r/BSD • • Sep 21 '12

BSD-based Open Source Desktop Solution.

Hi reddit.

Without beating around the bush, a question: would there be any interest in a BSD-based Open Source Desktop OS? Not anything like PC-BSD, more like OSX (except completely based on BSD).

1 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

12

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12

Not anything like PC-BSD

You'd have to explain this some more.

0

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

PC-BSD is a BSD distro with X+KDE on top it, as far as I understand, not really a "desktop solution". As much as I'd love to concentrate on better bigger things (beer brewing, wine making, surfing, traveling, and other forms of fucking off work), I'd love to see a solution that is elegant, easy to use, is not windows, is not under control of a fascist regime like Apple, Inc., and is OSS.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12

I mean I know there are issues with the X architecture, but how is X+KDE not a desktop solution? In what way is it inelegant or difficult to use? What are features you would want to see?

-1

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

Not a discussion about usability of KDE and drawbacks of X. Everything else is somewhere in this thread.

5

u/Axman6 Sep 22 '12

No one has any idea what you're talking about and what problems you have with X, and this is what they're trying to find out. You're making this all very hard for everyone by not giving details of what you want.

1

u/fsckit Sep 22 '12

He wants to clone OSX, basically.

3

u/puffybaba Sep 22 '12 edited Sep 22 '12

Actually, PC-BSD has options in the installer which allow other desktop configurations, if you so desire. For example, you could install with no DE at all, and then install X and fluxbox from the commandline, if that's your thing. Personally, I think fluxbox is the bees knees. Other people swear by tiling wms - FreeBSD has i3, one of the best tiling WMs, in ports.

Tangentially, the commandline interface is not as unfriendly as you might think. Here's a nice article: http://www.terminally-incoherent.com/blog/2012/05/30/command-line-and-user-friendliness/

Finally, there are about a zillion different linux-based desktop OSes that serve many people well, and I suspect that you might like Ubuntu if you gave it a try.

5

u/Atticus83 Sep 21 '12

If you are talking about creating desktop software that is built for the BSDs, rather than just creating a desktop-centric BSD distro using existing GUI software, then yes.

2

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

That is exactly it.

4

u/fsckit Sep 21 '12

I'd like to see an Amiga-like desktop sat on top of Dragonfly BSD.

1

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

That would be interesting in purely academic context but hardly usable, no?

3

u/fsckit Sep 21 '12

I don't mean to run Amiga programs, I mean that it behaves like the Amiga Workbench. I find it much more comfortable to use than the Mac desktop because the Screens allow you to manage applications' windows better.

1

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

I don't mean to run Amiga programs, I mean that it behaves like the Amiga Workbench.

I understand. I just don't see it being "sellable". Certain functionalities, if they make the experience of using the product, in case it all goes forward, would, of course, be considered. I, personally, don't have much experience with Amiga, and what little exposure I had to it, I just don't remember much of it. For shits and giggles though I'll find an emulator to dick around with. :p

1

u/fsckit Sep 21 '12

Try a modern implementation of AmigaOS on your PC. Burn the DVD and then boot it.

2

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

Grazie.

2

u/Broeman Sep 21 '12

I miss Amiga Workbench so much.

2

u/fsckit Sep 21 '12

So do this lot.

1

u/Broeman Sep 21 '12

Yeah, haven't had the time to play around with Aros yet. I just did my first FreeBSD install today after many years on Linux, so this is enough adventure for the next couple of weeks :)

I guess a VirtualBox could do it later.

1

u/fsckit Sep 21 '12

There used to be a FreeBSD-hosted version, but I don't know if it is still maintained.

2

u/Broeman Sep 21 '12

Oh, cool

6

u/badluser Sep 21 '12

Wait, did you use the interwebz before asking this question? MacOSX is based on BSD. They bought the XNU kernel from Carnagie Mellon and bought all the Free/Net/OpenBSD devs in the late 90s. The userland is BSD with a UNIX-like kernel.

How do you mean Mac OS X like? Do you mean it has a pretty dock and pretty 3d window rendering? Do you mean that it supports a large variety of commercial, not just FOSS, applications? If you could elaborate, I am sure you would get more of a response.

Also, Do you have the dev skills for dev'ing your own Custom GUI?

2

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

How do you mean Mac OS X like?

In this instance, use FreeBSD as the base — kernel and userland — and slap own UI on top of it. Monumental task perhaps, but imo well worth it. "pretty 3d window rendering" and other UI bells and whistles but primarily following Apple's UI design guidelines. X+DE/WM is a solution of course and will be considered, implementation details at this point are not as important as concepts.

Do you mean it has a pretty dock and pretty 3d window rendering?

Yes and yes. Usable, clean, not a lot of "customizations".

Do you mean that it supports a large variety of commercial, not just FOSS, applications?

Possibly binary compatibility with at least Linux and OS X binaries.

Also, Do you have the dev skills for dev'ing your own Custom GUI?

Yes, to a degree, though it's not the point. Resources could be acquired.

All-n-all, an OSS "clone" of OS X, if you will. OS X is fine, I love it, but it's under control of various marketdroid and management types and certain directions it's taking — it probably will become IOS-like crap in a matter of a few years.

3

u/ropers Sep 21 '12 edited Sep 22 '12

completely based on BSD

Possibly binary compatibility with at least Linux and OS X binaries.

All BSD-based and compatibility with at least Linux and OS X binaries?

Good luck.

(I'm not saying it can't be done; I mean, there's ReactOS for Windows, but it's gonna be fecking hard and I would anticipate Apple getting on your ass with "look-and-feel" and patent shenanigans even more eagerly than Microsoft (who have basically left ReactOS in peace, AFAIK). As for your question, would there be interest? Yeah, I'm somewhat interested. But I'm more skeptical than interested.)

PS: Of course, enough compatibility for some Linux and OS X binaries to work on the same BSD-based system might be achievable with Darwin and compat_linux stuff, but getting a significant number of Aqua and X WIMP-GUI programs to work... Good luck.

-2

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

That was constructive...

At the most, an easy way for developers to port OS X apps.

1

u/int80h Sep 22 '12

Thanks for the input, everyone.

5

u/miggyb Sep 21 '12

...go on...

4

u/can-of-bees Sep 21 '12

seconding, third-ing, and fourth-ing everyone else... go on.

1

u/moonhead Sep 22 '12

i'd be on board for this. but isn't that what canonical is trying to do with ubuntu?

s/BSD/linux/g

0

u/int80h Sep 22 '12

no.

2

u/moonhead Sep 22 '12

I think it sounds strikingly similar, actually. what am I missing?

-1

u/int80h Sep 22 '12

It's been explained.

1

u/hal68k Sep 28 '12

more like OSX

So, improving Etoile on FreeBSD?

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '12

[deleted]

2

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

I'd love to see OS X a) install out of the box on any x86 hardware without massive dicking around b) OSS and c) not under control of a corporate interest — no I'm not a communist.

1

u/archlinuxrussian Sep 21 '12

Just stating: you aren't satisfied with a software stack currently available that mimicked OSX? I once (during the days of Gnome 2) used cairodock and a variety of other customizations to make it look like apple. Now, I will say stuff like Finder and stuff isnt..."there", so those would need to be written, but I would argue most of the software you would need to do this exists already. Heck, the Pantheon Shell for elementary linux does a good job of SOME applle-like actions. The job may not be as complex as thought. Also: do you want the Best of apple and the best of bsd/etc? Or everything to be apple-like?

2

u/int80h Sep 21 '12

What I, and probably many others, would like is a desktop I can slap on any hardware with ease of installing, running, and using OS X.

Current OSS DEs and WMs are well below any usable expectations. Also, this is not about advocating the use of X+DE/WM, it's about feasibility and need/want for an elegant free FOSS-supported solution.

Also: do you want the Best of apple and the best of bsd/etc?

Something of the sort, yes.

3

u/archlinuxrussian Sep 22 '12

Well I wouldn't say all the DEs out there are unusable. I use cinnamon and unity, and they work for me. Sorry if there is a disconnect, with me being a linux user, and maybe that will skew my views, but take a look at elementary Luna, its nicely done and acts like OS X a lot. However, from what you say, I gather you want a replica of OS X, and I think the best choice is to have a software stack you can install that will mimick OS X. But I am with you in that I like a lot of what is in OS X, which is why I probably will use Elementary someday. And maybe I could write a replacement for Finder, but idk.