r/Bayes • u/dtuiranotugnvfgl • Dec 10 '15
Bayes and Darth Jar Jar
Can someone apply Bayes to the hilarious theory of Darth Jar Jar?
r/Bayes • u/dtuiranotugnvfgl • Dec 10 '15
Can someone apply Bayes to the hilarious theory of Darth Jar Jar?
r/Bayes • u/BestBooky • Jan 25 '21
Bayes Theorem
How would I calculate, using Bayes.
For the chance of going out on a date with one girl
If the likelihood of one girl saying yes is 40%, but I have 2 to ask ...
r/Bayes • u/vmsmith • Apr 21 '22
r/Bayes • u/ultrahumanist • Nov 24 '21
The reasoning is simple. If probabilities are subjective (as most Bayesians assume) and the asymmetry of time is explained by the second law of thermodynamics, according to which entropy always increases (as most physicists seem to assume), and finally, if entropy is in a sense a measure for the likelihood of a state (as seems obvious), then this must mean that the asymmetry of time is entirely in the eye of the beholder. Where does my reasoning go wrong, if at all?
r/Bayes • u/[deleted] • Jul 17 '23
People generally believe that we aren't alone in the universe in an absolute sense. The US government has also recently certified that there absolutely are objects flying in our skies which are unidentifiable.
So if our priors are that life is not rare/unique and that we should be able to explain flying objects aerodynamically, what is the likelihood that these objects are alien?
I'm looking for an actual argument. I'm not saying aliens are here, I actually want to hear your arguments. Please don't downvote me gratuitously
r/Bayes • u/vmsmith • Mar 03 '22
r/Bayes • u/MS-HUB • Nov 13 '20
r/Bayes • u/elrond_thorondor • Jun 03 '20
There is no such thing as a chance: anything that should happen will happen, and it only happens once. The so-called random events are due to human's inability to foresee. If you throw a coin, and the physics lead it to land face up, you get a head, or otherwise a tail: What is random? We might think it is random because we cannot tell how physics works since it is too complicated. Hence, the chance is subjective; it does not pertain to natural causes, but the limitation of human cognition.
r/Bayes • u/ichthis • May 02 '12
r/Bayes • u/BayesThrowaway • Dec 12 '13
Hello. I was hoping I could get a critique of my understanding of Bayes theorem based on an explanation I've given a family member who asked me "Why don't you think you're smart?". I know there's something to be said for accepting compliments graciously, but my family gets a bit hostile when I try and say "You can learn these things too, they don't make me special". So I decided to answer the question with this:
I think I have a pretty good idea of how intelligent I am. Imagine it's a number on a slider. Every time I do something smart, I slide my number up by how surprising that smart thing was. Every time I do something dumb, I slide my number down by how surprisingly dumb it was. I have to adjust it by how surprising the thing was, because if my number is perfectly accurate then I wouldn't have to change it at all; doing things that confirm my number was right won't change it. If I end up doing something above my number, either my number isn't accurate and has to go up a bit or I have to figure out why it seemed surprising. So over my life time, I've carefully tried to take each new thing that I do and let it move my intelligence slider in the right direction. Things like "I enjoy studying and am constantly learning" move it up, and things like not having accomplishments move it down until I get an accurate number that tells me how smart I actually am. It's not that I don't think I'm smart at all, just that the evidence shows me that I'm not incredibly smart.
That was my "explain it to your Grandma" explanation, but more technically:
prior probability: my intelligence number on my slider before I update on evidence
posterior probability: the number after I updated on evidence, will become my new prior the next time I encounter evidence
The amount something is "surprising" is the subjective probability assigned to it not happening given my priors. If something is 100% certain to happen given that I have an accurate assessment, it's 0% surprising and doesn't move my slider (I do understand I won't reach 100% certainty on anything, it's just for the sake of example)
So basically: you have a probability of something being true vs not true. This is your prior. When you encounter evidence, you slide your prior up or down as the evidence demands. This becomes your new prior when dealing with the next piece of evidence. This way, your probability of something being likely will be as accurate as possible given the information you have about it.
r/Bayes • u/ataber • Dec 10 '18
Using the formula of bayes with prior, power, and sig level for variable x on outcome z. If we find out that variable y, which is independent of x, seems to affect z, what component changes in our original bayes theorem?
r/Bayes • u/vmsmith • Feb 09 '24
r/Bayes • u/wikilogic • Jun 25 '16
Hello everyone. I am looking for suggestions or suggested reading for how to quantify chance. (Note:I have not read anything at all on this because i dont know how to Googles it and get the topic im interested in.) For example if i am looking at whether Alexander the Great ever existed and i take some evidence like coins minted with his name and image, how likely is it that they are proof and not a red herring? By 'eyeballing' the problem without using numbers, i can tackle this by thinking - The more complex a solution, the more chance that one element is wrong, thus throwing the whole theory out (Occams razor). So a simple theory like he existed is going to be favored by probability verses other examples: he was invented by others as a morale raising character, aliens planted the coins to confuse us, etc. How could i assign the chance of each a value? I have read ways ways people have guessed chance of extra terrestrial life, that life being 'intelligent' and intelligence capable of interstellar travel that could pull off the coin swap theory. So i guess i could make a calculation for that possibility, subtract from 100% and the remainder can be dished out to all the other theories. But what next? How do i decide the chance of someone making him up as a hero figure for improving the empires morale? Obviously i do not expect to get a high degree of accuracy but is there some approved method of working this stuff out so that people of opposing views could review each others research and say confidently "the proposed range of chance of that happening is acceptable based on your methods"
r/Bayes • u/vmsmith • Jul 27 '26
r/Bayes • u/8th_root_of_unity • May 25 '20
Claim:
The novel coronavirus that causes COVID-19 most likely came from the virus lab in Wuhan.
Proof:
Let L be the hypothesis that nCoV19 came from a lab that does viral research. Let M, for market, be the hypothesis that nCoV19 came about by chance evolution in a wet market of mixed live animals. Let W be the observation that the virus arose in Wuhan, China.
By Bayes’ Theorem, the likelihood or posterior probability that the coronavirus originated in the lab given that the initial outbreak happened in Wuhan is P(L|W) = P(W|L)P(L) /(P(W|L)P(L) + P(W|M)P(M)).
Similarly the likelihood that the coronavirus originated in the wet market given that the initial outbreak happened in Wuhan is P(M|W) = P(W|M)P(M) /(P(W|L)P(L) + P(W|M)P(M)).
In order to find likelihood ratios for the two hypotheses we simply divide their likelihoods P(L|W) /P(M|W) =[ P(W|L)P(L) /(P(W|L)P(L) + P(W|M)P(M))]/ [P(W|M)P(M) /(P(W|L)P(L) + P(W|M)P(M))].
The denominators are equal, so they cancel out to give us a likelihood ratio:
R := P(L|W) /P(M|W) =P(W|L)P(L)/( P(W|M)P(M))
Now we just need to assign our probabilities. If the virus came about because of random evolution in the wet market, then it could have evolved in any wet market in China. Since wet markets have been part of Chinese culture for centuries, every city in China has a wet market. There are 686 cities in China and therefore 686 wet markets that are more or less similar.
That means that the probability that the outbreak happened in Wuhan given that the coronavirus came from a wet market is 1/686.
P(W|M) = 1/686
On the other hand, there is only one biosafety level 4 virus lab in all of China and it is in Wuhan. Therefore, the probability that the outbreak happened in Wuhan, given that the virus came from the lab is 1.
P(W|L) = 1
If we start with an assumption that either scenario is equally probable, then P(L) = P(M) and so they cancel out, giving us a likelihood ratio
R = P(W|L)/P(W|M) = 1/(1/686) = 686.
Or in other words, given uninformative unbiased priors, Bayes theorem demonstrates that it is 686 times more likely that the novel coronavirus that causes COVID-19 came from the lab in Wuhan rather than from the wet market there.
Q.E.D.
Note that even if one assigns a prior probability of .95 to the wet market hypothesis, it is still 36.1 times more likely that the virus came from the lab.
Any comments, criticisms, or corrections are welcome.
r/Bayes • u/vmsmith • Aug 26 '24
r/Bayes • u/elrond_thorondor • Jun 07 '20
I developed a change detection scheme with the Bayesian approach, which outperforms CUSUM by a large margin. Not sure how to capitalize on this advantage though. What kind of detection problem that uses CUSUM now, probably can benefit from the scheme I developed. Any suggestion?
r/Bayes • u/mmoores • Dec 16 '17
r/Bayes • u/ichthis • Nov 12 '11
r/Bayes • u/rojowro86 • Jun 06 '22
We have priors, gather new info, then update to get the posterior. How is this different than me adding a few more rows to my CSV every month and re-running my calculations in frequentist fashion?