r/BOINC • • Jan 03 '21

Isn't boinc an incredibly inefficient waste of energy and computing power?

9 Upvotes

Millions of cpu and gpu cores times 50-150watts each to essentially brute force molecular dynamics simulations in an unfocused way. Traditional supercomputers would not run this work because of how loose it is, it wouldn't be worth it. Boinc projects do because they take advantage of the endless cpu power for free and a handful of grad students are the only ones who manage the projects with no incentive to improve anything because they are busy as students. I have participated in and watched these projects for 10 years and the majority of them basically waste all the computational power. Look at milkyway@home. How many trillions of galaxy spin model has it generated by now and what was the point.

In computing you don't need to brute force solutions, you can get much better results by optimizing your code and coding efficiently.

I think you should be careful which projects you chose to run because most don't do anything with the results and you are generating 99.999% statistical trash that doesn't get used.

There is a direct correlation between electricity usage and increased c02 emissions from power plants. Ironic that some of these projects to make the world better are actually wasting energy and contributing to c02 emissions Before someone says boinc electric usage is insignificant, it's not. Like 500 megawatts at least and more likely over a gigawatt.

Prove me wrong that boinc isn't a waste if you disagree with me


r/BOINC • • Dec 12 '25

Folding efficiency improvements - reducing carbon footprint

0 Upvotes

This might be an unpopular opinion, but as much as folding uses compute power for a good cause, the combined co2 emissions from folding are also immense!

Some suggestions on how to make folding more efficienct, to reduce carbon emissions, lower energy prices, and reduce foreign energy dependency:

  1. Using AI to calculate an efficiency score, to compare performance per watt between devices, users, and teams.

  2. Promoting and increasing ARM hardware support (Android, snapdragon laptop chips, apple silicon), to make people switch from x86 and discrete GPU's, which are more inefficiency in terms of performance per watt.

  3. Ending support for the oldest and most inefficient hardware, to make people upgrade and switch to newer more energy efficienct hardware.

  4. If CPU's and GPU's are doing the same tasks, only GPU's, especially iGPU's, should run those tasks instead of CPU's, since they are much faster and way more efficient per watt than CPU's doing the same tasks.

Just not seeing anybody talking about this, and I think the Folding community should contribute to reducing carbon emissions and saving the environment, like everyone else.


r/BOINC • • Feb 10 '26

Why I am reducing my commitment after almost 10 years

0 Upvotes

Not me, but on BOINC Italy they opened a topic that I think might be of interest.

Unfortunately, the article they cite is only in Italian, even though the website (hamburger menu) has a language selector to switch it to English. In any case, I’m leaving the translation below.

Translated (Google Translate not working so i used Yandex): https://translated.turbopages.org/proxy_u/it-en.it.d2ea90f6-698b7e9e-456e6ad6-74722d776562/https/consulente-finanziario.org/boinc-il-volontariato-quasi-tradito-perche-riduco-il-mio-impegno-dopo-quasi-dieci-anni/

From this board: https://www.boincitaly.org/forum/progetti/115460-dopo-10-anni-su-boinc,-riduco-il-mio-impegno%E2%80%A6-ecco-perch%C3%A9.html

Original article: https://consulente-finanziario.org/boinc-il-volontariato-quasi-tradito-perche-riduco-il-mio-impegno-dopo-quasi-dieci-anni/


r/BOINC • • Mar 27 '19

Boinc GPU computing is broken, lagging my whole PC to a point it is almost unusable. Even mouse lags and everything is totally unresponsive.

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/BOINC • • Aug 24 '23

Why is SiDock still studying Covid19 treatments?

1 Upvotes

I use Science United as my account manager and every now and then SiDock throw in multiple huge 5 days long tasks at me.

Apparently SiDock is an initiative that focuses on developing a cure for SARS CoV2 or covid19. Why is the project still sinking in computing power to study it?


r/BOINC • • Dec 06 '18

My CPU is not very powerful, how can I configure BOINC to use my brain for 1 hour a day?

0 Upvotes

I considered bitcoin mining but that would make mining difficulty skyrocket and bankrupt other miners.


r/BOINC • • 17d ago

I'm confused. Bitcoin puzzles are bad, but somehow they're okay if they're run by a veteran of the community? What?

3 Upvotes

What's going on in the community? What's all this drama about?

People discussing it on wuprop also: https://wuprop.statseb.fr/forum_thread.php?id=191&sort_style=&start=1960


r/BOINC • • May 31 '25

What's boinc? It's not written in FAQ

7 Upvotes

I got a random post about guy destroying his steam deck because of boinc and I got curious. I went to wiki page then FAQ but it didn't say "what is boinc" as if it was obvious.

What is boinc?


r/BOINC • • Jun 12 '22

Show Support for Team Ukraine / Formula Boinc Sprint #7 is in the books​

1 Upvotes

Show Support for Team Ukraine / Formula Boinc Sprint #7 is in the books​From

https://xs4s.org/index.php?topic=30190.msg96865#msg96865​

The results are in.

Congratulations TSBT, you worked hard for your win and deserve the respect

Nice to see Team Ukraine still rocking, when this started I was just hoping that TU would stay in the top 5
so this is excellent, I still think that keeping Team Ukraine relevant and rocking is a great show of support.
Go TU and all that are helping.
3rd is AMD users, nice job! followed up by P3d and LaF (both powerhouses!)

Also nice job to everyone involved! LHC is a very tough program to run, so much respect.

I do have more comments (my next post) but this sprint was mostly on track, late 1st day numbers but if that's all that can be said
this could be the start of FB getting back on track.

SV

Show Support for Team Ukraine / Team Ukraine has joined DC Boinc Games - Take a peek,

​Welcome to BoincGames

BoincGames - www.boincgames.com
BOINC Games is a year around BOINC competition. Aiming to keep BOINC fun and interesting for all involved.

Any questions please PM me.

Thanks
SV


r/BOINC • • Apr 10 '25

Improving BOINC structurally and architecturally (ChatGPT 4o)

0 Upvotes

Improving BOINC structurally and architecturally would mean modernizing it to better serve scientific computing, increase participation, and possibly adapt to the new era of decentralized and high-performance computing—including large language models, edge computing, and GPUs. Here’s a detailed breakdown of how BOINC could be enhanced: 🧠 1. Better Support for Heterogeneous and Modern Hardware

GPU Utilization Optimization: Improve native support for modern GPUs, including NVIDIA, AMD, and even Apple Silicon. Current support is project-dependent and limited.

ARM and Mobile Support: Fully embrace ARM CPUs (including Raspberry Pi and Android devices). Mobile devices are ubiquitous and underused.

FPGA & ASIC Awareness: As specialized hardware grows in popularity (e.g. TPUs, FPGAs), BOINC could offer modules that detect and utilize them where applicable.

🧱 2. Containerization and Sandboxing

Docker Integration: Rather than requiring custom clients per project, enable containerized work units using Docker or OCI containers. This:

    Simplifies cross-platform compatibility

    Improves security (sandboxing)

    Reduces dependencies on user systems

WebAssembly (WASM): For very lightweight projects, allow WASM modules to run directly in a secure environment.

📦 3. Project Distribution and Decentralization

Decentralized Project Hosting: BOINC currently uses centralized servers per project. A decentralized architecture using IPFS or similar tech could:

    Improve redundancy and fault tolerance

    Enable peer-to-peer result sharing

    Reduce reliance on any one organization

Distributed Scheduling: Enable distributed work-unit scheduling and load-balancing to reduce central coordination costs.

🧪 4. Unified Compute Interface

Cross-Compatibility with Other Frameworks:

    Integrate with Kubernetes or Slurm to schedule BOINC workloads on larger compute clusters.

    Allow cross-submit from platforms like Folding@Home or [Rosetta@Home].

LLM + HPC Bridge: Create an optional compatibility layer for LLM projects (e.g., local fine-tuning, embedding generation) to use BOINC-distributed compute.

📈 5. Modernized Incentive Structures

Tokenized Rewards (Carefully):

    Carefully designed, opt-in token incentives could increase participation (think Gridcoin done right).

    Could also integrate reputation or contribution scoring.

Gamification: Better dashboards, leaderboards, and team-building features integrated into the client interface.

🧭 6. Improved Client & User Experience

GUI Redesign: The current BOINC Manager is outdated and not user-friendly.

    Create a mobile-friendly, modern GUI

    Real-time feedback on contribution impact and system performance

Automatic Benchmarking & Tuning: Automatically tune performance preferences per user device to ensure optimal workloads.

🛡 7. Security & Privacy Enhancements

End-to-End Work Unit Verification: Ensure that malicious actors can't inject false results by enabling cryptographic signatures or ZK-proofs for completed jobs.

Privacy-Preserving Compute: Incorporate homomorphic encryption or differential privacy where applicable, especially for health/biological projects.

🔄 8. Federated Data Exchange & Open Standards

Standard Work Unit Format: Develop an open, versioned work unit format so new projects can plug into BOINC more easily.

Cross-Project APIs: Allow external applications to query data (with permission) across BOINC projects for aggregation and meta-analysis.

🏗 Example of a Modern BOINC Flow

User installs a BOINC+Docker client with sleek GUI.

It benchmarks their system, finds matching projects (GPU, AI, biology).

Work units are delivered via IPFS or other P2P mechanism.

Docker container runs isolated compute job.

Results are cryptographically verified and uploaded back.

User dashboard shows live contribution stats and scientific impact.

r/BOINC • • May 24 '24

When for a new Pi 5 client, still show pre release.

0 Upvotes

When will we get an update for raspberry Pi 5. With a fresh install today it still states it’s a pre release 7.20.5

My Pi 4 install gives me 7.16.16

Both have been at this version for months. Is it being updated anymore for Pi

They are both running PiOS bookworm 64bit


r/BOINC • • Apr 04 '20

Consider running Dreamlab

Thumbnail self.folding
3 Upvotes

r/BOINC • • May 11 '26

Ramanujan Machine - No work available despite 77415 ready to send - Snapdragon laptop

3 Upvotes

How come I'm not getting any work units, despite 77415 being available to send on my X2 Elite Extreme Snapdragon laptop?

Here is my event log:

11/05/2026 23.43.50 | | Fetching configuration file from https://rnma.xyz/boinc/get_project_config.php
11/05/2026 23.44.00 | | Fetching configuration file from https://rnma.xyz/boinc/get_project_config.php
11/05/2026 23.44.15 | | Fetching configuration file from https://rnma.xyz/boinc/get_project_config.php
11/05/2026 23.44.24 | RamanujanMachine | Fetching scheduler list
11/05/2026 23.44.25 | RamanujanMachine | Master file download succeeded
11/05/2026 23.44.30 | RamanujanMachine | Sending scheduler request: Project initialization.
11/05/2026 23.44.30 | RamanujanMachine | Requesting new tasks for CPU and Qualcomm(R) Adreno(TM) X2-90 GPU
11/05/2026 23.44.31 | RamanujanMachine | Scheduler request completed: got 0 new tasks
11/05/2026 23.44.31 | RamanujanMachine | Server error: feeder not running
11/05/2026 23.44.31 | RamanujanMachine | Project requested delay of 3600 seconds
11/05/2026 23.44.45 | RamanujanMachine | update requested by user
11/05/2026 23.44.46 | RamanujanMachine | Sending scheduler request: Requested by user.
11/05/2026 23.44.46 | RamanujanMachine | Requesting new tasks for CPU and Qualcomm(R) Adreno(TM) X2-90 GPU
11/05/2026 23.44.47 | RamanujanMachine | Scheduler request completed: got 0 new tasks
11/05/2026 23.44.47 | RamanujanMachine | Server error: feeder not running
11/05/2026 23.44.47 | RamanujanMachine | Project requested delay of 3600 seconds


r/BOINC • • May 05 '26

What is the point of wasting CPU cycles on apps that run 20x faster on a GPU?

8 Upvotes

I’ve been tweaking my PrimeGrid settings lately and it’s honestly making me question how we distribute work across the entire BOINC network. I’ve restricted my setup so that my CPU only touches LLR projects (which are CPU-only), and I leave all the GFN/Genefer stuff strictly to my GPU and iGPU.

When you look at the stats, it’s night and day. A GFN-16 task takes, according to the averages, 2 minutes on a decent GPU, but it can hang around for 40 minutes on a CPU. By letting CPUs crunch those, we’re effectively wasting massive amounts of compute time that could have been used for projects that actually need the CPU.

Why are we still allowing this overlap? It feels like we’re subsidizing inefficiency just to keep everyone’s "in progress" lists full. If we strictly pushed GPU-capable apps to discrete or integrated graphics, we’d free up a massive amount of overhead for the pure CPU projects.

Are we just afraid of setting standards because it might offend people with older rigs, or is there a genuine scientific reason to keep wasting watts like this in 2026? I’m curious how you guys handle your resource shares—do you actually micromanage your subprojects to avoid this, or do you just let the scheduler waste the cycles?


r/BOINC • • Sep 23 '16

who has ownership of some of the pcmr boinc teams?

2 Upvotes

i'm just wondering because i'm currently going to be overtaking the top spot on the team and am very active in keeping up with boinc stuff and would like to be an active owner of AT LEAST world community grid since it seems like the current one is inactive. i did make a handful of pcmasterrace teams for projects that currently didn't have one.


r/BOINC • • Oct 22 '21

BOINC not working in OpenSUSE (Linux)

2 Upvotes

Hi.

I decided I wanted to change my operating system yesterday from Windows, and decided to choose OpenSUSE. I really like it. I'm currently using Tumbleweed.

I first logged in as a root user because I wanted to avoid creating a user account. I installed BOINC through the software centre and it runs fine. Then I realised I needed to change to a user account when I began getting error messages on trying to do certain things like run games etc.

So I've created a Linux user account which I'm using now. When I open the Boinc client/manager, it stays on "retrieving current status" for about 3 mins then I recieved the error message:

"The boinc client has exited unexpectedly 3 times within the last 3 minutes. Would you like to restart it again?"

The client displays the message: unable to connect to the core client

Does anyone have experience getting Boinc to work in Linux?

I appreciate any help.


r/BOINC • • Nov 18 '23

Question to moderators. NSFW

0 Upvotes

I hear there is some hostility to an officially sanctioned census.

Please confirm qualifying BOINC related experience.


r/BOINC • • Nov 13 '24

What happens when you run a Nvidia Tesla V100 on Milkayway

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/BOINC • • Nov 24 '24

All the computational power we can use for the better if we do it right to solve the real problems while giving credit to its worker

7 Upvotes

Just read this early documentation of the cryptocurrency, and wonder if there are problems needed to solve with the computational power for ones own good, why not solving the real one and harvest all the computational power it needs? I believe that people would line up to solve the problems in no time.

Source:http://www.weidai.com/bmoney.txt


r/BOINC • • Apr 04 '25

My new computer's CPU was overheating. Turns out BOINC was somehow set to use 100% of the CPU all the time. Cutting it to 10% when inactive immediately fixed the issue.

5 Upvotes

Nothing else, just wanted to share a tip if you also have problems.


r/BOINC • • Jan 19 '26

BOINC - Maximize GPU Science Throughput via Parallel Task Saturation

5 Upvotes

Most GPUs and iGPUs are sadly underutilized when running BOINC, because they only run one task at a time, creating idle gaps while waiting for data.

By forcing multiple concurrent tasks, you can fill these gaps and maintain 100% hardware saturation.

On my base M4 Mac Mini, 10 tasks (1 per GPU core) achieved perfect stability and maximum output.

I would recommend these Safety Tiers:

For iGPUs like M4 or Panther Lake, run 1 task per GPU core (e.g., 10 tasks for a 10-core chip).

For discrete GPUs, run 1 task per GB of VRAM (e.g., 12 tasks for a 12GB card).

For high-end cards like an RTX 4090, try 1 task per 1,000 CUDA cores (approx 16 tasks).

To enable this, create an app_config.xml file in your project folder.

Replace PROJECT_URL with the folder name and APP_NAME with the application's internal name found in task properties.

Mac/Linux: cd "/Library/Application Support/BOINC Data/projects/PROJECT_URL/" && sudo printf "<app_config>\n <app>\n <name>APP_NAME</name>\n <gpu_versions>\n <gpu_usage>0.1</gpu_usage>\n <cpu_usage>0.1</cpu_usage>\n </gpu_versions>\n </app>\n</app_config>" > app_config.xml

Windows (PowerShell Admin): Set-Location "C:\ProgramData\BOINC\projects\PROJECT_URL"; $xml = '<app_config><app><name>APP_NAME</name><gpu_versions><gpu_usage>0.1</gpu_usage><cpu_usage>0.1</cpu_usage></gpu_versions></app></app_config>'; $xml | Out-File -FilePath "app_config.xml" -Encoding ascii

To apply this In BOINC Manager, go to Options and click Read config files. Scale the 0.1 value up or down based on your core count (e.g., 0.05 for 20 tasks).

Hoping this will increase the total contributed BOINC GPU compute power significantly. Let me know if you have any questions, and I'll try to help out as best I can

P.s. keep an eye on CPU usage so the GPU doesn't get "starved" of instructions.


r/BOINC • • Mar 09 '20

Why are my BOINC settings controlled via accounts on third party sites?

1 Upvotes

Hi all... I have a potentially contentious topic - sorry for this up front.

I would like to contribute to R@H and WCG but I have to ask... why is BOINC Manager controlled by settings in my accounts on these third-party services? Limits like CPU usage, resource sharing and stuff controlled through the honor system? I don't like it. I can set BOINC Manager to override CPU usage and some other very basic attributes, but there are many functions that it seems to not be able to override, like resource share. I Google how to change that and every response I am seeing is to do it on a project's web site.

Why is the software built such that I am the one willing to donate my time and energy, yet I have to ask a third-party service to abide by my configuration?

I would really expect to be able to have EXTREMELY strict control over what my CPU is doing. This is my computer and my electric bill and my time spent setting this up. If I want BOINC, on my computer, to run certain things or set certain limits, it should be possible. It boggles my mind that it appears not to be. I expect BOINC Manager to be like an htop for distributed computing. I want to be able to press buttons, kill things, change priorities or do pretty much anything. Is this really not possible? I realize not everyone thinks the way I do, but if using BOINC means letting BOINC do whatever it wants on my PC without me having much of a say, then I'll have to uninstall it.

When it comes to the things in life that I spend my own money to buy, I have a very extreme complex about retaining strict control over those things. People sometimes tell me I should lighten up and they might be right. But to me, I don't need/want any settings of any of my tech to be "in the cloud" and everything that is in the cloud is, to me, a security vulnerability. I'm fine with the data coming from the cloud, but not control of how the software on my computer operates. Both because of the security considerations and also just the general fact that I am not willing to log into accounts on websites just to configure the computer that I own. (Are you guys OK with that?)

However I just want to point out that I am posting this not so much to complain, but rather because for all I know there are actually overrides that allow me to control things like resource share, and I just haven't figured out how to do it.

Am I just missing something?

Thanks


r/BOINC • • Feb 11 '16

LIGO discovers gravitational waves, congratulations Einstein@home

Thumbnail
theguardian.com
6 Upvotes

r/BOINC • • Sep 22 '26

BOINC down?

6 Upvotes

It keeps reconnecting here. It connects, then drops again.


r/BOINC • • Jan 11 '22

How much potential is there for pay-as-you-go serverless scientific computing?

Thumbnail self.gridcoin
4 Upvotes