As someone that also suffers from this I’ve believed this for a while. I began studying the Bible as a teenager, after becoming a Christian. The subject of the King’s of Israel has interested me, and King Saul has always been the one that really got my attention.
Out of all the kings of Israel he is the one I have the most sympathy for. I acknowledge the wrong he did, but he is without a doubt one of (to me the most) self destructive King of Israel.
From the beginning he was because when he was announced as King he hid because he felt low of himself. Despite the fact that the Bible describes him as the tallest and handsomest man in Israel he was from the poorest tribe. The people didn’t view him positively and he knew it.
At the beginning of his reign it is said he had a strong and positive relationship with God, and this relationship resulted in the beginning of his reign being very successful.
He had what you would describe as “manic episodes”. Which made him a very successful soldier as well because his manic episodes made him devoted to battling for God’s kingdom.
However, pride soon took over him. Which is common for people with bipolar disorder. When we become obsessed our emotions make us feel grand. Especially if we finish what we start which isn’t easy with bipolar disorder.
While he became prideful at his achievements, he also still struggled with being self conscious. During one battle when they were waiting for Samuel to arrive his army began to complain and lose trust in Saul’s leadership. This ounce of doubt from his people caused him to make the mistake of breaking God’s real of sacrifice. Which cost him everything.
The fact that he could be very prideful while also thinking very low of himself and what others thought of him is not an uncommon trait in bipolar disorder.
He often tried to find “loopholes” when he did something wrong, and struggled with responsibility. To Saul he knew he did wrong but he tried to make his mistakes not as bad as they were.
Like when he tried explain to Samuel why he did the sacrifice because the soldiers were beginning to doubt him and he thought they would leave so he did the sacrifice himself so it wouldn’t happen.
And when he kept the animals after God told him to destroy everything in a city. Instead of obeying or owning up to the fact he did wrong he tried to justify it by telling Samuel he kept the best animals for sacrifice. Only for Samuel to point out it’s better to obey instead of sacrifice. Meaning you can’t just do what you want then repent later.
Another example is how he outlawed witchcraft but used it to talk to Samuel from the dead.
It’s not uncommon for people with bp to think this way. That we may have done something wrong but we have a reason.
I think the best evidence of his bipolar disorder is his feelings for David. He didn’t always hate him. The Bible describes Saul loving David like a son in the beginning. David’s music brought him peace and he knew David loved him like a father.
Saul’s began to hate David when his pride and low self esteem took over. David got admiration even before he was King, and the admiration came a lot quicker for him than it did Saul.
Despite trying to kill David several times David remained loyal and good to him. This is why Saul’s feelings for David changed often.
At times he loved David and at times hated him. It was back and forth many times, and this is common for people with bipolar disorder and relationships.
While we love those around us our emotions can overcome us and we can act in ways we really don’t mean. We don’t try to hurt the ones we love and we feel very terrible for it but it does happen. Emotions are very powerful and can be very destructive to our relationships.
Thankfully today we have many ways of helping the terrible effects of bipolar disorder, but Saul was not as lucky.
He did many wrong things and should be held accountable for them. However, he shouldn’t be labeled evil or even one of the worse kings of Israel.
He was a self destructive mentally ill man that sadly not only destroyed himself but his family as well.
I would like to add I’m not the only one who believes this. A few Christian psychiatrist believe this as well. And that I have bipolar 1 disorder so im not insulting anyone with it. It’s a very real and difficult thing to live with.