MODS, BEFORE YOU DELETE THIS (I made a similar post about a month ago that was deleted), please note that for all intents and purposes, this IS body dysmorphia, it IS an obsession with the way I look that is absolutely ruining my life, and NO, I do not believe what I'm seeing in the mirror when I say that "I look really good". Anyways, here goes.
This is a condensed version. There's more to it, but its way too convoluted to fit into a reddit post. So basically, I was-what would have grown up to be a very attractive person-before puberty. I had really nice long hair, piercing green eyes, just a genuinely nice cute face with really good skin. I got hit on by teenage girls when I was younger. I was very confident and talkative, somewhat obnoxious, and it could have been chalked up to that, but I believe looks played a significant part in it.
When I turned 14 this all changed it seemed. I thought I had already gone through puberty, but the worst was just starting. I got my first real pimple on my forehead, which turned into a breakout in my "T zone". This would have been all good, but my skin just generally got significantly worse. I also noticed my face was changing. My chin got bigger, my forehead got bigger (cro magnon like). I thought I looked like Robbie Rotten but greasier. This would have been all fine and dandy if it were just "oh you look like a man now", but it seriously felt like I had acromegaly or something. This is what could be chalked up to "regular body dysmorphia", but, of course, I didn't, and still don't, believe that I was wrong. I looked and still do look like a completely different person now than I did before puberty, and not in the normal way.
This kind of lasted until a couple years ago when I started to notice that I grew into my looks. Not just grew into, but to such a significant degree, that when I look in the mirror I see a hollywood actor level of attractiveness. I see piercing green eyes, a slightly large forehead that may be pre-balding, but not in a bad way (like Fez from Euphoria), an Italian prominent nose, an extremely masculine Jawline, nice facial hair, fair skin, but not sickly looking.
(I censored what's below because I don't want to offend anyone that can't handle it) I can tell this is not true though. I get ugly to average matches on dating apps. Nothing above a 6/10 and even that's rare. When I post about it on r/onlinedating people tell me "yeah, you're average and complaining about getting average looking matches, f*** off”. When I post on r/amiuglybrutally honest they tell me I'm very good looking (that sub lies). When I go out in public I don't get stared at by women like my brother does. I went to the extent of (and I know how insane this is) making a fake dating profile with my brother's pictures and the same bio as mine. He did way better. Got 8/10s swiping right on him and messaging first on Hinge. I made the same post on reddit with his pictures (the one where I was a jerk and being told that I was an ugly-average jerk), the worst reaction he got was "you look gay but you're very handsome" and "f***boy" etc. Keep in mind that I literally see no difference in attractiveness level between me and him, and while we don't look like twins or anything, from my POV we look VERY similar. Of course, like I said, I don't believe it, for aforementioned reasons.
Not sure if anyone else can relate, but I'm legitimately not okay with being average looking. Bad stuff happens. There have been four occasions this year where I have parties at my apartment with my male friends and we invite women over and they end up either hitting on, or having sex with them. These are people that I never thought were more attractive than me. I'm not okay with being significantly less attractive than my brother and I really don't know how to move on in life if this is true (which I'm 99% sure it is because I've proven it).