Long post, sorry. 2015 X5 35d diesel, about 108k miles. I’ve owned it since around 55k and kept up with all the maintenance the whole time. I knew an older BMW would need money, so I bought a full MaxCare service contract (Assurant) ahead of time instead of hoping nothing would break.
In May it started losing coolant and threw an EGR valve code. My independent shop replaced the EGR valve in June. Didn’t help. Coolant kept going down and a new code showed up for low EGR flow. In August they replaced the intake flap actuator and cleaned the carbon out of the intake. Still losing coolant. At that point they told me straight up this should fall under a BMW warranty or extension and I should take it to the dealer.
So on Sept 2 I dropped it off at Peter Pan BMW with the codes from my shop. The check engine light wasn’t on that day and they saw that at check-in. My advisor, Stephen Hooper, told me diagnosis was $630, but if the EGR cooler turned out to be a warranty issue I wouldn’t pay it. Two days later he calls: no light on the dash, nothing to diagnose, come get your car. They knew that when they took it. The light came back the next day, so on Sept 8 I brought it back. Same promise, second time.
Then they called saying they’d found a valve cover gasket leak and a broken connector on the MAF sensor. I told them to go through my service contract. Almost two weeks of waiting for Assurant’s inspector, who approved the gasket. The dealer pushed me to also do a new valve cover and the MAF sensor out of pocket, about $1,900 together. I needed the car so I said ok, and on that same call Hooper told me a third time that if the EGR cooler was covered, the diagnosis was free.
It was covered. EGR flow was at 29.1%, “severe sooting, clogged,” and BMW replaced the cooler under its own extended warranty.
Sept 30, 22 days after drop-off, I go to pick it up and the $630 is on the bill. Why? “Well, you had other problems besides the EGR cooler.” Ok, but one of those other problems was paid by Assurant, so why didn’t the diagnosis go to them? Answer: the leak was “seen visually,” so it doesn’t count as diagnosis. Funny thing is, my repair order describes the $630 diagnosis as hooking up the charger, reading fault memory, and “VISUAL INSPECTION FOUND” the MAF connector and the oil puddle. So looking at it is a $630 diagnosis when I’m paying, and not a diagnosis at all when Assurant would be paying. And on the BMW side, diagnosing the EGR issue is part of what BMW pays the dealer for under that warranty program. When I kept arguing, I was told that if I didn’t pay and take the car I’d start getting charged storage. There’s no storage rate anywhere in my paperwork. I paid.
The MAF part still bugs me. They replaced it for $1,112.84 ($590 of that labor) because of code 290900, “air mass too high.” Later I found BMW’s own bulletin for that EGR warranty (SI B01 11 25), and 290900 is literally listed as a symptom of the EGR cooler failure. So is low coolant, which is how this whole thing started. No idea if anyone actually tested the sensor.
I’m not complaining about paying to keep a 12-year-old car running. I paid for the extra work. My problem is that one diagnosis turned up two covered repairs, BMW took care of theirs, Assurant took care of theirs, and the only one who paid for the diagnosis was me, the guy who was promised three times he wouldn’t. Three weeks without my car, three taxi rides back and forth, and a storage threat when I asked questions. Nobody there acted like they owed me anything once the work was done.
If you want to be sweet-talked first and then dunked in an ice bath at the register, Peter Pan BMW is your place.