r/BattleForDreamIsland • • May 30 '22

Discussion Which one is better?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Nov 09 '23

Question Go ahead, downvote me, I dare you

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jul 17 '26

Other tf is this sub 😭

1 Upvotes

some friend of mine sent me this subreddit and i gotta be honest how are yall interested in objects of all things and secondly, what makes it so good that you have to be interested in an object that does nothing but exist irl??????

just give me an honest answer and if im convinced, i might take a serious look at it.


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • May 13 '25

Discussion can we please eliminate pin next episode

Post image
0 Upvotes

I honkING HATE HER AND HOPE SHE DIES


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Oct 04 '24

Discussion FreeSmart Fans! Now's our chance! LETS GET HER OUT! Spoiler

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Aug 15 '26

Art I really hope everyone agrees

Post image
1 Upvotes

the actual actual worst character in BFDI history


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jul 03 '26

Discussion hot take: this song sucks 😭

Post image
3 Upvotes

like i can't even stand the lyrics and the rhythm


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Aug 20 '21

Meme Can we make Four Plush the most down voted post on this Sub-Reddit? just switching it up!

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jan 11 '26

Meme So we all know about this, right? But…

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

41 and 67 were coincidentally mentioned in TPOT 1.

But it was also technically in BFB, because uh the finale was flower and gelatin and

Flower = 6

Gelatin = 7

Flower Gelatin!

since you don’t like me being silly, I’ll tell you a story instead.

When I was 8 I hurt my ankle because of a fly. I saw a fly on the car and I just like fell over backward while running and it was so embarrassing… and we were about to go to like a trampoline park or something, how bad timing. At least you probably don’t have some stupid injury…

still gotta be random tho

rocking chair

WAIT NVM

You like my new yellow and purple captions? So much cooler than just purple and white.


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jan 27 '26

Discussion Naily slander bcuz I hate her guts

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jun 27 '26

Discussion Basketball is the only character I genuinely dislike (rant)

Post image
0 Upvotes

she is boring, dumb, and annoying asf.

so lets start with bfb, what was she in bfb? she was.. kind? and uh thats it. she was kind. she just mindlessly tags along with Golfball/8-Ball in the first part, and then Golfball dislikes her at some point for some reason which doesn’t really add anything, just another Golfball rivalry shoveled in, but she is also just really dumb for some reason? even in bfb we get the impression she is supposed to be smart, like she knows machines like robot flower, which just makes her copy paste tennis ball but without the dynamic with Golfball, but despite being smart she is just stupid most of the time, like WHY would she randomly exclaim ā€œomg that was loud!ā€ as Rocky for no reason in bfb 12? everyone else was screaming and shes never spoke like that before, literally the dumbest throw ever, and its not a funny smart but somewhat dumb like Golfball sometimes is, she just contradicts herself in an annoying way constantly, like why tf was she asleep during tpot 13 when they were announcing the competition? there was no reason for her to do that other than giving us a somewhat funny scene later.

tpot is where she really gets on my nerves though, cause her voice is SO annoying, and she is constantly whining about something, like omg, shut up! theres more of that random Golfball rivalry at the start which is rarely expanded upon and feels bland af, she basically is just ā€œGolfball but niceā€ cause of the random above ground factory and other inventions, except way more annoying and making her boringly nice is erasing all the qualities that made Golfball interesting, now I get that the first few tpot episodes everyone was a bit dumb, but that doesn’t erase how stupid Basketball was despite her supposedly being smart, she is just annoying in tpot 1, annoying in tpot 2, she does nothing in tpot 3, and she does nothing in tpot 4 while being insanely stupid, yes, a lot of characters were stupid in tpot 4, but why tf did the ā€œsmartā€ character along with her whole team not just take the bracelet off so they could go give Bell back her bracelet? its annoyingly dumb, tpot 5 was kinda dumb as well, like literally what were they even doing there, they were just mucking around in the fish monster robot to make some bad jokes, also, the whole Robot flower arc she has is so fucking annoying, its a great concept, but it is just dragged to the extreme, Basketball has no character from it either besides just being ā€œkindā€ again, and then she is constantly whining about Robot flower for SO long, what little she had of her character was just reduced to a walking plot device until she was eliminated, first a device for Robot flower and then a device for One which was also so annoying to watch cause she was whining with that annoying ass voice constantly and it didn’t even really go anywhere for her

tldr: she has no character outside of being nice, her dynamics are bland outside of Robot flower which she moreso was just a device for the arc, she is supposed to be smart but nothing proves that besides ā€œoh look! I make gadgets!ā€ Golfball and Tennisball are smart and their dialouge constantly proves this, Basketball is just smart to make things, and she is constantly just straight up dumb in the actual episodes, and her voice is extremely annoying specifically in tpot cause of how much she whines about everything, especially in the Robot flower arc


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jun 15 '24

Discussion Let’s acknowledge this for a moment

Post image
51 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jun 22 '26

BFDI x II Meetup/Event im going to ask a question at the tour that will change a specific ship forever.

Post image
6 Upvotes

if you feel like im going to ruin the OSC and make an incident, you can check out the latest post i made as of June 23rd, 2026.

and no, im not gonna say it in this post cause i dont want people to steal it.

but right now, IM GOING TO CHANGE THIS SHIP FOREVER AT THE TOUR


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jun 29 '26

Discussion This might be the worst final 11 I have seen in OSC history

Post image
1 Upvotes

What is the point of having Tenis bum, marker, and bitchook on this show when they haven’t done JACK SHIT THIS WHOLE FUCKING SHOW. WHY ARE THEY HERE?!?!!?!!??


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • May 28 '25

My takes on TPOT and II2:

Post image
10 Upvotes

In my opinion, II2 does a much better job of telling a story than TPOT. II2 actually has emotional moments that make you want to cry. For TPOT, you can literally watch entire episodes with a poker face, because you feel nothing while watching TPOT. TPOT just strips itself of everything you were used to, and tries to go in a more serious direction, but in reality, they're just taking the fun out of everything, causing it to be bland.


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jun 05 '25 Bravo

Discussion Sick of Book at this point

Post image
21 Upvotes

Book is literally just Flower 2.0 and I’m sick of it at this point. Book in BFDIA is just a passive submissive Pencil follower with no backbone at all. ā€œBut she can’t do no wrong!!! Of course she should win because she sucks at the competition show and she has no backbone!! And because she’s a newbie she should win! Even though that’s a stupid argument and literally the worst BFDIA newbie to do so!ā€ It just sucks. I never see people bring it up, but people like to pretend the OSC has changed when the same ā€œniceā€ characters are still getting far, like think about this, Flower in BFB was such a ā€œnice character who could do no wrong but yet was always being hated on!!ā€ Just like Book, I won’t say that Book’s sympathy is as bad as Flower, but it’s pretty damn close, and honestly this parallels Pin, at least preBFDIA 15 Pin’s popularity, she, like Book, was hated on for no reason so she got sympathy, however, unlike Book, I actually think Pin is an interesting character, which makes me think her sympathy was justified. But what’s even worse is, with how passive and uninteresting BFDIA Book is, she’ll do nothing to warrant her getting eliminated and just automatically get runner up at least. I like BFDIA Book, don’t get me wrong, but she’s the worst option of winning of all the characters left, and this is certainly the worst season for Book to win, like what can actually be done with her winning BFDIA? Anyways Book needs to do something radical like Pin so she gets out, and quickly because she shouldn’t win this season.


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Aug 07 '25

Meme THIS SHOW SUCKS NOW

Post image
0 Upvotes

What happened to the nice roots of the show? Now we're battling for THE POWER OF TWO?? Why?? It's supposed to be BATTLE FOR DREAM ISLAND, or maybe even a BATTLE FOR BFDI, what about even a BATTLE FOR BFB. Why are we battling for something NOT related to BATTLE FOR DREAM ISLAND like THE POWER OF TWO!?!?!? And if you're saying "B-b-b-b-but Dream Island is GONE!!!1!1!!1!" What about the time they did a BATTLE FOR DREAM ISLAND AGAIN???? Seriously!!! Everything is all backwards, like some sort of DNALSI MAERD ROF ELTTAB.


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jun 29 '26

Memes Talk about double standards Spoiler

Post image
1 Upvotes

ok time to get downvoted into oblivion ig

for the record, the ragebait wasn't intentional, i just found the situation funny

also yes, I double-voted Liy to stay

edit: bro im actually gonna lose all the karma i've gotten noo

edit2: ok but seriously why is everybody ignoring the meme tag


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Sep 19 '25

Discussion jacknjellify has crossed the line

Post image
134 Upvotes

All of you will be saying, "BUT TPOT 20 WILL BE FUCKING PEAK"

That's not what I was meant to say. I'm saying this because of how many problems will emerge.

Also, please feel free to downvote me if you disagree, I deserve it anyway.

I'm not against TPOT in any way, but airing it in theaters is a HUGE mistake. And I feel the need to address these problems.

First of all, the obvious spoilers. TPOT 20 is extremely hyped up, so it would be no surprise that YouTube would be flooded with spoilers of TPOT 20.

Second, the decision to air it nationwide may sound like a great idea, however, I respectfully disagree. There's going to be freaks who are driving like maniacs to get to a theater just to see TPOT 20. That's going to cause LOTS of traffic jams or even car crashes.

And finally, the decision to air it in AMC theaters is possibly one of, if not, the riskiest decision ever. Everyone will be making a HUGE mess in the theater. There would also be people screaming EXTREMELY LOUDLY, because of Three. And that might cause hearing loss to some people who are just watching for fun.

So, I feel like TPOT 20 being aired in theaters nationwide might be the riskiest decision jacknjellify has ever made, and I'm worried about the chaos that would ensue once the episode drops.

For those going to the theaters, be careful out there.

And for those not going to the theaters, good luck, you'll need it.


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jul 16 '26

Discussion This is one of the WORST eliminations of the series (Tennis Ball Rant)

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Listen, there is many bad eliminations in the series to Spongy (BFDIA 11) , Teardrop (BFDIA 4) and Firey Jr. (BFB 13) but THIS TAKES THE CAKE FOR THE WORST ELIMINATION IN THIS SERIES. I'm not even joking this be BFDIA 11 which is coming from someone who adores Spongy. Let's start off with the likes. Tennis Ball did not deserve all those likes, many characters had better moments than him and all he did was act tougher while others were way better than him. Needle has her own new arc, Book getting robbed of a win and Coiny getting betrayed. These characters deserved way more likes. Hell​​, Book and Coiny deserved to win the prize not Overrated Ball. Not to mention, who got out. Tennis Ball is so damn overrated bro, all he does is simp over Golf Ball and is clumsy, how did he go from good Tennis Ball from BFDIA 1a-BFDIA 15 to this crap. That is why he is no longer my favorite. Fries was literally the last characters I was rooting for because Spongy, Pencil, Ruby, and Puffball all got out. I had to root for Book which while I like and deserved to win, she was my only option left at this point because I liked her more at the time than all the others. Fries was so funny and stuff and he just got robbed of a win over an overrated character who probably has bots always liking his videos >:(


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Jan 05 '26

Question if they do this a 4th time in a row, can we admit they're doing it for the money?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Sep 12 '24

Tpot 13 when!? It hasn't come out yet!

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • Aug 20 '25

Discussion am I the only one who thinks nearly every other host is more enjoyable than this thing

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/BattleForDreamIsland • • May 06 '25

It is NOT okay to headcanon Fries as female

1 Upvotes

To preface, I’ll first say that I’m not trying to offend anyone with this post.

Now anyway, Fries is canonically male. That’s how it always was, and how it still is. It IS okay to headcanon a character as female or male if they HAVE no confirmed gender. But Fries does. You can’t have headcanons that directly clash with confirmed lore.

(Repost because typo)


r/BattleForDreamIsland • • May 30 '26

Discussion i feel so bad for people who has book as their favoroute character i mean book literally decended to hell and got burnt by lava and had their eye sawed off with a drill and attempted suicide before burning to a crisp in the time frame of 2 minutes

Post image
1 Upvotes