133
95
u/matrixsuperstah Jan 17 '25
I prefer Star Glenn
59
u/HaleysViaduct Jan 17 '25
Really it should be New Heavy or Super Glenn since there’s no Starship anymore
27
6
u/H2SBRGR Jan 17 '25
Neither “New” nor “Star” or “Ship” are with us anymore; so we’re left with “Super” “Heavy” and “Glenn”
12
1
u/raptured4ever Jan 18 '25
In that case Glenn Super
In Australia we have some spray disinfectant product called glen20 so I'm sure it can be marketed
3
37
u/NASATVENGINNER Jan 17 '25
Not to scale
10
u/falconzord Jan 17 '25
It just needs a tapered interstage. Might make it look more like the original 2 stage New Glenn concept
71
24
8
u/F1ux_Capacitor Jan 17 '25
Literally had this conversation with my wife last night. "They're have a full rocket between them"
5
u/Maverick21FM Jan 17 '25
How amazing would it be if the 2nd stage of Glenn actually fit on Super Heavy.
5
u/WjU1fcN8 Jan 17 '25
It's not just the size difference. Recoverable boosters are small for the size of the rocket, they can't do as much work as a disposable booster or they can't reenter and land.
But for Starship they took that to 11, the TWR is extreme for a second stage, something like 0.88 and also the Δv. Because the booster always return to the launch site, it does even less work comparatively.
Even if the size increased, but still was disposable (so no heat shield tax), it still wouldn't be enough. It would need plenty more engines (perhaps even ditching Hydrogen) and associated plumbing to be able to be launched by Super Heavy.
Starship is a very different rocket to everything that came before.
5
4
u/Ok_Inevitable_7898 Jan 17 '25
Now make a rocket with New Glenn booster and Starship second stage. New Star
1
4
3
3
5
u/highgravityday2121 Jan 17 '25
Does anyone know if the crew capsule for new Glenn is going to me similar to starship in size wise and Reusability?
15
u/Unlikely_Promotion99 Jan 17 '25
No, not at all. First of all; second stage of NG is not reusable and Second, it is way smaller (only 7m diameter, instead of Starships 9m diameter) seems like not that much, but the area/ volume you gain with the small increase of diameter is gigantic.
NG is more like a beefed up Falcon, whilst Starship is a rocket that is the biggest rocket, with lots of techniques we have never seen in spaceflight.
1
u/highgravityday2121 Jan 17 '25
Could the second stage of NG be designed for reusability for a crew vessel? or would that be to much work?
How big would the crew vessel for NG be?
5
u/Unlikely_Promotion99 Jan 17 '25
It would be very hard to make the entire stage reusable/ crew vessel. It will probably be way more like SpaceX's Dragon; a small crew module on top of the second stage, instead of landing the full 2nd stage. The crew module could be reusable, but needs lots of refurbishments, like crew dragon.
Re-entring from orbital speeds is already insanely difficult, but making a heatshield that can withstand this multiple times is a million times harder.
3
u/AeroSpiked Jan 17 '25
I haven't heard anything about a crew vessel for NG, but it could potentially be much larger than Dragon. Going from a 3.7m diameter to 7m would be impressive, especially given that it could be roughly twice the mass as Dragon. For a closer comparison, Orion is only 5m in diameter.
No where near Starship, of course, but it would still be a huge improvement in pressurized volume.
2
u/Unlikely_Promotion99 Jan 17 '25
Yeah, 7m diameter and some more length would be suitable for a (short stay) liveable habitat! Really hope they are working on a crew vessel, which I guess they are, or will be, since the big dream of Jeff/ BO is to have a liveable habitat in space.
1
u/highgravityday2121 Jan 17 '25
I thought they designed NG with human flight capabilities in my mind so i just assumed they would have a crew vessel.
Heat shield technology is either ceramics which are light weight but weak or titanium which is heavy?
1
2
2
u/sptp Jan 18 '25
I was wondering if it would be possible and make any sense to mount an entire (expendable) Falcon 9 on top of Super Heavy, with some adaptations. To send probes to the outer Solar System, for example.
2
2
u/ryanl442 Jan 21 '25
if they put the NG stage 2 on the super heavy booster, it will YEET that thing to mars or Valhalla
1
u/Ill-Efficiency-310 Jan 17 '25
SpaceX has never shown much interest in using LH2 on their launch vehicles. Maybe you can bring along the blue origin launch engineers and hardware from their launch pad to supplement it.
2
u/WjU1fcN8 Jan 17 '25
According to Tom Mueller, they were very close to choosing Hydrolox for Starship. But the advantage istill wasn't great enough to justify the bother, marginally.
1
u/Ill-Efficiency-310 Jan 17 '25
I didn't know that. Thought they avoided it because it is more difficult to handle.
4
u/Mental-Mushroom Jan 17 '25
Methane is more dense than Hydrogen, so more energy per volume.
Hydrogen leaks very easily, Methane is better in that regard.
And re fueling on Mars should be possible by making methane there, Hydrogen not so much.
6
u/falconzord Jan 17 '25
You can make hydrogen on Mars and the Moon from water ice. Mars you can make methane, but not on the Moon
1
u/Ill-Efficiency-310 Jan 17 '25
That's true, hydrogen is not very dense when compared to other fuels, even when it is super cooled.
Biggest pro for hydrogen is usually in upper stages due to high specific impulse you get, very nice once you are in orbit, but I imagine transferring between rocket boosters would be very tough.
1
Jan 18 '25
The biggest reason NASA chose hydrogen for the SS was because they envisioned the space shuttle being used a lot more than Congress ended up allowing them, potentially having lots of space shuttles flying a lot more into Space, so using hydrogen caused a lot less pollution. Had it been a kerosene or even methane rocket, it would have caused a lot more pollution.
For Starship, the methane is still better than kerosene for sure (especially when Starship doesn't explode, since methane is a much worse greenhouse gas), but if Musk is serious about launching 100+ starships a year then the CO2 pollution will eventually be a serious concern
2
u/Ill-Efficiency-310 Jan 18 '25
I am not sure if it will, pretty sure more pollution is being introduced into the atmosphere from cars and trucks in like less than 10 minutes than what starship does during its entire flight. The pollutants being added in the upper atmosphere may be more harmful but I am not an expert on that.
Also technically water vapor is a greenhouse gas. Its not as bad other greenhouse gasses but if we lived in a world where every automobile and airplane used hydrogen as fuel there would probably be some consequences.
2
Jan 18 '25
Well there's a huge difference between a greenhouse gas that comes down with rain and is trapped in every possible form, and methane or CO2. The cars and airplanes using fuel is something the EPA has been actively involved in reducing since the very same time of the Space Shuttle development, the only reason they haven't gone as hard is the unfortunate dependency we have on those technologies for now. The same can't be said for Space exploration, we don't have anywhere near the dependency on it and except for Starlink, the satellite demand would keep up with hydrogen-only rocket launch capacity.
I will say however that methane based rockets are a huge improvement over the Falcon 9 fuel today, at least until something better comes up. If Starlink (or whatever internet constellation) can be launched with Starship or New Glenn, then there will be a significant rocket emissions cut. For smaller satellites systems who won't need an array, perhaps NG and Starship might be too big so there's room there for ULA's vulcan and other startups to reduce emissions, since SpaceX ditched the Raptor upgrade for that rocket family in favor of Starship
2
u/WjU1fcN8 Jan 17 '25
They did avoid it because of the bother, meaning the difficult handling. But just barely.
1
u/Taxus_Calyx Jan 18 '25
Since yesterday, this sub has really become like the Temu version of r/SpaceXMasterrace
1
1
-5
u/vartheo Jan 17 '25
Nice logically but the glen booster can't get to orbit on its own. The starship is designed to do so. The starship booster wouldn't survive a full re-entry either.
-39
u/hypercomms2001 Jan 17 '25
Why put a crappy boat anchor on the new Glen rocket… that made orbit on the first attempt…. While that other rocket just blows up…. For the seventh time…..
17
u/Datau03 Jan 17 '25
You aren't getting the joke are you? The upper stage Starship blew up on this one (NOT for the 7th time btw, it completed it's mission whole mission including reentry after what was basically (technically not but that was on purpose) orbit 3 times already) the same as New Glenn's Booster didn't manage to land. Meanwhile New Glenns second stage reached orbit and Starship's booster Superheavy performed flawlessly and got caught for the second time.
10
u/Datau03 Jan 17 '25
Also the reason Starship is not doing all that on first attempt is because of a completely different development approach SpaceX uses that leads to much faster and bigger results
1
u/hypercomms2001 Jan 17 '25
Nice one! You’re not getting the joke. That starship is a boat anchor……!
18
Jan 17 '25
Ahh yes the fanboy hate seeps again
-1
u/hypercomms2001 Jan 17 '25
Nah.. I just love trolling the trolls…. And I know you gotta love this…..just a. It of sport, and for a laugh! https://youtu.be/hAAEHEW-Al8?si=XZ-2GhxEdJv5oXC_
6
u/HingleMcCringleberre Jan 17 '25
Great first flight of New Glenn.
Blue needs to STREAM THE DRONE SHIP FOOTAGE. We know space is hard. We know some stuff is gonna blow up. If there weren’t any risk, nobody would get excited about it. If Blue tries to be “the Spacex that doesn’t make mistakes”, they will fail.
The Super Heavy chopstick catches and Starship suborbital test landings are AMAZING. Calling super Heavy a “boat anchor” is top-shelf silliness.
0
Jan 17 '25
[deleted]
0
u/hypercomms2001 Jan 17 '25
Item 1: yes granted that seven attempts of not making orbit… fantastic achievement Item2: touché.
14
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '25
It‘s wrong, it should be called Star Glenn.