First of all I want to say that I really love the books. I do not want to shit on the third book, it is actually my second favourite part, I just think that the conspiracy is not very well thought through. So lets begin!
In the third book it is revealed that the person behind the Lovelace Conspiracy was in fact Quentin Makepeace.
So the conspiracy in the first book was pretty solid.
1. Host the conference at Heddleham Hall 2. Make sure nobody gets out of the great hall 3. Summon a greater spirit that can kill all the other spirits 4. Use the Amulet of Samarkand to prevent you from getting killed by Ramuthra 5. Profit
The plan was almost perfect.
The only risk was that the amulet only protects you from magical attacks, but does not help you against physical damage. There were dozens of wizards in the hall. Lovelace/Makepeace should have planned that someone tries to to grab the amulet, but he still had Faquarl, Jabor and Ramuthra to protect him so it is a minor risk.
The second conspiracy was decent, but not as great as the first one.
1. Hopkins feeds information to the Resistance to gain their trust. 2. Makepeace convinces Duvall to join the conspirators 3. Hopkins convinces the Resistance to break into Gladestone“s Tomb 4. With Makepeace advice Duvall uses the Golem to distract the wizards from Gladstone“s Tomb. 5. The Resistance delivers Gladstone“s Staff to Makepeace 6. Makepeace uses the staff for a coup
Gladstone“s Staff is really powerful. But unlike the Amulet of Samarkand it is an offensive weapon than a defensive one. The staff will not protect you against magical attacks, so there is always the chance that one spirit kills you if you or your servants do not pay attention. Another problem is that Makepeace“s rivals could use the staff against him. But the staff is still a powerful tool that could help Makepeace with the actual coup against Deveroux.
So in the third book there is one final conspiracy and I think it is by far the worst plan of the three.
So Makepeace and Hopkins found out that Spirits could live inside human bodies so they developed a plan.
1. Hopkins summoned a spirit (Faquarl) into himself and is able to control him
2. Makepeace writes a play about the live of Deveroux and all important wizards appear at the premier of his play to appease Deveroux / gain his favour
3. All wizards desummon their spirits and remove their lenses, because Makepeace asks them to do it
4. Makepeace uses demons to to capture all the wizards, while they are distracted by the play
5. The conspirators summon demons into themselves and become powerful
6.Makepeace and friends kill everyone who does not join them
So on my opinion this is the worst plan ever!
So first of all Makepeace and Co. took a huge risk, when they summoned the spirits into themselves. They never knew that they could control a spirits but they tried anyway.
Makepace even said that it requieres a strong will to control a demon. And what does he? He does not summon a foliot or an imp he summons a greater spirit like Nuoda. This is totally crazy.
And the conspirators did not even need to become hybrids. The could killed all the government officials anyway like they planned in the first book. And if Makepeace is truly paranoid that somebody betrays him (which is somewhat reasonable- I mean there where three coups against the government during the last five years), then he could have just used the amulet and Gladstone“s stuff and nobody could have killed him. So why risk everything and summon Nuoda.
And their plan to capture all the wizards was not good either.
How do they know that all important wizards will attend the play?
How do they no that some wizards wont release their demons?
How do they no that some wizards wont remove their lenses?
But even if all wizards release their demons and remove their lenses, it only takes one wizard to turn around see that all his "co-workers" are captured and then he could have screamed and all wizards would have summoned their spirits.
Bonus round:
Ramuthra and Gladstone“s Staff could have at least helped them to stabilize the British Empire. If Lovelace or Makepeace went to Boston with Ramuthra or the Staff the Americans would not stand a chance. Or they could have used it as a bargaining chip during the negotiations with the rebels. Summoning the the spirits into themselves would not have helped them even if it worked. Because as soon as other wizards realize that this is possible the would have done it themselves and nobody gained any advantage. (Except the commoners, they are even more fucked)
Okay this was my analysis about the conspiracies during the three books. I hope you liked it.