r/BodyHackGuide • • 1d ago

šŸ’Š Supplements & Stacks Creatine

I am well versed on the scientific literature.
-> Seeking anecdotal.

Pre, intra, or post?
Mg?

I’ve been doing 5g intra, or midday on non-training days.

3 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

4

u/AnabolicUnc šŸ’Ŗ Muscle Growth Lab 1d ago

I have 5g pre, 5g intra and another 5g in the morning. Try going above 5g a day and thank me later.

2

u/NameChalky85 1d ago

Ah. Ok. Spread out 5g doses… I’ll have to try that. Over 5g in one dose does me dirty.

2

u/AnabolicUnc šŸ’Ŗ Muscle Growth Lab 1d ago

If monohydrate is harsh on your stomach, use HCL I have a few clients that needed to make the switch.

1

u/The_Cabal_ 1d ago

What benefits have you seen that you didn't see with 5g?

1

u/AnabolicUnc šŸ’Ŗ Muscle Growth Lab 1d ago

Mainly intracellular water retention, muscles stay fuller all the time. Whether it provides any additional training performance benefits, I'm not sure. I've been taking 15g daily for years.

1

u/NameChalky85 1d ago

I can get down w full muscles around the clock!

5g of mono doesn’t bother me at all; when I tried 10 in one serving it went straight through.

4

u/fortheloveofaminos 1d ago

There is also interesting research on the benefits of creatine for brain function, improved memory, enhanced attention... the research I read showed that these benefits start to kick in at the 10g a day dosage

2

u/NameChalky85 1d ago

It’s my understanding the research was focused on neurological benefits in sleep deprivation or neurodegenerative conditions and relied on very small participant groups. Some of the published studies have been questioned and/or retracted due to methodological errors.
Much of the research suggests creatine only really helps when the brain is under metabolic stress (sleep deprivation, severe fatigue, etc.), + there have meta-analyses and reviews which resulted contradictory findings, showing no reliable benefit even under stress…

2

u/01100101011000110111 1d ago

5g in the morning, 5g pwo

1

u/NameChalky85 1d ago

Do you notice differences in 10 daily versus 5g?
Or have you always done 10?

1

u/Cool_Temperature_970 1d ago

I take 20g a day. I mix it in my preworkout.

1

u/NameChalky85 1d ago

This would make me sh*t my brains out

1

u/The_Cabal_ 1d ago

Do you notice a difference from taking only 5g?

2

u/Cool_Temperature_970 1d ago

To me creatine really isn’t a supplement you get a ā€œfeelingā€ from. I just upped my dose with all the new studies that came out about the extra benefits you get from it. And it never made sense to me why 5g/day would be the same dose for EVERYONE. No mater the body size

1

u/NameChalky85 1d ago

That’s where my curiosity stemmed from.
I’m 5’8ā€ 150lbs 18% BF. My husband is 6’3ā€ 225… doesn’t make any sense we should be dosing anything the same…

1

u/Cool_Temperature_970 1d ago

Exactly my thought process. If your stomach can take it, upping the dose couldn’t be a bad thing. My wife’s stomach can’t take the normal creatine so she gets the HCl creatine and hasn’t had any issues.

1

u/MathematicianMuch445 23h ago

"I'm familiar with the science"... proceeds to show they clearly are not 🤣

0

u/[deleted] 23h ago

[deleted]

1

u/MathematicianMuch445 23h ago

Get familiar with the science. You claimed it. So do it

0

u/NameChalky85 23h ago

What a sad life that you choose to be dck instead of being helpful

1

u/MathematicianMuch445 23h ago

🤣 Why claim things that are clearly a lie thrn. Just start with "i know nothing and don't feel like lying and saying otherwise". You're an adult i assume. Go adult.