There is a phrase that circulates here and the world at large: "I don't owe other people anything". Not only is this literally untrue -- the entirety of tort law hinges on duties that civil society owes you -- but it is philosophically stupid. Actually, we do owe other people stuff! I am going to explain it to you.
THE BIGGEST CAVEAT, PLEASE READ THIS PART THREE OR FOUR TIMES BEFORE YOU POST SOMETHING DEMENTED: I am not talking about abusive situations. An abusive situation is one in which Person A in a position of power over Person B and uses harmful behavior to try and control Person B. Even if a situation is not abusive by these definitions, it can be deeply unpleasant and painful. Many of us have extracted ourselves from painful situations with less than the perfect amount of grace. So be it! This is not about toxic one-off situations. It is about how we generally relate to one another. For more on things like boundaries, please read "Are All Boundaries Valid?". (Spoiler: yes, though some boundaries are not conducive to healthy relationships, and some people with shitty boundaries should not be in charge of groups/communities/other people.)
The social aspects of roleplaying are challenging. Generally speaking, you are basically on a kind of dating circuit, constantly meeting and talking to strangers and trying to arrange a collaborative interaction. Strangers are -- it's in the word -- strange. They can be awkward, hostile, needy, and boring. They can also be interesting, charming, funny, and kind. We spend time trying to get away from the less pleasant people; we also spend time trying to impress or connect with the people we like. This can be anxiety-inducing, socially exhausting, and full of disappointments, just like dating. Some of us here even try to run roleplay groups! Now there's a whole new can of worms -- trying to manage a whole community of strangers. Sheesh!
On top of the inherently challenging social aspects, roleplaying attracts a bunch of freaks. (I will not argue this point. You are a freak if you are reading this. Congratulations.) These freaks are prone to being anxious, depressed, insecure, aggressive, competitive, horny, and socially awkward. It is hard enough to succeed at social activities. Online roleplay communities have the vibe of making a bunch of drunk raccoons try to run dog agility courses. This sub is full of people being shocked by the most banal of social snafus and then committing them endlessly.
So what does all this yield? Well, one of the things it yields is that phrase, "I don't owe anyone anything," mostly in regards to behavior like ghosting ("I don't owe anyone a polite goodbye"), compromise ("I don't owe anyone doubling/changes to my desired plots/etc."), and moderation ("I don't owe anyone basic civic justice"). Because people deliberately or accidentally confuse this with the concept that you should not stay in an abusive relationship ("I don't owe anyone the denigration of my human spirit, physical body, or financial well-being"), this phrase is repeated unquestioned and applauded when it gets trotted out.
But you are wrong! You do owe people shit! In the real world, for example, you owe people shit like not hitting their car. If you hit someone in a car and injure them, you owe them the damages to their car and some amount of money for their injuries. If you tell a bunch of lies about a person and get them fired, you owe them money for defaming them. On an interpersonal level, we owe people the equitable treatment we want to receive. Before we act, we should consider how we would want to be treated. No, like, seriously -- people are like "oh, but I would never [insert asshole behavior], therefore it is beneath me to consider what I would want in this situation." No! No! You are an asshole in a variety of ways yourself, I promise you, and since you are a roleplayer, you need to exercise a little imagination and empathy and compose a psychic parallel, and then consider what kind of call-out or rejection you would want if you were showing your whole ass.
Why is ghosting bad? Because in all but the worst cases, you can politely tell someone to fuck off, interview-rejection style. "Thank you for your message, but it doesn't look like we're compatible. Good luck!" Even if they yell at you, you can block them and you will not die. Most people won't even yell at you; the insistence on ghosting to avoid the one-offs is people reifying their own anxious habits.
Why is not compromising bad? Because we're all here wanting different things, and unless you come across someone who magically wants the exact same thing you want, some flexibility will be required. Hyper-specific desires and self-centered fantasies will, at best, gain less traction, and will, at worst, shaft someone with writing something that you should create as your own fanfiction.
Why is shitty moderation bad? Because even in the smallest of situations, we all want to feel like our interactions with other people operate by standards of fairness and justice. "But this is just my tiny group!" you say. "Why do I have to hold myself to a standard beyond my own convenience and whimsy? It's hard!" I don't care! You're the one who decided to create a community! You have duties now! If you want to run a friend group chat, where everyone is equal to you and you know everyone personally and thereby like them, you can do that. Then you don't have power over anyone. But by creating a community, you have created a hierarchy where you have power over others, and you absolutely have the obligation to exercise that power with fairness and kindness. I do not care if this is not your day job. You gave yourself a job. Stop demanding the right to do a shit job just because you made the job up.
It is hard to be kind and respectful to people all the time, especially to strangers. See above: they can be really annoying. Sometimes we even know enough about someone to personally dislike them. Oh well! Too bad! Do you want to live in a world that is driven by unkind and selfish whims? Does that sound fun to you? If it doesn't, then it depends on each of us individually to hold ourselves to a higher standard of behavior, one where we give a shit about the feelings and experiences of other people. You do not have to agree to every roleplay, give up on all your own ideas, or become a doormat for your community. You do not need to become an all-out people-pleaser to grant people some respect, flexibility, and fairness.
The idea that you owe people things can only be applied case by case, where you take a moment to simply consider the feelings of another person and remind yourself that they are just as human as you are. Even the most annoying, grossest, criminal, selfish person is still a human being. A good place to start with what you owe is this: what treatment makes you feel respected and considered, even if you disagree with an outcome? Even if someone dislikes you, what is the baseline of civil behavior you want and expect? If you were behaving badly, how would you want someone to intervene with you? For moderators: when you have had to work under an authority figure -- a teacher, a professor, a supervisor -- how have you wanted them to treat you? What exercises of their power or influence felt fair or helpful, and what exercises felt targeted, unfair, or selfish?
I can already feel the waves of fury this will generate, because everyone feels personally justified in their right to be shitty to other people, but loves to be a complainer when someone else is shitty to them. It is what it is. I cannot personally reach through this screen and make you a better person. Only you can do that. Start with the idea that you owe other people things beyond your most selfish, self-protective behavior, and figure it out.
Edit: in my one and only addendum, please read this rebuttal to the proposed 'paradox of tolerance' that was insincerely posed here.