r/BlueOrigin • • May 27 '21

The Human Landing System program needs competition, not the delay of starting over. The National Team has an open architecture, deep experience, massive self-funded investments and a safe, low-risk design to return to the Moon. Let’s go. #Artemis

https://twitter.com/blueorigin/status/1397930724607488010?s=19
3 Upvotes

140 comments sorted by

8

u/skpl May 27 '21

Next tweet

Here’s a snapshot of the progress that the National Team has already made to land Americans on the Moon. Link

28

u/[deleted] May 27 '21

From a 6month old video. Using old footage and cgi. With failing engine stand tests. And then to top it off the whole point of lobbying and protests are because losing and losing out on money and contradictory claims meanwhile the tweet itself states self funded

6

u/ReturnOfDaSnack420 May 28 '21

A 6-month-old video with CGI. In the meantime SpaceX has actually managed to land a Starship prototype and are building the Super Heavy stack to get into orbit. Pathetic but what else to expect from a company that spent 21 years to build a glorified tourist attraction of a rocket that can't even get to orbit

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

You do know that having a rocket wasn't part of the HLS contract right? They are using NASAs SLS rockets and NASAs Orion/gateway stuff to complete this. That's like being mad that Boeing had the 747 before Airbus took off.

SpaceX nearly died if NASA hadn't gone all nostalgic for the Dragon and stsrliner designs because they looked like the Apollo capsules.

BO only got into deep space in 2014. So your 21 year comment is asinine at better and the words of idiot at best. SpaceX took nearly EIGHT YEARS to reach orbit after it began building for orbital flight.

BO hasn't even been into deep soace for 8 years yet. They achieved getting a rocket to suborbital flight, which was the goal.

1

u/ReturnOfDaSnack420 May 30 '21 edited May 30 '21

BO only got into deep space in 2014. So your 21 year comment is asinine at better and the words of idiot at best.

Blue and SpaceX began at the same time, in fact Blue Origin was started a year before in 2000 LMAO. It's not my fault Blue Origin has jack shit to show after two decades besides a glorified tourist trap in the Texas desert. (still haven't actually launched a passenger yet for the record.)

SpaceX took nearly EIGHT YEARS to reach orbit after it began building for orbital flight.

And they did that by starting small with the Falcon 1 instead of going straight to Falcon Heavy like Blue Origin insanely is doing with New Glenn. Maybe they should learn how to crawl before they walk instead of letting Dollar Store Lex Luthor's Ego force them into competing with a company that is hopelessly ahead of them in every way?

36

u/Beldizar May 28 '21

Seems like there was a competition for the Human Landing System, and Blue/NT lost.

There's also going to continue to be competition for moon landings, because the HLS contract isn't NASA's last contract to go to the moon. There will be future contracts that the National Team can compete for, and now they know that keeping the price down, having some skin in the game, and exceeding the payload capacity all increase your chances of winning. I don't expect them to learn these lessons, but we can hope right.

5

u/NortySpock May 28 '21

Yep, NASA/Congress should put that $10B into a fast-followup mission proposal, akin to Cargo Resupply Services 2 (CRS-2) which brought Sierra Nevada's Dream Chaser into the mix.

Remember, SpaceX's HLS is for only two missions: one uncrewed demo and a single crewed landing. That's gotta be the textbook definition of "Flags'n'Footprints", and I want an occupied Moon Base, not an abandoned landing site.

Blue Origin should be looking to ride SpaceX's coattails, not complain about not being in first place. Plenty of space up there for multiple companies.

9

u/Beldizar May 28 '21

Unfortunately the $10B is an instruction by Congress to spend money, not Congress actually giving them the money to spend.

32

u/Cunninghams_right May 28 '21

"let's go", motherfucker, you're the only ones slowing things down. get out of the way.

17

u/ReturnOfDaSnack420 May 28 '21

Being cocky smug assholes with literally nothing to back it up is kind of blue origins trademark at this point lol

48

u/PickleSparks May 27 '21

What exactly do they mean by "not starting over"?

It seems to me they want to get most of that 10B despite their proposal being judged worse by NASA.

39

u/dhibhika May 27 '21

This is what will happen if they start over:

  1. SpaceX will bid at least 6 billion

  2. SpaceX will again win thus reducing the take of BO

  3. Worse SpaceX and Dynetics may win

26

u/getBusyChild May 27 '21

Even worse SpaceX continues to go on its' own and beats NASA and Co. to the moon.

31

u/xredbaron62x May 27 '21

I won't be surprised if Axiom eventually offers moon trips on a Starship just like they're doing with Dragon to the ISS

13

u/getBusyChild May 27 '21 edited May 27 '21

I wonder if eventually Axiom and SpaceX will enter an agreement to build a station that Orbits the Moon. Would be a checkpoint/hub before landing and offer a safe haven if something goes wrong on the surface.

9

u/sicktaker2 May 27 '21

Why build a lunar space station when you can build a moonbase instead? First company to build a pressurized space large enough for people to strap on some wings and fly under their own power will rake in the dough.

3

u/Apostastrophe May 27 '21

Ignoring the mass of the wings themselves, an average human would only have about a 10% margin max in force over what would be required to at least maintain altitude doing such a flying manoeuvre. I think the best people would be able to do is jump off a platform and flap to maintain a glide. Perhaps some really good athletes with good chest/shoulder strength to body weight could maybe take off and hover well, but it would become exhausting pretty quickly.

Perhaps a huge sort of modified wind tunnel would help.

For all it’s worth, it’s probably way easier to just learn to lucid dream and recall your dreams well. I spend hours flying and adventuring every night and I don’t need to go to the moon for it!

1

u/willyolio Jun 01 '21

lunar orbit station might work as a refueling depot. Have fuel production on the moon, ferry up to a tanker in lunar orbit. Ships from earth can refuel at lunar orbit without actually landing on the moon, on the way to mars or something.

4

u/xredbaron62x May 27 '21

Thats exactly what Gateway is going to be

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lunar_Gateway

1

u/ForecastYeti May 28 '21

It’s a start of a thought for a small station that relies on small crews. A fully loaded crew starship wouldn’t dock there

1

u/xredbaron62x May 28 '21

If starship couldn't dock to Gateway NASA wouldn't have chosen it

0

u/nuger93 May 30 '21 edited May 30 '21

Yet SpaceX makes no mention of utilizing Gateway, Orion OR sls, which are all part of the HLS contract (part of bezos point protest about NASA limiting themselves to the whims of a monopoly)

10

u/sicktaker2 May 27 '21

If they start over, then Blue Origin would resubmit their dinky 2 person lander that required pretty significant and risky upgrades to make it a sustainable 4 person lander. What Blue Origin is pushing for is to be given funding to just build their more final design, and not try for the rushed 2 person lander that's frankly a waste of money.

1

u/ReturnOfDaSnack420 May 28 '21

They don't want the competition reopened, they want SpaceX to get the 3 billion dollars they've already awarded and for them to get 7 billion dollars what is left for their lander. If the competition is open again then SpaceX would almost certainly up their bid from 3 billion and when the lions share of the new money leaving the national team with the scraps they deserve.

2

u/dev_hmmmmm May 29 '21

That's what I'm afraid of. These people have no shame.

19

u/dpw700 May 28 '21

Blue Orgins kinda throwing a hissy fit. Tbh.

-1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Have you read their protest? It's actually got numerous valid points, especially how every single one of the identified weaknesses are downplayed for SpaceX (including previous delays on previous NASA projects), Yet so much is blasted on BO (I mean a freaking comms issue? That's fairly easy to fix tbh).

There's also the fact that's its a MOON contract yet MARS is mentioned multiple times within the selection process. That's like being a public servant and hiring a certain contractor to do a current job, because of what they can do for a future project that hasn't been announced yet. It means factors outside the parameters of the Artemis/HLS contract were involved.

7

u/[deleted] May 30 '21

especially how every single one of the identified weaknesses are downplayed for SpaceX

Did we read the same selection document?

Yet so much is blasted on BO (I mean a freaking comms issue? That's fairly easy to fix tbh).

The comms issue shouldn't be "really easy to fix". It shouldn't have been submitted at all. It's a problem because it means Blue Origin failed to do due diligence before submitting the bid. This is in comparison to the technical risks of the SpaceX bid which were clearly stated with a set of milestones demonstrating the retirement of risk for these systems along the way. There's no plan from Blue Origin to retire the most critical risks of the Blue Origin bid before the mission.

There's also the fact that's its a MOON contract yet MARS is mentioned
multiple times within the selection process. That's like being a public
servant and hiring a certain contractor to do a current job, because of
what they can do for a future project that hasn't been announced yet. It
means factors outside the parameters of the Artemis/HLS contract were
involved.

They mentioned Mars because Starship represents an opportunity to tackle longer term agency goals than just the contract, even though the contract itself was just for a moon landing demo. It's like hiring a public contractor to do a job, and instead of doing the bare minimum, they did a dozen other jobs you had planned for the future but were unsure if/when you'd have the budget to do them. Does Starship meet HLS requirements? Yes. Is NASA excited that suddenly they have many more options than they would have if Blue Origin did the same job? Also yes.

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Here are actual FACTS regarding the issues that NASA left out to make SPACEX look better
1)Comms issue was FIXED in the development process (someone else mentioned how Starship progress could change opinions, well using outdated info in a selection process is unprofessional):
"To close this RFA, Blue Origin held a joint Communications Technical Interchange Meeting (TIM) with NASA where the details of the communications architecture, analysis assumptions, and link budgets were reviewed. In response to this TIM, and the materials provided, NASA formally concurred with the Blue Origin architecture and analysis approach and the RFA was successfully closed in the HLS Systems Engineering Review Forum (SERF) on December 1, 2020. In other words, the Agency previously received, during the CBR, the same information and data on Blue Origin’s radio frequency communication architecture as what Blue Origin submitted in its Option A and, in its previous assessment, the Agency found that Blue Origin’s RF communications links closed. The Agency provides no explanation for why its conclusion is different during this Option A evaluation. Moreover, Blue Origin’s communications analysis was also independently validated by a new NASA Space Communications and Navigation (SCaN) study released on January 26, 2021, substantiating Blue Origin's analysis and the results in its Option A proposal. The table in the attached document compares the links analyzed by Blue Origin in its HLS Option A proposal with NASA’s SCaN report.... NASA reviewed Blue Origins approach for communications as part of the base period CBR milestone and FORMALLY ACCEPTED Blue Origin's technical approach"

2)As far as downplaying weaknesses, it is on full displayed with the cryo stuff alone: "The Agency noted that SpaceX’s technical approach involves “immense complexity and heightened risk” and requires “numerous in-space cryogenic propellant transfer events” prior to the time-critical HLS Starship launch. (Source Selection Statement at 11). Such in-space cryogenic propellant transfers require advanced CFM technologies from SpaceX that are both “low in maturity and have not been demonstrated in space.” The low technology readiness level (TRL) for SpaceX’s CFM system is illustrated by SpaceX’s October 2020 selection for a Tipping Point award. SpaceX was selected for a “[l]arge-scale flight demonstration to transfer 10 metric tons of cryogenic propellant, specifically liquid oxygen, between tanks on a Starship vehicle.” (See NASA Tipping Point Selections). Given that SpaceX has never demonstrated this technology in space, and certainly not on the operational scale its solution requires, its CFM system must have a low technology readiness level. The evaluation rating by the Agency was irrational and disparate. Moreover, the Agency downgraded Blue Origin for a possible delay in the award of Lockheed Martin’s Tipping Point contract, which is the same Tipping Point selection for which SpaceX was also chosen. It is patently a disparate treatment to downgrade the National Team for a possible delay in a Lockheed Martin Tipping Point contract award while simultaneously assessing SpaceX’s risk as lower for their use of the SAME Tipping Point contract vehicle.

Again, the Agency treated offers disparately: Given that SpaceX has yet to develop a mature cryogenic propellant transfer system, much less demonstrate it in space, its proposal should have been assessed a weakness."

3) The whole ladder vs elevator thing. SpaceX gets a STRENGTH for the deck being 100 FEEt up, BO gets docked for being about 33 Ft up

"Further, the Agency also applies an unstated evaluation criteria. There is no Solicitation requirement that defines a height limitation, preference or otherwise, of the lunar lander vehicle. Crew safety concerns related to crew ingress/egress are addressed by compliance with EVASC.0113, EVA-EXP-0070 Human Landing System EVA Compatibility IRD. This requirement has a 10-minute minimum threshold and a 5- minute goal for emergency ingress of crew. Blue Origin’s proposed response is 8 minutes, as documented in Proposal Attachment 38, MLRE-19900 - ISPA Appendix: Design and Performance Metrics, Technical Perf Metric Tab, cell E10 (proposed) and cell I10 (requirement). Moreover, in relation to crew safety, Blue Origin’s design includes two alternative methods of ingress/egress – a powered ascender-lift system and a passive ladder. lift. SpaceX’s design, by contrast, contains only one method of ingress and egress – a powered lift.

The Source Selection Official charitably overlooked the risks associated with SpaceX’s 100-feet high design and assigned SpaceX a significant strength, while impermissibly applying stricter scrutiny to Blue Origin’s substantially safer design and assessing Blue Origin a weakness. Had evaluation standards been consistently applied, SpaceX should have received a significant weakness or weakness for the lander height"

4)2nd downplay of SpaceX weakness. The abort stage only include ONE part that is actually for abort procedures. the rest is gushing over SpaceX tech:

The Source Selection Authority praised SpaceX’s abort approach design, stating – “I particularly find SpaceX’s strength under Technical Area of Focus 1 for its robust approach to aborts and contingencies to be compelling. This approach contains several key features, including: the application of its excess propellant margin to expedite ascent to lunar orbit in the event of an emergency early return; a comprehensive engine-out redundancy capability; and two airlocks providing redundant ingress/egress capability, each with independent environmental control and life support capabilities that can provide a safe haven for crew. Additionally, SpaceX’s design allows for the sourcing of excess propellant, which will provide crew with a large reserve supply of life support consumables in the event of a contingency event.” However, only one of the attributes highlighted by the selection statement directly apply to the abort capability – the propellant margin for early return. Engine out capability is required per the solicitation to provide failure tolerance to catastrophic hazards (BAA Requirement HLS-R-004 - Failure Tolerance to Catastrophic Events). The above statement in the source selection rationale regarding a lack of impact to crew safety from landing a 30 meter tall vehicle with NO independent abort system DOES NOT provide additional detail to support it. The SpaceX abort approach, which relies on the same system for landing and return, introduces risks identified as far back as the APOLLO PROGRAM, yet NOT identified by the SEP. These risks include: 1) Risk of Engine Damage on landing on lunar surface as experiences on Apollo 15 2)Risk of Engine Plume damage on critical system as experienced on Apollo 16, and descent plume debris erosion as observed on Surveyor III from the Apollo 12 Landing"

5) The Nav/Guidance BS here's what NASA says about the software in the Blue Origins AE the Agency states that “[t]his capability has never been implemented in human spaceflight, applications and will require significant development to increase necessary technology readiness levels necessary to achieve the requisite reliability of this capability" The Agency is incorrect. Blue Origin’s software is derived directly from the Orion Crew Vehicle, which will transport astronauts to lunar orbit.The software on the Blue Origin’s AE is derived directly from Orion. This capability is inherent in the Orion software for Artemis 2 and has already been tested and will be inherited directly from Orion for use on the AE. In addition, an earlier version of this software was flown on the Orion Exploration Flight Test 1 flight test in 2014."

NASA is basically saying its own software doesn't exist to try making Blue look bad. That would get a regular CEO fired.

6) Suddenly changing the commercialization from strength to weakness:

"In NASA’s evaluation of Blue Origin’s original Base Period proposal from November 2019, the Source Evaluation Panel (SEP) scored Blue Origin’s Commercial Approach (Management Focus 4) as a ”SIGNIFICANT STRENGTH”. Specifically NASA commented: “The offeror’s execution on its commercialization strategy and corporate contributions will be highly advantageous for the Government and therefore represent a significant strength.”It is unclear how this significant strength at the start of the Base Period became a weakness by the end, when all that changed in the interim was that the lander’s design was matured. The commercial approach in Blue Origin’s final Option A proposal built on the Significant Strength assessed for the Base Period Proposal, and had substantiation. The Agency unreasonably concluded the commercial approach was unsubstantiated, errantly evaluated this factor, and otherwise lacked a basis for its assessment of a weakness to Blue Origin for its proposed commercial approach."

Im reading the selection document next to the protest and while some bias is seen in the protest (I mean cmon), you can clearly see the Pro-SpaceX bias in the decision making document. The rationales employed are weak at best and show clear preference for Space-X, especially when they blame BO for the data rights issues, when THEY APPROVED EVERYTHING beforehand and Blue willingly negotiated info throughout the process. There is double standards galore and obvious fanboying towards SpaceX.

5

u/valcatosi May 31 '21

someone else mentioned how Starship progress could change opinions,

What I actually said is that starship testing could help buy down risk. For example, SpaceX demonstrating their tanking/detanking procedures, the hop ascent profile, pitch-over, header tank transition, and generally avionics/flight software/control systems is absolutely transferable to HLS, and retires risks that were absolutely present when the previous selection was made in spring 2020.

Comms issue was FIXED in the development process

This is what Blue Origin claims in their protest. Without access to the relevant documentation, none of us can prove or disprove it. If in fact this is true and caused the selection to be flawed, the GAO should sustain the protest, but that's a question for the GAO.

Moreover, the Agency downgraded Blue Origin for a possible delay in the award of Lockheed Martin’s Tipping Point contract, which is the same Tipping Point selection for which SpaceX was also chosen. It is patently a disparate treatment to downgrade the National Team for a possible delay in a Lockheed Martin Tipping Point contract award while simultaneously assessing SpaceX’s risk as lower for their use of the SAME Tipping Point contract vehicle.

Both SpaceX and Lockheed were awarded Tipping Point contracts to demonstrate in-space propellant transfer. That doesn't mean they're at the same level of technical maturity, or that the propellant transfers proposed are of equal difficulty, or that the proposed vehicles and procedures are equally likely to be ready on time. You're asserting that both being awarded contracts under the same program is tantamount to them being awarded identical contracts, which is a massive stretch. Because you seem very misinformed about a number of these things, "Tipping Point" is the name of a program that issued a number of contracts to a number of companies for a number of objectives. The SpaceX and Lockheed contracts are not the same, and cannot be evaluated as if they were.

Crew safety concerns related to crew ingress/egress are addressed by compliance with EVASC.0113, EVA-EXP-0070 Human Landing System EVA Compatibility IRD. This requirement has a 10-minute minimum threshold and a 5- minute goal for emergency ingress of crew. Blue Origin’s proposed response is 8 minutes

I have not seen Blue Origin's proposal. I have not seen SpaceX's proposal. I have not seen the NASA documentation evaluating the proposals. But when I look at this, I see two things - firstly, that NASA may not have found the 8 minute timeline credible, and secondly, that NASA may have found that Blue overlooked some risks associated with the system. I'm not saying either of those is true, and this is another question for the GAO to evaluate since it has access to the relevant technical data.

The Source Selection Official charitably overlooked the risks associated with SpaceX’s 100-feet high design and assigned SpaceX a significant strength, while impermissibly applying stricter scrutiny to Blue Origin’s substantially safer design and assessing Blue Origin a weakness. Had evaluation standards been consistently applied, SpaceX should have received a significant weakness or weakness for the lander height

SpaceX was criticized for poor crew visibility of the landing site due to the tall lander. It wasn't overlooked. Maybe NASA thought a 100 foot elevator was safer than a 30 foot ladder? Idk though that sounds crazy. The reason SpaceX was praised for the tall lander is that it put the crew far from the surface and any debris, which is something the National Team was touting in their presentations all along the way.

The SpaceX abort approach, which relies on the same system for landing and return, introduces risks identified as far back as the APOLLO PROGRAM, yet NOT identified by the SEP. These risks include: 1) Risk of Engine Damage on landing on lunar surface as experiences on Apollo 15 2)Risk of Engine Plume damage on critical system as experienced on Apollo 16, and descent plume debris erosion as observed on Surveyor III from the Apollo 12 Landing"

These risks are mitigated by Starship's typical landing sequence, involving vertical landing in higher gravity, and the mid-belt landing thrusters which are deliberately set away from the surface to reduce erosion and debris. Powered landing under higher thrust ensures that (2) is enveloped by flight experience, and similarly (1) is addressed by landing vertically in higher gravity which is a harder control problem.

5) The Nav/Guidance BS here's what NASA says about the software in the Blue Origins AE the Agency states that “[t]his capability has never been implemented in human spaceflight, applications and will require significant development to increase necessary technology readiness levels necessary to achieve the requisite reliability of this capability" The Agency is incorrect. Blue Origin’s software is derived directly from the Orion Crew Vehicle, which will transport astronauts to lunar orbit.The software on the Blue Origin’s AE is derived directly from Orion. This capability is inherent in the Orion software for Artemis 2 and has already been tested and will be inherited directly from Orion for use on the AE. In addition, an earlier version of this software was flown on the Orion Exploration Flight Test 1 flight test in 2014."

Yeah...I'm not finding this anywhere in the source selection document. Where's it from? Specifically, the NASA comment on the software.

6) Suddenly changing the commercialization from strength to weakness:

"In NASA’s evaluation of Blue Origin’s original Base Period proposal from November 2019, the Source Evaluation Panel (SEP) scored Blue Origin’s Commercial Approach (Management Focus 4) as a ”SIGNIFICANT STRENGTH”. Specifically NASA commented: “The offeror’s execution on its commercialization strategy and corporate contributions will be highly advantageous for the Government and therefore represent a significant strength.”It is unclear how this significant strength at the start of the Base Period became a weakness by the end, when all that changed in the interim was that the lander’s design was matured. The commercial approach in Blue Origin’s final Option A proposal built on the Significant Strength assessed for the Base Period Proposal, and had substantiation. The Agency unreasonably concluded the commercial approach was unsubstantiated, errantly evaluated this factor, and otherwise lacked a basis for its assessment of a weakness to Blue Origin for its proposed commercial approach."

Or the commercialization plan changed. Either way this is a question for the GAO which has access to the relevant documentation.

Im reading the selection document next to the protest and while some bias is seen in the protest (I mean cmon), you can clearly see the Pro-SpaceX bias in the decision making document. The rationales employed are weak at best and show clear preference for Space-X, especially when they blame BO for the data rights issues, when THEY APPROVED EVERYTHING beforehand and Blue willingly negotiated info throughout the process. There is double standards galore and obvious fanboying towards SpaceX.

Many of the claims you made are based on taking the protest as gospel and the selection statement as a biased trash heap. I'm waiting for the GAO to rule on this as an impartial third party, and writing walls of text doesn't make you right.

-1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Thats not how government contracts work. it means it was awarded on parameters OUTSIDE the HLS contract. Meaning awarding the HLS contract wasn't based on NON HLS FACTORS, which is equivalent to if you got a C on a paper in school where the papers were graded against each other, despite meeting every requirement the teacher laid out, but someone else got an A because they built a model to illustrate their point. Is it cool? Sure? Should it affect how you score projects against each other? NO. You have to evaluate on the CONTRACT standards ALONE.

HLS is only to get us to the moon. FUTURE contracts are for beyond the moon. Mentioning its usage in future missions means that Pro-SpaceX bias was employed on on contract that is literally ONLY for a LUNAR LANDER.

Last time I checked, if I'm competing for a contract to build a house, whether or not I have the ability to do more jobs in the future outside of the contract has NO BEARING on THAT contract. They can only take I to account if I meet the requirements for THAT contract and HAVE to EVALUATE us fairly. By them mentioning MARS, it's a portion that wasn't included as a requirement for HLS.

3

u/valcatosi May 31 '21

...Jeff? Is that you?

4

u/matt05891 Jun 05 '21

For real I'm convinced in reading this he works there.

He continually refers to Starships unproven tech as some sort of defense. Yeah I get it innovative (Space Exploration Changing) new tech might delay it and is high risk. But Blue Origin hasn't done anything comparative either, Grumman did. And those people are long retired, so their design is retreading and relearning old ground for a PR stunt moon walk. Government contract law aside; who the hell, unless you have a leg in the race, would complain that we must use existing SLS/Gateway/Orion etc. Be rational as someone who wants to see the space frontier expand. If they evolve beyond the scope of what was deemed possible originally AND the mission is cheaper for it it's a GOOD THING. For the taxpayers and space enthusiests/science. Not to mention the sheer gain of having Starship for future projects should it succeed. The poster hasn't remarked one positive attribute about that, perhaps because he is in complete defensive mode and missing the forest for the trees.

I understand that shit could fail, it always can, but how could one not working for them, or derive something tangible from their success, look at SpaceX's Starship and not see that as the best opportunity cost/ cost-benefit scenario? You'd have to have a stake somehow in Blue to not understand why, even if he's right legally in a corrupt and inept government buracratic way, he's wrong in the realm of public opinion. Again, missing the forest for the trees.

50

u/[deleted] May 27 '21

‘Open architecture’ but wouldn’t given NASA access to data rights they specifically asked for

9

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

just like amazon "cares about its workers" eh?

-2

u/nuger93 May 30 '21 edited May 30 '21

If NASA isn't an official contractor, then they have no rights to the R&D lab (likely played in the whole immaturity' of technology thing). NASA only has that access at SpaceX because their R&D is already under the scope due to the Dragon mission implications.

Otherwise you're letting someone in without a guaranteed contract who can take proprietary info and pass it on to your competitors if you don't win the contract.

8

u/[deleted] May 30 '21

Luckily this has nothing to do with Dragon Lol. BO was straight up non-compliant with the solicitation on multiple areas in regard to data, even with data created in conjunction with NASA. BO just needs to get over themselves.

-1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

They DON'T have to provide anything they develop in house on a non guaranteed contract. That's how it works with contractors. You don't let the government in until you have the contract. Otherwise you are just giving the government your tech for free.

I read the selection and saw nothing about BO being uncooperative, considering they got a very good management rating.

The only thing they were being pains about was the engine and that's because NASA is massive leaky leakers. The engines BO is making for ascent stage are proprietary, and just letting the government in because someone who is already contracted with them did is not a great practice, especially since all that design and spec would be made public and you lose your tech to the government with no compensation.

7

u/sebzim4500 May 31 '21

just letting the government in because someone who is already contracted with them did is not a great practice

You know what else is not a great practice? Losing the bid.

27

u/JoshuaZ1 May 27 '21

The strange thing is that between the GAO protest and the lobbying it does look like they are willing to delay to start things over. This Tweet has little connection with what Blue and the rest of the National Team are actually doing.

23

u/Stop_calling_me_matt May 27 '21

NASA should award NT $2.9 billion and SpaceX $7.1 billion

11

u/Cunninghams_right May 28 '21

not even "award", make the remaining funding an "X-prize", so that NT gets $0 until they land on the moon. old space has made a cottage industry out of getting paid billions to get half way though building something before running out of money, requesting obscene amounts with no end in sight, and NASA just cancelling

2

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

NASA should send them a box full of dog crap.

NT is trash.

0

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Except Grumman is literally the only company involved that has ACTUALLY built a machine that landed humans on the moon (they built the Apollo Lunar modules).

SpaceX is all UNPROVEN flair with Starship. We are supposed to believe that a ship that JUST had its first successful unmanned landing is going to be ready for a crewed mission to the the moon in 3 years, with the modifications in tech noted that have yet to be developed? Dragon worked because it's basically a 21st century Apollo capsule. So what not to do was already done for Musk almost 40 years before.

5

u/PaulC1841 May 31 '21

50 years ago. I'm Not sure how many Grumman emgineers from Apollo are still alive and you make it somehow as a strong point for Grummam. For Chirst sake, Boeing forgot how to write software in a decade. The only thing what matters is who is doing real work now. Past glory doesn't get you anywhere.

5

u/[deleted] May 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ravenerOSR May 27 '21

Use whatever money they get for a second round, which presumably spacex wins again leading to just an expanded scope for the contract.

3

u/[deleted] May 28 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/ravenerOSR May 28 '21

The "second round" was always planned and spacex can absolutely compete in it, its a new contract and doesent interfere with the old

0

u/[deleted] May 28 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Except it's not. GAO could rule that NASA acted in an unjust manner and force NASA to rescind the contract. (The fact they don't address the risks of a 100foot elevator on the OUTSIDE of Starship, but blast a ladder that isn't all that much higher than the original Lunar Landers from the 60s and 70s (ladder came to a hatch about midway up the crew module on Apollo, and the ascent stage and descent adage together was about 26ish feet.) SpaceX got a contract BO won overturned in a similar fashion.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

It's BS because I spoke the truth about how that contract IS NOT guaranteed. NaSA literally had to susoend the contract until the GAO makes its ruling Ergo. it's not BS. That's how government contracts work in the US.. If the Government Accountability office (GAO) finds wrongdoing in the award process, it can pretty much force NASA, a government agency to undo the contract. If NASA refuses, the findings get forwarded on to congress which then could result in Congressional hearings. GAO typically doesn't overturn, but if it sustains many of the complaints, it can render the award process as biased which can force it to be withdrawn. It's NOT guaranteed contract, and since the objection of just BO is over 100 pages long, it's far more than just the money figures.

You can go eff yourselves until you learn how government contracts actually work. NASA wouldn't have suspended the contract if the GAOs decision didn't have the potential to undo it, as it can't spend money it doesn't have.

1

u/valcatosi Jun 05 '21

since the objection of just BO is over 100 pages long

As Scott Manley would say, "throw enough shit at the wall, and some of it's going to stick"

NASA wouldn't have suspended the contract if the GAOs decision didn't have the potential to undo it,

NASA suspended the contract because it's standard procedure to do so whenever there's a GAO protest. Including when the protest has no reasonable chance of success. I really wouldn't read much into this.

37

u/FutureMartian97 May 27 '21

Are they trying to seriously play this off like they didn't cause this mess?

6

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

Yup.

Exactly that. Blue is old space through and through. Cause problems, profit from it, and then pretend they didn't do anything.

-21

u/Veedrac May 27 '21

They didn't.

20

u/ravenerOSR May 27 '21

They caused the shitty legal and political circus, and they also caused this whole thing to begin with by submitting a pretty daft bid, especially in hindsight.

-8

u/Veedrac May 28 '21

Blue Origin... caused Congress to underfund NASA by submitting a bid that NASA liked and wanted to buy? This is an absolutely ridiculous claim. NASA was underfunded to buy a single bid, and only managed to afford SpaceX's because they footed half the bill and delayed some payments.

The largest farce of this whole situation is how much people have lied about what happened.

20

u/ravenerOSR May 28 '21

They didnt cause the underfunding, but they also didnt have a claim to a contract. The program would select up to two as far as i understand it, meaning that a single winner was always on the table. Going out to sabotage the process to to get into the club is a shitty move.

-11

u/Veedrac May 28 '21

Nobody's pretending they “have a claim to a contract”.

What happened is that Congress underfunded HLS, NASA didn't get to pick two landers like they wanted to, Congress didn't like that, so Congress is retroactively going through the process to fund HLS enough to pick two landers (though this is still about a factor two less than NASA's original funding request).

This is not Blue Origin's fault in any shape or form.

13

u/valcatosi May 28 '21

I think it's a bit disingenuous to ignore the obvious implication of Cantwell being from Washington state (and the co-sponsor being from Mississippi, which now gets endless additional core stage testing).

-1

u/Veedrac May 28 '21

This is just not what words mean. Yes, it looks like Congress is being favourable towards National Team for political reasons, yes there are problems this causes with regards to fairness. This does not mean that the problems with HLS were caused by Blue Origin! Those are fundamentally different things!

11

u/valcatosi May 28 '21

The problems related to underfunding? No, of course not. That's Congress being Congress.

The problems related to the Cantwell amendment, if it passes, slowing the whole program or drawing scrutiny from e.g. Bernie Sanders and getting funding cut further? I'd argue the amendment is at least in large part due to Blue Origin.

-2

u/Veedrac May 28 '21 edited May 28 '21

if it passes, slowing the whole program

Nonsense. Nothing in the amendment would slow HLS. It would not even make it more vulnerable to funding cuts. If anything, this makes Congress less likely to underfund the program again, because last time they did it they got bit.

drawing scrutiny from e.g. Bernie Sanders and getting funding cut further

It is absurdly ridiculous to blame Bernie Sanders' dislike of spending money on private spaceflight on Blue Origin.

→ More replies (0)

36

u/KCConnor May 27 '21

I fail to see how NT can be competitive when their bid is twice the cost of the winning bidder, and their capacity is less than 10% of the winning bidder.

That's not "competitive."

I'd be pissed at NASA for giving a contract, for more money and less value, to the "also ran" team.

6

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

NASA won't have a choice. This is happening because Bezos is buying politicians. Corruption pure and simple.

-1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Because HLS was primarily to get back to the moon. It wasn't what HLS was bastardizted to in the selection document. Commercialization was a subsect. Yet it seemed to become a NASA priority.

Also helps that the fact that the propulsion system for SpaceX relies on tech not yet developed (especially lunar refueling) was glossed overwhelming, while blasting a tried and true tech in the NT lunar module.

They also spent almost half a paragraph making it sound like having redundancies in the system to prevent loss of crew was a BAD thing, in addition to droning on about comms not closing acting like it would sink a mission.

Yet they barely touch on the issues with Starship (the elevator is hardly mentioned), nor is seeming disregard for the basic tenant of the HLS contract that it use SLS and Orion to get to the moon. If it doesn't use that, then NASA wasted billions to just give a contract that utilizes those to a company that won't use them .

4

u/IllustriousBody May 31 '21

So basically you can’t understand that riding an elevator in a space suit is safer than climbing 30 feet of ladder in a space suit.

1

u/nuger93 May 31 '21

BO has a powered lift too? NASAs selection document is rife with outdated info that is fairly easy to find documentation and updates from both SpaceX and Blue as it happened. But if you're going to knock 30 feet with lift AND ladder, you HAVE to knock 100 feet with ONLY a lift just as much especially when there wasn't a height limitation presference, or otherwise in the base requirements for the lunar lander vehicle.

The egress requirement was 10 minutes, and BO had a proposal of 8 minutes. I can't find documentation of how long it takes to get to the top of Starship in the SpaceX proposal. (Still looking)

Honestly, NASAs selection doc reeks of regret from picking Boeing to compete with SpaceX, so now they are just trying to justify not giving anything to anyone else, when you minimize risks for SpaceX on unproven tech, and Maximize it for everyone else on unproven tech. It's basically having 2 people who turned in projects that met the requirements, but one gets a better grade because you give the benefit of the doubt on EVERYTHING. Its a highly unethical way to do contracts.

5

u/IllustriousBody May 31 '21

No Blue only has a ladder. That's the problem. Physical exertion in a spacesuit is extremely difficult, and that's an issue. As long as the person is alive, you can get them back into the LSS, which may not be the case with the NT lander. SpaceX also has enough mass capacity to carry spare parts if necessary.

It's also important that SpaceX has mitigated a number of risks. For example, the refuelling. Not only do they have to develop it for other purposes, but also failing to transfer propellant on any given flight doesn't put the crew at risk, as they can wait to launch Orion until the LSS is fueled.

0

u/nuger93 May 31 '21

No they don't. Blue literally cites in their rebuttal that they have a Power lift as well. I trust the company making the rocket to know what's in their damn rocket!!! .

https://youtu.be/w6bTFpjeFgE

Time stamp around 9:10 clear shows an early animation concept LIFT (lifting a rover). Meaning the tech EXISTS for the Lander somewhere in development. If they have a lift, NASA HAS to co sider that too, and they just have to figure out how to attach upon landing. (I imagine SpaceX won't have their lift out when it's not in use either.

36

u/Interstellar_Sailor May 27 '21

It's so low-risk that the astronauts would actually have to do a special EVA just to throw away some parts of the lander 'cause it's too heavy.

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

No different than Apollo Lunar Landers.

3

u/MoaMem May 30 '21

EXACTLY! Hence the problem!

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

It's better than a system that the entire proposal hinges on a complex refueling system which hasn't even begun to be refined yet and NASA ide tidied as extremely high risk, even in the selection document.

Sometimes just because cmso.ething is fancy and flashy doesn't me it actually does everything. They haven't proven the star ship systems work in flight (anything can work in a lab when you control the variables when NASA is around). But it took SpaceX NINE YEARS to get Crewed Dragon flight, they are trying to convince the world they'll have people on the moon in 3 with a ship that has yet to make it to orbit. (APOLLO we knew we could do it because of the mercury and Gemini programs)

34

u/ghunter7 May 27 '21 edited May 27 '21

LOL "throwing everything away and starting over". This is a rich statement coming from a company whose history consists of almost nothing BUT throwing everything away and starting over.

Exhibit A: Goddard and the BE-1 engine. A neat R&D vehicle, but not one that lead down any path to an actual product.

Exhibit B: New Shepard as powered by the BE-2 engine all thrown away after one single test failure.

Exhibit C: Orbital launch vehicle powered by BE-3 They just dropped all this any moved onto the BE-3 powered New Glenn at some point.

Exhibit D: Biconic orbital human spacecraft for Commercial Crew Dev Blue simply dropped out of the CCdev program, this design seemed to have just disappeared rather than Blue trying to continue development of a cargo variant like SNC is doing with Dream Chaser.

Exhibit E: 2 stage New Glenn with BE-4U and 3 stage NG Somewhere in deciding that BO would compete for NSSL they tossed out this design and redesigned NG around a 2xBE-3U upper stage.

Exhibit F: Blue Moon powered by BE-3 engine and Methalox landing thrusters Original design would have used methalox thrusters for the final touchdown, I had read previously it was also envisioned to be powered by BE-3 for main propulsion before they decided to start a brand new engine program in BE-3 (source needed).

Exhibit G: 7 meter Blue Moon revised to 5 meter Blue Moon which of course directly relates to Blue Origin's ILS proposal which of course requires...

Blue Origin's HLS proposal literally entails throwing (most) everything away and starting over. From the source selection statement:

Here, although the design of Blue Origin’s sustainable architecture represents a strength within its proposal, I am particularly concerned with the offsetting weakness for Blue’s plan to evolve its initial lander into this sustainable design. While the solicitation does not require sustainable features for the offeror’s initial approach, it did require the offeror to propose a clear, well-reasoned, and cost-effective approach to achieving a sustainable capability. Blue Origin proposed a notional plan to do so, but this plan requires considerable reengineering and recertifying of each element, which calls into question the plan’s feasibility, practicality, and cost-effectiveness. Blue Origin’s two architectures are substantially different from one another. For example, the changes required for evolving Blue’s Ascent Element include resizing the cabin structure to accommodate four crew, thermal control system upgrades, bigger fans, and propellant refueling interfaces. And to accommodate the additional mass of the Ascent Element and to reach non-polar locations, Blue Origin’s Descent Element requires a complete structural redesign, larger tanks using a new manufacturing technique, a refueling interface, radiator upgrades, and a performance enhancement to its main engine. The SEP observed that this “from the ground-up” plan is likely to require additional time, considerable effort, and significant additional cost to design and develop new technologies and capabilities, and to undertake re-engineering and re-certification efforts for Blue Origin’s sustainable lander elements utilizing new heavier lift launch vehicles and modified operations. I share this concern. When viewed cumulatively, the breadth and depth of the effort that will be required of Blue Origin over its proposed three-year period calls into question Blue’s ability to realistically execute on its evolution plan and to do so in a cost-effective manner.

Of course some of these can just be written off as design changes and evolution, a company like SpaceX certainly has more than their fair share of those, but when a companies history consists of so many of these and so few completed products there is clearly a consistent theme that signifies a problem with leadership and vision.

5

u/JoshuaZ1 May 27 '21

This seems a little unfair. SpaceX has threw away their plans for a hydrolox upper stage for Falcon Heavy, and threw away Grey Dragon and Red Dragon. Throwing things away is fine. And one of the advantages of some of the new space companies (SpaceX especially but to some extent Rocketlab also) is a willingness to radically switch things. The key is to not throw away so much and keep switching directions so much that nothing gets done.

16

u/ghunter7 May 27 '21

Yes, I did an edit (probably while you were typing this) that said something similar.

"Sunk cost fallacy" is a term that gets thrown out far too often, as I think Blue is an example of the costs of overapplication of the opposite.

9

u/JoshuaZ1 May 27 '21

Yeah, I see your edit now and I'm essentially in agreement with that.

2

u/ioncloud9 May 29 '21

SpaceX abandoned Falcon 1e, Falcon 5, grey dragon, red dragon, full reusability on falcon 9, but the difference is they abandoned these projects to focus on other things that were more pressing AND which they executed on. Falcon 1e and 5 were abandoned to focus on Falcon 9, red dragon was abandoned because of changes in the dragon 2 landing and to focus on starship, grey dragon was abandoned to focus on starship and to avoid having to man rate falcon heavy, and the full reusability was pushed to starship as it was more feasible with a larger vehicle.

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21 edited May 30 '21

Getting the Crewed NASA contract in 2008 also had a shit ton to do with that because they had a contract to push the directive.

1

u/ioncloud9 May 30 '21

I thought it was just commercial cargo services in 2008

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

The contract was to prove it could get to the ISS unmanned (cargo)first, then passenger. But the cargo contractcwas lucrative to a company on the verge of bankruptcy.

29

u/Arata02_ May 27 '21

Can't believe they have the guts to post that

4

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

Why? Bezos has no morals. He's the richest man in the world because he steps on everyone else.

9

u/NotTheHead May 27 '21

I know, right? They've really got some gall. Who's suggesting that HLS start over? SpaceX is ready to go and chomping at the bit.

0

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

SpaceX isn't even using most of the HLS infrastructure. It's noted that they would ne using most of theirnown stuff, which begs the question of why NASA chose a proposal that uses very little of a system they've spent billions on? That would be like spending tons of money to fix up a house you bought, but then deciding to live in an apartment while still owning a livable house.

And Starship isn't 'ready to go they haven't sent a crew into orbit with it yet. They haven't even proved it won't burn up on reentry at the speeds it needs yet.

Some playing it safe is better until the infrastructures get set up.

Right now they are banking everything on UNPROVEN ideas and designs.

2

u/NotTheHead May 31 '21

SpaceX isn't even using most of the HLS infrastructure.

Are you somehow under the impression that SpaceX is launching the Artemis astronauts from Earth on Starship? Because that's not how this works. Astronauts will launch in Orion on SLS and meet whatever HLS lander in Lunar orbit, with or without the Gateway. SpaceX's HLS profile doesn't involve skipping the use of SLS or Orion, and while it can skip the Gateway, it doesn't have to, and thats a good thing because the Gateway may not even be ready by the first mission.

Or are you saying you should have launched their lander on SLS? Because that's a little ridiculous. Regardless, I don't see anything in the source selection document about them not using pre-established HLS infrastructure.

And Starship isn't 'ready to go they haven't sent a crew into orbit with it yet. They haven't even proved it won't burn up on reentry at the speeds it needs yet.

  1. I wasn't saying that SpaceX was already ready to put people on the Moon today. I was saying they were ready to start breaking ground on development of their HLS design and to get working on the first mission.

  2. It's entirely irrelevant that they haven't launched people on Starship because people aren't going to launch on Starship for Artemis. They're launching in Orion on SLS and meeting the Starship lander in Lunar orbit. They also aren't returning to Earth on Starship; they're returning on Orion after transferring back in Lunar orbit.

Right now they are banking everything on UNPROVEN ideas and designs.

But they're working right now on proving it out. They've got an enormous amount of run time on the Raptor engines, and they're rapidly making progress on getting the launcher to orbit. Specifically, here's what Lueders had to say in the source selection document:

Finally, within Technical Area of Focus 7, Approach to Early Systems Demonstrations, I agree with the SEP’s assignment of a significant strength for SpaceX’s robust early system demonstration ground and flight system campaign, which focuses on the highest risk aspects of its proposed architecture. This will allow SpaceX to isolate and address performance and operational issues early in its development cycle, which will meaningfully inform the maturation of its capability and increase overall confidence in its performance abilities.

Most of the "UNPROVEN ideas and designs" are things they need to work out to make Starship a competitive satellite launch platform, which is a thing they've dedicated to make happen.

5

u/ThreatMatrix May 28 '21

Literally everything in that tweet is a lie.

20

u/getBusyChild May 27 '21 edited May 27 '21

Would think someone would pull Bezos, and the management of Blue Origin to the side to advise them to stop this. They are throwing what good will, if they have any left, out the window. All for $10 billion, for a company that is owned by the richest man on Earth.

edit: Oops.

5

u/ReturnOfDaSnack420 May 28 '21 edited May 28 '21

I think that $500 million yacht has sailed by now. Blue Origin and Bezos have shown their true colors to the world at this point and what they've revealed is pretty damn loathsome.

5

u/webs2slow4me May 27 '21

$10 Billion

9

u/[deleted] May 27 '21

Why doesn’t Blue just design their own lunar lander? Like make an SSTO hydrolox one like Lockheed originally planned. They have the capital (I’m pretty sure).

10

u/KCConnor May 27 '21

Pretty sure the Lockheed MADV is utter vaporware. If such a vehicle can descend to Mars surface from Mars orbit and reascend again and refuel at an awaiting space station, then it's capable of the same on the moon. No need for staging and oldspace parts leprosy.

If it was any farther along than a 3D model that may not even accurately reflect its mass, engine output, and fuel consumption needs, Lockheed would have been foolish to pair with all the others and should have just pitched it alone.

21

u/webs2slow4me May 27 '21

Bezos needs another yacht instead

3

u/WendoNZ May 27 '21

yacht island

1

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

At the size of his new one, is there much of a difference?

2

u/captaintrips420 May 27 '21

The ‘self funded’ part is only for building construction and not for anything that nasa would want.

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Because Grumman is still the ONLY US company to have successfully landed man on the moon. You can't just pass up that expertise because the design doesn't look like a comic book. Dragon literally is a 21st century Apollo capsule, why can't BO make a 21st lunar lander that looks like the classic one?

19

u/aullik May 27 '21

well that's some marketing speech if i have ever seen one.

The dynetics concept was much better IMO. The BO concept sadly wont get anywhere.

13

u/sicktaker2 May 27 '21

The design had some attractive features at first glance, but fell flat when they actually started fleshing it out. Negative mass allocation is rocket design doom.

6

u/aullik May 28 '21 edited May 28 '21

Negative mass allocation means the system was in fact NOT fleshed out. It means they either build their system to large or their engines to small. We don't know. I'm not saying they didn't make mistakes but their design is inherently better than the National Teams system where your payload ends up on the very top and have nearly no way of bringing material back from the moon.

BOs decent element is by all accounts massive while being one time use. Can't say anything positive or negative about The ascent element other than it being ON TOP of BOs module is also not reusable. Meaning its a one time throwaway system. The Transfer element is a one time throwaway unit that only brings you half way. Meaning the Ascent Element has to power all the way to the gateway.

This concept is worse than the Apollo concept despite them having much more limitations. Sure the implementation will be better due to newer technology, but that's nothing to be proud of. You should at least come up with a better concept than what was used 50 years ago

EDIT: I just noticed that the Ascend Element isn't reusable either.

1

u/sicktaker2 May 28 '21

The ascent and transfer elements were designed to eventually enable reuse. While they would initially not be reused, it would have been attempted with later missions.

5

u/aullik May 28 '21

That is incorrect. The Descent element, so the BO module, was intended to be reusable once they create fuel on the moon. However don't expect this within the foreseeable future and not with current generation hardware. The Transfer element was designed to be destroyed. The Ascent element works on hypergolics and it is not build as to be refueled in space.

1

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

No

They are designed to be "redesigned for several billion more". Option A is a single use, and then get paid billions of dollars to design a reusable version. Its designed to screw NASA repeatedly

0

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

So I guess Apollo never brought anything back from the moon??

The Dragon Capsule is literally a 21st century Apollo capsule.

You literally don't understand that Grumman (part of NT) was the one who designed the lunar modules used on Apollo. That design is PROVEN. Starship isn't. The contract was only to get people TO the moon and back to Gateway/Orion which is no different than the ascent stage of the Apollo lander having to meet up with the command module in lunar orbit.

Flashy isn't always better. Sometimes the tried and true tech is the way to go initally, at least until you can get inital infrastructure set up. THEN you can make the hub.

3

u/aullik May 30 '21

Have you even read my comment?

 

So I guess Apollo never brought anything back from the moon??

They brought back a few small rocks. This system will have an even harder time doing the same. Why? Because they have to get it up a 10 meter ladder. Don't expect them to bring anything bigger with this system.

 

The Dragon Capsule is literally a 21st century Apollo capsule.

Correct. Same basic concept, small changes and upgrades mostly due to better materials, manufacturing and electronics. Same goes for Orion and Starliner. Soyus and Shenzhou are a bit different, but all are capsules. Turns out that capsules are pretty cost effective systems for small spcacecraft that want to reenter into the atmosphere.

 

You literally don't understand that Grumman (part of NT) was the one who designed the lunar modules used on Apollo. That design is PROVEN. Starship isn't. he contract was only to get people TO the moon and back to Gateway/Orion ...

I do understand / know that but I don't see the point you are trying to make here? The basic concept was proven, the new design wasn't. This is still different than the Apollo lander and judging by the 10m ladder even worse. It is correct that the initial contract is just to get you from the gateway to the surface and back once. However the mission statement is to get to the moon and to stay. So the goal is to do that repeatedly and this system simply cannot do that and this is what I'm judging it by even tho as you said it is not the primary requirement. However spending soo much money for something that becomes irrelevant within a short time is just stupid.

Starhip is a gamble and nothing else and its a cheap gamble. If it works, its massive, even if it is 10 or even 50 times more expensive than what Elon claims (which is likely, as his claims are mostly bullshit). However starships price per ton to the moon will still be a lot lower than anything the competition can do. The tradeoff is that its has to be a massive payload to get it cheap, however that would still be great news for a moon base.

 

And just to make this clear, im primarily arguing against the National team here as their system sucks. I still carry a slimmer of hope that the dynetics system actually wins out over blue origin as they simply have the better concept.

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

It's not that hard to employ a pulley system (like Apollo did) An elevator has a great chance of breaking down too. What the faux are you expecting them to bring back, a moon cow? Bringing back bigger things means they have to be able to CARRY itto the ship as well.While they could deploy a rover, they'd still be hameavikt limited by weight on the rover.

A 10 m ladder is still more reliable than a 30.48 meter elevator, against a ship that is reflecting radiation and such onto the astronauts and has a high probability of failure in 1/6 gravity. If the cables fail, those astro nuts are screwed, especially if they are 50+ feet up as there isn't enough gravitational pull to pull them down right away like there is on earth. The fact the elevator is outside and not inside is a horrible design.

The dynetics system was actually rated MARGINAL by NASA (BO and SpaceX got acceptable) so Dynetics has worse chances.

2

u/aullik May 30 '21

I know the rating and if you look at the comment on top you see my opinion on that. Their design was NOT fleshed out.

An elevator should be better than a ladder but thats not the point. Starship is OVERKILL. I have no idea why that should fail more in 1/6 gravity tho. Why would the cables suddenly fail? Why wouldn't there be enough gravity for the elevator to go down? That argument makes no sense. Point is that they have to test/prove this without crew repeatedly. But for big material and machines it will be the best solution.

Starship will be a lot more expensive than whatever perfect case estimate Elon made. It will be a more expensive than the BO solution, however it will also be more than 10 times as capable. So it will be the primary provider for material.

Even tho I have to repeat myself, the BO concept is not good. They might win due to better lobbyists, but at the end their system can only ever be used for a repeat of the apollo mission, not if you want to stay on the moon. Which means when the second phase comes along, this concept has to be scrapped nearly completely.

Creating a concept that is such short term is just stupid. Even if Dynetics have their problem, their concept is much better because it doesn't have to be scrapped.

What the National team proposed here is designed as an employment creation measure as they will receive a lot of money again for the next step.

Now its not my money, im not American, I still think its really stupid to pay money for that. Go with Dynetics, they make much more sense. Sure they might be less experienced and the first mission might actually be more expensive with them, but once reuse becomes a mission requirement you do not have to develop a completely new system.

6

u/szarzujacy_karczoch May 27 '21

What the HLS program needs is less meddling. If BO can do that, it will help NASA return to the Moon. It's literally as simple as letting NASA do its job

0

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Except with this contract, SpaceX has effectively monopolized NASA due to Boeings failure (which everyone else is being punished for)

SpaceX owns the EXCLUSIVE lease to launchpad 39A, the only commerical pad at the Cape. (Companies can use 39B for now until SLS picks up), it has the cargo and passenger contracts and makes $60 million per launch from NASA.

NASA DIDNT do its job here. It's job was to get back to the moon using SLS and Orion and an HLS chosen.. The NT design is literally a 21st century design of the Apollo Lunar Moduke Grumman designed that landed Armstrong on the moon (kind of like how dragon is a 21st century Apollo capsule) HLS was hitching a ride on SLS/Orion. There was no prerequisite that you needed your own rockets.

SpaceX is using an unproven design that hasn't even left earth's orbit yet, and yet they got the Lander contract and aren't using SLS or Orion.

3

u/szarzujacy_karczoch May 30 '21

SpaceX has a great track record and many orbital flights and commercial contracts under their belt. Meanwhile BO failed to secure a single major contract in their 20 yeas of existence. Obviously, NASA has infinitely more faith in SpaceX being able to pull this off. They got burned by the old space approach with Boeing and the Commercial Crew program

1

u/nuger93 May 30 '21

Except BO has gotten plenty of contracts (it actually got one pulled out from under it in similar fashion by Musk and SpaceX, for something Musk didnt really care about, he just wanted wanted screw with Bezos) BO has only been on ORBITAL flights for about years. It took 7.5 years for SpaceX to go orbital and if NASA hadn't gone all nostalgia colored in its commerical crew program, SoaceX would be dead right now. That 08 contact ked to millions in investments into spacex.

I don't have faith in S0aceX creating tech that doesn't exist, quality testing it, testing it and having it ready by 2024. Yet they didn't bash SpaceX ONCE for their propulsion system still relying on tech that doesn't exist. But they bashed BO for the fact that life support parts might not be fully tested before the UNCREWED mission.

SpaceX hasn't shown that Starship has good life support either. It hasn't shown Starship can safely land a crew either. They want us to believe Starship is landing people on the moon in 3 years, when it took them almost 3 years to build and land a Starship without it blowing up? Dragon was easy, it was basically updating the Apollo capsule for the 21st century (and Boeing managed to doink it up because of thr bean counters being in charge rather than engineers in high posts)

But Starship hasn't proven anything crew wise, yet NASA is staking the future there, when HLS is SUPPOSED to use SLS and Orion/Gateway.

4

u/Nickolicious May 28 '21

Does open architecture mean a wide open, empty building? Get to orbit first you asshats

6

u/JoshuaZ1 May 27 '21

Could people please stop expressing their displeasure by downvoting official Blue Origin tweets and announcements they don't like? There's legitimate reason to be annoyed at this, but this is clearly a relevant topic of discussion that should be here.

13

u/Cunninghams_right May 28 '21

BO tweeted it to spread a bullshit message. the downvote button means "I think fewer people should see this". but I think think fewer people should to see BO's propaganda to try to spin the whole shit-show they've caused.

2

u/JoshuaZ1 May 28 '21

I'd be sympathetic to that argument if this were in say a general space sub. But this sub is dedicated to discussion of Blue in general, which should include discussion of things Blue does even if those are things one considers bullshit.

5

u/Cunninghams_right May 28 '21

the post wasn't removed. I would agree that it shouldn't be removed.

0

u/JoshuaZ1 May 28 '21

No, but downvoting such posts discourages others from posting similar things in this subreddit in the future.

13

u/ravenerOSR May 27 '21

No i dont think i will. One of the mods might want to make a burner account for posting these if they care for karma because that thumb down came out on pure instinct.

3

u/deadman1204 May 28 '21

Its a BS message trying to lie and make it not look like they are lining up to steal billions from NASA.

Like it or not, voting on reddit is agree/disagree.

1

u/tanrgith May 30 '21

I'm in favor of the National Team getting a contract since I think having more than one option is a good thing as it provides redundancy.

But the idea that them getting a contract for a lander would be because it adds needed competition to the HLS program is kind of laughable.

1

u/IllustriousBody May 31 '21

How anyone can call a design that will not have its main propulsion system tested in flight configuration before attempting to use it to take off to bring astronauts home from the Moon low risk is beyond me.

0

u/[deleted] May 27 '21

[deleted]

16

u/ravenerOSR May 27 '21

I dont root for them at all, and it has nothing to do with them just being bad at showing progress. I just cant stand the culture they show and honestly wish them the worst. Even the pr makes me angry. They trump themselves up to be gods gift to the aerospace comunity for the most menial stuff.