r/BmwTech • • Aug 01 '24

Electrical problem

i have an e92 335i im having alot of ignition problems it shuts by itself and sometimes it just doesn't crank

19 Upvotes

100 comments sorted by

67

u/DukeOfAlexandria Aug 01 '24

Dude you were already given a shit ton of answers last time you posted this.

Either do proper diagnostics and start with battery voltage and scanning for codes or take it to a dealership.

22

u/domrosiak123 Aug 01 '24

After looking through, OP says it starts normally when jump started

So, it’s bad battery, alternator, or a current draw draining the battery after being powered down

Battery health can be checked by autozone or some place like that for free

Alternator can be checked by looking at battery voltage when running

And if it’s not any of those, and the battery is dropping voltage when powered down, then there is a draw somewhere or a loose connection

But unfortunately, OP seems to have no trouble shooting skills, and is relying on us to fix it

13

u/DukeOfAlexandria Aug 01 '24

I can’t measure battery voltage from this phone lol….which is why bare basic diagnostics needs to be conducted.

He also said that a DEALERSHIP “fixed it” 4 times….even at the worst stealerships I’ve ever been to that is nearly impossible.

4

u/GalwayBogger E61 525i LCI N53 Aug 01 '24

It has been modified though. Who knows what electrics are lurking under tha dash. The problem could be some aftermarket equipment or dodgy woring the stealership is not expecting too. Then I could realisitcally see them saying they exhausted their diagnostic powers.

3

u/DukeOfAlexandria Aug 01 '24

Fair, but they would have at least identified any parasitic draw on k-can throughout the system….or at least I would have.

2

u/e36freak92 BMW Specialist - 95 M3, 99 M3 Aug 01 '24

Wouldn't be surprised if it has a jb4 that is taking a shit and causing havoc on the can bus. Seen it numerous times

1

u/DukeOfAlexandria Aug 01 '24

Wouldn’t be surprised either, but getting infinite this guy is like pulling teeth….you all have fun if you want to keep at it ha.

2

u/mr308A3-28 2018 G30 M550ix Aug 02 '24

Is there a mechanic equivalent troll to “press alt+f4 to heal yourself”?

Like cutting a lambda sensor or rerouting a PCV tube ?

1

u/kieranhendy Aug 02 '24

To be fair, one of my DRLs was strobing randomly - biggest VW dealer here in Scotland (Arnold Clark) took the car a 4/5 times before I eventually gave up and contact VW directly, they sent me all the way to a Lookers VW dealership who fixed it while I was sitting waiting.

The worst bit is that Arnold Clark told me they had replaced the light on one of the first times it went in meaning that all the other times they must have just been staring at it saying "why you not work" because they sure as hell didn't fix it.

To add insult to injury, I was told by Arnold Clark to come in when the issue is happening so they can see it happen - I did so and got turned away because I "didn't have an appointment".

Makes you wonder how a different dealer fixed it on their first time ever seeing the car within an hour when they couldn't despite having the car for days at a time.

1

u/domrosiak123 Aug 01 '24

Yeah 4 times for a dealership is crazy. Maybe they should share what the dealership already did. We need way more info, but I don’t have the car in my driveway

4

u/DukeOfAlexandria Aug 01 '24

Have I seen dealerships fuck up? Sure, but 4 times….unlikely.

More info is needed for sure.

2

u/DIJames6 Aug 01 '24

Should share which dealership didn't fix it 4 times, so that everyone else know not to go there..

2

u/GalwayBogger E61 525i LCI N53 Aug 01 '24

I have an e60 and I had a similar gremlin when I bought the car. It sat up for a while at the previous owners and they let the battery go to shit. Nice fat bosch AGM, 2 years old, way overspecced.

Anyway, I was stubborn, didn't want to change such a nice battery. So I trickle charged it overnight... 5 times or something. It would charge fully, start the car fine and the next, dead as a dodo. Like nothing, 11v, couldn't even open it. I was pulling my hair out checking earth wires, diagnostics, etc. Not a clue.

After that, I decided the best way to charge it was to drive the hell of it, and if that failed, then replace the battery and bettery sensor. I drove it 800 km in a day... that was 4 years ago. Never changed anything and it's never had a start problem since.

Not sure how relevant that is here but if all else fails, maybe pack that jumper pack and do a day trip to some far away place you wanted to visit. Worked for me, but maybe a battery could have done the same.

1

u/BackgroundArt6028 Aug 02 '24

Hey, I had the same thing on the E46, car wouldn’t run for long unless hooked up to another car. I found a loose ground wire in the engine bay. After I put it on properly the car ran like usual and all error codes went away.

1

u/mr308A3-28 2018 G30 M550ix Aug 02 '24

A blind monkey could install ISTA+ and have this shit sorted in no time. It even spoon feeds you diagnosing steps.

2

u/DukeOfAlexandria Aug 02 '24

Truuueeeeee, but god forbid we do any actual diagnostic work or science here!

-12

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

that's the problem its the the 4th it got to the dealership he always mention that he fixed it and to test it and always end up at the same problem so maybe a help of yours would help me figure this shit out

6

u/DukeOfAlexandria Aug 01 '24

A DEALERSHIP said it was fixed 4 times…? Or an Indy?

4

u/Unhappy_Respond_3432 Aug 01 '24

Not defending him but dealership to dealership can be a factor due to the techs, l would recommend going to a different dealership if they say it's "fixed".

-16

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

im sick of this i tried many people trying to figure out the electrical issue and no one is figuring it out im stuck

1

u/mr308A3-28 2018 G30 M550ix Aug 02 '24

Bro just install ISTA and see which sensor is not returning a signal and replace it.

72

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

start with replacing those ugly paddle shifters

8

u/cjvcook Aug 01 '24

bahahahahahahahahaa!!!!!!

-36

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

thank for your help!

18

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

invoice is in the mail

6

u/ShowerShoe77 Aug 01 '24

How much faster can you shift with those paddles?

In all seriousness you need to check battery voltage.

In addition to that establish a pattern in the behavior. Does it shut off after it reaches operating temp? Does it not start when it’s hot? Etc etc.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

okay at first she was shutting off and turning back on normally then by time it starts stalling and giving me cancer to turn it back on the dashboard is always flickering its like ur putting the key on and off but after like 10 min it starts back on and sometimes when i finish my ride park it try to start it again at the same time and it just doesn't crank the lights starts to flicker alot even when the key is out of the car

1

u/ShowerShoe77 Aug 02 '24

Okay, how old is your battery?

4

u/lunarc Aug 01 '24

Buy a new battery. Had almost this exact same issue on an e92, new battery solved it all

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

was it stalling randomly too?

2

u/null-g Aug 01 '24

If your car has low power it gets no spark and it stalls.

If your car has low power it can't pump fuel and stalls.

If your car has low power it can't light up the dash.

If your car has low power it can't crank and turn over.

If your car has low power it makes buzzing and whirring sounds instead of cranking and turning over.

Low power = tons of scary random bullshit, full stop.

Don't fuck around and make it worse. It's bad for the car to try to run without electricity lol.

First: Battery, is it fucked?

Call local auto parts store and ask for a charge and test. If you can't take the car to them, just take the battery.

Second: Cables, are they undamaged, clean and connected properly?

Ask local auto parts store to do a continuity test while they test battery. Buy a $3 wire brush and scrub at the connections then reconnect.

Thirds: Alternator, does it make enough power? Ask local auto parts store to do an alternator test while they charge the battery.

Go from there. They do all this for free, what are you waiting for?

Nike✓

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

i charged the battery for a whole day the car cranked like 4 times and then this

2

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '24

So the alternator is faulty or the battery is faulty and won't hold a charge. Come on man

1

u/GuideOutrageous1636 Aug 02 '24

Then it's the alternator... Why repost the same question when you already had your answer?

1

u/null-g Aug 02 '24

Ok but do you get what ppl are saying here? Charging it isn't the answer. You have it tested, and the cables and alternator tested and inspected and connections cleaned. If you want to have a working car you'll have to do this.

I did all this twice on an e90 and an e84 and in all cases I had fixed the car in under 3 hours and under $300. One was the battery (replaced and installed in 30 minutes, ~$200), one was just the cables/connections (15 minutes to disconnect, clean with $3 wire brush, reconnect), one was the alternator (first time working on a car and it took 2.5 hours to replace, $150). You should really get started and stop sitting on reddit.

3

u/Chrispy_king Aug 01 '24

Check the connection between alternator and starter. There’s a bolt on the strut tower where you clamp a positive jump lead - this joins the alternator to the starter therefore feeding it - mine wasn’t 100% tight and caused similar problems. Jump started fine but wouldn’t crank.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

can u help me out to locate it?

2

u/Chrispy_king Aug 01 '24

On mine there’s a red plastic cover over it in the engine bay (look at the suspension tower on the intake side) and as I say, it’s where you clamp the positive jump lead if you’re jump starting. Lift the red cover and there’s where the bolt is.

There will be a cable that goes from it down to the alternator on the front of the block and another cable that goes from it down towards the bulkhead which will go to the starter. It basically bridges the two.

On mine the nut wasn’t 100% tight and a few turns with a socket set sorted my issue.

3

u/Nutcup Aug 01 '24

I had the same issue. O’Reilly’s confirmed my battery was complete shit and dying, so I bought one from them for around $300 or so. I replaced it myself, then programmed it in using BimmerCode & BimmerLink.

100% resolved the issue and my car starts instantly ever since.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

ur giving me hope. but the car stalls sometimes and the lights flicker alot when the key is off the car

1

u/Nutcup Aug 01 '24

Literally exact same symptoms as me

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

so ur issue was the battery? and no i don't any smartphone charger

1

u/Nutcup Aug 02 '24

100% my battery

3

u/Nutcup Aug 01 '24

How about this one: starts first time of the day no problem for you > you drive somewhere close and run in > 2nd start is womp womp womppp

Do you have a smartphone charger plugged into one of your ports? BMW specifically states in the manual NOT to do this, as BMW batteries and systems aren’t built in a manner that supports this, and it can lead to premature battery draw.

I haven’t read anything else from you other than the OP, but I’m telling you I can see the gremlins a mile away because I had them for a year.

Battery, bro. Just go to an autozone and have them test it before anything else. Save yourself time and energy. If they say your battery is good to go, come back here with the receipt (they will give you one) and be vindicated. At which point, the community will hop back in to continue troubleshooting.

You have nothing to lose and everything to gain 😎

3

u/E90-Rage Aug 01 '24

... Did you have the battery tested like I suggested last week? If the car doesn't have enough power to crank, either the battery is shot, or the alternator isn't charging the battery.

Either way, the very first thing to verify is if the battery is still good.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

i checked it it was not giving anything recharge it for a whole day and then she was good for like a day and now this ;(

3

u/E90-Rage Aug 01 '24

Was the battery tested with a battery load tester, though...? because, like I told you before, the likelihood that your battery is the culprit appears to be pretty darn high.

3

u/getafewlives Aug 01 '24

What's the date stamp on the battery? I would replace it regardless and at least you know you have a good battery.

Battery needs to be coded to the car, or you're going to continue to have issues.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '24

That's not what he asked. A faulty battery won't hold charge

2

u/beamerthings Aug 01 '24

Battery health?

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

i recharged ut yesterday it started normaly then the 2nd time im trying to start it it did that

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

How old is the battery? Have you replaced it yet?

2

u/TheDaiquiriMan Aug 01 '24

If you know the battery is healthy, have you checked the charging current or for parasitic draw?

2

u/beamerthings Aug 01 '24

… alternator health?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

Bad ground cables? Or main battery cables? Or bad fob battery ?

You could try and replace the fuel pump relay and/or the CAS relay. My old e90 would start and then die immediately, initially thought it was a bad fuel pump...They're like $20 per on most sites even Amazon.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

what was the issue?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

Bad fuel relay. Can't say for sure what exactly is wrong with yours though.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

i read alot about the fuel pump relay but can't quite locate it since the fuse box diagram is missing

9

u/The-chiefers Aug 01 '24

If you can afford to take it to the dealership 4 times you can afford a 20 dollar meter to do some simple electrical checks. People might actually be able to help you with the problem with some added info that a 10 second video showing nothing does.

2

u/huyiho Aug 02 '24

It’s his 3rd post in a week with no data given, or any effort to get any tools to obtain said data, helping this man is as useless as helping a fish walk.

10

u/muckyJim Aug 01 '24

Ok have you got a laptop?

If yes, download ISTA and plug the car in properly.

If no, and you've got no multimeter then how on earth do you expect us to diagnose this for you??

If the dealership can't help and you won't go to another one, and haven't got the tools or won't get them. Then I dunno, sell the car as spares repair?

If I was going to do a parts cannon special with no real diagnostics, I'd replace the battery first. These cars are complex and battery voltage will mess with things badly!

But honestly, these cars are getting on now and techs who know them well are getting fewer and further between. At the least buy a cheap topdon dongle and use that to read codes etc. Then you become your own tech with experience and suffering!

2

u/Unhappy_Respond_3432 Aug 01 '24

Is it recognizing the key? Looks like it is not.

-6

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

it is the key symbol is shown bc i have my door opened when i close it it goes away

2

u/Unhappy_Respond_3432 Aug 01 '24

What's the voltage of the battery?

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

sadly i don't have a multimeter i can't determine. is there another way to determine it?

4

u/Unhappy_Respond_3432 Aug 01 '24

I would start with swapping to a new battery

2

u/moccolo Aug 01 '24

Go to the secret menu in the BC and see what voltage is displayed

google secret menu bmw e90

EDIT: that is almost 100% dead battery, you can charge it but it dosn't hold power for long

4

u/Ktor011 Aug 01 '24

Maybe it’s them fighter jet pedals

4

u/humboldtliving Aug 01 '24

Hey brother what you do is go ask mom and dad for a new car since you don't fucking listen to anyone

3

u/Illustrious-Unit-480 Aug 01 '24

Check the main power cable behind the fusebox inside the glove compartment

3

u/RcklssGz Aug 01 '24

Fam, just burn the car and claim the insurance. Cause you’re only gonna drive yourself crazy and there’s something about trouble shooting the car; that you just can’t seem to go by basic knowledge and figure out where your issue is stemming from. People here can only do so much

Knowledge is power, so do some reading. Do some unplugging and checking with a meter. If you can’t or don’t know how; than you should def pay someone around you to do the diagnostic that the dealership is only “telling you” they did

3

u/PossessionMost2092 Aug 02 '24

It’s probably the paddles glued to the other paddles.

2

u/qpgt Aug 01 '24

If it’s automatic transmission - check ground wire

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

Commenting on Electrical problem ...i checked it its good

4

u/qpgt Aug 01 '24

If you are not happy with suggested actions in the comments - be smarter - create the complete list of things that you have already tried. You mentioned 4 visits to a workshop - what have they done?

4

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

This information would be very helpful. Even then, we are shooting in the dark from here.

What's your battery voltage when it's sitting? When you try to start it?

Is it possible you have a parasitic draw that is killing your battery? Lots of techs these days are too ignorant and lazy to test for this. It's not easy, but any good tech can do it.

2

u/qpgt Aug 01 '24

Man, this is his 3rd post about the same thing. His quote: “whenever i boos it it turns back on its okay for a day or a two then the lights starts flickering and boom she dies again”

It’s impossible to help, he is just refusing any help.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

i recharged the battery literally today

2

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

Recharging a bad battery isn't going to fix it. If that's the problem. How old is the battery? See my post above, I'm asking questions to try and help you.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

Gotta love it. I have customers like this in real life that text me shit like this lol.

Bring it over, give me your money, I'll fix it.

2

u/MadamFloof Aug 01 '24

Have you done any of the diagnostic from the prior 3 posts?

Sometimes no crank can be caused by the battery monitor. Pulling the blue wire that goes into the battery block might fix it. But really should be checking your codes to start.

2

u/TheDefected Aug 01 '24

Check your engine earth strap.
There's an issue where a bad earth strap or cracked engine mount means the block can't earth properly. Anything else trying to earth itself through the block tries to find any path to ground which can often be through the starter motor.
This upsets the CAS to the point you can't switch the ignition on to get codes.

Simple tests are switch the ignition on as best you can, and use a multimeter to check between the engine block and the chassis (like the earth jump point or a strut mount bolt.
You should see zero voltage difference.
You can also try with a jump lead from engine block to a chassis ground as an extra earth and see if that helps.

Another possibility is something shorting on the T15 line, T15 is the switched ignition.
Intelligent battery sensor, some seat occupancy mats and a lot of other stuff are on that line.
If the CAS switches on the power to that, but it is shorted to ground, nothing else gets the 12v to switch on.
Unplugging the IBS intelligent battery sensor for example can check and see if that is the short.

2

u/BklynBodega Aug 01 '24

Has to be some aftermarket shit going on here

2

u/oreidosol Aug 02 '24

Whomever came up with that gong is annoying in real life

2

u/[deleted] Aug 03 '24

Take it to a proper auto electrician. Dealership mechanics just swap parts, they are no good with modified cars or older models.

1

u/smh6706 Aug 02 '24

Time to stop cranking and scan for error code. No one here can trouble shoot your electrical problem with your lack of details

1

u/Uniblab_78 Aug 02 '24

Not enough cursing for me to take this seriously

1

u/[deleted] Aug 02 '24

My e92 did that for several months and the ECU packed in.

As for this one I think the issues started with the steering wheel being on the wrong side 😀

1

u/That1f30 Aug 02 '24

Check your alternator voltage regulator i had similar problems and that fixed it for me

1

u/freshxdough BMW Master Elite Tech, Gen 6 HV, HV specialist Aug 02 '24

Yes. Start with basic diagnosis.

1

u/mhsyd808x Aug 04 '24

It’s the paddles

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

The car is old and tired and wants to depart to Co-Parts for its final resting place, RIP.

1

u/Kennywakep Aug 01 '24

FIRST STEP: Plug in a scanner. It will tell you what component is not providing power. It’s doing to be something simple:

Alternator, battery, intelligent battery sensor.

Then use a voltmeter and test where faults are identified.

For me it was an alternator. Battery was charged and it started acting possessed, overheating and windshield wipers with a mind of its own. ☕️

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

you 100% have a chaffed wire shorting to ground and draining the battery while not in use. Next step is to either shoot resistance for every single wire that could cause this, or manually inspect every single wire that can cause this

0

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

actually a good thought

3

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24

well sadly i bought the car a month ago and no not on my knowledge and started doing all of this