r/BandCamp • • Oct 04 '25

Discussion Think I’m done with Bandcamp

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

Not only does my band get sales anymore, we don’t even get streams on Bandcamp despite heavily pushing it on social media. Conversely , we get a decent amount of streams on Spotify and Apple Music despite rarely if ever promoting it. Honestly if it were up to me I’d pull everything off Spotify as I actually despise that company but that’d be me cutting off my nose to spite my face , so to speak. And I keep seeing all these videos saying to give up on streaming and concentrate on selling direct to fans, but at this point that’d be career suicide.

I don’t know what to do at this point , but it’s becoming very disheartening


r/BandCamp • • Aug 26 '25

Bandcamp Problem After hundreds of albums I'm done with Bandcamp (since they don't want my money) and am moving to Apple Music

0 Upvotes

I've been using Bandcamp for almost a decade and the one thing which has remained a constant is Bandcamp's constant refusal to let me give my money to artists. At this point I've spent almost five figures on Bandcamp, but this has come at a huge cost to my sanity. Every single time I change my Credit Card I never know what kind of uphill battle I need to climb to get Bandcamp to accept my new card, and this week is no different.

I recently lost my Credit Card and had it changed with a new number. I recently tried to purchase a couple of new albums, and straight away I was greeted with Bandcamp's infamous "Transaction cannot be processed" error. My bank confirmed that no transaction was attempted and that the issue was at Bandcamp's site. After a few rounds of removing my saved card, creating a new saved card (this never works), adding an album to the cart and then paying and then saving the card (this only sometimes works)... I eventually tried to make a purchase where I wouldn't save the card and it finally went through. So I repeated it for my next purchase, that worked... and then the third one... bam, Card Declined. This time the issue was with my bank, I had previously told them to stop declining my Bandcamp purchases, but because this was a new card that exemption was lost and they had to add it back. My bank told me to try again in half an hour, and so I did... Card Declined. Eventually after a few more attempts, I suddenly got an error telling me that my CVC code was wrong (even though it is correct). My bank confirmed that there wasn't a single CVC error on my card for the entire day and again reiterated that the problem is with Bandcamp.

So I tried again 10 minutes later... and now... back to the infamous "Transaction cannot be processed" error.

Excuse my language here, but: WHAT THE FUCK?

I tried again numerous more times, again making sure I don't have a saved card, trying with a saved card, everything. Every single fucking time... "Transaction cannot be processed." My bank confirmed that all of these errors are on Bandcamp's side.

And you know what? I've fucking had enough. I emailed Bandcamp about this, and of course they haven't replied yet. The last time I tried to contact them they took an entire fucking month to get back to me with some half-arsed reply which didn't address my issue at all.

A long time ago Gabe Newell, the CEO of Valve, famously said: "Piracy is almost always a service problem and not a pricing problem."

I've been vehemently against Apple Music and Spotify because I know how impossible it is for smaller indie artists to make a living on these platforms. They simply can't. I pride myself for the thousands of albums I own outright (not just on Bandcamp, but CD's as well as Beatport) and on Bandcamp especially I always give the artists at least 30% more on top of their asking price; in some extreme cases I've even given 100% more. I'm also extremely anal with my music collection, I have extremely specific tastes and I'm known for spending dozens of hours deep-diving the gutters of Bandcamp to find obscure bands with zero followers and zero purchases. My fan page has gained a decent following over the years and I've given many smaller bands that much needed extra little bit of exposure to hopefully sell at least a couple more albums. And I feel that all of this is for fucking nothing, because Bandcamp keeps fucking with my purchases.

I'll admit that I'm extremely OCD when it comes to this as well: because of the way I manage my massive music library, I always buy my albums in batches, and in each batch there is always a theme I follow for that specific batch. This helps me remember my vast library and it allows me to find stuff quickly (sometimes I might not remember the exact album I'm looking for, but I'll remember an adjacent album). So the fact that I have a half-arsed batch now because Bandcamp started to block my card mid-way is driving me fucking nuts.

My husband is the opposite of me and uses Apple Music because he too got fed the fuck up with Bandcamp a year ago with the fucking "Transaction cannot be processed" error and told me it's extremely stress-inducing and time-wasting to have to go through so much effort just to buy some music when he can have it immediately available on Apple Music.

Bandcamp, get your fucking shit together. Your artists deserve better. And to all the artists I've supported over the years: sorry, I really tried. But I just can't fucking do this anymore.


r/BandCamp • • Oct 06 '25

Discussion 16 bit audio should be a requirement, not just a minimum. Let's discuss this.

0 Upvotes

As mentioned in their FAQ:

"Files must be at least 16-bit, 44.1 kHz lossless files (WAV, AIFF, or FLAC) in stereo to ensure that fans are able to purchase music at the highest quality available."

I’m unhappy with the audio quality of my download. What should I do? – Bandcamp Help Center

Some artists choose to upload music in a higher 24 bit resolution though, with no 16 bit option available by default. This creates a problem for people like myself who want to burn music onto CDrs. If an album exceeds 700mb, then it cannot fit on one disc. I know that I can always contact the artist or record label if I want them to replace the files, but I don't really like having to do that every time I purchase/download high res audio. I don't want to be the death of the party, but I don't always like talking to people. Not everyone is going to want to do that.

I am aware that there is another page in the FAQ that explains how to fix this problem:

"If your lossless downloads are not playing in your DJ tools (Traktor, CDJ, Serato, Rekordbox, etc.) or other media players like Sonos, chances are they are encoded in 24-bit. Some audio programs don't support 24-bit audio files, or are incompatible with Bandcamp's 24-bit encodings. In order to get the tracks working correctly, you'll need to convert them into the universal standard 16-bit. We recommend using Apple Music or fre:ac to convert your downloads into 16-bit."

My downloads won’t play in my audio player. What’s up? – Bandcamp Help Center

However, not everyone is tech savvy, and converting files to the correct specifications can be a pain in the butt, especially if there are a lot of tracks. I think it would make sense to give artists the option to upload 24 bit audio as well and let the buyer choose the resolution, but at a cost paid by the artist/record label, so that Bandcamp can afford to facilitate these bigger uploads.

I think this is an unnecessary inconvenience that we don't need. 24 bit audio isn't really worth it in my opinion. The differences to my ears are negligible. 16 bit audio sounds great and it's been the standard for CDs ever since the format was created. If an artist has an album in 24 bit resolution, it should be their responsibility to export the audio in an appropriate resolution, not ours.

The 24-Bit Delusion - Mojo Audio

So, let's discuss this. I am no business expert. Could this work realistically, and are there any good reasons not to do this?


r/BandCamp • • 16d ago

Free Album Codes My latest album, TEPIDARIUM II - [ambient electronic]

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm an independent electronic musician from Hungary, and I've been making music as Tangram for over 20 years.

Over the years, I've played quite a few live shows, including opening for Tangerine Dream in 2011, which was definitely one of the highlights of my musical journey.

Seventeen years ago, a day spent at the Széchenyi Thermal Baths in Budapest inspired me to create an album called Tepidarium.

The title also had a personal meaning. My nickname is Tepi, so I imagined the tepidarium as a place where my thoughts, emotions, and musical ideas could come together.

About a year ago, I came across the word again and started wondering: what would a new Tepidarium sound like today, after 17 more years of life and musical experience?

That's how Tepidarium II was born.

Life has changed quite a bit since the first album. These days, I run a software development company, and finding time for music isn't always easy. But over the past three months, I finally managed to bring the album together.

Interestingly, I composed it from both ends towards the middle: tracks 1 and 7 first, then 2 and 6, and so on. I wanted the seven pieces to form a continuous emotional journey.

The album is about 50 minutes of atmospheric electronic music, and it was released on October 30.

If you're interested, you can listen here:
https://tangram.bandcamp.com/album/tepidarium-ii

10 codes for downloading (2 remaining, edited):

ltu9-6x7p

ck5k-gqpn

I'd love to hear what you think, especially if you enjoy listening to albums as a whole rather than individual tracks.


r/BandCamp • • Aug 28 '25

Question/Help Finding the words (with a little help)

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ve gone back and forth on whether to share this here. Many of you already know I’m autistic and ADHD. For a long time, I hesitated to talk about it because I never wanted it to sound like a gimmick or a way of asking for sympathy. But the truth is, it’s inseparable from why I make music as Arcane Synthetic.

I’ve made mistakes in the past—said or done things that landed wrong. I carry the weight of those moments, and I’m trying to be better. My music is part of that process: taking fracture, distortion, and overload, and shaping it into something meaningful.

I also want to be transparent: I didn’t write this alone. I asked ChatGPT to help me shape the words. It wasn’t one quick prompt, but a slow process of trying to capture honesty without pretension.

If you’re going through something similar—autism, ADHD, or just the weight of being human—my messages are open. Sometimes reaching out helps both people.

Thanks for reading, and for walking alongside me in this process of becoming.

—Benjamin / Arcane Synthetic arcanesynthetic.bandcamp.com


r/BandCamp • • Jan 17 '26

Article Holly Herndon Says Bandcamp’s AI Ban Is Misguided

Thumbnail
stereogum.com
0 Upvotes

r/BandCamp • • Jan 16 '26

Discussion I'm worried

0 Upvotes

Now with all this ai ban going on, i had some bad thoughts about how the ai sloppers will take revenge on us because we're banning their stuff.

(As a side note, i agree with steo0315 that we should make a megathreat to show which slopper has been banned, so the subreddit doesn't get filled with "look at this slopper being gone" posts)

So with 1 of my more smaller worries (which i personally can live with) is that they will now flood the subreddit and annoy or insult us for kicking their ass out of bandcamp. I already got insulted for being "a cu nt and a dick". So i recommend getting ready for some nasty comments.

But my biggest fear right now is how innocent artist could be attacked by those sloppers. How one guy said "lets ban everyone" or "lets bring the whole website down". I'm very worried that ai sloppers will report innocent people for using ai despite them being honest people. There are/could be also "normal" people who could also do the same with artists they don't like. (Like one guy said "lets ban trash pop artist" etc.)

Don't forget why we are doing this: For the love of the craft, for sitting your ass down, writing the lyrics, perform music and maybe learn something new or let other people learn something new and not to just lazely type smth into a clanker. We are protecting the musicians who try their best.

But if you think, people get deserved to be banned because their music is as "worthless as ai" then you are just a hater and not better than those freaks over on twitter.

So dear AI Sloppers: YOUR KIND IS NOT WELCOME.

And to the people who actually care about music: Stay safe, those sloppers are pissed and will do anything they can to make our day worse.

Kepp yourself safe and i hope ya have a nice day.👍


r/BandCamp • • Mar 21 '26

Discussion Holy Crap! Really?

0 Upvotes

I was just looking at some new music and was shocked at some of the pricing. One album, the digital album is more expensive than the CD. WHY? There's no material involved, no processing to create physical hardware, no shipping costs. Just a computer download over the net. This is getting absolutely ridiculous.


r/BandCamp • • Sep 18 '20

Rock THE PENIS SUCKERS DEBUT ALBUM OUT NOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!BUY NOW ONLY 100 USD DOLLAS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!BEST ALBUM OF 2020 ROCK N ROLL ROCK N ROLL ROCK N ROLL NSFW

Thumbnail
moogly.bandcamp.com
1 Upvotes

r/BandCamp • • Mar 02 '26

Question/Help Why the phonk is so expensive ?

0 Upvotes

I just search a music than i can't bought in cd and i see a lot of "album"/single with the price is over $10 for 3 songs, isn't that super expensive?


r/BandCamp • • Oct 06 '25

Discussion If I have to buy your record and then wait a month to be able to listen to it, I’m not gonna buy it.

0 Upvotes

Just release the thing when it’s done guys. Enough with these long ass “preorders”, you’re not gonna run out of digital files are you? Ohh yeah I got it first, they’re running out! Grow up.

Makes a little more sense for physical releases, but just a little.


r/BandCamp • • Jan 16 '26

Discussion How can you promote your music on this subreddit?

1 Upvotes

Since this subreddit doesn't allow self-promotion, how can people promote their work? Is there any other way of doing so?


r/BandCamp • • Nov 12 '22

Question/Help is it possible to report an album for spreading COVID conspiracies?

0 Upvotes

I ran across an artist I used to follow as a kid and he's gone full conspiracy theorist on his latest album. Like, full-blown antivax "plandemic" Alex Jones water-turning-frogs-gay kinda stuff. What's Bandcamp's moderation policy?


r/BandCamp • • Aug 25 '25

Question/Help I've never seen anything like this...

2 Upvotes

Today I found a house music/garage label on Bandcamp selling their 3 or 4 song EPs for $1000
Never in my life have I seen someone asking those kind of prices. Has anyone else seen something like that before?

I like their music, but I don't like it that much!


r/BandCamp • • Nov 12 '25

Question/Help My only disappointing BandCamp purchase

0 Upvotes

I really appreciate BandCamp - it lets me support artists more directly than any other means except for maybe at the merch table at a concert, and the breadth and depth of the available releases is great. My only bummer of a purchase was of the Dub Reggae album by The Scientist: Rids the World of the Curse of Evil Vampires. It sounds like the settings of the Analog to Digital transfer were just way off. Comments (including mine) complain about it, I used the "contact" button to request a re-digitization, and haven't heard anything back. If u/bandcamp_official has any ability to get this fixed, I'd be over the moon.


r/BandCamp • • Mar 04 '26

Discussion What merch sells the best?

1 Upvotes

hey all, I am looking to start making physical merchandise soon. I am wondering what seems to sell the best? genre is punk/pop/rock/Christian. not sure if the religious side would change the demographic or media preference.


r/BandCamp • • Oct 01 '23

Question/Help Am i allowed to use AI generated art for album covers/profile pages?

0 Upvotes

It's certainly cheaper than hiring artists, which I can't afford. Not that I feel good about artists (possibly including musicins one day) being replaced by AI mind. But am i allowed to use this stuff?


r/BandCamp • • Aug 16 '25

Bug report: Full discography prices stay the same even if you buy individual releases from an artist

0 Upvotes

EDIT: As enough people have told me in the comments, this id not a bug but more of a feature request.

Original message: This means that you're paying for releases that you already own a second time when you buy an artist's full discography and the UI doesn't even make you aware of that fact. Imo a full discography's price should be reduced proportional to the value of the releases you already own, as is the case for game bundles on Steam, for instance.

A bit of backstory: After being on it for a few years I just cancelled my Spotify subscription in order to move back to my self-hosted music server and there is this one artist whose music I really liked and whose discography I want to buy some day. Their full discography is 25% off on Bandcamp, but to get started I only bought one of their especially good albums because I'm still saving up money for a big vacation and planned to buy the rest of their discography some time later this year with the 25% discount. However, after I bought that one album I realized that the price of their discography didn't go down as I expected, it stayed exactly the same. I really didn't expect to have to pay for that one especially good album twice, but I guess I do since buying their discography on sale is still cheaper than all of their other releases individually

Since I couldn't find a bug report form for bandcamp anywhere, I'm just reporting it here


r/BandCamp • • Jul 14 '26

Discussion Retirement

0 Upvotes

Hello community, i sadly announce the end of my adventure and no more music will be available on bandcamp. I failed but at least i tried, i just wanna thank each everyone who supported me even if they are not too many. Maybe announcing the end of my adventure is not something interesting to all of you but i just wanted to share it with you as i shared my music. God bless you all and i wish to all independent artists success.

I hope my music catalog will stay alive and if it will not it's not gonna matter for me anymore . I love you all even if i don't know you , but you are a real family ❤️

Goodbye and don't forget to remember me with some of my stuff , i'll be missing you .

https://medmc.bandcamp.com/music


r/BandCamp • • Aug 16 '25

Singer-Songwriter Story to my music - NSFW the musical NSFW

Thumbnail
amaraelise.bandcamp.com
3 Upvotes

I made an erotic music video and here are the tracks. It starts with a deep electronic bass with a fast pulse, that quietly and slowly builds. And then my echoey voice whispers - “you there, yes you, you came here for a reason didn’t you? Maybe you don’t even know why - maybe you were just scrolling, searching, or maybe you know exactly what you want. Either way, here we are”

The bass builds as symbols tap. My harmonising voice enters whilst the whispered dialogue repeats.

Drums stop, tension builds Harmonies continue

Whispers stop, harmonies build. Music goes crazy

Harmonies go whacker

Melody drops

We vibing

Whispers come back in as music falls back

Silence encapsulates

A guitar string is tuned And some harmonized vocals after

Anyway - you get the point - you can listen to the whole thing

This was a journey to make. Very expensive hehe Lots of mic nerve

It’s hard when you’re standing with your music producer and he’s like ‘sound sexy’ - some awful takes

It was fun to change genres through. Electronic, singer songwriter vibes, drum & bass

I think that’s all

I hope I piqued your interest


r/BandCamp • • May 02 '26

Discussion What does my Bandcamp library say about me

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/BandCamp • • Feb 14 '24

Question/Help Looking for musicians that are new to me

7 Upvotes

Hi! I tend to listen to the same songs, albums, and artists on loop due to my neurosis (lol), but I want to check out and support more indie musicians. I’m mainly looking for music by Black musicians and other musicians of color, so please share your favorite overlooked/underrated musicians and bands. Thank you in advance! 🎶


r/BandCamp • • Mar 22 '26

Free Download After Viral Dr. Dre Post / Free Single

0 Upvotes

Free quality download 16/44 bit rate as a result of the below... https://smel.bandcamp.com/album/he-makes-his-own-beats

Dr. Dre, 300k views and my New Response  Record

So what had happen was… back on 12/26/25 I brought a well known question among musicians, beat makers and producers about Dr. Dre that has been for decades. Many are curious to know if Dr. Dre can cookup on his own, just him? So, respectfully, I brought the age old question (in hind site, no one had the guts to ask) to my small following on various social media platforms. Well, to my surprise on instagram (out of all of them) the post took off 300k views and still counting. Everyone from Ice Cube, Teddy Ridley, Warren G, Scott Storch, Terry Fly Jam, Quest Love, Dj Toomp, Scarface and so many more legends responded to the post.

The post now is considered a historic hip hop comment thread on instagram. A post that you want to check and save. However, the post for the most part was taken as if I was trollin  Dr. Dre, and that was not the case. It really was directed to musicians and those producers who say beat makers are valueless with a deeper point to say the days of musicianship in beat making is dying with the present attitude about beat makers and the introduction of AI.  

Side note: I really think that post pop, because Legendary DJ Toomp (who follows me) co-signed off on the post and that brought wave of his peers in to rebuttal. I forget sometimes that I have some heavy hitters that follow me on my instagram page. That post only pop on instagram no were else.  

 
The Response

No one answered the question with footage.  The question was not can Dr. Dre play the piano. The question was more about can Dr. Dre (whom we love), can he go into the studio by himself and come out with that heat? Is there any footage of it? 

So many other well known producers have footage of this for the public to observer. We all known people who can play the keys (John Legend can play the keys), but can they go in the studio and make that heat the way many well known beat makers can? 

That question was bring balance to all the trash talking beat makers are getting to these days. The Dr. Dre fans (and some legends) and bots came in like a swarm of bees and attacked for asking the question. It’s crazy that we were are in these times, where people are afraid to investigate and critically think.  

I did pin a post to curve the craziness the post was starting to take, all the name calling and hate, which worked to a great degree. I was very surprise to see how one legendary producer was trying gain clout off the post by making me the bad guy.

However, a beatiful, fun playing creation came out of it!  I hope you enjoy!  And, yeap I made my own beat...LOL


r/BandCamp • • Aug 30 '26

Question/Help Does anybody know how to put on 10+ hour long songs?

1 Upvotes

so, here’s my bandcamp, https://deepnoise.bandcamp.com/music and I have bandcamp pro, I make some really droney sludge music, very very inspired by Nadja, I export my music on Flac file, and I found out my super long song files can still reach over 2 GB large, even in FLAC, I use fl studio for my music but I haven't gotten to the point of my solo bands life yet to where I’m dropping 5-10+ hour long monoliths of songs. I know there are bands who have been able to put out over 10+ hour long songs on bandcamp. and idk how to change the sample rate on fl studio. please give tips.


r/BandCamp • • Feb 03 '26

Discussion Could my music be categorized as AI?

4 Upvotes

I've been making music entirely in Bandlab for several weeks now. I compose everything myself (guitars, bass, keyboards, and drums), but I only use virtual instruments since I don't have all the real ones.

I was inspired by Frank Zappa's album "Civilization Phaze III," especially the creative aspect, where Frank composed and recorded most of the music using the Sinclavier. It's a large project in which I plan to create 250 tracks and release them as weekly EPs of 5 tracks each, once I've finished composing and recording everything.

The intention was to publish my project on Bandcamp once it was finished, but now I have some doubts, especially with the new policies on artificial intelligence.

Is there a risk that my music will be classified as AI? Would it help if I indicated from the beginning how the music was created?