At the end of episode 1 of Ave Mujica, after Nyamu unmasks the band, Uika, the narrator says:
Her secret is revealed under the moon, and the dolls regain their human form. Whether this leads to salvation or to doom, there is no stopping the wheels of fate.
In other words, the show itself raises the question of whether the unmasking is correct. Now, my goal here is not necessarily to convince you that "salvation" is the right answer - the show isn't over yet. (Though I think it is). My goal is to remind people that this is a legitimate and open question, when the atmosphere of the discussion is extremely consumed by the unmasking as a negative thing.
In the first part ( https://www.reddit.com/r/BanGDream/comments/1iqy8ca/nyamu_was_correct_to_unmask_the_band_pt_12_why/ ), I addressed Nyamu's intent. My point was that it was at worst a neutral one - perhaps it was impulsive, perhaps she should have thought more about it, but she had a plausible reasoning for it based on sensible human goals and feelings. In this second part I'll talk about the consequences and thematic meaning of her action.
The argument from realistic consequences
Let me first address a certain school of argument. It basically goes like this: (not a quote, paraphrased)
Nyamu's actions are terrible. They would lead to massive production headaches, clearly violate the privacy of her co-workers. It would have been a disaster to try to improv the show after Nyamu just changes the script. She clearly would have other options to contact the others beforehand and obtain their consent. Also, Sakiko had gotten them this far, which proves that Sakiko's competent and has a plan. Besides, she's just a 15 year old youtuber, what does she know?
Some of these arguments are just factually incorrect. No, Sakiko does not have to change all the scripts, all the lyrics, even rewrite the music of the songs. We see two productions of Ave Mujica before the unmasking, and the scripts do not mention the masks at all. The songs performed are the current form of Ave Mujica and KILLKISS and again, the lyrics do not mention masks. Let alone requiring the rewriting of the music. Sakiko chose to change the scripts to explicitly mention the masks.
Some of these arguments are essentially fanfiction. I mean, okay, maybe Sakiko had a brilliant masterplan and if Nyamu just waited a week things would have been great. Maybe there are additional songs that did mention the masks and need rewriting. I could also write a fanfiction where if Nyamu didn't do anything, things would be far worse, because it would be Sakiko doing the unmasking, leading to Mutsumi feeling doubly betrayed, oops.
These are just nitpicks though. A more significant point with this type of argument is that they apply "realistic" logic to the show instead of working with what is actually shown in the anime. But the show, the universe just isn't that realistic.
This is an universe where MyGO can write TWO songs in an overnighter and perform it the next day. Is adjusting scripts for the absence of masks that much of a problem? This is an universe where during rehearsal time, we can take the lyrics for the "I want to become human song" and invent music to it straight off. Is it that unbelievable that Nyamu can just handle the aftermath of unmasking and make it a successful show? If Chuchu can be a genius producer at 13 who is to say that Nyamu isn't a genius publicist? In the real world, dragging an unwilling girl out of the crowd on to the stage to perform would literally be assault. In the real world, Nyamu would be able to sue Sakiko for contract violation, if "give me the rest of your life" even counts as a conscionable contract in the first place.
Realistically, the unmasking is not a problem for Ave Mujica as a production because they can just put the masks back on. The fact they took off the mask doing one production doesn't mean the masks are permanently off, they can just add the unmasking as a scene at the end of each show, or imply the unmasking is just a special thing they do for special concerts. Realistically there's no way a 15 year old unknown would be writing scripts AND songs AND staging for a Bokudan production, so if rewriting the scripts is a pain for Sakiko she can just delegate the other tasks.
But despite all this, this isn't really a rebuttal of the realism arguments. I'm not saying my realism is better than yours. Rather, this is an appeal to recognise such arguments for what they are - a matter of pure vibes.
For you, it may be unbelievable that Nyamu can't just simply ask the other members for consent, that it's irredeemable that she failed to take such a simple step. For me, it's perfectly believable as an element of a hostile work environment where someone feels shut out because 3/5 members are a lot closer than the remaining 2/5 and are actively taking steps to marginalise the rest. (This is especially the case if you realise that Nyamu has to mask her normal speaking accent around the other band members which already puts her at a disadvantage when it comes to communication.) For you, success might dictate the trustworthiness of a boss and hence the need for the staff to obey, for me success means nothing of the sort, rather success means an organisation should have more latitude to address the needs of their employees. For me, ultimate responsibility for these issues lies with the boss, who has the duty to inform and train staff to avoid these problems. If a 15 year old employee doesn't get any "working with vulnerable people" training and then fucks up, it's HR's fault. Time to unionise, band girls!!
Ultimately these arguments are about our personal backgrounds and how we see the world, and what we are willing to handwave. So I don't think these arguments are fundamentally productive. It's just the route to a political argument which will never be settled.
I think that it's better to look at what is actually in the show, what the show chooses to show you to be the consequences of Nyamu's actions. Yes, in the real world things might be different and we can argue our political differences all day. But if we limit the question to is Nyamu correct in the story, it's something more amenable to debate and itself useful, since it lets us answer questions like the one posed by the narrator above. Let us engage with the story as a story.
In terms of the effect of the unmasking, there's basically two main people the action is shown to affect in the show - Mutsumi and Sakiko. Umiri doesn't care (characteristically), and Uika says she's fine with it. (Maybe she's not fine with it, who knows, let's wait and see)
Mutsumi breaks...
The most dramatic effect Nyamu's unmasking had on anyone is poor Mutsumi. The common narrative goes like this, basically:
Mutsumi's shy, with a complex about her parents. By unmasking her, Nyamu directed the eye of global fame on to Mutsumi. Thus, the unmasking was the precipitating event that led to Mutsumi's breakdown, both at the end of episode 2 and episode 3. Which is bad, actually.
The evidence for this looks pretty clear. In episode 1, Sakiko says "Mortis is a bit shy". Mutsumi looks pretty freaked out at the start of episode 2. Taki further primes us with
Taki: Besides, Mutsumi hates it when people make a fuss about her parents.
Mutsumi does indeed react negatively when her parents are mentioned. We even get the line in Minami-chan's movie, skilfully translated as
Minami: Why are you suddenly doting on the child you ignored all this time?
And we get the scene at the start of episode 3 of Mutsumi thinking none of the praise belong to her.
The easy, boring counterargument here is that well, this doesn't mean the breakdowns are inevitable. It was Sakiko's (and Umiri, but Sakiko actually knows Mutsumi, so she should have done something) decision to give Mutsumi a heavy workload. This workload, including a job directly before the first concert of the tour, caused Mutsumi to miss a rehearsal and go into the show in a clearly stressed state, leading to her to make a mistake and thus have her first breakdown. During this period, Uika is shown looking at Mutsumi trembling after the show and says nothing. Nyamu actually points out:
Nyamu: By the way, Muuko seems to have the most work to do~
There were lots of steps the issue could have been averted.
Mutsumi's second breakdown is caused by a combination of factors. Nyamu's wrong-headed idea that Mutsumi's career interests would be best served by recreating the "mistake" (the reason for this is because Nyamu projects herself on to Mutsumi. She imagines that if she had the talent Mutsumi had, she would want an opportunity to display it) is one aspect. That said, this only arose because Sakiko lied to the agency claiming that the breakdown was intended all along. In the story, Sakiko freaking out at Mutsumi and saying she isn't on her side is the more key incident.
At the end of the day, we get three people who offer explanations of who was to blame:
Mortis: I hate you, Sakiko
Sakiko: It's all because I relied on you too much
Taki: Mujica abandoned her
I don't actually want to push the blame on to Sakiko, Sakiko's self-hatred is a whoooole thing, and Mortis is not an objective observer. Of the three perspectives, in my view, the show wants us to agree with Taki's. In stark contrast to the sensitivity of MyGO, Ave Mujica was a ruthless badger-hole where no one looked out for each other. All the members had a part in this to some extent. I could point out the few times Nyamu acted in Mutsumi's interest, most notably pushing for the band to disband, but frankly this is splitting hairs. What is important is what is blatantly lacking in the show: anyone that ascribes *special blame* to Nyamu. There isn't a single part of Mutsumi/Mortis that blames her. When Nyamu pushes for disbanding, Mortis is actually surprised:
Mortis: Why, why would you be mean to me?
The show and the characters in the show just doesn't want us to blame Nyamu in particular for this.
But I'm not actually arguing that "Nyamu's unmasking is only an element in the toxic stew that is Mujica". I'm arguing Nyamu's unmasking is correct. So let's go deeper.
Mutsumi's true problem
There's a few things odd about the picture we have of Mutsumi. Firstly, I was being sarcastic about Bushiroad's "skilful translation". That line in the movie (今まで放っておいて ノコノコと) doesn't say anything about doting on a child at all. Here's Loftmoon's translation:
Minami: Why?! You run off from me for so long and come back like nothing happened...
Here's the next issue:
Soyo: You're related to Wakaba, the comedian, right...?
Mutsumi nods
Sakiko: Oh you knew?
Soyo: You used to appear on TV shows a lot, right? Those shows about the celebrity families.
Mutsumi: …
Soyo: Oh I'm sorry, I probably shouldn't have brought that up.
Mutsumi shakes her head
Soyo: (thinking) I wonder what's on her mind...
This is from "Swaying in the Rain, Looking for the Sunshine", the MyGO manga. CRYCHIC-era Mutsumi appears annoyed by people talking about her parents but only to a mild extent . Now, we can raise the question of the canonicity of the manga, but the essential points I want to raise here are in the show too.
Mutsumi had no problem performing unmasked in CRYCHIC
Mutsumi at some point in the past appeared on TV, recently enough that she could be recognised by appearance and this wasn't really a problem for her
Indeed as of MyGO there's little sign of Mutsumi being anxious and requiring a mask. Sakiko never connects the need for a mask to Mutsumi, when she lays into Nyamu after the unmasking, she says:
Sakiko: But the band first needs a solid foundation—
Sakiko: It's the haste I don't like.
Sakiko: It defeats the entire point of masks.
Sakiko: It might even affect Sumimi's activities.
Mutsumi is notable by her absence!
During the events of episode 2 Sakiko piles Mutsumi high with publicity jobs to advertise for the tour (again because Uika is too busy, Sakiko's minimalization of Uika's role is pretty interesting, but I have no idea what it means) Now, one might say this is just the hand of the writer absolving Nyamu from blame and making a point that Sakiko's a bad friend, but I actually want defend Sakiko here and argue that she isn't as evil as all that. Her crime is not paying enough attention, it's not "knowingly selling her mentally vulnerable friend out for clout". If we take Sakiko's actions as even slightly non-crazy-evil, we would require that Sakiko genuinely thought Mutsumi facing the cameras is somewhat tolerable.
Then there's another thing, Mutsumi is also in the room during the conversation between Nyamu and Sakiko about unmasking in episode one. Watch it carefully, paying attention to Mutsumi's reaction.
What do you notice? Well, when Nyamu says "Daughter of the great comedian Wakaba and the star actress Minami Mori", in the next shot, just before Nyamu blocks Mutsumi's face, we see... no reaction at all. It's not like they forgot to animate her - in that entire scene, Mutsumi reacts exactly once, and it's to this line:
Nyamu: The world is cruel and they might get bored if you keep messing around.
What do all these points add up to? We can't deny Mutsumi's familial issues (especially since they seem about to come up again in ep 8) but what they look like is only a part of what's stressing Mutsumi out. What causes Mutsumi's acute levels of stress is something different, something new. Something we get told by Mutsumi over and over again:
Mortis: Mutsumi-chan didn't want to ruin the band...
Mutsumi: Whenever I speak up, I ruin everything.
Tomori: Mutsumi said that because CRYCHIC failed, she'll do her best.
It really comes down to this, caused by the trauma of CRYCHIC. Yes, the unmasking, the family stuff all boosted the issue, but they did it by exposing Mutsumi more, and creating more avenues for Mutsumi to mess up the band, emphasising Mutsumi's feeling of inadequacy. The crux of the parents issue is that "none of the praise belonged to Mutsumi" but Mutsumi tolerates the denial of the self. During the Ave Mujica performance at the end of MyGO, there is this scene:
Uika: Discarded… dolls?
Umiri: Oh, are you the type who has no self-awareness?
Nyamu: Yes, that type! The ones spoken to by humans, and so they think they’re the same.
Throughout the scene the camera rests squarely on the motionless form of Mutsumi. She does not speak. She has two lines in the entire play and almost no lines in Ave Mujica up until Mortis emerges. In the play, her lines are:
Mutsumi: I am Mortis, I do not fear death
And also, how does a doll die, Mutsumi?
Mutsumi: To not be loved.
Mutsumi's stress is about her overwhelming dread of letting down Mujica and Sakiko and causing its and her ruin, a dread induced by her own perceived role in causing the end of CRYCHIC. What is the thing that finally (in ep 7) allows Mortis to let Sakiko in to meet Mutsumi?
Sakiko: To Mutsumi, CRYCHIC was a precious treasure.
Hopefully this was somewhat convincing. But hey, you might ask, what does this change, why does this make the unmasking good? What it changes is what Mutsumi needs to address her problem.
Doctor's orders
If parents alone was Mutsumi's issue, one might credibly argue that performing under masks, Ave Mujica as a safe refuge, all of that is good for Mutsumi. Maybe Mutsumi's parental stuff could be solved in the background somehow.
But if the overwhelming fear of failure and absence of love is the true problem, then what does Mutsumi need? Let's look at what the show gives her:
Friends (Soyo, Raana, and eventually Sakiko) who do not view their relationship as dependent on Mutsumi performing some kind of service
Reconciliation and closure on CRYCHIC. People firmly telling Mutsumi CRYCHIC was not her fault
Mortis
I'm going to go out on a limb here since the series isn't done (well, it's not like I haven't been doing that so far), but I think Mortis is good for Mutsumi. Mortis is essentially the antithesis of Mutsumi's problems.
While Mutsumi is hypersensitive to failure, Mortis moves fast and breaks things and doesn't feel bad about it at all. While Mutsumi subsumes her own desires to those of Sakiko, Mortis is 100% clear that Mutsumi comes first and is damn assertive about it. While Mutsumi is fixated on originality, Mortis embraces imitation, a collage of Mutsumi's experiences.
Mutsumi: I am Mortis, I do not fear death
Mortis: Thank goodness! I thought you had really died!
At this point the realism-folks might be pretty mad. Like, am I really saying Mutsumi having a mental breakdown is a good thing? Yes, alas, I am. Ideally of course she would get therapy, but in anime-world there are no therapists (except Anon, lol). What we are seeing with Mutsumi's breakdowns is also a breakthrough. Let me point out to the realism folks that there's many people with DID that do not consider their alters to be a negative thing.
But if we go back from the real world to the world of the story, well... Of course, I don't know if the show intends for Mortis to integrate with Mutsumi, or for Mortis to be accepted and stay around (I prefer this) but Mortis in the story represents things Mutsumi needs. The imagery that we see with Mutsumi's breakdowns are scary, but they are not entirely negative.
Nyamu: I knew there were no strings.
Nyamu: But I saw them pulled tight and then snap.
Uika/Narrator: Is this sleep, or is it death?
Uika/Narrator: At least, it may be peace.
Is it truly bad for a puppet (language note: doll and puppet are the same word in Japanese, 人形) to snap its strings? Is sleep, peace, that terrible of a thing? Yes, the show's using horror imagery. But they've tricked us with that a lot, haven't they?
When Anon reads Tomori's lyrics, "the song about wanting to become human", she gives Mutsumi her guitar, telling her to play it. It wasn't that they decided to play it, they needed a guitar and then Anon nominated Mutsumi. The five CRYCHIC players all play "I want to become human" together. All of them want to become human in their own way.
Soyo laughs at the lyrics because back in the Crychic manga she looked at an earlier version of the same song and was scared by them, but now she embraces the idea that you can be a many-faceted human being. Taki finally managed to admit she's kind of a dick. Sakiko and Tomori, well, that's spelled out. Mutsumi is part of this group.
What Mutsumi needs, what Mutsumi wants is to become human.
Let me also point out what playing with Crychic also does for Mutsumi. It's a performance that is objectively bad. But afterwards, everyone agrees it's a great experience, Anon even praises Mutsumi directly. Do you see how important it is for Mutsumi? Mutsumi needs to learn this lesson from Mortis - it's okay to make mistakes.
Could all of this have happened without the unmasking? Can we credibly argue this? I don't really think so. Not coherently, anyway. It's precisely the failure of Ave Mujica that got MyGO moving, precisely Sakiko answering Tomori's "are you happy" note with a decisive "STOP", Soyo seeing google search results suggesting Mutsumi died. The start of Sakiko's turnaround comes out of Mutsumi doing the specific thing she was most afraid of - hurting Sakiko.
If we're arguing Ave Mujica would have continued as they are without the unmasking, then we are arguing that Mutsumi will just have to continue playing perfectly, never making a mistake, hoping nothing else goes wrong, her fears that Nyamu might be right about "people will get bored of Mujica" never coming to pass, that Umiri's premonition that "it'll all fall apart eventually" never comes true, that whatever is going on with Uika isn't going to create a crisis, that when Nyamu does get pissed off enough to leave the band it wouldn't trigger Uika's "if one member leaves that's the same as disbanding", that 15 year old child Sakiko is just going to sleep in the office forever, and that nothing will ever go wrong because Mutsumi will inevitably blame herself if it does. And in the middle of that somehow all the positive things will happen?
Remember Uika-as-narrator's line about the unmasking again:
人形たちは人間の姿を取り戻す the dolls regain their human form
Did you know that this is actually a pun in Japanese? 人 = person and 形 = form. Person-form becomes human form again. I can't help but think this is deliberate. The thing, the doll, is deconstructed into its basic elements, and pointed directly to its connection with 人間, human beings. The dolls of Ave Mujica have always been human shaped, a mask doesn't change that at all, so Uika's statement is absurd on its face. But what the narration is doing is more metaphorical. What I think the narration is doing is that it directly ties unmasking to the transformation from dolls towards humanity.
If dolls are bad and becoming human is good, and Mutsumi wants to become human... then this is a step that must be taken. A painful step, no doubt.
But a necessary one.
To sum up, I'm saying the unmasking is good because it has good consequences for Mutsumi that are directly tied to it in the narrative, narratively and thematically. Perhaps you aren't fully satisfied. Like, I think you probably can believe that Mutsumi will be in a better place at the end, but like, is the haste really necessary? Maybe we could have done this more gently, slower somehow, without creating a crisis, without breaking Mutsumi, without breaking Ave Mujica.
I could just say "well, that would be a boring show". That feels a bit cowardly, to leave it to narrative convenience in the end. Besides, I haven't addressed Sakiko at all. Have I really made a persuasive point that within the story, "breaking" can be actually a good thing?
Fuck it, I'm going to do a third part of this.
Next time, Mujica delenda est