[This is a very, very long post. I hope you will read to the end before responding.]
My pwBPD and I have been together for five years. Currently, we are the happiest we’ve been in our entire lives, our mental health has never been better, we have great jobs and pets and a nice home. Our marriage is stable and utterly boring.
Before I tell my story, I want to preface this with some general statements:
pwBPD are often manipulative and abusive, particularly to their romantic partners. This is a fact. Abuse is abuse, no matter what mental illnesses you use to “excuse” the abuse. (There is no excuse.) Abuse victims deserve to be validated, treated with respect, and given space to heal in a safe space away from their abusers and apologists/enablers. This post is not directed at any person who was abused by a pwBPD and is currently dealing with the resulting trauma. You are all valid, and I hold space for you in my heart.
Simultaneously to the above, many pwBPD experience excruciating psychological pain. This pain often leads the pwBPD to behave badly, and many times, the pwBPD does not intend to cause harm. In more lucid moments, they might feel a lot of shame. Ultimately, there is no way to justify or defend abuse, even when it is “unintentional” or born out of great suffering (see above). But I want to acknowledge that the psychological pain experienced by pwBPD is real. Again, I hold space in my heart for pwBPD, who all deserve a great measure of compassion that they often do not receive.
No one should ever stay in a relationship if they are unhappy. No one. You don’t need a “good” reason to leave, you never need to give an explanation or a justification. This is the rule for all relationships, and it’s been better expressed in “The Truth That Lives There.”
In the story I am about to tell, both SO and I made choices. Many of these choices seemed to be bad ones. I want everyone reading this to know that I am completely aware that I made the choice to stay when I probably would have advised any person in my position to RUN. Do not ever think that my purpose in writing this is to convince everyone that “staying in an unstable, toxic relationship with a pwBPD will have a happy ending if you just wait long enough.” That ain’t it, friends.
Okay. Here goes.
I. Background & Context.
SO and I were in our early twenties when we met, and our relationship moved fast. We decided to get married after three weeks and signed the marriage license within five months. And yeah…this was really fast—I would be alarmed to see even a healthy neurotypical couple move so fast.
I had a traumatic childhood that I’m still working to unpack; however, from a young age, I have had a rock-solid understanding of what my vision for a healthy marriage looks like and what traits/values I require from a partner. I gave this a lot of thought. I wasn’t looking for a long-term relationship when we met, but it was clear to me that SO ticked all of the boxes. He was and is my ideal partner. Not in a romantic, “we’re soulmates!” kind of way. SO is definitely not my soulmate, nor am I his. While I did (and still do) have romantic feelings for/about SO, the decision to sign the marriage license was very much an exercise in pragmatism, not love.
I give this insight because it’s important in a couple of ways. First, the fact that my default mindset is “super logical and analytic” is a direct contrast to…every pwBPD ever. When my boundaries and sense of self are properly maintained, I have the ability to remain objective and see the shades of gray in a situation. (I think we can all see why this is important.) Second, I have historically been confident in the soundness of my choices because they have always yielded good results. This is why even when I was suffocating in the swamp of SO’s irrational behaviors, I trusted that I had made the right call.
As to why SO married me? We genuinely do not know. I asked him again yesterday, and even after years of self-reflection, he’s got nothing. I’m certainly not like any of his exes, who all contributed equally to the vortex of drama he formerly surrounded himself with (and who, in some cases, retaliated with emotional abuse ten times worse than anything he committed). Instead, I challenged his perception of reality from the beginning. He didn’t like it one bit, but he married me anyway.
Another important background detail is that SO received his diagnosis some time before he met me, and he disclosed his BPD to me prior to our first date. He was already receiving therapy. (I've never met SO's therapist, but I know that sometimes she has single-handedly kept him afloat. She's amazing.) Additionally, it was helpful for me to have a concrete reason as to why everything was happening. Even when I felt insane and even when SO acted like reality was negotiable, part of me knew better. I did not yet understand BPD, but the knowledge that BPD was present helped a lot.
II. The Swamp.
Right, so…I’ve just jumped headfirst into a hasty marriage with an awesome guy who tells me he has BPD. What’s next?
Well. The next six months were without question the worst experience of my life. That’s the short answer.
But you want the long answer, so here it is.
SO’s disorder is on the less extreme end of the spectrum overall, and it doesn’t really look like the textbook description of BPD. Most of SO’s issues are heavily internalized. Which is not to say that it was a fun time for me. He was prone to implosive anger and intense outbursts, which I found frightening even though his anger was never directed at me. His emotions were all over the place and he frequently “coped” with strong emotions by dissociating. It’s truly wild to watch someone literally “turn off” their entire personality and zombify themselves at will. And finally, he was splitting, with everyone, all the time—but particularly with one of his exes, who he swore he hated but who he also claimed was his “soulmate” and the only person he could ever be happy with.
It’s an oversimplification to say that SO’s unresolved trauma and feelings surrounding this ex were The Problem, but…they were definitely a problem. I cannot speak to SO’s experiences, but through speaking with him after the fact, I believe that he felt very frightened and confused. He genuinely thought this ex had been his “one chance” at a normal romantic relationship and that their breakup had doomed him forever, but he also understood that objectively speaking, she had been unspeakably cruel to him. He could not reconcile his idealized image of her with her actual behavior. Hence: splitting.
My experience was equally frightening and confusing. Here’s this guy who says he loves me, but who hates every single aspect of my character. He claims to loathe his ex, but then weeps each time he encounters evidence that confirms I am nothing like her. And then when I push back on what he says, he starts “diagnosing” me with various mental illnesses in an effort to protect his version of reality. But he swears that he has no feelings for his ex!
I was not equipped to handle any of this. I was young, had never even heard of emotional manipulation, and also I didn’t think BPD was the root cause of our issues, since everything I read online focused on the more destructive BPD behaviors like addiction, violence, etc. Pretty much the only thing my husband was doing was crying constantly and telling me how he was doomed to be miserable. I thought he was being kinda dramatic, but hey, I loved him and wanted to help.
“Helping” SO turned into an excruciating process of excising the parts of my personality that caused him distress. (Note: all the parts caused him distress.) I modified my behavior, my hobbies, and my thought patterns at his request, because I loved SO and wanted him to be happy. But nothing ever made him happy. He would say he needed X, but then he'd be just as depressed when I did X as he was before. I’d remind him that he had promised X was going to make him happy, and he would backpedal and say he’d wanted me to do Y all along.
It was a mess. We were both miserable, though we claimed that we still loved each other. I struggled because even though he was being a piece of shit, the specific characteristics I’d pinpointed as desirable were still very much there. And surely I couldn’t have been that wrong about him??? But whether I was right or wrong about SO’s “true self” was immaterial in the end. Even though I could barely discern what was real anymore, I hadn’t given up all my boundaries. In fact, just three months after we married, I told him I was done.
We prepared for a divorce. I was devastated, but firm. The relationship simply was not working, and it did not seem likely it was ever going to work in the future. I did feel better once I decided to leave, though—it was easier to hang on to my identity when I no longer faced a lifetime of cutting myself into pieces, bit by bit.
But while I was feeling better after the separation and the prospect of an upcoming divorce, SO got worse and worse. Since I was no longer in Active Crisis Mode, I extended him an offer of limited friendship and support. It turns out that right around the time we got married, his ex had sent him an email full of groveling almost-apologies and other self-pitying bs. She had been toying with him ever since, while SO had been having a chaotic, one-sided emotional affair.
Yeah. This wasn’t great to hear, and I was pretty pissed. But all things considered, it was a “not my monkeys, not my circus” situation. Mostly, I felt sorry for the both of us.
So, I let SO tell me all about this ex, about how he felt literally addicted to the idea that she was his “soulmate,” even though she was a toxic person who had abandoned him time and time again. This time, hearing about his feelings for her didn’t bother me at all. For the first time in months, I accessed my hyperlogical analytic mode and processed everything SO said as a fact instead of a feeling. (Fact: he had been speaking with this person behind my back; Fact: he truly believed she was a terrible person; Fact: in spite of this, he did not feel that he could live without her.) I didn't let myself make any of what he was saying become about me. I just listened.
You know…if you ever get a pwBPD to sit down and calmly explain to you what’s going on in their minds, it’s absolutely fascinating. SO is the most interesting person I’ve ever met. Not in a bad way, just in a “huh, brains sure are something” kind of way.
Anyway, after SO spilled his guts, I felt intensely curious but completely separate from the drama. It was clear that this was an issue with SO alone, not even remotely related to any “failures” of mine. I felt very chill. Then, for the first time, I did the thing that has now become my favorite tool in supporting SO. I asked him a Hard Question:
“I get that you think this person is your one true soulmate, but I gotta ask…in your head, what kind of future do you see with her? By your own admission, she’s terrible and completely untrustworthy…can you tell me where you think this is headed?”
(*crickets*)
Some time afterward, SO told me that this question utterly unraveled the entire mythology he had built around this person. He recognized that he’d been feeling a lot of feelings and had been doing a lot of things to get rid of those feelings, but he’d never taken time to self-reflect and think of the big picture. (Lucky for him, I am the queen of the bigger picture.)
After the conversation where I asked the Hard Question, SO executed the most drastic behavioral change I’ve ever encountered. He quit acting like a pwBPD, 100% cold turkey. This is not an exaggeration. He just…stopped. I haven't had even the smallest glimpse of “crazy” SO since.
He stowed every single one of his emotions in a big box and took the box to his next therapy appointment, where he and his therapist started the slow process of interrogating his perception of reality in a constructive manner. (Needless to stay, even if you can stop behaving like a pwBPD overnight, you can’t just stop feeling like one.)
The fact that SO was able to (a) comprehend the inappropriateness of his behavior and (b) take immediate, comprehensive action to course correct is the reason my marriage still exists. His willpower and mental strength are nearly superhuman. Our relationship was already dead and halfway to the grave, but he single-handedly resurrected it. (I do not believe that any other person could have done what he did in just 24 hours.)
We decided to call off the divorce.
Things didn’t get better right away, of course. I especially struggled because even though SO stopped doing XYZ bad things, he had done them in the past—and it didn’t appear that an apology was forthcoming. It was like SO was working so hard to make a better future he skipped the part where he took responsibility for the past. (A mostly benign manifestation of rug-sweeping?) Honestly…I felt like shit. It may seem weird, but my lowest low was not when SO was actively gaslighting me and projecting his skewed worldview on me—it came afterwards, when he was working to improve but I was still struggling in the swamp by myself. I was in a very dark place, and I had no idea how to get out.
Seven months after we were married, SO went out of town for a conference. I felt better the second he left. My anxiety disappeared, and for the first time, I didn’t feel as if every second was a precarious balancing act where the smallest misstep would result in an incomprehensible argument. I spent a couple of days reveling in the fact that I felt like an actual person again, and then I took the alone time to do some serious thinking. I was then able to put my finger on exactly why I had not been able to initiate any sort of healing process.
Meanwhile, SO was on the other side of the country and missing me terribly. Even in a short time, he’d worked hard in therapy and made a great deal of progress. Our relationship was much better than it had been, and he had a newfound appreciation for me. He called me one night, all excited and whatnot, but my response was basically one big “ewww, no.” (This hurt his feelings rather a lot, for understandable reasons.)
After a brief back and forth, I texted him: “I can’t stay with someone who claims to love me but can barely acknowledge that he mistreated me, much less apologize for it.”
SO responded almost right away: “You’re right. I was terrible to you, and none of it was okay. I’m sorry.”
He came back home at the end of the week, and he’s never failed to take full responsibility for his shit again, usually without being prompted. And no matter which of us is more at fault in any given situation, he’s always the first to apologize. Always.
A Time for Healing.
And now we get to the part of the story where it’s just a lot of hard work. Rebuilding a marriage after it’s been reduced to rubble and the foundations have been yanked up is not a fun time. Neither is it a particularly interesting time, since it’s a lot of focused conflict interspersed with long conversations and varying amounts of self-reflection.
Basically, it sucked, but in a good way. Healing is actually very monotonous. You do the healthy thing over and over again until it becomes second nature. You spend a lot of time examining yourself in very uncomfortable ways. My marriage often felt wonderful, and it often felt horrible. Only the passage of time and consistent effort evened out the dynamic into a consistent “this relationship pretty damn good, except for when this asshole doesn’t refill the reservoir in the effing Keurig even though I’ve reminded them twenty times this month,” which is where things are at now.
(In case you’re wondering, I’m 100% that bitch who never replaces the Keurig water; it’s an ongoing issue, I’m trying to address it.)
We fought a lot at first, then we fought less and less. Nowadays, we don’t really fight or have arguments at all. Instead, we engage in quiet conversations where both sides express their feelings and perceptions. Everyone’s interpretation of the truth is respected and validated, then we work together to figure out what changes need to be made so that everyone feels okay with the situation. Okay, to be fair…this is what we try to do, but mostly we succeed! The best gift SO and I have given each other is understanding while that we both experience the same events in radically different ways, neither experience is necessarily incorrect. Once we stopped wasting time trying to “win” the war over whose truth was the Real Truth, things got so much easier.
And I, obviously, have had to do some work with respect to the trauma I experienced during the first six months of the marriage. After the active crisis ended, I took stock and realized how small I had made myself in my attempts to appease SO. I got angry. Very, very angry. For a while I tried to punish present-day SO for the things he had done in the past. That wasn’t too great of me. I eventually realized that I had two choices: either I could file for divorce and go work on myself in private, or I could stop using SO as my emotional punching bag and work toward forgiveness. That was super tough. (Naturally, my lizard brain preferred the non-option of using “you were an emotional terrorist who ruined my life!!!” as a perpetual trump card in all future marital conflicts.)
Ultimately, I chose to stay with SO. This wasn’t a decision I made lightly, and it’s not a decision that has felt 100% good, 100% of the time. Regardless, I now strive to process my trauma without SO’s input. As with everything else, it’s a work in progress.
You may want to shake me and say “girl, you do know that relationships don’t need to be this hard, right?” Trust me, I do know this. I am 100% aware that sustaining my marriage has required far, far more emotional labor than is typical or even advisable. Being married to SO is the hardest thing I’ve ever done. (I say this as someone who survived law school and the bar exam with undiagnosed, unmedicated ADHD; 0/10, do not recommend.) But to me, it’s been worth it.
As you remember, I based my decision to marry SO on a non-emotional, pragmatic calculus of what I needed from a partner and what he had to offer. I picked him for a reason. We have wildly different personalities and approaches to life, but we have compatible values and life goals. We’re both flawed, and we both carry a metric ton of baggage from our childhoods that we will spend the rest of our lives unpacking. We’re also self-aware, emotionally intelligent, and brutally honest with ourselves and with each other. I ask him the Hard Questions, and he points out the ugly parts of myself in a way that feels caring rather than cruel. We extend each other so much grace, especially when it isn’t deserved.
Yes, I could ditch SO tomorrow and find a wonderful new partner, no problem. I could find a better partner! My life could be much easier than it is right now. Hell, I could probably even be happier than I am now. But for right now, I’m getting so much out of this marriage, precisely because of (not in spite of) the hard bits.
I love this man so so so much. He has given far more than he ever took. Nowadays, I don’t ever think about those terrible six months, because they’re barely relevant to the relationship as it stands today. They’re an important part of our past, and they brought us here. But like...I am not even kidding when I say that the biggest conflict in our relationship right now is whose turn it is to clean the kitchen. It’s wonderful. (And it's probably my turn to clean.)
Closing Thoughts.
I know there are many who would not consider this to be a “success story” and who perhaps believe that I have deluded myself into acquiescing to a toxic relationship. You have every right to this opinion! I won’t argue with you, even. But again: the most irritating thing SO currently does is chew gum with his mouth open (every. single. day). I’ve experienced emotional manipulation/abuse in the past, and this ain’t it.
In this post, I have attempted to present an honest picture of my marriage to a pwBPD. I have tried to avoid making generalizations. I’m not trying to give advice of any sort. I know there’s a commonly held opinion that pwBPD are incapable of forming stable, healthy relationships—even pwBPD themselves sometimes feel this way. But no mental illness is a monolith. Sometimes, it’s okay to feel a measured dose of optimism. Sometimes, consistent self-examination and a qualified therapist really can result in long-lasting change.
A marriage is a unique blend of circumstance, personality, and behavior. Every person must decide for themself which battles are worth fighting and which compromises are worth making. More than that, the only person who can define “happiness” for you is you.
I have been married to a pwBPD for five years, and we are very happy together.
This is my truth.