r/BethMidrash • • Dec 15 '20

Playing Devil's Advocate, does the Torah Foreshadows Mother Mary at all? What are verses that describes her future role, esp as Queen of Heaven and the Theotokos?

0 Upvotes

There have been attempts to use the Old Testament to show that not only Jesus's coming was foreshadowed centuries ago before Jesus's birth but also to foreshadow Mother Mary and her role as Mother of God and Queen of Heaven.

But I heard Jews argue this is all bunk since to start with most of what is classified as Old Testament are not really strict canon to Judaism but most Old Testament stuff is more like supplementary stuff to Jewish religion and are not supposed to be followed strictly. They are to be disregarded in prophecy and as far as sins go, are more like general guidelines than strict church or more accurately synagogue rules. And that its actually the Torah thats the real sacred book of Judaism. So they use this argument why most foreshadowing is baloney.

I already seen people take quotes from the first 5 Book of Moses to support predictions of Jesus's coming in the New Testament. But where as people can find stuff foreshadowing Mary in the whole Old Testament very easily, unlike Jesus analysis of strictly the "Torah" part of the Old Testament in regards to Mary is almost nonexistent esp on the internet. Can anyone find verses for the 5 Books of Moses that predicts Mary's coming?

I know this is sub is mostly by people who only read the Torah thus most people here are Jews. But since I am so curious about this topic, if you are willing to play Devil's Advocate can you find verses showing the future reign of Mary as Theotokos and Queen of Heaven in Moses's 5 Books? I'm not a Christian in fact I am atheist but Mariology has taken a special interest so I am legitimately curious about this.


r/BethMidrash • • Aug 12 '25

Does the Hebrew Bible Say that Yahweh Will Appear in Human Form?

Thumbnail
tumblr.com
0 Upvotes

Aside from theophanies——or temporary visible manifestations of God's presence in human form that occur throughout the Jewish Bible——are there any specific prophecies in Hebrew Scripture which state that God will take on flesh and become human?

For more details, see the above-linked article.


r/BethMidrash • • Apr 04 '25

Selling chametz vs. other options

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Dec 17 '20

Why doesn't modern Judaism (including ultra conservatives like Haredi) practise animal sacrifice anymore?

5 Upvotes

Finished Exodus today and started on Leviticus. Animal sacrifice is mentioned so much so it makes me wonder why modern Judaism including Haredis and other ultra conservatives no longer practise it?


r/BethMidrash • • Feb 03 '23

Other than Sefer haYashar, are there any other sources that reference a baby speaking in Joseph's defense?

1 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Jul 04 '22

Moses’ Kushite Wife Was Zipporah the Midianite

Thumbnail
thetorah.com
1 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Jun 17 '22

Just read this book and contacted the mechaber. Real eye opener for me. Moshiach can come from living or maisim for as long as he is "FIT"

Thumbnail shmoishelmoshiach.files.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Jul 04 '22

Why Do Miriam and Aaron Criticize Moses for Marrying a Kushite Woman?

Thumbnail
thetorah.com
2 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Nov 23 '20

How does Jewish Intercessory Work With Saints and Archangel Aid Work?

3 Upvotes

As someone from a Roman Catholic background, pretty much all my spellwork is based on intercession of the Saints and calling upon the Archangels for help with very specific prayers along with used of blessed items using symbolism of angels and saints that have been blessed by priests such as a medal of Saint Archangel Michael or wearing the brown robes worn by Franciscan clergy during rituals or fasting before a ritual to emulate Saint Margaret of Cortona's life before calling for her aid in intercession.

So how does Intercession and calling upon the Saints and Archangels for help work in Judaism? I seen the concept of asking the Tzadik for help while praying esp at the graves in some sources and some Jewish prayers involving calling out the Archangels such as the Shema prayer (in this specific example you call the angels to be beside you at a certain direction). Is this similar to Catholic prayers asking for intercession of the Saints and calling the archangels for direct intervention?


r/BethMidrash • • Oct 21 '24

Does Judaism have its own equivalent of the Rosary?

3 Upvotes

A quick googling earlier led me to discovering that Buddhism, Hinduism, and even Islam have used prayer beads in a fashion similar to the Catholic Rosary. So I ask, does Judaism using a similar device?


r/BethMidrash • • Dec 17 '20

Are all pagan gods (particularly religions Judaism never had contact with in the Tanakh esp during the Torah) shedim? For example would Shinto spirits and Hindu deities be considered unclean false gods in opposition to Yahweh?

4 Upvotes

One of the predominating thoughts in fundamentalist Christianity is that pagan gods of the Old Testament were demons in disguise. Its gotten to the point that any time discussion about religion gets involved with cultures that Moses and his descendant Prophets heck the Jews never got into contact with during the Biblical period such as say the Chinese, there is immediate accusation that these cultures' deities are demons posing as humanoid divine beings.

I cannot tell you how many blogs there are out there by Christian fundamentalists accusing Shiva and the Hindu gods as demonic entities or videos on Youtube proclaiming Buddha is a servant of Satan (under the wrong assumption that Siddartha Guatma is worshipped as the God of Buddhism), etc with frequent citation of Deuteronomy 32:17 and Psalm 106:37 as proof.

With that said I am curious on the Jewish pov? Is Shedim correctly translated as demons like most English translations of the bible state the verses?

Or is there so much misunderstanding on shedim and "demonology" of Judaism by Christians? If shedim is correctly translated as demons, do they apply to all other Gods including Amaterasu, Mithras, Ganesh, Zeus, the Trinity of Christianity, and Allah (even if Muslims and Christian believe they are the same as Yahweh)? Or are they only region-specific around Israel and the border countries around her today?


r/BethMidrash • • Jun 23 '22

I made a video about the Biblia Hebraica Quinta, a new scholarly Bible

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • May 10 '20

The Talmud

Thumbnail self.askbiblescholars
4 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • May 04 '20

Kashrut in times of poverty/famine?

5 Upvotes

I was watching a show that mentioned duck blood soup. My first reaction was revulsion and gratitude that blood isn’t kosher. My second reaction was to wonder how Jews in the 16th-18th centuries utilized their food resources. Back in the day, people tried to utilize every part of the animal (hence, blood soup 😝) because waste could mean starvation. This leads to my question:

How did Jews handle the non-kosher parts of their animals? Did it just get thrown away? Did they sell it to non-Jews? Or did they eat treif when the alternative was worse?


r/BethMidrash • • Sep 23 '21

Dr. Amy-Jill Levine is named Hartford Seminary’s first Rabbi Stanley M. Kessler Distinguished Professor

Thumbnail
jewishledger.com
5 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • May 03 '20

Reading Groups of Primary Texts in Translation with Experts

6 Upvotes

Hello all,

I am part of a new non-profit, Save Ancient Studies in America. We are offering free reading groups led by experts and I just wanted to pass along the information in case any of you want to join!

Here is the link to the event page of the current and upcoming reading groups (you can join for all 10 weeks or just pop in every now and then. And feel free to join late!)

https://www.saveancientstudies.org/events

Here is a link to an interview that the reading group leaders did this morning on the Digital Hammurabi YouTube channel.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ru6sJGo7_IE&t=190s

Hope you all will take advantage of this opportunity! Feel free to reach out with any questions you may have.


r/BethMidrash • • Jul 07 '20

A debate is raging on FB, and I’d love your opinions: do you interpret Ruth’s interaction with Boaz on the threshing floor as one of transactional sex?

8 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Feb 28 '21

The Garments of the High Priest: Anthropomorphism in the Worship of God

Thumbnail
thetorah.com
8 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • May 24 '20

I found an interesting possible correlation between a passage in Mark and a passage in the Talmud

11 Upvotes

I'm almost certain that I'm not the first person to notice. I was just wondering if anyone else encountered any scholarship or otherwise on the subject.

…there is no one who has left house or brothers or sisters or mother or father or children or fields, for my sake and for the sake of the good news, who will not receive a hundredfold now in this age—houses, brothers and sisters, mothers and children, and fields, with persecutions—and in the age to come eternal life. But many who are first will be last, and the last will be first.

  • Mark 10:29-31

This is like the incident involving Rav Yosef, son of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, who became ill and was about to expire. When he returned to good health, his father said to him: What did you see when you were about to die? He said to him: I saw an inverted world. Those above, i.e., those who are considered important in this world, were below, insignificant, while those below, i.e., those who are insignificant in this world, were above.

  • Pesachim 50a


r/BethMidrash • • Apr 07 '20

I'd like to learn more about Elijah as presented in The Torah but I don't really know where to start.

12 Upvotes

I have found Elijah to be fascinating and wondered how today's academics understand him. In particular, the story of Elijah and the priests of Baal in Melachim I (1 Kings).

Are we to understand Elijah to be a historical figure? What is The Torah attempting to teach people through the character of Elijah?


r/BethMidrash • • Apr 01 '20

Sefaria - a living library of Jewish texts online

Thumbnail
sefaria.org
23 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Sep 22 '25

Does Viewing Exercise as a Mitzvah Help You Stay Consistent? (Survey)

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Jul 01 '25

Who created verse numbers and why? [OC]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Jan 15 '25

Which Scholarly Tanakh Should You Buy? (Unsponsored Recommendation)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/BethMidrash • • Apr 17 '25

Map of where Tanaaim lived?

8 Upvotes

Seeking a map of where the Taanim lived during the end of the second temple and into the period of the Mishnah. Does such a thing exist?