r/AutoModerator • [Δ] • Sep 17 '17

AutoModerator issues this weekend

As many of you have noticed, AM has been having issues where it misses items, or fails to take all of the appropriate actions on a given item. These issues have, for reasons not yet fully understood, greatly increased over the past few days. I've just rolled out an urgent change which will hopefully act as a stop-gap to improve things.

I have more thorough changes planned for rollout on Monday. My hope is the stop-gap I just pushed out will tide things over until then.

Sorry for all of the recent trouble. I know many of you greatly depend on AM. I won't let this drop until things are improved and AM is acting reliably.

Edit: The more thorough change has been rolled out as of ~1200 PDT / 1900 UTC today (2017-09-18). If you notice any new issues since that time, please drop a comment here to let me know.

44 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

18

u/ShaneH7646 Sep 17 '17

Have you tried turning it off and back on again?

10

u/jippiejee +79 Sep 17 '17

That worked for my milk frother... so why not.

28

u/alienth [Δ] Sep 17 '17

AutoModerator operates in almost exactly the same way as a milk frother.

15

u/Deimorz [Δ] Sep 17 '17

I don't understand why anyone would even bother with a milk frother without full regex support.

5

u/The_White_Light +6 Sep 17 '17

I need to upgrade my milk frother to use regex instead of the re module.

1

u/DragonBard_Z Sep 19 '17

Now i expect more from my milk frother

2

u/ShaneH7646 Sep 17 '17

worked with my cat too.

4

u/2th Sep 17 '17

I'm more a fan of percussive maintenance.

4

u/twilexis Sep 17 '17

Hi :) Something we've observed over in GoneMild is that all the posts AutoMod isn't catching are unverified submitters who upload to i.reddit. Not sure what that means but figured you'd want to know.

1

u/alienth [Δ] Sep 18 '17

I saw you had some issues earlier. Do you have any examples of it missing unverified posters since I made this new post?

1

u/twilexis Sep 18 '17

I'm not home at the moment but I'll find some examples and reply as soon as I'm at my PC.

2

u/Austion66 Sep 19 '17

Hi /u/alienth,

I was checking spam in /r/psychology and our automod is still triggering removals based on the letter s. No worries if y'all are still working on it, just wanted to let you know we're still seeing issues.

3

u/alienth [Δ] Sep 19 '17

This is actually a behaviour change in how the regex engine works. In short, you have a unicode regex which includes the long-s letter (ſ). The long-s letter matches successfully with the normal character s in a case-insensitive search, because the capital of ſ is S.

The rule in your config to fix this is commented as Latin Extended-A. To fix it, simply add the case-sensitive modifier to the rule, like so:

title+body (regex, includes, case-sensitive):

A fun demonstration of this problem: if you Ctrl-F for the character ſ in chrome, it will highlight every s in the page.

1

u/Austion66 Sep 19 '17

Thank you so much for the help!

9

u/_ihavemanynames_ +83 Sep 17 '17

Thanks for keeping us informed! I'm glad you're working on the issue.

6

u/theothersophie +16 Sep 17 '17

So that's why I came back to a page full of spam and reports on my subreddits...thanks for the update

Am's reliability has seemed off for a long time, especially the schedule feature. Hope Reddit addresses this and continues to improve on the tool,

4

u/printf-username Sep 17 '17

It seems to be having string detection issues as well. We've been having issues with one of our link flairs for quite a while. Thanks for working on this!

4

u/Pissmittens Sep 18 '17

Seeing improvement in /r/holdthemoan, /r/realgirls, /r/amateur, & /r/homemadexxx. As of the time of this post, we haven't had to manually flair any posts, and it appears to be catching non-flair related stuff (word/phrase filters, domain whitelist, etc) that was previously slipping through.

A sincere thank you for being so persistent in resolving the problem, /u/alienth. Fingers crossed for tomorrow's deployment!

1

u/gutpocketsucks Sep 24 '17

Automod seems to have been working fine until today, when we had two sequential posts that it missed.

Post 1

Post 2

1

u/alienth [Δ] Sep 24 '17

It didn't miss those, but it is lagged at the moment. Being investigated now.

1

u/gutpocketsucks Sep 24 '17

Ah, no worries then. The changes have overall been very successful, so thank you for all your efforts!

6

u/TonyQuark Sep 17 '17

Thanks!

Bring back /u/Deimorz

3

u/V2Blast +38 Sep 18 '17

AutoMod seemingly missed at least 1 or 2 posts in /r/SampleSize earlier, but this one was quite noticeable: this post was made 5 hours and 45 minutes ago, but wasn't removed by AutoMod for not having the required tags until 22 minutes ago.

Thanks for working on this issue. Hopefully you guys can figure out the problem soon.

3

u/pcjonathan Sep 18 '17

While it's great that you're looking into this, I gotta say that we've been noticing this for many months. Even on a good day, it's taken minutes for a post to be enacted upon (which sucks for filtering due to spoilers) so it's a little sucky that this is only about this past weekend.

And the worst part is that something as simple as a filter API doesn't exist despite being requested for years. I mean.... It can't be THAT hard to add but without it, it keeps us heavily dependant on AutoModerator.

3

u/CosmicKeys Sep 18 '17

Thanks for the dedication to getting it done.

If you're wanting us to update you about further failures, r/hmmm is an easy place to check. All titles should exactly be "hmmm" so it's obvious when one slips past AM.

5

u/Greypo +0 Sep 17 '17

<3

6

u/awkwardtheturtle Sep 17 '17

a wild greypo appears

4

u/root_su Sep 18 '17

a wkward turtle appears

2

u/adeadhead Misleading title Sep 17 '17

Thanks alienth!

2

u/orochi Sep 17 '17

if this at least catches half the stuff it's been missing until the more thorough patch is rolled out, you will forever be my third favourite admin behind /u/ocrasorm and /u/kethryvis

2

u/DuckOfDuckness Sep 18 '17

For situations like this it would be really handy if we had a way to tell AutoModerator to check a post it has missed. Kinda like we have "retry thumb" for link posts.

2

u/Br00ce Sep 18 '17

Oh wow you're back at Reddit alienth? That's awesome. You were one of my favorite admins back in the day. Super glad you're back!

1

u/ani625 Sep 18 '17

Thanks for the update.

1

u/ladfrombrad Sep 18 '17

I had to be a bot this weekend after Adolf Meanie posted the OP, but missed its accompanying top level stucky comment.

Thanks for looking into this! beep

1

u/ixfd64 Bots rights advocate Sep 18 '17

I was wondering why an incorrectly titled post didn't get auto-removed in /r/TIFU. I'm guessing this is the reason.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '17

Thanks for the update. I notice "he" will send the approval, but not post as promised.

I know he used to drink a lot, so, maybe it's catching up to him.

1

u/error23_ +0 Sep 21 '17

Everything smooth now on /r/PhotoshopRequest. It seems like you did it. Thank you!

1

u/devvydowner Oct 04 '17

Hey there /u/alienth, I know I'm a bit late to this party but a day or two ago our AM on r/AnimalCrossing just gave up completely on posting it's regularly scheduled posts, I'm wondering if/suspecting maybe it has something to do with the issues related to this thread? Any help would be greatly appreciated! Thank you!