So I wanna preface this… I want to like Isagi like I did for like 4 and half arc (kinda grew tired of him in pxg match) also this post is not here to shame people for being Isagi fans let’s be real they are the happiest blue lock fans out of all of us and more power to them
But lately there has been multiple people saying Isagi is overused… and I agree wholeheartedly but a defense I often see is the MC defense
The defense is pretty simple it implies Isagi getting the focus on everything is due to him being the main character…
And honestly it’s quite a bad defense because main characters don’t do that in most stories especially good ones
A main character is the main focus that as much is a truth we all can agree on… main focus doesn’t mean all the focus
I will compare this to a lot of anime mostly popular ones
Let’s start with dragon ball Z and specifically my favorite saga: the Android saga
Goku and Gohan are the main characters we can all agree on that and of course they get the most focus on this arc… but characters can develop out of them
Trunks and Vegeta do interact a lot with them but their main development come from their father son bond which reveals to trunks his father wasn’t all that he thought and that might be better, and to vegeta that he is clearly capable of loving someone in his own vegeta way.
Same for characters like funny enough the androids who develop a bond in between themselves and for 18 we got krillin. Krillin who gets a lot of focus this whole saga especially about his dilemma of ending a life before this life did anything wrong.
Picolo reconciliate a lot with his past due to his link to Kami. Of course it’s part of his development
And of course Tenshinhan gets one of the best moment in all of dragon ball
This is something I can’t see blue lock doing. Because if you see character development and actual focus almost all of them are based around Isagi
For Japan Isagi was not a focus in… like 1 goal since the begining of this competion. Bachira’s goal of course and that’s not a problem I think that was an awesome goal and it was sick to see their duo again.
Reo goal actually doesn’t have any Isagi focus
Rin goal of course does and Isagi scored the winner it’s okay I feel hell people had problems with the match not showing enough Isagi despite the match glazing him to death and beyond.
But the match still has one big problem to me… Aiku’s defense being Isagi linked is still… such a bad move especially due to how aiku is treated in this arc
Now France match… and it’s again Isagi focus
People will say “but Isagi didn’t score” but all goals but the first one from France are actually here to further develop Isagi.
Karasu’s development is here to give a philosophical adversary inside the team to Isagi and I love Karasu but it was kinda shoehorned to have him all of a sudden be jealous of Isagi even with his known inferiority complex
Hugo’s goal of course is focused on him and Isagi
Barou’s goal is used to make Isagi distress about his place
Loki’s goal is used to have Isagi figure out something
And then the final goal of course had the luck battle which I hate personally because Isagi went hulk hogan and could not lose clean which in turn kinda made France feel weaker.
And now England match… the Isagi been absolutely at the peak “what are we doing” to me
Isagi is the only one who gets matched up with teddy in the first half consistently. Not any defenders. Isagi
Isagi also somehow gets lines with agi… and not reo?! This also brings another point. Isagi is the only character who gets any meaningful relationship with any adversaries and that’s a big problem and I will compare it to Haikyuu
Haikyuu got multiple rivalries between teams and characters that are neither Hinata or Kageyama. My first thought is Tsukishima and Kuro which is an amazing rivalry
Hell we know rivalries from outside our own main team with Oikawa and Ushujima for exemple.
This makes the cast of Haikyuu feel alive they are not characters that solely revolve around what the mc is going to do or help develop them each time they do an action. They have their own things to do.
Tanaka scoring is solely about Tanaka scoring and we focus on that
Yukimiya scoring is “here damn take your goal” and immediately transition back to Isagi
None of the other characters feel to have any meaningful relationship with their opponents only Isagi does. Shidou and Charles had one interaction in France match, Loki and Rin had 2.
Karasu apparently heard Hugo from afar because Hugo never talks to him.
The focus being completely on Isagi is hurting a lot of the cast especially in this arc because it seems to be a boiling point now of all places for a lot of people. The reason is pretty simple it’s because now that we have the whole team together (ignore the lazy white haired elephant in the room) we want our favorite characters to get focus. But since none of them really do in term of pure character focus or if they do it’s undercut by Isagi we kinda just don’t get it
Kaneshiro shows he is very much unwilling to give more meaningful character relationship in the team. We got a tease of Shidou X Barou but I doubt it will amount to much. Our defensive line has no relationship. Aiku is my favorite again but I can’t tell you any relationship he has right now except for Sendou’s. The cast in turn feels weaker since none of them can get meaningful time without having Isagi behind them. Hiori scored a big goal and we went straight to Isagi Vs Karasu. Which was a banger chapter don’t get me wrong… but damn Hiori been on the backfoot
It’s also even more of a shame when we know Kaneshiro sees what people are saying. Lockheart Vs Zantetsu literally it told as a joke but it could have been fun to see two idiots go at it… just something to give our characters actual rivalries
And again their devs in turn feel very surface level. Like in England match only Isagi in Japan got any meaningful characterization. The rest are just there. They don’t do anything to further their characters.
Is Isagi a bad mc? Dawg I don’t know if you like him good for you I don’t have the objective opinion of god.
But I think Isagi can be a frustrating mc due to his monopolization of the screentime which is not what a mc does no matter what some people say because we have lot of anime that show that you can have meaningful development without your mc.
Also side note but I hate the end of the half of England match (for something other than the horrendous pacing) because Isagi “ok” felt very much manufactured to give him a “wow such aura” moment and kinda breaks the immersion of a 3-1 comeback being needed. I feel it breaks the stakes a lot but hey that’s another thing.
Again if you like how Isagi is treated more power to you but trying to shame people about the fact that they don’t like people being sidelined and saying the mc excuse is just.. well straight up wrong
Well I think I went thought it all of course I got more manga in mind (notably Gintama for exemple who is a masterclass on how to use your cast)
Have a nice day