FYI There’s a TL:DR example at the bottom.
I’ve seen so many clips of people explaining how BttF’s time travel mechanics don’t work because old Biff shouldn’t have been able to return to the future AFTER changing things in the past.
But I wonder if those same people who think this have forgotten one of the most essential elements of the films;
The pictures within newspapers and Polaroids changing depending on the minute to minute actions of the time travelers.
Let me explain:
Some people seem to believe the mechanics should work like this;
Marty lives in a present 1985 where Biff never became a rich asshole.
Old Biff goes to the past, hands young Biff the Almanac, now immediately middle-aged Biff becomes a wealthy man, and when old Biff returns to his timeline to an altered 2015, the timeline should be altered.
In reality the Polaroids and newspapers prove that the mechanics work like this;
Whatever has been set in your past is how it was meant to be.
When you travel to the past, you’re not changing things automatically.
If you disrupt how your parents meet, and you look at the picture of your brother, sister and you, the three of you have begun to incrementally erase from existence.
At this point you have however long it takes until the maximum timeframe is reached where there is no going back, such as the enchantment under the sea dance, to change this back.
If you choose to go back to the future at the moment your siblings begin to change, you disappear on your way back because you forwent reaching that farthest point of no return to save yourself.
You simply accepted that fate that you’d be erased from existence.
So essentially the things changing in these pictures is dependent on you being in that timeline. And the pictures can change moment to moment as you change things moment to moment.
So when Biff went back in time and gave himself the almanac, up until that point, young Biff had not made the ultimate decision to use the Almanac yet.
Had old Biff had a picture of himself in the future, the picture would look the same because in reality nothing had been changed in his past yet.
The event changing moment for young Biff was when he listening to the UCLA vs Washington College football game.
It was at this moment that the time limit would have started for Biff.
Had old Biff given young Biff the Almanac at that moment, that’s when his picture would have appeared different.
Had old Biff travelled to 2015 then, he would have gone to a future where he was rich and powerful.
This is what happened to Marty when he altered his timeline. He stayed all the way through to the moment where his existence was assured, but also where his father gained confidence. That moment became set in stone when he pushes the guy dancing with Loraine and kisses her. Any moment after that, Marty would always go home to a changed timeline where everything is awesome.
Had old Biff stayed in 1955 after the moment young Biff listened to the game, were he so inclined, Old Biff would have had all the way up until young Biff made his first bet to stop that timeline from happening.
So;
Old Biff left BEFORE the catalyst event: The UCLA/Wash College game. So he returned to his 2015.
Had he left AFTER young Biff listened to that college Game, he would have arrived as himself but in a changed timeline.
Time is extremely malleable to your presence and the presence of others in the timeline and that’s proven most of all in BttF 3, where the headstone picture is changing minute to minute as events unfold around the people responsible.
TL;DR Example:
If you and I went back in time and both told our younger selves to play the lottery, with no proof, most likely nothing would happen.
We would return to our original futures.
If we both show proof to our younger selves by telling them the winning numbers the week before?
That would be the beginning of our time limit to change things. We would have one week.
If we leave anytime before the end of that week?
Our timelines would reflect the change.
If you left back to the future and I stayed? You would go back to a changed timeline where we won the lottery.
If I then took that week to stop younger us from playing those number?
I would go back to the original timeline.
It’s all malleable and dependent on the minute to minute actions of the last person out of the timeline.