r/BSG • • Aug 10 '26

No matter how hard I try, I can't like The Expanse TV show

0 Upvotes

I'm a massive BSG fan, and people have told me for years that I have to watch The Expanse, that it's the greatest sci-fi show ever made. Twice in the past I've tried to watch it, gotten 6-7 episodes in, and lost interest. I recently decided to read the books, and they're incredible, some of the best sci-fi novels I've ever read, so I thought I'd give the show another try. Maybe I was just in the wrong headspace previously.

Well, I'm 6 episodes in and this show is just... bad. Lots of weird or stiff acting. A slew of unlikeable characters (I don't want to root for any of these assholes). Sets that feel like sets, not real places. Practically every scene I'm just annoyed, having recently read the books, by how far off the show is from what I had imagined reading the books. Those characters in the books are likeable... who are these characters in the show?

I'm baffled by the nearly universal praise of this show. What show are these people watching? Am I insane? Am i just spoiled by the ridiculous quality of BSG and somehow people have forgotten how good sci-fi can be?


r/BSG • • Mar 04 '25

Am I the only one who finds Starbuck annoying?

2 Upvotes

I mean she's just awful.


r/BSG • • Feb 22 '25

I love this show so much. IMO, it's one of the best shows ever made, but can we just take a moment for female fans to sound off on what plotlines feel the most r/menwritingwomen

46 Upvotes

Just keep scrolling if you're not a woman who loves BSG in spite of the r/menwrittingwomen moments.

I love this show, but the Leoban/Starbuck plotline is hard to swallow. Why does our most badass female character have to go through the farm, and the dollhouse on New Caprica, and her special destiny being tied to the man who manipulated her, gaslighted her, kidnapped her? I hate that this disgusting creep is central to her finding her purpose. I don't care that he's a Cylon. It would be fine for her to have a Cylon involved in Kara Thrace and her Special Destiny, just not the one Cylon who is a miserable incel creep trying to force a woman to love him and sleep with him. Gross. Gross. Gross. Men writing women.


r/BSG • • Dec 01 '24

It takes a certain kind of man to pull off a mustache, as much as I love him he is not one of those men.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Just no!


r/BSG • • May 18 '24

When does Adama learn to use the One Power and when does Rand al'Thor meet his first Cylon?

3 Upvotes

sulky hungry pen scale silky scary axiomatic cable adjoining insurance

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/BSG • • Dec 31 '16

I just watched the finale of BSG and I think it should be renamed to 'Battlestar Plothole'

6 Upvotes

I loved this series and it's concept and it's story from the beginning on, but at the end there are just way too many plotholes (or plotholes being filled with very weak "IT WAS GOD ALL THE TIME"-filler)

What the hell happened to Starbuck?! She died, suddenly popped up again, went to earth in the meantime, and then, on the last episode, she just vanishes to thin air? honestly?! Without leaving any explanation? That's ridiculously bad writing.

Who or what the hell was that Six who Gaius saw through all of the series? And don't say 'angels' ...

George R.R. Martin found the perfect words:

"Battlestar Galactica ends with 'God Did It.' Looks like somebody skipped Writing 101, when you learn that a deus ex machina is a crappy way to end a story... Yeah, yeah, sometimes the journey is its own reward. I certainly enjoyed much of the journey with BSG... But damn it, doesn't anybody know how to write an ending any more? Writing 101, kids. Adam and Eve, God Did It, It Was All a Dream? I've seen Clarion students left stunned and bleeding for turning in stories with those endings."

EDIT: Yeah guys, it's not that I don't get it that ghost-Six and ghost-Gaius are 'angels'. My point is that this explanation is a no-no of story-telling. This is a rhetorical question and actually a rant, get it?


r/BSG • • Dec 18 '22

BeastStar Galactica: the music JUST WORKS

5 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Oct 25 '23

Dr Gaius Baltar makes the show frustrating to the point of unwatchable NSFW Spoiler

7 Upvotes

He's manipulated, caused the problem, and continues to be manipulated despite everything. The worst part? He won't expose the Cylons, despite having info – illogical given his self-interest and past attack on his lab.

If it was someone of less intelligence I would believe it somewhat. He has no capacity for self reflection which most smart individuals have. No paranoia that he might get fucked over by the women who started all of this again. Like what the fuck!


r/BSG • • Oct 03 '24

Helo was wrong and should have been executed.

0 Upvotes

In S3, the humans find a disease that will kill only Cylons, and have a way of spreading it throughout the entire Cylon race (uploading an infected Cylon into a Resurrection ship). Helo says "that's genocide" and sabotages the plan by killing the Cylons before they are in range to get uploaded.

The only evidence that Helo has about Cylons being good is his wife Boomer/Athena. EVERYTHING SINGLE OTHER CYLON IS CONSISTENTLY ATTEMPTING TO KILL OR ENSLAVE ALL HUMANS. Every single time a Cylon fleet jumps into range of the human fleet, the Cylons are ATTEMPTING A GENOCIDE. Hell, the Cylon’s ALREADY COMMITTED GENOCIDE when they nuked the colonies. There is no sign that the Cylons are willing to stop either. In fact, right at the same time, we learn the Cylons are also trying to find Earth and claim it for themselves, thereby causing more conflict with humans. There is no evidence that the Cylons will stop chasing the humans. There is no evidence that the Cylons will not stop TRYING TO GENOCIDE ALL HUMANS. In fact, the Cylons make it clear that they believe they MUST kill all humans since humans will always seek revenge.

For the purposes of the story, I get why they needed Helo to stop the plan. But this is utterly baffling and makes no sense. They started summarily executing people who joined the human police force on New Caprica. Helo should have been thrown out the airlock, after being tortured, for sabotaging this plan. He commits the greatest betrayal to the human race in the entire show.


r/BSG • • Jun 21 '24

9/11 and frakking insurgents.

0 Upvotes

"Frakking insurgents." is a line delivered by Leoben in the opening episode of the third season, Occupation.

This word was in common usage when the episode was broadcast in 2006, during the Occupation or Iraq during the height of the War on Terror, which the New Caprica arc references and comments on heavily.

The 'insurgents' Leoben refers to are the colonial resistance movement, carrying out guerilla attacks against the occupying force, the Cylons. The Cylons say they are there to 'help' humanity, even through initially subjugating them.

This is directly comparable to the Occupation of Iraq, which was part of the War on Terror, which was a direct result of 9/11.

Further, the colonials using suicide bombers to kill Cylons and indigenous, Cylon trained police forces is another direct comparison.

As a personal ancedote, its was chilling to head Leoben use this phrase casually on broadcast, as it was a very clear indication, with a single word, that BSG was 'going there' in regards to the Occupation of Iraq, nevermind that it then used the Cylons as the Coalition forces and 'our heroes' as suicide bombers that the audience is on the side of. Genuinely there was no other show at the time being so On Point.


r/BSG • • Mar 15 '13

Starbuck's gonna steal your grandma's style (OC)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Oct 14 '23

Roslin's presidential oath - was she even the president?

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm just starting a re-watch of the series and for the first time I noticed that Laura Roslin made a mistake while taking the presidential oath. She said she "accepted" the office but the priest says "that I take the office". Now it might be even deliberate on her part - that she doesn't want to "take" it because she doesn't really want it and instead she just accepts that she has no other choice. But IIRC Barack Obama had to take the oath again in private after making a mistake while taking it publicly to become a president.

So Roslin maybe even wasn't a president of the twelve colonies in a legal sense. Yeah, others have surely found this before me. I just like how I can find new things each time I watch the show!


r/BSG • • Nov 06 '24

OK hear me out… Hugh Grant to play Admiral Adama in the BSG reboot!

Post image
0 Upvotes

I mean I’m definitely getting EJO vibes from his new movie poster! Any other (terrible) casting suggestions you’d like to share?


r/BSG • • May 13 '18

Uh oh

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Nov 06 '22

Lee, REALLY subtle with your symbolism there (S2E16)

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Jun 18 '25

Starbuck wants to rip Baltar’s head off. Any theories on how the Cylons found them? Was it because of the Chief and the Colonel, or was the other Sharon still there? Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Jun 09 '24

Amused by frontal nudity in "The Plan"

4 Upvotes

I had not seen The Plan before so it's new to me, after a 12+y rewatch of the main series.

What made me laugh is when I saw the scene (in the Picon strip bar) I thought [to the extent that anyone was waiting for or would have relished any particular nudity in the BSG universe]: "after 4 seasons of the regular series, This is Not the Nudity were waiting for..."

I not going to say I was disappointed, of course. It didn't occur to me that the rating might differ from the main series, so I wasn't anticipating anything leading to me being let down. But to the degree that if there was something specific that fans would have wanted along those lines, it would surely have been to see 8, 6, and 3.

I mean, c'mon. 8 earned an special mention for her form from Cavill, for goodness sake. I'm sure "They're real, and they're spectacular." Not sure if we ever saw 3 in all her glory during Xena, but if not, people have been waiting.

Again, I'm not saying I'm disappointed, but ... if you're not going to give the people the main event, why even include the undercard?


r/BSG • • Mar 18 '24

Who was the most beautiful/attractive person on the show?

0 Upvotes

The show had a lot of good looking actors. In your opinion, who was the hottest/most attractive?


r/BSG • • Jan 02 '24

The Gallifrey Gals have started watching BSG!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Apr 18 '24

I'm a massive BSG fan and just found out Felix is gay. Like i'm gay myself so i'm kinda happy to finally have some lgbt representation in this show. I just started the web series, but this should have been in the main series, like it has fluff in it so there is space (20 ep seasons be like that).

Thumbnail
gallery
148 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Sep 02 '12

Someone told me that my daughter looks like a tiny starbuck. What do y'all think?

Post image
38 Upvotes

r/BSG • • Feb 10 '25

S02E20 Did Adama get the glasses/false nose/moustache combo from a children's cereal pack from the 1970s? Lol

Post image
1 Upvotes

Please, please tell me he doesn't start smoking cigars like Starbuck. Then he'd look like Groucho Marx (okay the stash is the wrong shape but still). I'm actually having trouble watching without laughing.


r/BSG • • Apr 19 '23

Jesus, that Finale.

6 Upvotes

I've watched this entire series, back to back to back, four times since it aired, and I never cease to be confounded and disappointed at how it ends. No, not because it's silly and fluffy and doesn't really make any sense, although that's true as well. I'm not going to get into a nitpick fest about what I would have done if I were Adama. If he wants to spend his twilight years overseeing the systematic abduction and rape of cavemen, that's on him I guess.

No, my main beef is literally just the way that they "end" the Cylon War. The central, defining conflict of this series is a four year running gunfight across the universe, with the literal survival of the human race hanging in the balance. And it ends in five seconds because Tyrol had a temper tantrum and can't stop hitting women.

I'm sorry, but it just seems like a very perfunctory and bizarre way to end things. The Cylons deserved a better send-off than that.


r/BSG • • Feb 02 '23

What is the difference between star trek and battlestar galactica?

0 Upvotes