r/BanishedModding • • Sep 04 '14

Request/Concept [Request/Concept] Military and Combat - Banished as an RTS platform

0 Upvotes

I'd like to say first of all that this is really just an idea I feel might be interesting to discuss and brainstorm (I was on the fence about whether to use the 'Miscellaneous' flair). A mod like this would be a big project, akin to how DayZ is a mod of Arma 2.

Banished is a wonderful simulator and I think one of the most interesting games out there. One of the things its most successful with IMO is conveying just how fragile a town can be. Its so very easy to find oneself without enough food or without a sustainable population, and it takes a long time before a player can get good enough to sustain a town comfortably.

I was playing AoE II just today and it struck me just how different the towns of Banished are compared to the towns of your average RTS. In these games the nuances tend to be (as you might expect) centered around military development and conquest, and they largely hand-wave everything else as the player's 'economy'. In these games we barely get any sense of what its like to build a town from the ground up - the towns are the means to the end of military development.

That's all fine and good, but it is interesting to think of what kind of game we might have if we (effectively) took the combat mechanics of something like AoE II or Rise of Nations and situated them in the world of Banished. Consider how important it would be to secure land on the map for instance, or how you might balance achieving stability in your town with defending it. How early on could you dedicate citizens to a military role? When would it be worth it to risk your resources on a raiding party?

Ideas regarding the military itself;

  • First of all, I'm thinking that to keep with the spirit of Banished in a mod like this you'd want to emphasize the supply of your military quite a bit. Soldiers away from home have to sleep and eat for instance; perhaps a supply wagon unit capable of (a) acting as a miniature mobile market, (b) setting up a temporary camp acting as a boarding house, and (c) acting as transport vessels for moving units across water.

  • Weapons of varying quality (iron, steel) would probably be produced via blacksmiths and would wear down like tools.

  • I'm thinking that the over-all tech level of the military would not change much (unlike most RTS games), but perhaps a Barracks would allow for the option of selecting which units would be produced.

  • Military buildings would work similarly to schools, but with a cap such that only X amount of a selected unit would be trained at one time.

  • Unlike all other professions, military units would have a maximum age. All soldiers upon reaching some set age (45 maybe?) would become educated laborers.

  • From the Barracks, available military units would probably be foot-soldiers, archers, spear-men. If Horses were to be allowed (which might make for a good mod idea itself actually...) a separate building, the Stables, could produce light cavalry, heavy cavalry, and mounted archers. Siege weapons would be produced in another separate building, the Siege Workshop, and these might be things like battering rams, catapults, supply wagons, and trebuchets. Siege weapons might work more like mobile buildings, staffed by dedicated personnel trained at the workshop, and having their own resource storage for ammunition (or supply in the case of the supply wagon).

  • Defensive buildings would be very important. Guard towers manned by archers, week walls made of wood or more fortified walls of stone, large gates, and so on.

  • It would probably be dangerously imbalanced if only military units were capable of attacking other units (a single foot-soldier could effectively annihilate a town without defenses), so adult citizens would be capable of temporarily becoming militia units when under attack - weeker than other military units but better than nothing.

Anyway, Anyone have any other thoughts on the ideas here? I realize that Banished doesn't need a mod like this - a mod like this would effectively make it a very different game, but an interesting one I feel. As for feasibility, I can only imagine how difficult a mod like this would be to make - would this sort of thing be possible realistically?


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 03 '14

Mod [MOD] The Fappening! [Disease]

Thumbnail
banishedinfo.com
0 Upvotes

r/BanishedModding • • Sep 10 '14

[Mod Request] Swap the trade values for Firewood and Logs

0 Upvotes

Seems kind of silly that you take something worth 2 and chop into into 4 pieces each worth 4 for a total profit of 800%. It feels like cheating to trade firewood, so I'd like a mod that nerfs the value and doesn't make me feel bad about selling logs, or flipping them (buying them, turning them into firewood and then selling the firewood).

TL;DR: Trade values: Firewood: 2 Logs: 4


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 27 '14

marijuana crops?

4 Upvotes

Just wondering :) seems like it would be useful for fuel/fabrics etc. Is anyone working on this? If not then i may consider doing this.


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 15 '14

possible mod

0 Upvotes

would it be possible to get a mod for either making foresters huts more efective or a new building for getting wood?


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 09 '14

[Mod Request] Turn on achievements

0 Upvotes

Achievements are turned off when you turn on a mod. A mod that turns them back on would be nice.


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 03 '14

[Mod Request] I thought it would be neat to bring some kind of magic into Banished, hear me out.

0 Upvotes

The basic idea is just a sacred tree kind of thing, an upgrade to the church (like the stone houses) that is not buildable directly, only through an upgrade button. It would take no only a lot of logs, but various fruits and vegetables, and a "burnt offering" of 200 beef.

It wouldn't have a priest, instead it would have a Keeper that maintains it by offering it another burnt offering of 400 Beef per year, over the course of the year, if that fails the tree dies and must be rebuilt from the ground up.

The tree would support four times as many worshipers as a church, also giving a slight boost in overall health and (if possible) field harvests.

Just a neat thought I had, wondering if anyone would want to do it if it is at all possible.


r/BanishedModding • • Mar 09 '14

Miscellaneous [ELI5] Why hasn't the dev released the mod kit

5 Upvotes

Also from what I've read (I know nothing of modding just love seeing what you guys are thinking of) you say you don't know what the dev will make available in this mod kit, why would he not give access to certain parts? Thanks in advance!


r/BanishedModding • • Oct 07 '14

[REQUEST/IDEA] As time goes by so does the era the game is in.

1 Upvotes

Title might not be very straight forward but what I mean is that overtime your game goes through different era's (as in medieval, industrial age, etc; progress through history) This would extend the game by not having everything straight away and new things are unlocked as you go. I would make this myself but I don't know how to mod or make any models for new items(though I wish I could). So if anyone thinks this is a good idea or is willing to teach me the basics on how to mod and/or help me out with the mod, please respond. Thanks!

edit: Oh and if I learn how to mod/ model I will realise the things in smaller individual packages for people who don't want the whole thing.


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 01 '14

[Mod Request] Raiders and defenders.

1 Upvotes

I was thinking about this and it seems feasible.

Weapons would be limited but could be pulled off by making a two handed sword model that the villagers would use the pickaxe animation with, this would be considered the "tool" they would use.

The above would be for both defenders and raiders, raiders themselves would be an altered type of nomad that would, instead of trying to go to the town hall, would follow villagers at random, or run to buildings and start fires. When they meet a villager that isn't a defender then they would kill them, if they meet a defender I think it might be feasible to have a "coin flip" kind of thing happen in the background that determines the victor. The loser would die.

Us as players wouldn't have any control over our defenders, we would simply have them as a job type and hope it worked out in the end. Maybe have their age affect their chances?

Anyway, it was a thought, and could probably be tied into the disaster system in some way.

If anyone thinks this could be done and was willing to do it that would be amazing, and thank you to anyone that took the time to read this.


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 09 '14

[Mod Request] Change just the name of Fuel to something else, like Firelogs

0 Upvotes

I understand that there probably should be two separate words for firewood and fuel but fuel is a weird term to use for the time period this game is set in. I would love a mod that changes the word Fuel to Fire Logs (with a space in between both words).


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 07 '14

[MOD Request] Reduce the rate of death during childbirth

0 Upvotes

I've been playing Adam and Eve and it's been very interesting. However, I now have a town of 10 men and no women because all the women have died during childbirth. I understand that it was a leading cause of mortality for women... but couldn't this number be cut in half?


r/BanishedModding • • Jan 08 '15

[request] demand and wealth

0 Upvotes

I started playing Banished, being a huge Anno and Simcity 4 fan. Do you think its possible to create a mod, that makes it possible to just place house fields and the game decides which sort of house will be build? Visually I imagine something like stone houses around the market etc. (could be compatible with CC) It would depend on something like a demand and wealth system. Demand means how many people are needed in a specific area (by jobs) leading to cheap buildings with maximum space. Costly buidlings would be placed surrounding buildings which provides happiness like churches etc. hosting maybe one family. I think that would lead to more realistic towns and maybe its easy to develop :) sry for my awkward englisch ofc.


r/BanishedModding • • Mar 27 '14

Request/Concept Better looking citizens

3 Upvotes

has anyone zoomed in on the citizens, they look good but they are kind of pixely and don't fit in with the great looking buildings and landscape. I am no modder so I cant make it but if someone else could make really sick looking people that would be awesome. Maybe in addition make children skins look smaller and like children.


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 10 '14

[Mod Request] A mod that disables Quarries/Mines

0 Upvotes

Separate mods preferably.


r/BanishedModding • • Apr 29 '15

Help Me Find Mods that make banish run better.

5 Upvotes

High FPS. Stuff like that.


r/BanishedModding • • Jul 11 '14

Request/Concept [Concept] People need to keep cool

1 Upvotes

Somewhere or other, a user here suggested being able to convert depleted quarries into swimming pools (in summer) and skating rinks (in winter). I second this notion.

Additionally, I would propose that, in addition to needing to keep warm in winter, people would need to keep cool in summer. They could accomplish this by drinking from a river or well, but the best option is to take a dip in a pool. (And they could skate on them in winter for a happiness boost).

Naturally, this would come with a few new death types:

  • Heat Exhaustion

  • Drowning

  • Fell through the ice


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 08 '14

[Mod Request] New Disaster-Being Drafted

1 Upvotes

Your people were Banished from somewhere, right? Somewhere that can go to war with other places. They draft all your students and 80-90% of your babies then return a portion of them uneducated 4 years later (the rest fill up your cemeteries).


r/BanishedModding • • Oct 11 '14

[REQUEST/IDEA] Orchard and Crop farmers as fluid assets in the winter

0 Upvotes

Every time winter comes around, I get pretty annoyed by the fact that my crop and orchard farmers aren't productive at all. My solution to this is that whenever the workers at a certain farm or orchard finish the harvest for the year, they get categorized under a special, static, temporary class of laborer and/or builder that can't be assigned to any other profession (to prevent a sudden lack of farmers once spring comes around). This would make winter the perfect time to send out swarms of these temporary laborers/builders to collect as many resources as they could in the given time or meet a construction quota etc...


r/BanishedModding • • Jul 12 '14

I'm curious. With all the suggestions has anyone actually made any progress forwards a functioning Mod for Banished? Great ideas aren't very useful without even better developers.

2 Upvotes

I'm also curious as well. Has anyone mentioned, worked on, or brainstormed over adding Epochs to Banished? I realize that this would be a very large undertaking but wow, the possibilities.

Also, can I have aeti?


r/BanishedModding • • Feb 21 '14

Mod [MOD] Banished with ENB ! Installation Guide in the comments

Thumbnail
imgur.com
15 Upvotes

r/BanishedModding • • Aug 29 '14

[Req] Unlimited Materials

3 Upvotes

I know it kind of defeats the purpose of the game but i would like to just build a monster city.

Any one willing to work on this?


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 13 '14

[Mod Request] Money for trading.

0 Upvotes

Is it possible? Sell resources for their value in money. Not only exchanges.


r/BanishedModding • • Sep 14 '14

[Mod Request]Tech Tree?

3 Upvotes

What do you think about a a tech tree for the game?