r/BetaReaders • • 4h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Newbie!

2 Upvotes

Hi! I have been reading for quite a while now, and have started being interested on being a beta reader, mostly for fun! I have no clue how this works or if my critique would even be valid, tho i do think i have a good eye for engaging writing (not that i can do it myself), i wanted to ask for tips on how to not sound super biased without meaning to and how to improve on it!


r/BetaReaders • • 5h ago

70k [Complete][78k][Fantasy]Ragnarok Interrupted

1 Upvotes

An adult contemporary fantasy. Combining the dry humor and practical, older protagonist of T. Kingfisher’s Hemlock & Silver with the mythological family drama of Genevieve Gornichec’s The Witch’s Heart, it will appeal to readers who enjoy voice-driven urban fantasy with high apocalyptic stakes.


r/BetaReaders • • 6h ago

80k [Complete] [80k] [Science Fantasy / Space Opera] Legend of Circé: The Anomaly

1 Upvotes

Looking for beta readers for my completed 80k science fantasy novel.

Blurb:

Zerya, a high-ranking noble fleeing her own trial, crashes onto a scrapyard planet at the galaxy’s edge. There, she encounters Kael, a Wielder with unconventional powers and the last survivor of a planetary massacre orchestrated by the Order of Conquista.

Forced into an unlikely alliance, Kael and Zerya must escape the planet before they can even think of striking back. Their only hope lies in mastering the Æther.

But survival is only the first step.

To defeat the Order, their quest will take them across the Seven Kingdoms—worlds shaped by raw elemental power. Yet, these nations are already falling under the shadow of the Conquista, which relentlessly hunts down the last remaining Wielders of the universe.

DM me or comment if interested 🙏.


r/BetaReaders • • 7h ago

>100k [Complete] [112k] [Historical Fiction] Ballyclavas: An Oath of Blood and Canvas

1 Upvotes

Hello, fellow readers!

I'm K.M. Roy, author of The Shadow of London series, and I'm seeking beta readers for my completed novel, Ballyclavas: An Oath of Blood and Canvas, the first book in a new historical family saga.

About the book:

Set in late Victorian Ireland and England, the novel follows Brian Kavanagh, an Irish solicitor with a dangerous past, and his wife, Lady Kamie Kavanagh, as they navigate marriage, family, loyalty, and the secrets of a powerful Irish brotherhood.

When Brian's past threatens the family they have built together, Kamie finds herself confronting a world she never expected to enter—and challenging the traditions that have governed it for generations.

The story combines historical fiction, romance, family drama, suspense, and humor.

Manuscript details:

  • Approximately 112,000 words

  • Completed manuscript

  • Adult historical fiction with strong romantic elements

  • Set primarily in Ireland during the 1890s

Content warnings: Domestic violence, violence, mature themes, strong language, and non-explicit adult content.

Feedback requested:

  • Character development and relationships

  • Pacing and engagement

  • Emotional impact

  • Whether the story works as a standalone novel

  • Overall enjoyment and interest in continuing the series

Previous knowledge of The Shadow of London is not necessary. In fact, I would particularly welcome readers who are new to the Kavanagh family.

I would ideally like feedback within four to six weeks.

If you're interested, please comment below and send me a DM. I will share the manuscript privately with selected beta readers.

Thank you for your time and consideration!

K.M. Roy


r/BetaReaders • • 12h ago

40k [In Progress] [40,000] [satire, comedic fantasy ] A Brief History of Old Man McGunderson

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’m a aspiring author who has been working due diligently on a comedic historical fiction novel about an immortal old man named McGunderson who is older than the big bang (which he created) and is responsible for major disasters and grievances in all of history, by trying to help make things better despite his lack of self awareness or understanding of how things work and his out of touch and out of place demeanor and forgetfulness and self interests get the best of him.

This also leads to McGunderson unintentionally creating a secret society with the goal of stopping him from helping any further by the victims and their descendants of his many mistakes and of the problems he’s caused.

This book is inspired by Douglas Adam’s and Terry Pratchett as well as Christopher Moore and Kurt Vonnegut.

If anyone wants to read it just dm me on Reddit and I’ll share you a copy!


r/BetaReaders • • 13h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [4k] [Dark Fantasy] The Beacon — Prologue and First Two Chapters

1 Upvotes

About a month ago, I posted the 40K-word first part of a dark fantasy novel I was working on. The reviews were not good. It was long-winded and, frankly, boring. I took the critiques to heart, listened to the feedback, and decided to start over.

I'm coming back now with something new. I don't want to spend months writing again only to discover that my story is overwhelmingly dull or simply not enjoyable.

This is a short read of approximately 4,000 words, consisting of the prologue and the first two chapters. You will meet the protagonist and two of the main characters.

I'm interested in hearing what readers think.

  • Are the characters interesting?

  • How is the pacing?

  • Are the fight scenes enjoyable to read?

  • Does the worldbuilding intrigue you?

  • Would you want to read more?

Please feel free to provide any additional feedback. Constructive criticism is absolutely welcome.

I can share the manuscript through Google Docs.

About the novel:

The Beacon is a dark fantasy adventure featuring ancient magic, unlikely companions, brutal combat, dark humor, and a world filled with dangerous creatures.

Content warning: Graphic violence, strong language, and threats of sexual violence.

Thanks in advance, friends!

Nick


r/BetaReaders • • 15h ago

90k [Complete] [91k] [Gothic Fantasy] What Grew There

2 Upvotes

Blurb: A young woman takes a job looking after a little girl in an isolated house in a northern valley. Then the number seven starts turning up everywhere, and something outside starts knocking.

Content warnings: 18+. Two explicit scenes, sexual content, child in peril, violence, blood, death.

Feedback I’m looking for: pacing, characters, how the tension builds, whether the ending lands, and anything else you notice.

Timeline: about 4 weeks.

Critique swap: happy to swap. I read fantasy, romance and horror.

Comment or DM me if you’re interested!


r/BetaReaders • • 15h ago

90k [COMPLETE] [93,000] [Crossover Fantasy With Queer Themes] Behemoth of the Inverted Sun

1 Upvotes

Hello! I have just completed the third draft of my fantasy novel, Behemoth of the Inverted Sun, and I'm currently looking for beta readers to let me know whether the novel is working and how close you think it is to being publishable.

Behemoth of the Inverted Sun is a fantasy novel about a young man named Oliver who bonds with a powerful creature known as a titan. Though Oliver's titan gives him a path out of his dead-end life of poverty, it also represents a great danger. Titans are strictly the military's property, meaning that if Oliver's bond with his titan is discovered, he will be killed. With titan hunters lurking around Oliver's sleepy town of Eastisle, raising a titan in secret is far from easy.

As if that weren't enough, Oliver is also trying to sort out his feelings for the mysterious stranger, Raine, who gave him his titan.

The novel is a creature-bonding fantasy with a slow-burn M/M romance.

Please reach out to me if you're interested! I'm totally down for chapter swaps.


r/BetaReaders • • 16h ago

Novelette [Complete][8503][Literary Fiction] The Pit

1 Upvotes

Hello! I am looking for some criticism for my short story, The Pit. It is a modern take on The Myth of Sisyphus that features a stoner protagonist. In it, I wrestle with different methods of meaning-making such as friendship, science, mysticism, and money/employment. Mostly, I want to know if the story works - is it boring? does it make sense?

I'm happy to read your short story in exchange. Please message me if interested. Thanks!

Excerpt: "The first time I looked at the pit - a tentative glance over the putative railing (four metal poles, each propped in the holes of a stacked pair of cinder blocks, circumscribed by twine) - and gleaned modest appreciation of its unfathomable magnitude, I was instantly consumed by vertigo and nearly pissed myself. And I don’t mean it in some cutesy or metaphorical way. I mean for a very (very) brief moment, I was no longer in complete control of my facilities and was therefore unable to impede an exigent pulse of urine. It was all I could do to prevent more than a little leakage. Okay, so I did piss myself, but only a little. A fact I would never admit to Allison and Taylor. That would just be asking to be branded with an enuretic epithet (“potty pants” or some other juvenile concoction) for the remainder of my existence. Actually, I’d probably have to stop speaking to them. Change my name, move to a new city, start a new life… Instead, when they asked about my new job, I put on an intrepid front. Of course, their having not seen the pit, there is no way they could have understood what I was up against, so my feigned heroism was somewhat wasted on them."


r/BetaReaders • • 18h ago

Novelette [Complete] [8512] [Contemporary Fiction] What Silence Holds

1 Upvotes

What happened when MC became unwilling to continue living in the current family situation and the fallout that followed.

Excerpt:
...
“And I’m telling you,” my brother said, voice gaining volume with every sentence, “this shareholder is obsessed with the process. Paperwork. Transparency reports. Budget forecasts. As if you can reduce vision to a mere spreadsheet.” He laughed sharply, the sound dismissive. “It’s like asking a painter to submit a quarterly creativity plan.”

Dad nodded, sympathetic, the cutlery steadily reducing his food into bite-size pieces. “That’s what happens when accountants get involved. They don’t understand people’s hearts.”

I nodded. I always did.
...

I'm VERY interested in reader reaction, because this is my first completed story and I've never shown it to other people.
Are the characters believable as people?
I know that the switch between scenes is more of a jump than a bridge, but is the passage of time felt, or does it all seem to have happened quickly?
Were you bored? Was there any moment that made you excited? Any passage where you felt anticipation for anything to come?
Any time you were Uninterested? Confused? Frustrated? Emotional? Were any parts unbelievable?
Were you able to connect with the characters? From the beginning or later on? If later, when?

I'd prefer feedback for each scene separately, about one scene per week. There are 15 scenes in total, and some are very short.

At this time, I don't feel confident I'll do a good job giving thorough feedback, so maybe next time.


r/BetaReaders • • 20h ago

[COMPLETE] [60.0000] [YA FANTASY] Ingebeeld en Ingesloten (DUTCH)

3 Upvotes

Lijkt het je leuk een YA Fantasy proef te lezen?

Zonder ‘De Kracht’ telt Eloise niet mee. Als haar machtige familie weesmeisje Vivienne adopteert om hun plek in de regerende Raad te redden, staat alles op scherp. Terwijl de beruchte Derde Week dreigend dichterbij komt, slaat jaloezie om in obsessie – en blijkt alles een duistere prijs te hebben.

Vier van mijn boeken zijn al gepubliceerd dus ik heb al schrijfervaring! Ik zou het heel leuk vinden als een aantal van jullie wil proeflezen.

Als je wilt proeflezen kun je me hier een berichtje sturen of een DM sturen (@paris_duivenvoorden)


r/BetaReaders • • 20h ago

>100k [Complete] [125k] [Political Dark Fantasy] The Coin Keeper

1 Upvotes

Hey all! 👋
I know it’s a big ol’ book, but I would love to see if there’s anyone interested in reading my book!

Blurb:
Saeryn sees what others miss: a subtle shift in posture, the cadence of a lie, the telltale sound of missing coins. A talent she has used to survive slavery, but not evade it. Blindfolded and bound, she exposes her master for shortchanging Lord Kaedric Krath. Impressed, he purchases her. Presuming him to be as incompetent as her previous masters, she seizes the opportunity and escapes.
But Kaedric is no ordinary master. As head of one of the four Houses aligned to the gods themselves, he needs only nod to his men to have her hunted down and recaptured. Instead of punishment, he offers her a deal: spy on his opponents, and every secret she uncovers earns a coin in her jar. Once it is full, she goes free.
Determined to earn her freedom, she accepts. But the more coins Saeryn earns, the more she realises that Kaedric’s grip on the ruling council is weaker than it seemed, and his growing list of enemies makes every secret more dangerous to uncover. As his allies turn against him, he becomes increasingly reliant on the very slave desperate to leave him.
Saeryn has never been closer to buying her freedom. But the more valuable she becomes to Kaedric, the less likely she is to survive long enough to claim it.

Tropes (for those that enjoy them):
Found Family
Grumpy x grumpier
Secret Histories
Strong female leads
Enemies to (honestly idek what lol)

Genres:
Epic Fantasy, Dark Fantasy

For readers who loved:
The Tainted Cup
The Raven Scholar
ASOIAF
The Cruel Prince
The Goblin Emperor
The Assassin’s Apprentice
The Starving Saints


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

70k [Complete] [75k] [Pre-Apocalyptic Romance] When the Ocean Falls

1 Upvotes

I am looking for some readers for my book. I have finished it to what I would love to believe it’s publish ready. But I would prefer some eyes in it to read it like a book not like it’s being inspected per line, just able to highlight any major issues, or things that might not make sense. Anything I may have missed as I’ve stared at it now for around 6 months.

It is a relatively easy reader with uncomplicated science.

It follows a marine biologist called Amelia and a fisherman Jake Johnson as they form a quick and unexpected romance, while the ocean starts dying around them.

Extreme chemistry shifts, a strange microorganism and a collapsing food chain.

Amelia is made to sign an NDA, and breaches her first one for Jake, but the second one comes with a threat, because there seems to be something more sinister going on behind the scenes.

Isolated from her research, and given information in a meeting that could carry dangerous consequences. She has to choose between keeping a secret that could destroy everything, or tell him before it’s too late.

Any reading help is highly appreciated I aim to publish in a few weeks if I can help it.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

>100k [Complete] [120k] [Adult Romantic Academic Dark Fantasy] Born of Light, Cursed by Darkness

2 Upvotes

Hi!

I have a 120K-word adult dark romantic fantasy novel, Born of Light, Cursed by Darkness, the first in a series.

Set in a world where magic lives in one’s vibrant colors and Darkness consumes them, the story follows a young woman whose concealed prismatic-iridescent powers begin awakening at a magical academy where defeat in The Cage costs pieces of one’s soul.

Welcome to Wychlith, where physical education involves fighting monsters, roses can lure you into a trance, dragon doppelgängers can curse you with their wings, and a sixteen-story library holds magical secrets.

Expect unconventional classes, extravagant balls, elaborate attire, mythical (twist on folklore) creatures, and a slow-burn romance with the tyrant’s morally gray son.

I’m currently completing another personal read-through in preparation for ARCs. I’m hoping to find someone with a good eye for grammar, punctuation, inconsistencies, and passages that may be confusing or unclear. I’d also love to hear your overall thoughts, reactions, and, just for fun, what kind of mage you’d be and which rank you think you’d achieve at Wychlith! :)

I can provide a list of trigger warnings, a pronunciation guide, and a reference sheet for spells and mage rankings (and character artwork, if interested!).

Tropes & themes: Mental health representation, found family, dark academia, morally gray characters, ensemble cast, dystopian elements, own voices, resilient heroine, soul-costing combat trials, a unique color-based magic system, and slow-burn romance (no smut--I don't mind reading it!).

I’m open to manuscript swaps and would ideally like a 3–4 week turnaround.

We can start by exchanging the first one or two chapters to make sure our stories and feedback styles align with what we’re both looking for.

Please DM me if you’re interested! :)!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

50k [In progress] [55k] [memoir] [mental health]

2 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm writing my first novel, a darkly funny story set on a psychiatric ward in the UK, in the vein of ensemble character comedy with serious emotional undertones. It's an early draft (around 48,000 words so far) and I'd love a reader's honest reaction to one or two chapters before I go any further.

Content note: the book deals with suicide, self-harm, childhood abuse and pregnancy loss, so please only take it on if you're comfortable with that.

I'm not able to swap manuscripts at the moment, so I realise this is a one-way ask, and I'm very grateful to anyone who can help. I'm mainly after: where you lost interest, what made you laugh, and which characters stuck with you.

If you're interested, send me a message and I'll share the chapter. Thank you!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Discussion [Discussion] At what point should I update my post?

2 Upvotes

I made a post a few weeks ago, about me searching for beta readers. Since then I’ve written more in the book, and the word count has grown larger, so I’m wondering at what point should I update it? Or should I just make an entierly new post?


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

80k [Complete] [84k] [Post-Apocalyptic Sci-Fi] Looking for a few beta readers for Book 2

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm almost done with Book 2 of my post-apocalyptic series, Life of Ashes, and I'm looking for 2 or 3 beta readers before publishing it.

It's around 84k words and follows several groups of survivors dealing with the aftermath of the Yellowstone supervolcano eruption.

The book is pretty much finished, so I'm not really looking for a major story overhaul. I'm mainly hoping to get a fresh pair of eyes on the English.

Basically, I'd love someone to read it and tell me if it feels ready to publish. Does the English sound natural? Are there any awkward expressions, weird sentences, or dialogue that feels off?

And of course, I'd love to hear whether you enjoyed the story!

One small catch: it's a direct sequel, so reading Book 1 first is pretty important. If you're genuinely interested in helping, I can provide a copy of the first book too.

I'm hoping to publish before Christmas, so ideally I'd love some feedback within 2 or 3 weeks.

No need for a huge report. Just honest impressions and a few notes if something feels wrong.

If that sounds like your kind of thing, leave a comment or send me a DM!

Thanks!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novella [complete] [22k][monster romance] unwrapped by the reindeer NSFW

0 Upvotes

Title: unwrapped by the reindeer

Current goal: book 1 of 3– follows their life. This does end on an hea.

It is open door and explicit. Everyone is a virgin, reverse age gap, size difference, no mm. Non human characters- no one is human. Does include magic. Does include ruts and heats. NOT A SHIFTER ROMANCE

It is a novella so it’s between 20-25k words.

Blurb:
I might be over triple their age, but they are double my size, completely dwarfing my petite Omega frame. Two giant, antlered Alphas I can’t stop dreaming about—and now we are trapped inside their cabin together.

Can one blizzard finally bring us together this Christmas?

As Nick Claus’s Head Elf, I help keep the operation running smoothly leading up to Christmas. But for the past six months, two rookies on Santa’s sled team have made it completely impossible to concentrate: Ronan and Chance.

With our biology flaring out of control, our deepest instincts bring passion—proving that six months of longing can spark a wildfire in the snow…

all three of us are about to experience a lot of firsts. But when the blizzard clears, will these two Alphas still want the bonded future I’m beginning to imagine?

This is a high-heat, fast-paced monster omegaverse set in the North Pole. Expect enthusiastic consent, helping hands, and a guaranteed Happily ever after

I can do a google doc, epub or pdf file. I would hope to have feedback back within a week. So Nov 25th.

I’m looking for how the story flows. If you enjoyed it. Was the spice believable? Was their relationship believable? Did I portray the characters well? Are there any plot holes? Did I miss any important details? Are there any continuity mistakes? Did anything not make sense? Just overall vibes of the book? Did you like the characters?


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

>100k [Complete] [140k] [Romantasy] Not By Deceit (Book 2)

2 Upvotes

Hello! I'm looking for someone to beta read the sequel series to my book. I can send an arc of book 1, or I can send you a summary of book 1.

Here's the blurb for Book 1:

When Choice Defies Fate...

In Amara City, where everyone’s expected to find their soulmate, Prince Amias is devastated when he’s told he doesn't have one. Though one dream is crushed, his other wish — to serve the kingdom — can be fulfilled. When he runs into Clara, a snarky girl who just arrived in the city, Amias insists on helping her settle in.

But being around Clara has its consequences. When the kingdom needs Amias' help to stop murderous black-furred shifters, her arguments have him asking if his people are lying about them. With innocent lives, his family and friends on the line, he must decipher the truth before he misses his chance to save everyone — all while resisting his flourishing love for Clara, doomed to destroy them both.

Not By Fate is the first book in a contemporary fantasy romance trilogy. This heart-wrenching journey is perfect for readers of forbidden romance, magic and unique takes on fated mates.

Blurb of Book 2:

After being forced away from her, Prince Amias escapes home to reunite with his beloved Ignatia. Now haunted by betrayal and lies, he’s become a shell of himself but he's determined to prove to Ignatia that he's still the same blissful tender-hearted man she fell for.

Opportunity comes when Ignatia's people need her to ascend her throne — only they resent her for falling in love with their enemy's grandson. If he is to be her king, he must prove his loyalty in three competitions against Felix — a highly adored soldier that everyone says is more deserving of the throne. If Amias can't face the cold truth about himself nor his family, and earn the trust of her people, he will lose her. This time, forever.

Not By Deceit is the second book in the Soulmateless Trilogy. This emotional journey is perfect for readers of forbidden romance, found family and journeys of self discovery.

Triggers:

Book 2 has violence/gore, emotional and physical abuse, references to racism, mentions of sexual assault, beastiality and suicide (none of which take place), open door sex scenes, violence against children, intrusive thoughts, suicidal thoughts, self harm, kidnapping, body hatred, starvation and anorexia (from depression, not from the fear of weight gain).

I'm not the best at manuscript swaps! I can maybe do one but I'm not the best at it with my schedule


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

80k [Complete] [80k] [YA/thriller/romance] Untitled/ willing to trade beta reads

0 Upvotes

In a small Tennessee town, where everyone knows your name, some secrets are meant to stay buried.
16 year old Maureen “Maurie” Claxton has spent her whole life on the outside, looking in. Raised by her strict grandparents on an isolated family farm, she’s relentlessly bullied by the local girls, and kept completely in the dark about parents who left her behind.

Her quiet existence shifts when she befriends, newcomer Jamie Bradley. For the first time, Maureen feels like she might actually belong.

But a dark shadow is closing in on the valley as local girls begin turning up, murdered. Maurie barely survives a brutal attack by a stranger who claims to know her father. Swearing to secrecy Maurie tries to move on until a devastating truth about her family‘s past comes to light, revealing that the killer isn’t finished with the Claxton‘s yet.

Let me know if you’d like to read. I’m willing to send over the first few chapters before committing to reading the whole book.
Also willing to exchange books! Although I’ve never beta read before I will do my best to give constructive feedback!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

80k [Complete] [80,186] [Horror Adult Romance] Jerimoth Manor NSFW

1 Upvotes

Jerimoth Manor

Appalachian Gothic Horror | Adult Romance (18+)

A fresh start at a secluded Appalachian estate seems like the perfect opportunity for Natara Mallory to rebuild her life. The job comes with a beautiful home, a generous salary, and two men who are increasingly difficult to resist.

But Jerimoth Manor has secrets.

Whispers drift through empty rooms. Things move in the woods. And the folklore Natara once dismissed as superstition begins to feel terrifyingly real.

The manor's history is darker than she could imagine, and an old bargain is coming due.

As Joe, one of the groundskeepers, puts it:

“Things ought to be done in their time. Other things ought not be done at all.”

This is an Adult Romance/Horror novel. Beta readers should be 18+ and expect explicit content. This novel explores body horror, sensitive historical events, and trauma.

I will have a questionnaire for you to fill out. You can DM me with any questions you have. We will work out a format that works for you to read.

I AM available for a swap.

Time frame on return, 2-3 weeks.


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novelette [In Progress] [14.1k] [Fiction, Dark Fantasy/Romance] To Kill the King: In a kingdom consumed by imperial corruption and oppression, two rebels rise to challenge the Crown, only to find themselves consumed by the same greed, ambition, and lust for power that made the

1 Upvotes

First time writer, four chapters in, looking for any and all advice and guidance from readers to ensure I am on the "right" track with the book. From harsh criticism to general advice, anything will be helpful to me!


r/BetaReaders • • 1d ago

Novelette [In progress] [16k] [Historical fiction - fantasy] I Am Your Queen

3 Upvotes

Hello, I just discovered this group and wanted to clarify if you guys are okay with rough first drafts for beta reads, or does it have to be at least minimally polished first?

Right now, I'm in the middle of working on my historical fiction novella, and I've shared it to basically nobody yet, but it would be lovely if someone could do a beta read, tell me more about the pacing, plot and characters; basically, tell me about the premise and what can be maybe improved in my work. I've been writing since I was a kid but has only gotten back to it after a darn decade! Right now, I'm picking up on books and learning how to write again.

By the way, this story was inspired of 15th century late medieval period in England. Right now, I'm just very fascinated with reading medieval history, and I felt very inspired to create my own version of it.

Thank you so much!

Plot:

Millie, a twenty-five-year-old office worker, has finally reached her limit, and suicide is the only option she can think of—and has ultimately resorted to. But the afterlife is not what she initially expected. Instead, she is thrust into a new life as Ariana, on the eve of her coronation as the new Queen of Roana, an unknown kingdom in the year 1460.

Armed with nothing but her twenty-first-century sensibilities and finding herself in the most unimaginable trouble, she must learn to navigate a court that wants a King—and wants her silenced—while performing a calling that only the Anointed Queen can do so for the sake of her subjects.