r/BetweenTheBuriedAndMe • u/Harry-Is-Sleeping • Oct 04 '25
Am I the only one who felt disappointed with the new album?
Not here to give an in-depth review or anything but The Blue Nowhere didn't feel as tight in direction and scope as previous albums felt. That's not to say I didn't enjoy the album, but the only tracks which I loved from beginning to end were Absent Thereafter, Psychomanteum, and Slow Paranoia (These are the heaviest and longest tracks, equating a little under half of the length of the album), other than that most of the other tracks were pretty hit or miss for me.
The record also felt pretty bloated and meandering. Both of the interim tracks surround Door #3 (the shortest song) and the album closes with 2 pop-oriented/simpler tracks. TWTOITD is fine on its own, but I really don't like it as an album opener (I've rarely wanted to start listening to the album). God Terror and Door #3 both sound too awkward for me, it's hard to put into words but it just feels like being wacky for the sake of being wacky (which is fine, but whereas for Colors II it felt in service of its direction, in this case it feels as if it is defining its direction). As consequence, it feels that for every good element, there's something else I dislike glaring back at me
Maybe it'll take time for an acquired taste to form but it's almost been a month and idk if it'll grow on me. Does anyone else share the sentiment?