r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Oct 04 '25

Am I the only one who felt disappointed with the new album?

1 Upvotes

Not here to give an in-depth review or anything but The Blue Nowhere didn't feel as tight in direction and scope as previous albums felt. That's not to say I didn't enjoy the album, but the only tracks which I loved from beginning to end were Absent Thereafter, Psychomanteum, and Slow Paranoia (These are the heaviest and longest tracks, equating a little under half of the length of the album), other than that most of the other tracks were pretty hit or miss for me.

The record also felt pretty bloated and meandering. Both of the interim tracks surround Door #3 (the shortest song) and the album closes with 2 pop-oriented/simpler tracks. TWTOITD is fine on its own, but I really don't like it as an album opener (I've rarely wanted to start listening to the album). God Terror and Door #3 both sound too awkward for me, it's hard to put into words but it just feels like being wacky for the sake of being wacky (which is fine, but whereas for Colors II it felt in service of its direction, in this case it feels as if it is defining its direction). As consequence, it feels that for every good element, there's something else I dislike glaring back at me

Maybe it'll take time for an acquired taste to form but it's almost been a month and idk if it'll grow on me. Does anyone else share the sentiment?


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Sep 14 '25

Quite possibly an shitty/edgy/controversial take you guys are probably going to reject yourselves to death, but I'll just say it anyways: I think Beautifully Human it's a bad album closing track, not a bad song, but a bad finale

Post image
0 Upvotes

(Disclaimers: I just didn't listen to Coma nor Automata. Reason? I just couldn't find my way to like said albums, and I'm sorry for that

Also, I'm unaware if that has been said here earlier)

Since Colors, one of BTBAM most remarkable staples was to have their closing tracks to be always, if not the lengthiest ones of their respective albums, at least on pair with the lengthier songs on the whole album, always exceding the 11 minute mark. I mean just look back at White Walls, the track that made Colors, well, Colors, right? Arguably the best song on the album, same thing applies to STTM, Silent, Human, etc.

Now, do I sincerely think that there is any reason whatsoever to think of Beautifully Human as at least top 3 on TBN? No, absolutely not, Psychomanteum SLAYS that song, so are Absolute Thereafter and Slow Paranoia as well. And yes I'm being biased, and yes I could have only came to this thought only by the matter of said tracks being the lengthiest ones, I agree with that.

But c'mon, isn't the whole purpose of an lengthy track to sound like an immersive rollercoaster trip with a climatic tension and a joyful and tearjerking relief? Thus fitting nicely for a final track? BH doesn't have any of that, the build up is linear af, there isn't "hype" moments (breakdowns, fast widdly widdly tech stuff, genre morphing sections, mind numbing shredding/drumming and intense perfromimg, memorable repetitive sections that sound like chants ("We will be remembered for this", "Look into the picture", "Jet propulsion disengage"), awesome guitar licks "post relief" that cues the listener to its closure, unexpected awesome blood pumping choruses that comes out of nowhere (no pun intended)), it doesn't give the feeling of closure, it's just a more "prog" version of the title track

If they had done this before IDK, but if they are trying something new with this approach, I just think it didn't work, for me the best parts of BTBAM albums where always the closing tracks, for me they were the most essential parts, and I can say the same for TBN


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Aug 11 '26

Am I the only one who doesn’t like The Blue Nowhere?

15 Upvotes

Almost a year from the release date and this is easily my least favorite album, but I see so much praise for it. Am I just not getting it?


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Sep 27 '25

Hot take: TBN is more a spiritual successor to Colors II than Colors II actually is

0 Upvotes

For me, Colors was the epitome of creativity, musical freedom, and the dawn of something new when it was released. That's what Colors meant to me back then. Colors II doesn't do that justice, in my opinion. Don't get me wrong, Colors II is a great album, but musically it was hardly such a huge development for the band like Colors was back then but more of a throwback to Colors. All the references to the first Colors album, including near-copycat versions in terms of the structure and musical ideas of the songs (Monochrome and Double Helix are basically Foam Born 2.0, just as Sfumato and Human Is Hell are Viridian + White Walls 2.0), naturally suggest calling the album Colors II, but I'm missing the musical liberation in terms of creativity that defined Colors back then. Colors II is a good album, but it just didn't blow my mind like Colors did. With TBN on the other hand, I have that same feeling I had with Colors. Lots of fresh ideas packed into chaotic song structures, crazy technical riffs, and epic choruses. It feels fresh, new and exciting and that's why for me, TBN is more a successor of Colors than Colors II is and, in my opinion, the best thing they have released since Parallax II.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Apr 02 '23

IDK guys ...

0 Upvotes

I really don't see the hype with Colors 2. Ive been a huge fan since The Great Misdirect, and I pre-ordered colors 2 thinking it was going to be fantastic. Now after sitting with it for sometime, I really don't understand how much praise it has. I've seen lots of people say its not only better than colors 1, or their favorite BTBAM record, but top 5 albums of all time.

To me, I feel like Automota 1&2 are much better records. I think the composition is the most mature new age BTBAM we have. However Automota is not even my favorite record from them, I feel they outshine colors 2 by some margin.

Its hard to say what my all time favorite is but its something like

  1. Parallax 1&2 (1>2 if we had to choose)

  2. Colors 1

  3. TGMD

  4. Automota 1&2 (1>2 if we had to choose)

What am I missing with Colors 2? Is there any insight to it I'm just not seeing? (for the record my favorites on it so far are double helix, fix the error, and bad habits)


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Nov 30 '23

Am I doing this right or am I a "poser"

Post image
1 Upvotes

In 2007 I must have listen to Colors 3 times a day if that helps my case..


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Jun 08 '23

It feels like a more complete response is past due.

0 Upvotes

I'm aware that there is an active ruling that this discussion should only be confined to a singular thread. But there feels like a need to have a larger discussion, so I'm going to throw this out here and let the mods do what they feel. I hope that this discussion isn't sent to the nether. This being a sub reddit about the band, it feels necessary to talk about.

I'm aware that there needs to be time for the band to sort through their personal, legal, and emotional responses to the claims made against Dustie, yet it really feels like the current vague response doesn't cover the ground it needs to at this juncture. We need a statement about the position and future of the band, lest this be interpreted as a temporary bandaid and a return to normalcy after the tour is over. The DGD method.

The continuation of their touring promotion with no further address than "Dustie won't be on this tour" has left a sour taste in my mouth. I hope that there's something more complete on the way...

Am I off base here? Does anyone else feel like this whole ordeal has been pushed out of view for at least the time being? How much time is too long for a lack of response?

Edit:

I expected more of the fanbase than to act like a bunch of gutless and scared neckbeard faux lawyers. The pseudo-intellectual pseudo-legal responses make my head spin. Still no reasonable explanation as to why other bands have had much better, much swifter responses. You're telling me that they cannot produce a simple statement about the situation? Okay. Whatever you want to believe. As long as your chosen musical escapism isn't interrupted, I guess.

The long and short of the situation is that you all care nothing about a denial or action by the band. You're fine with it going right under the rug and continuing on as is. I cannot. As much as I love progressive music, I'm honestly ashamed of the community response at large, both now and when the claims were first made. And, as a huge and long term fan, it sucks.

It sucks not knowing if some of your heroes are going to be yet another big musician abuse of power ignored by the masses because they won't say *anything* about it. It sucks sitting in lines for shows, buying shirts, learning parts to song after song and, when the unthinkable happens, not even getting some kind of basic assurance that it's being looked into. I shouldn't have to come to reddit threads to get a stranger telling me that it'll be addressed. This is less than the bare minimum. If the community is fine with it, then it's growing more apparent this community isn't what I thought it was.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Sep 03 '21

Still haven’t heard Colors II

5 Upvotes

I have to fast scroll any talk I see of the album. I bought both the vinyl and cd with the preorders. I don’t subscribe to any music services as I like hard copy music. I haven’t listened to any of the singles as I want to hear the album as a whole, front to back since I think they do that better than anyone else. YouTube probably has it, but it will be full of ads. I feel these days the physical buyers get boned as it happens with any new release for me. This one has been probably the toughest wait, not due to length, but due to anticipation of how killer I know the album will be. Old man rant complete.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Sep 13 '25

I think we should talk about Dustie

0 Upvotes

Im really curious if other people have noticed this too. I’m not here to talk about his character. BTBAM has been extremely close to me since 2011 and I was gutted when all the information about him came out. I literally remember where I was.

When Dustie left and they released the first single I immediately felt that the “tech-death” aspect that I’m assuming Dustie brought was going to be gone on the album. (I know I know it was ONE song call it BTBAM intuition). An aspect I knew existed but really really never noticed until listening to Glass Casket. Then after they released Absent Thereafter I really noticed an “abscense” so to speak of this Metalcore sound found in many many many songs since 05. I then began to not worry but reserve my expectations (because my musical heart was broken) about the new album.

My impression of the album is honestly that, for me it’s missing that tech-death aspect. I’m very much still digesting this album. Slow Paranoia is fucking MIND BENDING and Absent Thereafter has been on repeat since it came out.

ANYWAYS I don’t know shit about shit, I’m not trying to stir the pot. I love BTBAM, they could put out an album of chicken sounds and train horns and I’d still buy it. I’m just CURIOUS if anyone else has noticed this and/or knows how much Dustie contributed to the writing process of the music.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • May 25 '23

My song and album tier lists. What am I right and wrong about?

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Colors II and Automata II were each a tier lower until I went through the song ranking process and realized how consistently high quality they are.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Sep 24 '22

I would give up my pinky toe for instrumental or clean vocal versions of all the BTBAM albums.

0 Upvotes

I'm not joking, if I were hanging out with a group of nihilistic Germans who wanted to make a rich guy think they'd kidnapped his trophy wife, I would paint my pinky toenail red and let them chop it off and send it to him if I thought that would get me those clean-vocal albums somehow.

It's not even that I don't like Tommy's harsh vocals, they're pretty good as long as he mixes it up. I just want to be able to listen to BTBAM in public without annoying all the normies around me.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Nov 27 '19

Btbam was perfect last night BUT

8 Upvotes

I was at the Montreal show front row, wearing all my colors attire for the evening, I enjoyed every minute of it.

Flawless

Was worth it to wait in line at 11:30 am and managed to meet all of the dudes in the back oh and intervals!

HOWEVER.

I despised Chon. I disliked how they were headlining and they were so boring it practically put me to sleep most of their set.

Why the fuck is Chon headlining over btbam all the hype literally drained me from chon. They were God awful and repedetive.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Mar 12 '24

Anxiety around masking at show? Anyone still masking?

3 Upvotes

Full disclosure, I probably wouldn't wear a mask if I was left to my own devices, but my partner is a healthcare worker who is concerned about me being in the pit without a mask and has asked me to wear one. I know it'll probably get in my mouth/get moist from sweat at some point rendering it virtually useless, I know it's silly to wear a mask while crammed into a pit with a bunch of strangers, believe me, I know. But I respect my partner and his wishes and this will be my first pit show since before 2020 and know he's just concerned about our health.

Anyway, I'm having some anxiety about masking at the show as I suspect I'll be one of only a few people wearing one, likely the only one. I'm not big on drawing attention to myself and I have definitely gotten asshole comments from strangers for still masking in certain spaces. Anyone masking/has anyone who's been at previous shows seen anyone masking? It will be my first time seeing BTBAM since 2010 and I'm extremely excited but the idea that I'm going to be drawing attention to myself for wearing a mask is bringing me some anxiety.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Nov 29 '23

In an alternate universe, you are about to go see the boys live. Which shirt are you rocking?

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Sep 08 '25

All Albums Ranked with The Blue Nowhere (Just My Opinion)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

And before you even ask, I have legit early access.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Nov 15 '22

prove me wrong

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Jan 12 '26

Guide To The Parallax II: Future Sequence for sale [RARE BOOK]

Thumbnail
ebay.us
0 Upvotes

Official hardcover guide book.
Pages clean, cover has minor wear.

Hard to say goodbye but looking to pass it on to a fan who’ll appreciate it.


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Jul 25 '25

Btbam hasn’t gone djent folks they just never dropped the metalcore

0 Upvotes

To those few who spout this type of nonsense online and to the real people in your life know you are wrong. Now discuss I’m curious


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Dec 01 '23

Any thoughts?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Jun 11 '21

Will you still attend a concert if Tommy doesn't sing?

0 Upvotes

Like if Tommy doesn't want to sing and says that you either get the money back or watch the instrumental show, what will you do?


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Aug 22 '21

a band that lies to his fan base doens't need our money. pls guys after this big lie I destroyed all the cds. Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Feb 15 '23

How are they still considered progressive metalcore?

1 Upvotes

I understand that for alaska and before. But for later album, I can't really hear the metalcore anymore. Considering I'm from metalcore genre. So I'm more used to djent than this prog scene. For me the riff from band like Caligula's Horse (some from In Contact) is more metalcore than Btbam riff in their later album.
Are they actually still metalcore, or not anymore, but people still call them that because of how they sounds like in the early day?


r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Sep 18 '25

BTBAM isn’t really the type of band to play their most popular songs in a set list are they?

1 Upvotes

r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • • Dec 04 '24

The worst BTBAM song, give me your takes.

2 Upvotes