r/Beowulf • • Aug 09 '25

BEOWULF: The Original Superhero Story That Still HITS Different

Thumbnail youtube.com
1 Upvotes

Tonight: Reading the poem that made Tolkien, Marvel, and every fantasy writer steal ideas for 1000+ years 🐉 BEOWULF goes LIVE - come for the monster fights, stay for the existential crisis ⚔️ #BeowulfLive #EpicPoetry"


r/Beowulf • • Apr 16 '26

(Beowulf) Why are some people so obsessed with acting like Grendel was tragic?

5 Upvotes

His motivation was basically just "I hate seeing people happy", and the only motivation we truly get for his carnage is just that the noises coming from the feasting hall had harrowed him, and that's hardly an excuse to slaughter everyone there. I do agree that there's some tragedy in how Grendel was outcast for being a Nephilim and hated by society, but by the time Beowulf came along, he had become the monster they said he was.

It seems like most adaptions of the book Beowulf are fixated on making Grendel seem tragic and sympathetic, the movie decided to say that he has a ruptured ear that makes loud noises hurt him.
Make no mistake, adaptational changes can be for the better and offer a unique way of looking at the story, but this served no purpose other than desperately trying to make the cannibal murderer monster seem sadder and more understandable.

The "tragic" villain in that story, really, in my opinion, was Grendel's mother. Sure, it seems like she was just as evil as him, either being a Nephilim, or a creepy hag-bitch who was fine with laying with one, but there's nothing to suggest she didn't genuinely love her barbaric son and wanted to avenge him, but because she's a more manipulative villain who is a woman, adaptions take her a bit more seriously, and often make her more beautiful or have her try to seduce Beowulf instead of trying to kill him, because god forbid a woman try to avenge her son with violence instead of her looks.

What do you think? I'm terribly sorry if I got a bit ranty here, but it kind of bothers me because I liked the original book so much.


r/Beowulf • • Jun 28 '24

Is Beowulf Achilles’ well-behaved, much less complicated spiritual brother?

3 Upvotes

The ninth book of the Iliad comes after seven books filled with defeat after defeat for the Greeks. Achilles was right: without him, the war to conquer Troy is lost. The damage Agamemnon did to the honor of the light-footed hero turned out to be a fatal mistake. The fate of all Greeks hangs in the balance. The Greeks' main problem is that their enemies know it too. The "high-hearted Trojans" (as they are described by Homer), strengthened by victory after victory, have already left the safety and security of their high walls and moved to the attack. At the end of the previous book (the eighth), night falls on the Trojan camp, a thousand fires illuminate it, and the soldiers, led by Hector, wait for Eos, goddess of dawn, to announce the coming morning and the resumption of fighting, hoping this battle will be the final blow to the Greeks parked alongside their hollow ships.

Agamemnon convenes all the heroes of the Greek camp for an urgent war council, in which he allows all the speakers to berate him. Nestor, the legendary king of Pylos, is the main speaker who pours out his anger on the pride of the king of kings, which has caused Achilles to refuse to fight. What is amazing is that Agamemnon agrees with everything being said. He recognizes and fully admits his mistake. His desperation at the outcome of the war has brought Agamemnon to a place where he can put his immense pride aside, for the main concern is that the Greek camp not be eliminated. He even offers his fellow men an unbelievable proposal: he is ready to admit defeat and return home. The Greeks refuse. They have only one solution in mind: to appease Achilles.

To this end, Agamemnon intends to shower the most splendid gifts he can on the hero—if Achilles returns to battle. Seven golden tripods (Did Achilles sign up for a film school?), many captive women who will serve as sex slaves for him, the woman who was stolen from him at the beginning of the story and whom Agamemnon swore he did not take to his bed, silver, gold, jewelry, and what not. Agamemnon is so desperate that he not only promises Achilles the hand of one of his own three daughters—and that the hero will choose the one he wants—but he even promises Achilles seven cities that are not technically under his, Agamemnon's, own rule. The naked truth is that this is exactly what Achilles was waiting for.

Would it surprise you to learn that the expedition to Achilles fails?

Despite all the excuses that Achilles provides as to why he will not return to the fight, one explanation stands above all and provides a glimpse into the man's psychology: it is not the woman he fancied so much and that was taken from him by Agamemnon, not his love of life, not even the disgrace he experienced when—while always leading the warriors at great danger to himself—he did not get the reward that is his due. What troubles him most, driving him to such paralyzing wrath, is the fact that the Greeks did not seem to recognize that without him they have no hope of winning. It was the way Agamemnon (in book one) dismissed Achilles in front of the whole camp and mocked him. This is the glory he asked for himself and which was tarnished by those Achilles perceives as lesser men than him. And Achilles, we should never mistake this, thinks that everyone is less than him. And rightly so, as the events proved. In other words, Achilles secretly, actually not even so secretly, is satisfied with the situation the Greeks have found themselves in. He doesn't care how many of them die at the hands of the Trojans. He doesn't even care if the Greek ships catch fire. He is aware that it was only thanks to him leaving the battlefield altogether that Hector, hero of the Trojans, dared to venture as far as the Greek camp.

Beowulf, the other epic hero I want to talk about today, is never that complex or obnoxious. Why?

The medieval epic poem Beowulf provides us with a glimpse into the Scandinavian world of the seventh or eighth century AD. Although it is considered England's earliest epic, England itself is not mentioned at any point. In the opening lines of the poem, we learn about the desolate palace of Hrothgar, king of the Danes, of Heorot, which has been attacked for twelve winters by a terrible monster named Grendel. Each and every night, when the moon appears, Grendel slips into Heorot to attack, slaughter, and carry the bodies of Denmark's brave warriors to his lair. Twelve winters pass in terror, with most of the king's loyalists fleeing far away from the monster's wrath and hatred. That is until the coming of Beowulf, a fierce young warrior of the Geats. What is fascinating about this epic, certainly compared to the Iliad, is the complete absence of any psychological complexity in the hero of the work. Beowulf is the perfect hero, which is another way of saying—quite the dull person.

If Achilles is faced with a choice—to return to his home and die in the bosom of his family as an old man or to stay in Troy and die a glorious death that will gain him worldly fame (we still talk about him, right?)—Beowulf is the embodiment of a flat character. He is the strongest warrior the world has ever known, as we are told repeatedly. Unlike the disorder and scheming that reign in the Greek Olympus, Beowulf is God's chosen, and therefore his efforts to kill Grendel will surely succeed. And they do succeed. Even when Grendel's mother arrives (I swear I'm not making this up), and she turns out to be an even more terrifying monster, he also slaughters her with relative ease. I mean, he almost loses, but in the end—naturally prevails.

Many scholars have debated over the years to what extent the Christian declarations in the poem and the relentless invoking of the Christian God and his justice, declarations and appeals that appear every few lines in this poem, are authentic to the original pagan poem or if they are actually a late editing by a Christian poet—perhaps a monk—who inserted them into the text so that the poem would fit more easily in the Christian era. I have no way of offering an educated opinion, because even the language in which the work was written—Old English—is completely foreign to me. Still, I wish to presume to say something about that Christian-Pagan divide, well aware of my lack of real scholarly knowledge or expertise. Do you mind?

I have no idea if the Christian poet who edited the poem was the first writer who put on page the stories and legends about Beowulf, stories and legends that must have circulated from Northern Europe all the way to Saxon England. The world of Beowulf, no matter how often that anonymous poet interweaves it with appeals to the Almighty Christian God, is a pagan world of glory, of honor, and of monsters. This fact is always maintained—visible to the reader or hidden, but never too far away. Consider this: before the coming of Beowulf to the rescue, when the Danes' efforts to defeat Grendel fail, they immediately fall back to praying to their ancient stone gods, whom—the Christian poet tells us—they will meet in the hell that awaits them for this outrageous heresy.

In the Odyssey, Homer describes the monstrous Cyclops as uncivilized. The poet of Beowulf emphasizes that Grendel is unloved and unlovely. While Grendel is of human descent, he is an offspring of the hated Cain. For a hardened war poem about fearless warriors who kill monsters barehanded—which is how Beowulf killed Grendel—love seems to be a key concept in their worldview and crucial to their survival. Is the reference to love in the poem another, later Christian addition to what is a harsh, unmerciful pagan world? I doubt it, as the reason given for its centrality has nothing to do with the Christian gospel.

A young prince, says the poet at the beginning of the poem, should "So use his virtue, give with a free hand while in his father's house, that in old age when enemies gather—established friends shall stand by him and serve him gladly. It is by glorious actions that a man comes by honor in any people."

And so, love is of practical use. A good king is always described as a "ring-giver," a ruler who distributes the loot with his loyal followers. And Beowulf, most beloved by all, accepts that fact wholeheartedly. The dullness of his character can be largely attributed to his predictability—as "Falsity in those days had no place in the dealings of the Danish people."

In 1971, the American author John Gardner published the novel Grendel, a retelling of the poem Beowulf In 1971, the American author John Gardner published the novel Grendel, a retelling of the poem Beowulf from the perspective of the monster. The voice that Gardner gives Grendel is surprisingly moving. It is not the voice of a villainous character but one that acts like an element of destruction. It’s not cruelty that drives Grendel to feast on the Danes. Not even hunger—or just hunger. It’s just what he does. With delight and also shame. This is the way he is created. His image is likened to Cain, the first murderer.

It was only after reading Gardner’s novel that I began to think about the Beowulf/Achilles equation in a new light, and the more I did, the more I became—what? Ashamed myself? While we are talking about fantastical works here, it’s still important to realize how our need for a complex character could blind us. It’s almost like going on a date with someone who is just so nice. And mentally sane. So-called good person. Not too loud or rude or insecure. And you’re having a good time together. It’s fun in a comfortable sort of way. Not bad comfortable. Just not roller-coastery. So nice and cozy, in fact, that you never call that sane person again… Because who needs that, right?

Beowulf—it’s sad to say—is that kind of date. He kills monsters with his (mostly) bare hands, and he does so to save a people in need, for a king he didn’t know but respected from afar. He wants glory for himself but not at the expense of others—the opposite is true, in fact. He comes to Heorot to kill Grendel because no one else could. Essentially, he is the hero we need. A sort of Superman stripped of the neurotic Clark Kent.

If you had to pick between Beowulf and Achilles to fight alongside you and have your back in an epic war, who would you pick? I’d wager that you wouldn’t want Achilles on your side. I don’t. Because, actually, he has none. In Book 20 of the Iliad, after his best friend dies at the hands of Hector, Achilles goes back to warring with a wrath that knows no limits. He slays everyone that comes his way. He massacres so many people that he fills a river, which turns against him in an effort to drown the hero.

Before the death of his friend Patroclus at the hands of Hector, Achilles was ready to return home. He knows that the ideals of his age are hollow, and that war is futile. Beowulf isn’t capable of anything near this level of complexity. But at the same time, he isn’t vengeful. Not against people. He’ll not only fight to protect you, but he’ll also most likely convince you to stay out of harm’s way, far from the actual fighting, so he can slay the monsters himself.

I open this essay with the ninth book of the Iliad, which tells the story of the expedition to Achilles consisting of the cunning Odysseus, the elderly Phoenix, and the fearsome Ajax. I wish to go back to that expedition for a closer look.

The conversation that develops between the messengers who came to bring back Achilles and the warrior is a central moment in the plot. During the exchange, Achilles makes it clear just how much he no longer partakes in the ideals of Greek honor. The arrogant Agamemnon recognizes the grave mistake he made. Achilles will never recognize his. Each and every Greek loss only proves to him how essential he is and how unjustified the disdain for him was. There is a moment when Phoenix the elder tells Achilles about a past hero who was in a similar situation to Achilles—refusing to fight for his people because of his fury, and of the similar expedition that came to convince him to relent. The first time I read this, I found Phoenix’s story to be somewhat long-winded. It was only later that it actually clarified for me how different Achilles’ situation is. His wrath was not sent by any god (unlike the story told by the old man in which the wrath was sent from Artemis). This is a rage that Achilles has been actively and consciously working to produce and perpetuate since Agamemnon’s insult.

Achilles is not interested in the gifts of reconciliation that were promised to him. He knows his fate very well. But in order for his future glory to be worthy of his great dimensions, it will have to be attained after many torments. Achilles doesn’t mind paying the price and cares even less that the Greeks will have to pay it with him, at least for now. He still doesn’t know how high the final price will be. And so, the gods are currently encouraging him and supporting his wrath. At least the most important of them, Zeus.

In sharp contrast to Achilles, what does Beowulf have to complain about? His whole being is in perfect alignment with the war maxims of his society. Even as he is dying after slaying the dragon—single-handedly, of course, and at old age, mind you (age 70 plus)—all he can do is watch the plunder with pride, saying:

"For this, this gold, these jewels, I thank

Our Father in Heaven, Ruler of the Earth—

For all of this, that His grace has given me,

Allowed me to bring to my people while breath

Still came to my lips. I sold my life

For this treasure, and I sold it well. Take

What I leave, Wiglaf, lead my people,

Help them; my time is gone. Have

The brave Geats build me a tomb,

When the funeral flames have burned me, and

Build it

Here, at the water’s edge, high

On this spit of land, so sailors can see

This tower, and remember my name, and call it

Beowulf’s tower, and boats in the darkness

And mist, crossing the sea, will know it."

I don’t think Beowulf goes happily to his grave because God promised him a better future in the afterlife. I think he goes because, again, he’s just not that complicated of a man...

So, why should we bother to read this old poem? A poem that doesn’t specialize in complex psychology. Well, I can think of several reasons. First of all, lovers of myths and fairy tales will find a very different world here compared to the recognized ancient Greek or Judeo-Christian worlds. Secondly, lovers of poetry will find beautiful and unusual poetic descriptions, providing a closer look into the worldview of the Scandinavian warrior cultures that gave us this poetry. For instance, consider the description of the true warrior who "cuts his wealth with the sword" or the poetic terms like "salt trails" for the sea and the "sea-worthy wave cutter" for a ship.

But there is another reason, one that was lost on me the first time I read Beowulf: the tragedy that befalls the people of the invincible hero.

Beowulf ends in a mirror image of its beginning. The mighty king Shild, mentioned in the opening lines of the poem, was not just a great leader of men, but unlike Beowulf, he gave the Danes a son:

"A new leader,

Allowed them by the grace of God

...

Shild's strong son was the

Glory of Denmark."

The Geats, Beowulf's people, had no such luck. They remain kingless and miserable and eventually disappeared as a people—probably defeated, conquered, and enslaved. Just the story of their once great king remains, saved by chance from becoming just another forgotten page of history.

If you enjoyed this, maybe I can tempt you with The Library of Babel newsletter. I write a weekly email full of literary essays like this :)


r/Beowulf • • Jun 05 '26

Is he gay? And can he beat Bigfoot in a fight?

4 Upvotes

Asking for a friend


r/Beowulf • • Oct 09 '23

Bone-house

1 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Oct 08 '25

What do you think of the plot changes in Beowulf 2007?

Post image
3 Upvotes

That being Beowulf not killing Grendel’s mother yet instead fornicating with her and conserving a son that became the dragon.


r/Beowulf • • Nov 05 '22

Literary Criticisms of Beowulf

3 Upvotes

Hey people,

I need 6 literary criticisms of Beowulf. Any recommendations?

I would be very grateful for any help, thank you!


r/Beowulf • • Sep 25 '22

High School film project circa 2000 recreating the Epic of Beowulf using toys

Thumbnail
youtube.com
4 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Jul 14 '25

Why isn't Beowulf as ubiquitous in British mythos and literary canon as King Arthur, Robin Hood, and Shakespeare?

4 Upvotes

Especially when you consider that its the biggest source of inspiration as far as a specific single book go on Tolkien and his Middle Earth esp The Lord of the Rings which is practically the bestselling single volume novel ever written in the 20th century?


r/Beowulf • • Sep 18 '23

Can someone make a gay fanfic between Beowulf and Hrothgar? NSFW

5 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Feb 11 '23

Who remembers playing Beowulf video game

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Apr 25 '23

Is Grindel the OG incel?

5 Upvotes

First time read through this week. I thought I’d have some level of sympathy going into the text, then was surprised to learn that Grindel’s motivation was jealousy of others’ happiness, feeling like an outsider? Yuck. He sounds like someone who would be a cowardly and evil school shooter nowadays, posting diatribes on social media.


r/Beowulf • • Aug 09 '21

I just watched the 2007 CGI Beowulf, and it was FUCKING AWESOME!!!

6 Upvotes

That is all.


r/Beowulf • • Sep 12 '24

Retvrn to tradness Grendelcels

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • May 05 '24

Beowulf the Musical

7 Upvotes

Interested in collaborating? It’s a comedy. I’m working on the script and have written a couple songs. However, I have no training in Music Theory and can only play the piano by ear.

It will be EPIC. Text me if you are interested.


r/Beowulf • • Jan 05 '23

What is your favorite chapter of Beowulf?

7 Upvotes

For a speech competition I’m planning on reading through a chapter of Beowulf, but I’m still deciding on what chapter. So I want to ask you all, “what is your favorite chapter?”


r/Beowulf • • Jan 20 '24

If Beowulf was a Christmas movie

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Mar 22 '25

Have any of you seen this?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Curious to hear if it's worth watching.


r/Beowulf • • Dec 13 '22

Bruh momentum

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Nov 22 '22

Crossed the sea to kick some monster hiney!

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Sep 12 '24

Grendelcels suck swamp tits

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Apr 17 '21

Could it be argued that Beowulf was monster-like himself?

30 Upvotes

I noticed when reading it for class that Grendel couldn’t be harmed with swords because he enchanted them so Beowulf killed him with his bare hands. Later when Beowulf fights Grendel’s mother, she can’t stab him with a dagger because of his armor, and resorts to using her bare hands. I thought this would be an interesting comparison to write about for my class, but I don’t want to waste effort if the idea is stupid, so I figured I’d ask the experts. What do you guys think? (Also if you think it’s a good idea to write on, any additional info/examples would be nice)


r/Beowulf • • Jan 14 '22

Title

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/Beowulf • • Jul 14 '25

The Dragon's Hoard?

3 Upvotes

Can someone please explain the chronological events of the dragon's awakening and the hoard. At about line 2283 in my version it suggests that the slave who stole the cup from the dragon's hoard gives it to his master. Then, it seems to say this lord goes to the hoard and takes more riches from the dragon. Maybe I'm misreading this part? Because later (approx line 2299), after the dragon awakens, he searches for the thief via footprint, and then learns the cup is missing. It only mentions the cup here? What about the rest of what his lord took? When exactly did these men take more?

Is this the timeline:

thief steals cup, gives cup to master, master raids hoard, dragon awakens and freaks out, dragon goes back to hoard and notices that the cup is missing

Or is the master going back some other time in the future? Or, did I truly misread this part, and the master doesn't go back at all?

I appreciate the help. I'm so confused.


r/Beowulf • • Mar 07 '25

Where could I buy a copy of Beowulf in Old English?

5 Upvotes

I'm interested in whether I can buy the original text if it is still being publicised. I can't find much online, any help would be greatly appreciated.