Before next season starts and we get deep into the trenches of it, I wanted to write this piece explaining why our reigning Big Brother champion is one of the best players to ever step foot in that house. I think that the dialogue surrounding Taylor’s game has become quite muddied. There are people who love her personally and therefore try to rewrite history and credit her for things she did not do, which is quite unnecessary given that her game is good enough at it is. As a result of people hyping her up too much, some people feel compelled to downplay her successes in order to even things out. There is some misinformation surrounding her game even among people who are big in the community, so I wanted to write this to a) set the record straight and get the facts out there and b) establish why Taylor is an incredible player. I am going to take this week by week. There is not going to be a TL;DR, because I want to do everything in my power to get people to read the facts that show why Taylor is a top-tier contestant. Big Brother 24 is a season where I followed the feeds religiously, so I can assure you all this information is accurate.
Week 1:
So obviously Taylor’s week 1 is really rough. However, I do not feel like she is to blame for the negative perception that her fellow houseguests had of her. Daniel mentions that Taylor is going to explode when he nominates her and that production will step in if necessary. Alyssa and Kyle say she is going to freak out. Pooch states that it is going to get loud if she is nominated. Nicole says she is going to flip out. What behavior did Taylor demonstrate throughout her 85 day stay in the house that indicates that she is the kind of person who is going to have a meltdown if she is put on the block? There’s nothing. Literally nothing. There’s a stereotype in Big Brother and in the real world of the loud, angry, black woman. Black women are often falsely labeled as people who are going to pop off. This is what happened to Taylor. To fault Taylor for being an outcast in the first week is to essentially fault her for being a black woman. None of her behavior coincided with what was being said about her. They were microaggressions. You cannot blame someone for being the victim of racism. I understand that some of these houseguests have grown from this experience and become better people. I do not intend to badmouth them as I am always one to support growth, but I need to state what happened.
Taylor also gained the reputation of being a “guys’ girl.” This also isn’t Taylor. She intended to work with women but was immediately shut out by the other women. They had issues with her being a pageant girl for some reason. Due to these incorrect presumptions made about Taylor, she is ostracized. I do not think the argument that Taylor is bad socially holds any weight, because as we see later on, once she is actually given a chance to socialize, people feel great about her. She was simply judged incorrectly based on other people’s insecurities and prejudices. Also, in the first week of Big Brother, people tend to pile on one person. No one wants to be the first one out and everyone is still trying to find a place to land, so when one person vocalizes their dislike for someone, others join in. People like Nicole and Daniel actually felt good about Taylor initially, but joined in on trashing her once they heard so many others doing it.
There are some more instances of Taylor being vilified by her fellow houseguests. People encourage her to wear her finale dress for a fashion show and then get mad when she does it. Jasmine completely misconstrues something Taylor says as Taylor calling her fat and that spreads around the house. There was also an incident where Turner left a dish out and said he was always on his bullshit, to which Taylor responded by saying “you’re always on your bullshit.” Plenty of other people joked around like this in the house, but it was only a problem when Taylor did it.
Despite being alienated by most people, Taylor does do some good work this week. She did start to develop a relationship with Joseph early on, but that is squandered for the time being due to him being close with Monte, who is vehemently against her. However, she does build relationships with Brittany and Michael. They get along personally and strategically.
Speaking of Michael, after he wins the veto, different members of Oasis (the guys’ alliance that includes all of the men except Terrance and Michael) come into the HOH room to pitch for Taylor to go up on the block. Daniel was considering Taylor as an initial nomination, but of course ultimately did not go through with it. Turner pushes Taylor, Monte really pushes Taylor, and Pooch comes in and seemingly seals the deal by saying that if she is a replacement nominee now, they will only have to put up with her blowing up for a few days. Again, nothing about Taylor’s personality suggests that she would blow up. Once she is nominated, she does the exact opposite.
There is also an incident where Monte misconstrues what Taylor is saying about Paloma. Taylor was trying to narrow the gap that she thought was between them, but Monte thought he was trying to push them apart. He reports this back to his alliance and the bashing of Taylor increases dramatically. Michael joins in, not because he agrees with what they are saying, but because he realizes that people bond over a common enemy and he wants to stay in the good graces of the house. He feels bad about what is happening, as does Alyssa who tries to tell people that Taylor really did not do anything. However, no one listens to her.
Once Taylor actually hits the block, she explains what she was saying to Monte about Paloma. People understand it now, but think Taylor did other bad stuff so it doesn’t matter. One of the common critiques of Taylor is that she did not do enough to learn what she did that hurt other people. This is ridiculous as Taylor is not being told by other people what she did wrong.
The rest of the week is quite hard to watch. She tries to campaign, but is gossiped about and scoffed at. She is going to be voted for unanimously. The eviction is canceled as a result of Paloma self-evicting, but Taylor probably stays regardless due to the Backstage twist. It is obvious that the first part of the second HOH competition was meant to be a part of the Backstage twist. We saw Taylor beat Alyssa in this and since this competition favored height, I am confident she would have beaten Paloma as well. I really think Paloma goes home whether she quits or not. Is it a mark against Taylor’s game that she is definitely out first without this twist? I don’t know. Maybe, but what did Taylor do to get herself in this position in the first place? None of the things they said about her were accurate or fair. She didn’t do anything to anybody.
Week 2:
Jasmine wins HOH and immediately wants to target Taylor. However, Pooch volunteers as a pawn. He wants to be next to her on the block because he feels it would be a great move on his resumé to be able to volunteer for the block week 2 and still stay. Plus, so many people dislike Taylor so he feels that he must be safe, and he wants to win the veto to ensure her downfall. However, Monte ratted out Oasis to Mamba (the core alliance that included himself, Kyle, Michael, Paloma, Ameerah, and Alyssa) the previous week and said that Pooch was the one leading it. It should also be noted that Nicole replaces Paloma once she leaves and the alliance is changed to Po’s Pack. Ameerah recognizes that she has two options: a) take out Taylor who has no alliances in the house and is a social pariah or b) take out Pooch who is the head of an opposing alliance. She of course picks option b, believing that she will be limiting the options of Monte and Kyle and forcing them closer to her. She convinces Jasmine to take out Pooch instead of Taylor.
The nominees are Pooch and Taylor. As I previously mentioned, in week 1 Taylor was able to form bonds with Michael and Brittany. She was not able to get anywhere with anyone else, but these two connections are super important. Brittany informs her that the majority of the women in the house think that she is a guys’ girl. Taylor is able to obliterate this perception by telling the women that she is after the men, Monte in particular. This is when Taylor becomes The Sword. She positions herself as someone who other people think they can use as a weapon against people they do not want to take shots at themselves. Taylor doing this is crucial. Monte and Kyle, but more so Monte, are constantly pushing for Pooch to stay and Taylor to leave. It is possible that the women would have relented, but with Taylor pledging her loyalty to them, it gave them extra incentive to not let Monte and Kyle get their way.
Taylor’s impressive work does not end there though. She has a discussion with Monte, not about the game, but about life. This changes Monte’s feelings about Taylor and he goes from campaigning incessantly to get her out to wanting to preserve her. He goes to Kyle and says he wants to keep Taylor in the game and have her take shots at the other side of Po’s Pack, who he is frustrated with because of their desire to keep Taylor! All of a sudden, both sides of the most powerful alliance in the house want to use Taylor to take shots at their other side of the alliance. Meanwhile, Taylor is telling the cameras she has no intention of even winning the HOH. She got people to think they were using her when she was using them. There were other issues within Po’s Pack, but I think Taylor is the most essential part in the alliance’s breakdown.
To make things even better, Brittany approaches her about making a final 3 with herself and Michael. Things are really looking up for Taylor. I think this week illustrates one of the reasons why Taylor deserved the win over Monte. She completely outplays him this week. Despite these successes though, the Taylor bashing does not cease. It gets especially gross when she is labeled as the culprit for Paloma’s mental decline by Terrance, Daniel, and Nicole.
Week 3:
Thanks to the horrible Festie Besties twist, all of Taylor’s work is seemingly eradicated. Twists tend to make people play more conservatively. Each member of Po’s Pack picked someone outside of the alliance to be their partner. They were incentivized to keep working together, which is something they did not want to do before. The chasm Taylor helped create is closed. Taylor is immediately back to being on the bottom, through again, no fault of her own. She was twist screwed. Turner wins HOH and Po’s Pack concocts a scheme to blame Taylor for Pooch being evicted, something Turner was in the dark about until the very end. Turner buys it and plans to backdoor her.
But then some magic happens. If you were watching this season live, you probably felt super dejected and hopeless about this season. However, it turns out that the cracks in Po’s Pack were not completely filled in. Not only that, but Alyssa outed Old Skool (herself, Ameerah, Nicole, Terrance, and Daniel) to Kyle. This motivated him to create a new power structure and oust Ameerah. Kyle informs Joseph and Turner that Taylor was not behind Pooch leaving, Ameerah was. These three plus Monte create The Pound.
But then things get bad again. Nicole does not want to throw a competition, but she has to in order for Taylor to go on the block due to the nature of the twist. She does not want to look bad on TV. She is very upset. Taylor is worried that the reason Nicole is upset is because of her mom’s health. Taylor tells Nicole that if Nicole needs to leave, it is okay. She does not want Nicole to feel obligated to stay for her because they are partners in the twist. Nicole interprets this as Taylor trying to emotionally manipulate her into quitting the game. She spreads this and this is what leads to Daniel screaming at Taylor and saying she was the one who made Paloma spiral. It is really bad and almost gets Turner to want to stick to getting Taylor out, but Kyle and Joseph are able to get him to keep looking at Ameerah. They need to have the numbers to get Ameerah out, so they recruit Michael, Brittany, and Taylor and The Leftovers are created. Taylor now has an official alliance.
Taylor wants Nicole and Daniel out after Ameerah. She still talks to Daniel and Nicole though. They talk about what happened. This is a skill Taylor has that is great. She continues to talk to people even after they have treated her horribly. She never closes lines of communication. I also want to talk about how resilient Taylor is. She goes through the ringer all season, especially this week. No one would fault her for quitting the game with all the horrible things she has been wrongly accused of doing. She does not though. She continues to stay and fight. She never gives up and that is a huge strength in this game and in life in general.
Ameerah and Terrance are nominated, blindsiding everyone outside of The Leftovers. The Leftovers want to hide their existence, so Taylor pretends to be shocked about not going up on the block. She does a very good job at it. Taylor is still kind of a pariah in the house because The Leftovers choose to pretend they still want her to go to keep the alliance a secret. People outside of it do not bond with her for that reason. However, people in The Leftovers do begin to talk to Taylor more. She gets tight with Turner quickly. He even confides in her about his business, something he kept secret from most people. She also becomes close with Joseph. The final three alliance of herself, Brittany, and Michael is formalized. She makes a final two with Brittany. Once Taylor is actually allowed to have conversations with people, she thrives socially. I will never agree that Taylor ever had a bad social game. When people are not closed off to her due to things like prejudice, jealousy, and groupthink, she flourishes.
Ameerah is evicted, again blindsiding the other side of the house. Taylor has to take the blame for this happening yet again. She is supposed to lie and say she overheard Po’s Pack being discussed and that set off everything. Stuff like this means Taylor is in a bad position outside of The Leftovers, but within it she is doing great.
Week 4:
The plan is for Nicole to go when Monte wins HOH, as she is the biggest threat outside of The Leftovers. I also want to note that Joseph states that part of the reason he wanted Daniel and Nicole out was because he wanted to do it for Taylor. They decide to backdoor Nicole so Taylor does not have to sit on the block the entire week. The alliance recognizes she has been through a lot.
There’s a lot of confusing stuff here that is not super relevant. Taylor ends up on the block at the end of the week. It ended up not being the plan for her to go up. Not because of anything really related to her. Michael convinced Monte to get rid of Alyssa because of the way the twist worked. Monte tried to get Daniel to not use the veto, but Daniel did anyway and Nicole and Taylor ended up next to each other on the block. Once on the block though, Taylor convinces both Alyssa and Jasmine to want her to stay over Nicole, which is great stuff.
There’s also a point where Kyle talks to Michael and Brittany about getting another alliance going. Michael and Brittany advocate for Taylor’s inclusion and Kyle agrees with it. This goes nowhere, but it is still worth mentioning because it shows how well Taylor integrated herself with Michael, Brittany, and even Kyle. Nicole is ultimately evicted.
Week 5:
Michael is HOH this week. Kyle starts thinking there is an alliance that includes the racial and ethnic minorities in the house. Taylor cannot be blamed for this. Taylor was not that close to Monte at this point and she was closer with Michael and Brittany than she was Joseph at this time. He tells Michael and Brittany this, but Michael and Brittany say they do not think so because they trust Taylor is with them. Again, Taylor did so well forming a bond with Michael and Brittany. It is so huge for her game. Michael loves Taylor and he is a comp beast. There is a bit of a problem though, because as the week continues, Taylor and Joseph get closer which worries Michael and Brittany that she will choose Joseph over them. Michael and Kyle also see her as a threat in the game.
Other than that, Taylor does not do that much this week. She does not need to though, because the eviction is once again benefitting her a lot. Daniel leaving is amazing for her game. I also want to note that people are still saying horrible things about Taylor, but she still keeps going.
Week 6:
Taylor wins HOH! This should be phenomenal, right? Unfortunately, no. Taylor has admitted pre-season, during the season, and post-season that she is not a strategic person. She is very self-aware that this is a weakness in her game, which is good. I’ll set the stage here: there are 11 people in the house. Festie Besties is over. The Leftovers are a 7 and on the outs are Terrance, Indy, Jasmine, and Alyssa. Taylor is going to pretend to those on the outs that Monte is her target, when in reality it is Terrance. Taylor promised all the women safety. Her plan was to nominate Turner and Terrance. Turner states that Terrance could win the veto. Taylor realizes the danger in this, so she decides she will backdoor Terrance and nominate Monte and Turner. Turner says someone outside of The Leftovers could win the veto and not use it. Taylor sees the danger in that also. Suggesting to Monte and Turner that they should be pawns does not go over well with them, especially Turner. The great relationship Turner and Taylor once had is forever burned in the house. Eventually, Taylor is convinced to nominate Terrance next to Indy. Her alliance would prefer Indy goes and Taylor gives into that. They would actually prefer Jasmine goes, but Tayor did not want a black woman to go out on her hands. This frustrates her alliance members a bit.
So Taylor does not really know how to be the HOH, but Joseph is going to help her… sort of. It is obvious Joseph has a lot of influence over Taylor to Michael and Brittany, who do not like that Joseph is in such a good spot. Joseph has The Leftovers, but also the Five Swatters with Kyle, Jasmine, Indy, and Alyssa. Michael and Brittany convince Taylor that the Five Swatters should end, but Joseph then changes her mind. She tries to explain to Brittany why the Five Swatters still need to exist, but she cannot do it. She has Joseph help explain it. At this point, Michael and Brittany are hesitant about continuing to work with Taylor.
Terrance correctly does not believe that Taylor is not going to backdoor Monte. This makes Joseph think she should nominate him (as in Joseph) instead. Taylor is hesitant, but ultimately agrees to it until Joseph decides he does not want to do it because Taylor was chained to him this week as a part of a punishment. He did not want her to have to technically be on the block with him. There is a good chance Joseph would have gone home if he followed through with this.
Brittany says the target should be Alyssa, because Taylor can easily justify it by saying that Alyssa took her prize in the yankee swap veto competition. Taylor is into this idea, as are Michael, Monte, and Joseph. Michael, intending to position himself in the middle of The Leftovers, goes to Kyle and informs him of this. Kyle won the veto and feels Alyssa should not have to go home because of him and she agrees. However, Joseph convinces her that it should be Alyssa again. Taylor, Monte, and Joseph push for this hard and it causes Kyle to be against her, Monte, and Joseph. Turner is on Kyle’s side and now wants to target Taylor in the future.
Kyle does not use the veto. Taylor, without informing him that she was going to do it, yells at Kyle that he was supposed to use the veto. This upsets Kyle, but they smooth things over later on. She tells Indy and Jasmine that she wanted Kyle to use it so she could backdoor Monte.
Taylor really hurt her relationship with Turner and Kyle, but she recognizes that. She wants to get closer to Monte and make a final 4 with Joseph, Michael, and Brittany. Joseph is not into this and Michael and Brittany are not either. However, Michael and Brittany do want to take Taylor to the final three again. They just want to eliminate Joseph so they can be the closest to her.
Overall, this is not a good week for Taylor, but there are some positives. She bonds with Jasmine and Jasmine begins to feel guilty for the things she said about her. The way Taylor handles conversations with people who have wronged her is wondrous. She is able to make Jasmine feel good about her but also herself. Also, despite going back on her word to Indy, Indy wishes she worked with Taylor earlier and actually thinks Taylor is a wonderful person. I know some people, including Terrance, say that Taylor won because the people doing exit press asked questions that informed them that the public reception to the way Taylor was treated was negative. Yes, Indy did say these positive things about Taylor after she was evicted, but she also said them while still in the house.
I know a lot of people will look at this week and think Taylor cannot be an all-time great because of how bad she was strategically here. Big Brother is more than strategy though. It is about making people like you and Taylor was able to wrestle herself out of that early dogpile, eviscerate those preconceived notions, and get people who trashed her to regret their actions and admire her. That to me is top-notch Big Brother play.
Week 7:
This week is interesting because the house is split with half of the people being in Dyre Fest and half of the people being in Big BroChella. Michael picks Taylor to be in Big BroChella with the intention of protecting her. Again, that relationship she built with Michael is great. It was able to withstand all that happened last week. Taylor even questioned Michael about not taking sides the previous week but he still wants her in his final 3. Michael and Brittany think about taking out Monte this week, but decide not to do it. There were multiple factors that went into this, but one big one was that they did not want to piss off Taylor by doing so. Taylor might not have been a player who had a lot of direct influence on things (though she still did at key points) but the relationships she builds get people to do what is in her best interest.
Monte talks to Taylor about targeting Michael soon. They get closer this week. Michael really should have taken out Monte here, but does not in part thanks to Taylor. People in this season were constantly doing what was best for Taylor’s game, which is what makes her game so impressive. Taylor tells this to Brittany and they both say Michael has to go eventually. This never gets back to Michael. We know Brittany was playing for Michael to win, yet she never ratted Taylor out. Again, that social game is unparalleled. While Taylor is plotting behind his back, Michael is saying that he wants Taylor in the final 3 because he loves her. He admits that she will take Brittany over him, but he still wants her there. I have seen people on this sub say that forming a relationship with someone is not a move. I completely disagree with that because Taylor’s relationships are what propelled her through the game and got people to do what benefitted her.
Taylor is doing well inside, but Joseph outs her proposed final four to the people outside in a last-ditch effort to save himself. This hurts Taylor a lot on both a personal and a game level. I do not think she can be faulted for this too much though, because this happened as a result of a twist. She was not even there. Anyway, everyone is trying to get Jasmine’s jury vote this week by talking to her. Taylor does the best here. She explains the hardships she went through in the game and how it was unfair. Jasmine, just like Indy, deeply regrets not standing up for Taylor. That is the biggest thing she wishes she did. She says this in the house. Taylor had the first two jurors lined up to vote for her before they exited through the door. Two people who hated her now wish they could go back in time and defend her. Joseph was more loyal to The Pound than Taylor, but he still thought extremely highly of her when leaving the house.
Week 8:
I am tired of people saying that without Michael revealing Kyle’s theory, Taylor would have gone home. This is not true. It would have been Monte. Taylor bonded with Alyssa and said sorry for some of the things that happened during her HOH. This connection caused Alyssa to tell Kyle that she trusts Taylor more than Monte. She says she wants Monte out if Michael wins the veto and Kyle agrees. If Michael never reveals Kyle’s theory, he takes Brittany off the block, Monte goes up next to Taylor, and there are 4 locked votes to send Monte home.
Taylor has yet another great conversation with someone who has wronged her. This one is with Kyle about his theory. Other than that, there’s not much to discuss about this week.
Week 9:
This is the week that cements Taylor as one of the best ever in my mind. Michael targets Terrance this week. This is not a good shot for him. You know whose game it does help out a lot though? You guessed it! Taylor’s. This week, Taylor becomes a target. Brittany helped create a women’s alliance, but also ratted it out. She was working to keep Michael safe. All of this hectic stuff makes Monte and Turner want to target Taylor as they correctly see her as the best player left of the women. Taylor, though, is able to undo all of this and create the situation that is best for his game.
Taylor tells Monte about the women’s alliance. She wins him over and he decides he will target Alyssa over her. Awesome work. Taylor pretends to be upset with Brittany to Turner. She wins him over and he decides he will target Brittany over her. Awesome work. Later on, Taylor convinces Monte that he will not be the biggest target if he takes out Michael. This is what prompts Monte to go from targeting Alyssa to Michael. This is a game winning move for Taylor. It’s a double eviction. Turner wins HOH, Monte wins POV, and Monte convinces Turner to take out Michael. At this point, all Taylor needs to do is get to the end and the game is hers. If she had not gotten Monte onboard to take out Michael, I truly do believe Michael would have won the game.
I also wanted to mention that Taylor shut Monte down when he floated the idea of keeping Terrance. If not for Taylor saying no, I think Terrance could have stayed. This would have been bad for Taylor because she had built a strong connection to Alyssa whereas Terrance was always against her for some reason.
Weeks 10 and 11:
Alright, these weeks were pretty weak for Taylor, I won’t lie. But bad weeks for Taylor still tend to be pretty good. Alyssa and Brittany left and were two locked jury votes for her. Monte has also said that he took Taylor to the end over Turner (he picked a loss over a win) because of Taylor and Brittany hyping up Turner as a big jury threat.
Week 12:
Monte takes Taylor to the end and she delivers one of the best jury speeches ever. She wins 8-1.
Final Thoughts:
Things in the early game really could not have been much worse for Taylor, yet she still won. Imagine how well she would have done if she was with people who did not have those prejudgments. She has specific feats to point to that illustrate her capabilities, she had people doing what was best for her, she was able to flip people so many times, her jury management is some of the best ever, and she is remarkably resilient. She is one of the best ever and I hope history remembers her as that.