r/BillyJoel • • Oct 25 '23

We didn't start the fire is he's worst song.

0 Upvotes

I consider myself a giant Billy Joel Fan I like all his songs, I know all his Demo songs, I heard everything he has ever put out, and I got to say that we didn't start the fire is he's weaker song. (he doesn't have bad songs)


r/BillyJoel • • Jul 04 '25

Image/video Taylor Swift as Billy Joel albums

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

I love Billy, and I hope one day he can collab with Taylor. They have a lot of things in common. Both are brilliant songwriters, storytellers and performers. Billy’s album Storm Front came out in 1989 and has two songs “So It Goes” and “State of Grace”, also names of Taylor songs. Billy also attended the Eras Tour with his family!

I made edits of Taylor to resemble Billy’s album covers and maybe I can manifest a collab into reality 😆


r/BillyJoel • • Feb 02 '24

Discussion Theory: Turn the lights back on sung by AI Billy Joel?

1 Upvotes

Hear me out….could Billy Joel be pulling a stunt?

I’ve listened repeatedly to the new song and pondering whether the vocal could be “sung” by an AI model of Billy Joel. The autotune, the absolutely squashed compression, and the weird phrasing in places sound more like current AI models of famous singers that are all over YT and Instagram these days than like anything he’s previously done.

I can’t really think of a previous Billy Joel record that didn’t sound GREAT, from a production/mix perspective. If this isn’t AI, it’s very, very weird to me that he’d be ok with his trademark voice being massacred like this.

I hope I’m right and we eventually get a great-sounding record with a non-robotic vocal of what’s a lovely song that I’d dig if it wasn’t so goddamn sterilized.


r/BillyJoel • • Aug 10 '25

Discussion Billy smoking

2 Upvotes

I was watching Billy Joel's documentary, and I think it's funny that he never had lung cancer even though he smoked so much. Great health.


r/BillyJoel • • Aug 18 '20

Meme Hey, I'm Billy Joel! Nice to meet you

0 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Jun 26 '25

Billy Joel album Tier List

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Jan 23 '26

Question question about billy joel and the queer community

0 Upvotes

hi! new to the sub. i've been listening to billy joel since i discovered him a couple years ago (i'm pretty young) and i have noticed that he has lyrics that references the queer community, such as the "closet queens" in captain jack, "liberace" and "sally ride" in we didn't start the fire. does anyone know if he has publicly spoken about this? has he been influenced by queer culture in anyway? i find it very interesting


r/BillyJoel • • Jul 16 '25

Image/video My Album Tier List

Post image
0 Upvotes

Why do you think they always have River of Dreams at Goodwill?


r/BillyJoel • • Nov 02 '25

Discussion Have anyone heard Im moving out (anthony’s song) by Billy Joel.?

1 Upvotes

I was just made aware of im moving out by Billy Joel and it’s a very catchy song both the intro and the piano outro. Wondered if anyone else has heard it and wanted go give their opinion.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=cJtL8vWNZ4o


r/BillyJoel • • Apr 07 '26

Discussion "Only The Good Die Young" - What is the meaning of the title?

2 Upvotes

Only the good die young means that all who die young are good. It does not mean that all who are good die young, nor that only those who die young are good. Does the title really have enough to do with the rest of the song? The song being about girls who don't want to break their religions and their words and their hymens (and the guys who want to break them), but even if "the good" is defined as those whose religions, words, and hymens remain unbroken, then the title would be telling us that the good are the ones who die young, and those who aren't good are guaranteed long lives. I guess I'd find it hard to believe that Billy put less thought into this than I have, but I remain uncertain.

Surely someone knows more of this than I do.


r/BillyJoel • • Jul 23 '25

Ranking My (maybe controversial) tier list of albums

Post image
0 Upvotes

I didn't feel like any deserved to be in F tier because I do have an appreciation for all of them. What do you agree or disagree with?


r/BillyJoel • • Nov 22 '23

Discussion COMPLETE TIER LIST

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Feb 21 '26

Discussion Harry Truman, Doris Day, Red China, Johnnie Ray!

1 Upvotes

South Pacific, Walter Winchell, Joe DiMaggio!

Joe McCarthy, Richard Nixon, Strudebaker, Television, North Korea, South Korea, Marilyn Monroe!


r/BillyJoel • • Feb 07 '24

Am I the only one that isn’t overly joyed about the new song???

0 Upvotes

I mean, hear me out …

I don’t bemoan the new song. I actually kind of like it.

But, I’m going to go see him play here in a few months. And his tagline from his shows is “I don’t have anything new for you. It’s all old shit”. And I love that. His music is much of the soundtrack of my life. His music was the musical bridge between me and my parents. The appeal is that I’ve heard “You May Be Right” or “Piano Man” over and over and over. And I can’t tell you how many times the cassette of The Stranger or Turnstiles played, auto-flipped, and played again in the car during my earlier years. Those songs are ingrained.

And every concert of a classic artist … they say, “here’s something from the new album”, and that’s when you go pee or get a beer.

I like the song, but when I see him, that’s gonna be the difference between him playing that new tune in lieu of a classic. I’d rather hear him play My Life, Summer Highland Falls, Miami 2017, or whatever other classic gets omitted because he ain’t playing three hours of all the classics.

Anywho …


r/BillyJoel • • Mar 04 '25

Mama Leone is an okay woman

2 Upvotes

I mean, she could've been a bit nicer with telling Anthony to move out, but it was for his own good.


r/BillyJoel • • Feb 01 '26

Discussion Through the Long Night

1 Upvotes

I’m a super huge fan of all Joel’s songs… except this one. For me it’s the really out of place horn, it just feels so jarring, and if not for that horn, Glass Houses would definitely be my favourite album of his. But let me know what you think, does it bother you at all? I’m wondering if anyone else here thinks the same.


r/BillyJoel • • Jan 23 '23

Discussion Personally, I see no issue here

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Apr 05 '22

Who else though billy Joel sang American pie 😂😂😂

2 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Jul 18 '26

Meme Darling, I don‘t know, but I love Extreme

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Apr 06 '19

This dude sounds just like billy joel!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
1 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Mar 03 '24

Made my own BJ tier list

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BillyJoel • • Apr 05 '26

Question Scenes from an italian restaurant question

0 Upvotes

How did brenda and eddie get married in July of 75 but also get divorced in the summer of 75? It also says they bought “a big waterbed” that they saved for a couple of years. How does all of this timeline work out?


r/BillyJoel • • Oct 16 '25

Question Confirmation of lyric

7 Upvotes

In We Didn't Start the Fire, who tf is Old Miss John Glenn? A friend thinks it's a reference to a well-known transvestite from some time last century. I'm not so sure.


r/BillyJoel • • Jul 22 '25

Question about doc - Is it too long?

2 Upvotes

I’m a casual fan. I grew up in the 70’s and 80’s. I bought all of Billy Joel’s albums up until I married and had kids and he kind of moved off my radar. I saw him live around 78-79.

I watched Part 1 of the doc and I was surprised it would be 2 1/2 hours long. I loved watching it and learned so much. But I have to be honest, I checked a couple times like “how much longer is this?” You always want a new generation to learn to love your heroes and I wonder if a non-fan would be turned off by the length.

I wonder why it wasn’t broken into more parts like the Bon Jovi or Willie Nelson documentaries? I joined this sub to see what more serious fans thought. I know some may have wanted even more detail, but I would say I probably would have cut it off if it had been bogged down with much more.

Also found it interesting that Sean Hayes was an Exec Producer. Tom Hanks has done a lot of music projects, but never saw Sean Hayes involved in one before.