exemption.

Edit 2: And actually, the brokerage account may never need to pay that much in taxes. You choose when to realize LTCG. You could actually keep it close to the 0% threshold and just never pay taxes on that growth. So the tax free growth benefit of the HSA actually just goes away, there is only some minor tax drag difference due to dividends, yet you have basically as big of a pile of cash for the brokerage account (funded by HSA medical expenses) versus the HSA being left alone.


r/Bogleheads • • Apr 30 '26

Married couples with combined finances: why do you do it?

0 Upvotes

As a corollary to a similar post from earlier today, I’m curious why some of you decided to combine finances in marriage/long term partnership.

For us, it greatly simplifies things. But I can appreciate that this isn’t true for everyone.

What has your experience been?


r/Bogleheads • • Dec 18 '23

Rich dad poor dad approach

0 Upvotes

What do you think about the approach of Robert Kiyosaki using debt to buy assets that generate more income as the interest of the debt.

He classifys between good (buying an asset that get money in your pocket) and bad debt (buying liabilities that get money out of your pocket) and I am only talking about the good debt here. He thinks of debt in a completely different way and sees it as an opportunity to make money and generate income. What is the catch? How many people are doing it that way? And would you recommend that methode to a young person after university in Germany?

I know that this is not a methode out of the boglehead toolbox but I am wondering, what you guys think about that. In my opinion, it definitely sounds to easy may have a lot of risks.
Somebody of you has experience with that approach?

Thank you!


r/Bogleheads • • Jan 06 '24

Has Bogleheads became an echo chamber?

0 Upvotes

Strange but it seems everyone is recommending a certain ticker I won’t mention but regardless of its attributes, everyone seem to be piling on.

I’m reading at moment irrational exuberance and he mentions this exact problem where ideas grow on internet and everyone seem to rally behind it.

Again, just an observation and always a good idea to make your own judgment rather than collective group


r/Bogleheads • • Aug 20 '25

2M at 40, can I stop saving for retirement

0 Upvotes

Hello, first time posting. I’ve been following the low cost index funds approach and currently have $2M in savings at 40. I work a well compensated job I don’t really like. I don’t want to retire early or anything but I do want to take a step back and potentially work a job that makes much less money.

With this much set aside can I stop saving for retirement and just let the index funds do their work?

Thanks


r/Bogleheads • • May 26 '26

Ready to restart my life.

0 Upvotes

Hi. I am 24 male. I have a gambling problem. There I said it. Since the first day I turned 18 all I’ve done is day trade stupid stuff. My first loss was ibio. Lost everything at 18.
I lost everything again at 20. We are talking like 20-30k. I’m tired of all the stress I am putting my self through.
Fast forward to today. I have a lovely wife. We bought our home in 2022 with a 4.25% rate and we are about to go on our honey moon. Hawaii. It will be a blast.
I SOLD for a 100k loss today. My net worth was about 500k.. now I’m at 400k. I can’t keep gambling like this. I am ready to flip the page. I really just need a path to stay on. And would appreciate anyone’s advice.
Here’s what I’m working with.
I own a lawn care business and will have a full time employee starting next year. I make about 15-20k a month during the busy times. And drop down to about 7k in the winter. So about a 150-175k average. Expecting to be above 200k next season with a helper.
Anyways. I want to be safer about my investments. I’m ready to settle down and get over the fact that I won’t become a filthy rich overnight or even a week. I’ve been close! Don’t get me wrong. But my account over the last 6 years has basically evened out with all my losses and gains. I think I am 15% up. Definitely did not beat the s and p lol. I’m disappointed but also proud of my self for finally calling it quits. Ok here’s the summary.
We want to buy our dream home within the next 2-3 years and have a kid or 2. We have about 400k saved.
I have a sep ira but I think I will have to change that to a 401k once I get an employee on board. That employee will be my dad. So it’s pretty awesome.
I’m tired of my emotions being so throttled with how much I’m losing but also winning. I. AM. DONE. BEING. A POS. DEGENERATE. I am ready to be a loving husband that can be trusted with our financials.
Any words of wisdom is greatly appreciated. Part of me just wants to take a breather and throw it all in SGOV and focus on building my business.
Thank you.


r/Bogleheads • • Mar 02 '24

Investing Questions What's the next big thing to invest in?

2 Upvotes

I know a few years ago, I Bonds were the popular thing.

Last year the Ally No Penalty CD was clutch to get in on.

The CD finally matured and I need to figure out what to do with the money next.

Already maxed Roth IRA. Doing 10% of my 401k, considering upping the amount.

I can use some advice and direction.

UPDATE: I completely spaced on mentioning I am planning to buy a house within the next year, but hopefully this year if the cards fall in my favor.


r/Bogleheads • • Nov 16 '22

Anyone else worried about Fidelity getting into crypto?

1 Upvotes

Went to log into my Fidelity account recently and got hit with a big ad for their upcoming crypto product offering.

It was a bit disconcerting to see what I consider a reputable organization getting into that area. You certainly don't see Vanguard doing anything like that...

When an org goes and says "hey come invest in this big negative-sum, self-referential, fraud, scam, and manipulation rife space with us!" - it makes you stop and pause for a second to reconsider your choice to use them for your retirement / 529 accounts...

I'm reasonably assured/hopeful that they won't actually be _exposed_ to any of it and this is purely a move to cash in on gamblers, but it does plant a little seed of doubt for me.

That's not even considering recent events in the space....


r/Bogleheads • • Sep 01 '22

Can you lose all the money you invest in low cost index funds if the market crashes?

2 Upvotes

People say don't panic sell but if you have 10,000 invested and the market keeps going down like this, couldn't you lose all your money even if it is in low cost index funds? Is it smarter to pull your money out?


r/Bogleheads • • Jul 15 '22

Why is VXUS pushed so heavy? It has a return of 3.28% since inception in January of 2011. Factor in real rate of return with an average of 2.54% inflation annually over that time and you’re barely positive.

8 Upvotes

r/Bogleheads • • Apr 17 '26

My 401k is really expensive. It’s really bothering me.

1 Upvotes

Hi. I’m not sure if I want to contribute at all to my 401k bcs of the rip off fees. I have 70k in it bcs I started late and I’ve been at 8 percent contribution from my paycheck every two weeks. It’s really terrible bcs every three months I get an asset management fees and a fund fee. I have read so many books and these fees really bothers me. It’s through empower and it’s a freaking target date fund for God sake how difficult would that be in a something called Gray American fund or something similar I don’t remember exactly but it’s basically 59 percent American companies, the rest is international plus cash and mmf. So far this year in January 120 was deducted plus 40 for the fees and in April 140 . So about 300 in fees in 3 months which means 1200 in fees and more every year. This is really a ripp off. I’ve called them and complained about it but most of them don’t understand anything about fees and expense ratios. I have spoken to the ppl that knows what I’m talking about but they down play it and say they can’t do anything about it. The last person said don’t worry it will come out of the investment. They don’t understand the point I’m trying to make. I have a TDF through vanguard I think it’s at 0.08 . I think I don’t wanna contribute bcs even the match is really terrible through my job bcs Sometimes I contribute 800 when I get paid since my income fluctuates and the match is at 75 dollars. The match is absolutely terrible and the fees are wayyy too high. I’m considering to send everything into my Traditional Roth and just choose my own investments with vanguard and completely stop this terrible ppl stealing my money. I just don’t know if this is a good idea. The fees don’t hurt me financially but I just can’t accept it anymore bcs I understand what’s going on now and this contradicts my knowledge of investing. The only reason why I kept it was bcs I could lower my income by putting money in it but honestly I don’t care about that anymore. So what do I need to do here? I do have a traditional IRA account open and ready. I use it for back door conversion once a year. What are u guys thinking? Thx much


r/Bogleheads • • Feb 12 '26

What's wrong with VTI?

68 Upvotes

I have made a couple suggestions on here about buying VTI, and notice it gets downvoted. What's wrong with VTI? It's Vanguard Total Stock Market Index, and seems to be about as Boglehead as you can get.


r/Bogleheads • • Dec 06 '23

Is Bitcoin a legitimate investment?

0 Upvotes

Has anyone began allocating a percentage of their portfolio toward Bitcoin or Crypto?


r/Bogleheads • • Mar 08 '24

Anyone else not have an emergency fund?

12 Upvotes

I have a Roth IRA and a taxable account. 31m. Opened them both 5 years ago, 100% VOO in both. Around $66k total. House almost paid off.

Is a Roth IRA and taxable account all I need? I don’t have employer 401k, no hysa (idk what that is) or any of the other things commonly seen here.

I always have a minimal amount in savings checking since I’d rather have more invested (time in the market?) so far it’s worked out well as I’ve never had to sell anything….yet.

Is this ok to do?

As a quick example I’d rather have $66k in VOO instead of $56k and $10,000 just sitting in savings? I sort of view the taxable account as an emergency fund? Then it’ll be just long term capital gains if cashed out so not even that bad?

I work full time so I just pay for what I need per month, then invest the rest/more towards the house principle.

With the house and taxable account after the Roth IRA is maxed, I just feel like I always need to put $ towards those?


r/Bogleheads • • Dec 15 '23

Investing Questions Could we live in times where the SNP500 is overvalued?

1 Upvotes

I think this community is great at addressing my concerns.
Recently, I've been pondering the surging popularity of ETFs like the S&P 500 and MSCI. They've become incredibly popular, more and more people have realized that going long term SNP500 is the right way to go, and I wonder if this widespread popularity has potentially caused overvaluation, that will might lead us to a new time where we no longer expects 8-10% annual return, but something like 5-7% or even worse.
What are your thoughts on this? I kind of starting to see it as a pyramid scheme, but a trusted one.
I hope I'm wrong


r/Bogleheads • • Oct 19 '23

Index Funds: I've Only Lost Money

0 Upvotes

It's been a turbulent past few years as I (24) graduated in 2021 and started investing around that time as well. I received an inheritance in the mid 6 figure range, and following advice I read on this sub, invested all of it into total market index funds. On top of that, I've been investing 15% of every paycheck into these index funds as well, so I'm pretty much all-in with my savings.

Checking my account today, the balance is still quite less than the principle amount I have deposited. Meaning I haven't even made a single dollar yet, I've only lost money investing into index funds. I'm now understanding that I probably bought when the market was at it's ATH, but it's still disheartening to know that putting the cash under my mattress would have yielded better results over the last 2 years. I also understand that I'm very young and this money should compound exponentially over the course of my lifetime, but I feel like it's been off to an incredibly rocky start especially considering this hyper-inflationary period we are now in.

This is not to even mention I-Bonds or MMFs which have yielded over 5% to 8% returns which I've missed out on since I went all-in on index funds. Doing the math, that would have yielded over $50k in returns had I done that. Should I consider re-allocating some of my portfolio to bonds or other assets which guarantee a return?

Had I invested a year earlier at the start of the pandemic, I would be up over 200%. Isn't that crazy? Am I just that incredibly unlucky or is investing really that finnicky?

I know I'm in it for the long game but the day where I even approach my break-even point seems like it may take years. I really hope the next decade isn't like 2000-2012 where the overall market was fairly flat.


r/Bogleheads • • Aug 16 '23

Articles & Resources Thoughts on elite college being almost a negative indicator of wealth?

Post image
3 Upvotes