59
u/Ayn-Randy_Savage Mar 03 '18
Sorry no, you are only allowed to enjoy life if you are feeding corporations through conspicuous consumption.
Think about it: The most talked about people spend a few hundred at a casual dinner, and consider only 1 vacation property to be poverty.
The world is not made for us have-nots, even though we have given our blood, sweat, and tears to build it.
6
Mar 04 '18
I definitely agree. Do you think that's why many people do not believe this planet to be their "real home", in a sense? That maybe they have awoken to the fact that this place is not meant for us anymore? Just a thought..
24
Mar 03 '18
To bad he died immediately after starting to enjoy his life. Because he was standing in the street like an idiot.
46
u/green_meklar public rent-capture Mar 03 '18
Nah, the robot cars would automatically brake for him.
5
Mar 04 '18
Not if programmed to not care because he was an 'unproductive slacker' due to not having a job.
4
8
Mar 04 '18
Here’s my idea, each robot has to subsidize one workers life. I mean, they’re better than people so the owner is still getting a better output for the price. Then only machines would be owned, not people.
19
15
u/gurenkagurenda Mar 04 '18
I get why that seems like it has a certain elegance to it, but it doesn't really make sense in practice. The first reason is that defining "each robot" in any coherent way wouldn't be possible. You don't automate a process by simply building robots and plopping them in wherever the humans were. The whole process changes.
The second problem is that it puts us in this really bad position of having to decide which tools are "robots" and which tools are just "tools". If a worker is twice as productive using an electric drill as if they used a hand drill, is the electric drill a "robot" which must now subsidize the additional worker who would be employed if it weren't used?
The third problem is that if a single machine cuts the number of workers required by a factor of ten, "one robot subsidizes one former worker" doesn't come close to solving the job loss problem.
But the fourth, and in my opinion most important problem, is that it discourages automation, which is exactly the opposite of what we should be doing. Getting rid of work is a good thing, as is increasing productivity. The fact that automation causes suffering through job loss is not a problem with automation. It's a problem with an obsolete economic system built on the core assumption that we will always have more work for humans to do than humans capable of doing it.
2
u/Kaarsty Mar 04 '18
You hitthe nail on the head there. The crawl towards global automation will include a shift in paradigm. What is a machine? What is a tool? What IS human? My bets are that they're gonna try - HARD - to position it so that they maximize control and profit.
Some small part of me can't wait, but another part is super concerned about the future. Luckily I won't be around to care! The eyes with which I gaze upon what they've done will feel right at home.
2
2
u/tamingthemind Mar 05 '18
Reminds me of a post a while back in /r/LateStageCapitalism: "You ever think about how much we had to fuck up to create a world where robots taking all the jobs is somehow a bad thing?"
2
2
u/Kaarsty Mar 04 '18
Also how bad is it that one day these responses might be recorded in history books as the final complaints of those who might have fixed it had they stood up.
1
Jun 13 '22
Survival of the fittest - that's how it's been for the entirety of the existence of life. The worker turning obsolete is the newest iteration of this principle.
-12
u/soyouretelsoiso Mar 04 '18
Right, and 90% of the population would sit on their asses and watch tv. Guaranteed.
13
u/LoneCookie Mar 04 '18
Americans are considered lazy despite working more than people do in other countries
I suggest you look up laziness: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laziness#Psychology
17
6
u/udon_junkie Mar 04 '18
job stress is a factor when it comes to avoiding exercise. Unemployment stress is just as bad, but only because of the dread of getting old without any experience and thus the means to provide for yourself.
8
0
Mar 03 '18
[deleted]
10
u/DoYouNeedALieDown Mar 04 '18
Basic income is not about redistributing all the current wealth. It's about giving a level of income to live on. Agreed, difficult to find money in current system but the concept is solid in terms of resources to people.
Recommend reading Guy Standing book on universal basic income to see research data overview
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
1
u/DoYouNeedALieDown Mar 04 '18
Has a bit of everything. Later chapters about where the money could come from. Regarding getting the money from tax, there is one inyeresting point about taking from goverment quantitive easing. Mentions an exact situation in the UK where the government would of have enough money to support a basic income in the for a couple years instead of bailing out corporations. I'll get a link when I can.
6
u/TrumpAltPleaseIgnore Mar 03 '18
Source please!
0
Mar 03 '18
[deleted]
8
u/exmachinalibertas Mar 04 '18
That's a simplified view though, only taking into account global GDP at any given time. But money is completely imaginary. It is a measure of arbitrary psychological value. As far as actual resources go, there is more than enough on the planet to provide food, shelter, healthcare, and education for every single person on earth. We're just really bad at allocating resources, and even our best economics and societies are still miserably bad at it.
I'm not claiming UBI solves or even improves that miserable state, but my point is that the global GDP and available money aren't really the problem. The physical resources are more than enough. The problem is our ability to meaningfully organize in a way that even approaches any kind of efficiency of utilizing the resources we have available.
3
u/TrumpAltPleaseIgnore Mar 04 '18
Source please!
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
8
u/Kingreaper Mar 04 '18
That "very easy google search" says $280 trillion in 2017.
Try providing actual sources.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
9
u/Kingreaper Mar 04 '18
A) Assuming that no new wealth is being produced, and that the basic income has to be worldwide on a US standard.
So yes, you're right, taking all the wealth in the world and then bunging it out bit by bit while preventing anyone from doing any work would never allow the entire world to experience a US standard of living.
But no-one is proposing doing that...
B) It's still 4 times as much as you thought. Had you not even bothered to google search?
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
8
u/Kingreaper Mar 04 '18
A UBI sufficient to stop people starving anywhere in the world is a lot less than $10k per person per year.
Hence the "US standard of living" part.
And, of course, you're ignoring the fact that more wealth would be being produced all the time, just as it is right now.
→ More replies (0)2
4
u/Shishakli Mar 04 '18
Open and shut case... Pack it in boys, ubi is a pipe dream... Go back to your unemployment offices, stop whinging
1
u/red-brick-dream Mar 04 '18 edited Mar 04 '18
It's adorable that you think you're safe from automation.
Cya in the breadline, batshit.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
3
u/MeshesAreConfusing Mar 04 '18
. And without an incentive against it that's exactly what people will do with all the extra time and money they're given.
All the data points to the contrary
5
u/red-brick-dream Mar 04 '18 edited Mar 06 '18
If they gave a shit about that, the t_d-brigade would be here as members rather than trolls.
This is ideological for them. They want to preserve capitalism at any cost whatsoever to human well-being. They defend capitalism as a means to the end of human flourishing, but if you really press them, you find out that they'd rather see the world reduced to ashes around them than accept any structural change.
1
u/TrumpAltPleaseIgnore Mar 04 '18
This is in physical currency, you should've mentioned this but instead you cut out that information presumably for the purposes of deceiving people. This is also ignoring the fact that money can be made, the amount of physical currency isn't static and there are forms of UBI which involve dedicating a percentage of all the money created to UBI. In conclusion... shut the fuck up, you clearly don't know what you're talking about.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
0
u/TrumpAltPleaseIgnore Mar 04 '18
https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-total-net-worth-of-the-world
Has the same $80 trillion estimate.
0
u/smegko Mar 04 '18
World capital is close to $1 quadrillion according to Bain & Company's A World Awash in Money.
$1 quadrillion / 7 billion = $142,000 / person
7
u/Vehks Mar 04 '18
Fuck it, take the money anyway.
All these wealthy types do is abuse their absurdly vast fortunes to make life unnecessarily harder on everyone else.
No more billionaires.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
4
u/red-brick-dream Mar 04 '18 edited Mar 04 '18
If you devoted half the time to thinking as you did to trolling, you'd be here as an earnest subscriber.
Tell me: what is your solution?
To maintain constant labour input with exponentially increasing productivity (output per unit of labour input), we would have to overproduce. This, in addition to being breathtakingly stupid, is also physically impossible, due to ecological constraints among others. So labour will be displaced.
So if you reject basic income in the long term, you are de facto adopting one of the following stances:
1) We should let everyone starve and die (in which case, as I think I said to you elsewhere in this thread, it's very cute that you think you'll be in the high-tech citadels and not the breadlines with the rest of us), or
2) We should invent mountains of pointless busywork for people to perform on threat of starvation and homelessness.Both scenarios are simply shocking in their absurdity and their cruelty. But to take ownership of one of them would at least be honest.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
3
Mar 04 '18
Unfortunately, history has proven this to be untrue. The rich tend not to understand the poor, causing them to make assumptions about the poor that aren't true.
How do you explain to someone who owns a yacht and a jet that some people can't afford a car, or hell, a bus pass? How could someone who has a private chef understand what desperate hunger is?
We can't rely on the (even selfish) good graces of the rich. That won't go well.
7
u/rlxmx Mar 04 '18
So many fascinating ideas in your comment. First, there's the all or nothing assumption that UBI is taking everybody's money, then divvying it out equally among all 7 billion people on Earth. And of course, if that isn't practical, neither is UBI in any form or at any scale. (Why?)
Then there's the add on idea that we keep multiplying faster than the resource pool can provide. This is an interesting assertion, since the wealthy portion of the world typically has few children. The birth rate in America has actually dropped below replacement level. And America isn't the only place. It's pretty much universal that the wealthier a society is, the fewer children are born.
If you're also worried about the population crisis, the smartest thing to do is to advocate for funding a UBI for less developed countries, to work toward helping average families achieve the financial security, excess budget necessary to access birth control, and the female empowerment needed for those nations as a whole to eventually control their own fertility (and for individual families to feel secure enough to be willing to do it).
People in rural Kenya can double their current income with a monthly UBI of $22 US dollars. This will vary by country, of course, but UBI is a terrific economic development tool for the developing world. People in Kenya typically use UBI & cash transfers to buy medicine, education for their children, to start or improve businesses, and to put a decent roof over their heads.
If any of you readers want to join me and give someone in extreme poverty a UBI, I encourage you to check out GiveDirectly, a charity just launching a massive UBI campaign/UBI study in Kenya. They did one pilot village in 2017, and now they are expanding to the full intended reach of the campaign.
Within the next year, I aim to be giving 10% of my income to the most effective ways of combatting extreme poverty, because by world standards, I only have to make about $32k a year to be in the top 1% of world income. After all, #BeTheChange.
1
u/gurenkagurenda Mar 04 '18
Just to give more of a shoutout to GiveDirectly: GiveWell rates them as one of their top-rated charities in terms of effectiveness. So if you want altruistic bang-for-buck, you can do a lot worse than GiveDirectly.
Note that GiveWell assesses GD's basic income project as less cost-effective than GD's standard cash transfers, but they don't have a lot of confidence about that assessment. GW also isn't factoring in the research benefit of the program, which could plausibly outweigh any short-term inefficiency compared to standard cash transfers.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
3
u/smegko Mar 04 '18
Because there is enough oversupply to raise everyone's standard of living to the equivalent of the median income for their country.
1
u/rlxmx Mar 04 '18 edited Mar 04 '18
Maybe you do believe this, but it has nothing at all to do with the point you originally made.
If you are concerned about the effective use of discriminatory dollars, perhaps you can advocate for a larger percentage of government spending to go to humanitarian international development, and for those interventions to be better vetted for effectiveness.
Perhaps the government should be raising taxes specifically with the intention of funding more and better foreign aid (since Americans obviously need less money than we have, as you point out).
Less than 1% of the US budget goes to international aid. Most people assume that it's a wildly higher number. It's actually a drop in the bucket.
2
u/gurenkagurenda Mar 04 '18
Dividing the total world wealth by world population is so incredibly far from UBI that I don't know what your point would be even if you hadn't gotten the answer wrong by two orders of magnitude.
1
u/LoneCookie Mar 04 '18 edited Mar 04 '18
Depends where you live
Also people keep asking you for the source.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
2
u/LoneCookie Mar 04 '18
You're awefully trusting and incapable of critical thought...
1k$ means nothing unless we know the exchange rate between countries.
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
5
u/LoneCookie Mar 04 '18
Wow, you're one of those Russian shills I keep hearing about... Browsing utopia and UBI making up facts and praising the Donald posts...
Sigh
0
0
Mar 03 '18
[deleted]
31
u/queenofcompost Mar 03 '18
You could still work a meaningful job, even more so if you weren't stuck working a lame job for financial purposes. I love my meaningful job but it sure doesn't pay well. Even $10k/yr of UBI would allow me to continue doing so comfortably.
12
u/YarnYarn Mar 03 '18 edited Mar 03 '18
Imagine how meaningful your work could be if you choose to do it free from any financial impulse or constraint - A pure expression of your passion or desire to do that work for the good of all who would benefit from it.
Talent and skill untethered from anything but your willingness to employ them for whatever reasons you see fit.
Talk about fulfillment.
Edit: you not your
18
u/PanDariusKairos Mar 03 '18
Work != job.
What must end is employment under others. We must all become self-employed, with all basic needs met.
6
Mar 03 '18
I didn't work a meaningful job
What is stopping you?
0
Mar 03 '18
[deleted]
4
u/TiV3 Mar 03 '18
How would you feel about working a job that would be more efficiently done by a robot? Seems like a dead end to me, in a way.
Maybe being in a position to look around in the world, and to be free to act where you find wants and needs of others or even yourself, that you'd consider worthwhile to work on fulfilling, that'd be interesting? Especially if a majority of people was more able to put a bounty on their want/need fulfillment?
I don't think there's a lot of freedom in being told what to do till we're out of meaningful roles to hand to people on that basis. Economy is a lot more than that. Sure we could despise the people who want to build a more efficient economy, possibly costing you your current role in society. But then again, amish settlements exist, too. You can always join those, or start one on a different level of technology!
You're free to form a community that will have your current job forever, if you like it so much. As much as there's plenty work left unfinished, even if we automate most jobs that neural networks can automate. So maybe worthwhile to look around in the world. But only you can know for yourself if that's something you like. If not, go (role-)play!
8
3
u/YarnYarn Mar 03 '18
I mean, all due respect, but this honestly reads like you tie your self worth to paid labor.
I just don't know where to begin...
2
u/Hunterbunter Mar 03 '18
I think you're right, if not in this particular case then that there are plenty of people out there who don't know what they would do with their time if they didn't have to work (and would therefore feel no meaning). Don't forget there has been selective pressure for the last 10,000 years to work for pay. You could say we've become adapted to that as a species. Thankfully we're human, and adaptable within a lifetime.
He says that he wants to do his job because it makes him happy, and a robot doing it better than him would take away his meaning. I think it's about habit. He has the habit for his job and he earns enough to have his needs met; a robot taking his job means he can no longer do that known thing for a known reward. For centuries, people have been so short of time that they don't even know how to derive meaning from just being alive. This is something that takes time to get adjusted to. In my opinion, it starts with a smaller UBI and a lowering of the 40hr week. People need time and space to see what they can achieve with the time that they have, that aren't mundane monotonous and repetitive tasks (which is what the first stage of automation is targeting).
2
Mar 03 '18
We are not a potty to just do one thing. Through your life you should be changing passions and interests every five or seven years.
1
u/LoneCookie Mar 04 '18
What do you do?
0
Mar 04 '18
[deleted]
1
u/LoneCookie Mar 04 '18
I don't think that would be automated. Just more streamlined. I also think research is not a field that would suffer from unemployment (unless we do something stupid).
Better productivity in research means more things you can research. A part of that field is just blind funding, the other is selling your idea to someone older than you (who wouldn't know how much you need now vs before). I think what it would do is let you have more leeway with funding/be over funded.
Correct me if my perceptions are wrong. I'm a programmer by trade. I can see automation taking away simple jobs, but so far it has only increased productivity in others. These others go the route of downsizing and retraining or rehiring those who can use the new tech. It's a messy transition sometimes but it doesn't axe people entirely.
For idea-based fields like software development or research I cannot see there be a downsizing. When people leave work something else pops up because more people are willing to fund them.
(I also apologize for this sub that nobody asked you your concern and instead down voted you and made assumptions about your understanding)
2
u/DoYouNeedALieDown Mar 04 '18
Geez why the downvotes for this? He was making a solid point. People get lots of meaning from their jobs. Automation will take all types of meaningful jobs from healthcare to software.
I guess the point is if you had basic income and automation is helping the world you will have more time to find new meaningful jobs :) imagine if you had time to learn new instruments or study maths just for fun
2
1
u/Lawnmover_Man Mar 03 '18
It's perfectly possible to do any meaningful thing without signing a contract with a third party.
157
u/alwayslurkeduntilnow Mar 03 '18
Until we free the ownership from those who desire mega profits we are still screwed.