Hi Reddit! Tone intention: warm, friendly, seeking kind validation, practical tools, and any explanations or perspectives you may be able to provide 🙂
(Context: I work in education/human services/social services my whole career. Irate clientele and complex situations are normal)
This is the pattern I keep hitting across multiple (if not all) jobs examples below:
Hello Supervisor, 🙂 (tone/intentions: warm, friendly, professional) I have finished the outreach list, my morning case notes are in, and the improvement plans are prepped. Once I've gotten calendar confirmation from the clients (see attachment), we can schedule an on-campus appointment or Zoom. May I have confirmation that you see my case notes are in, and that the master calendar is accurately reflecting the times?
May I also have a calendar invite, please, for us to check in on protocal for those two clients with extenuating circumstances? I have space Thursday morning or Friday after lunch, but if a time on my schedule fits better, please go with whichever works best. All the best, Employee
Example Response: (typically comes within a few hours later, or the next day):
Hello *employee’s name,*
Thank you for this information. I can confirm that your notes are in and that the scheduling reflects accurately. And yes! I want ITS to fix our scheduling software soon as well!
Warm reguards,
*supervisor name*
Hello Superivsor, 🙂 (tone/intentions: warm, friendly, professional, and seeking clarity) Thank you for your affirmative response! I had a question in my prior email I'd like to follow up on: May I also have a calendar invite, please, for us to check in on those two students with extenuating circumstances? I have space Thursday morning or Friday after lunch. I am also flexible to where you see oepnings on my calendar.
Respectfully, employee
Silence. About 80% of the time. If I'm lucky I get a thumbs-up reaction, which tells me nothing, my questions aren't yes/no. Does a 👍 mean "received," "will answer later," or "that's your whole answer"? So I wait the standard 24–48 hours and follow up again, gently, to the same thread, including: "If your schedule isn't able to accommodate our check-in, who should I go to next for this consultation?" Silence again. I often give up here. I asked two weeks in advance, knowing it would take advocacy to get an answer, as most requests go.
A few days after my follow ups. I give up and handle it myself, or ask a collegue or a more understanding supervisor. But now recently group emails start to go out to the whole office about "being mindful of professional conduct in written communications" and "respecting people's time by waiting the full 24–48 hours between communications." Which I'm literally doing? Meanwhile my emails/messages on other topics get replies within hours. Anything requiring a check-in, a direct conversation, or problem-solving? Silence. So naturally I don't feel the group email applied to me. So I try a different way.
I approach my supervisor in person. They were happy to see me, says they have 15 minutes to spare when I asked directly if they had a moment to talk. I reiterated my questions, directly from my email. Before I could even finish my first sentence, she immediately directs me to confirm if I've read the group email, and asked me to confirm before continuing our verbal conversation. I confirmed, verbally and in writing. I showed her my timestamps, and referenced the policies in the employee handbook. They didn't beleive and checks, sees on their screen. When they see that I did reply with confirmation, they get flustered, states an emergency meeting, and tells me to leave their office. When I ask if there's someone else I can consult on the clients, I'm shown the door and left with - "Please re-read the email with written expectations and guidance on professional communications and proper supervisory structure. We will follow those only those expectations moving forward." Cue another email to the group before the end of the business day.
Day of: I don't have the guidance, so I follow protocol and ask the on-call supervisor. It took 10 minutes, if that, and the work got done. That's how I've had to work this whole position: no guidance after asking multiple times, so I get help in the moment from the on-call supervisor or the senior employee on the floor. Apparently not protocol until that moment.
Eventually I'm pulled into a one-on-one where my writing and verbal communications are "showing a pattern of unprofessional and insubordinate behavior." HR does the same thing my supervisor did. They were both in the same room. My supervisor says nothing, and has HR do all the talking.
Me: "May I have an example or an explanation for how my email and spoken conduct was received, please?
" HR/Supervisor: smiles and giggles, looking back and forth at each other "Please re-read the expectations. Once those are followed, we can address your concerns."
Me: "I understand. I would like an example so I can improve. I have read the expectations. I felt I have followed them, if you check the timestamps and my tone indicators. I started asking back at the start of the month. I am still uncertain how this pertains to me and where I can improve? I am open to an honest conversation to repair this misunderstanding."
HR/Supervisor: more smiles and giggles "Please re-read the expectations for professional communications and focus on only work-related tasks, moving forward."
Me: "I am feeling frustrated that I am asking a direct question and still not getting an answer. You are repeating the same phrase. I would like some context, please."
HR/Supervisor more smiles and giggles: "Please re-read the expectations for professional communications and focus on only work-related tasks, moving forward. If you are feeling frustrated, you can take leave and come back tomorrow, bu the expectations are still the same, and we expect you to follow them like everyone else."
So my workaround becomes a problem too. Going to the on-call supervisor or an experienced colleague gets added to my "continued pattern of unprofessional communications and insubordination of the proper supervisory structure." Apprently, for coaching. Those colleagues should have redirected me, and I should have known better. Even though they vouched for me and confirmed I followed protocol. There's a group email about this, yet again. Going to everyone about, "following proper supervisor and employee structure, redirect all requests to the employees desginated supervisor."
For the record: zero performance issues. My coworkers love me and know I'm reliable. Clients request me over other teammates. I asked for a performance review the whole time — those requests were left on read too. I never once received one.
Some coworkers tried to explain it to me. I don't know if I understand it:
Apparently, management will never help, because the moment they help, they're accountable to it, and helping one employee means they'd have to help everyone who sees it happen, which opens liability for favoritism, budgeting limitations, and legal issues. It's operationally easier to make the employee the problem, build a case, send group messages so it seems like more than one person has the issue, and repeat vague expectations and redirect to one's supervisor instead of naming the actual problem behavior. For the 24/7 operational services we provide, they lose nothing by firing me and putting in someone who learns quickly that the culture is to not ask for help. Apparently the trade off is just suffer and struggle until they figure it out alone, or they're content in producing subpar services? Their advice is that I need to be more subtle about getting help, instead of asking directly.
But how??? I honestly don't know what to do with that explanation in my situation.
I know positive language works, I used it when I taught high school and young adults with behavioral needs. "Please walk in the hallway, not run" works for most. But when the behavior continues, I had to be specific: give an example, explain why it matters, and then implement consequences or problem-solve the underlying need. What I never did was repeat "please walk" smiling, over and over again until they the comply.
If someone had consulted me, it would have taken 15 minutes at most to review my draft support plan and give some feedback. Instead I got the answer elsewhere and got asked why I didn't go through my supervisor first. Like… this is why!
How it plays out over my career: I keep a job 2–3 years before this cycle repeats, until I'm bullied and targeted enough that I quit for my own well-being. If they use the clients needs against us, I have pushed myself to the point of needing hospitalization. Getting accommodations is a battle. This last job, I held my ground, got the accommodations, had everything in writing, used my best coping strategies, and was fired anyway. They listed every conversation as a "coaching attempt" and mischaracterized them into a false narrative.
I'm trying to reflect on what I can do better next time, for myself and in the next job, without thinking this was entirely my fault...
The one wild card factor is my tone, and voice during verbal communications. Mainly because I don't feel like I can accurately self-assess how others may be perceving me. The supervisors that knew how to work with me, my collegues, and my clients all give me great feedback on how I handle myself, even in conflict, or really stressful client interactions.
Yet I've been told that the reason I'm given expectations in writing is that I continually demonstrated and openly disclose a "frustrated, reactive and willful objection the provided communicated directions. Employee was provided expectations, in writing, and verbally directed to re-read them numerous times."
My asks:
Validation: Does anyone else experience this? Part of me needs to know it's not just me, while also taking honest responsibility for my part. From what I'm gathering, this is common in a lot of workplaces and something I may need to accept and cope with long-term. I don't attribute it entirely to being AuDHD, but it flavors my experience through a different lens.
Distress tolerance: The uncertainty builds up until it affects me physically (meltdowns, crying). I'm making progress, but staying regulated while still performing in the moment is hard. Walks and breaks aren't always long enough — I'm working on lengthening my "bridges" so I can make it to lunch, clock-out, or a safe space. What helps you cope in the moment, at work?
Tools and templates: I love Goblin Tools and run drafts by trusted colleagues, but my communications still get read as unprofessional/insubordinate by supervisors — because they're human, not a robot. Go figure. Have you found tools, scripts, or templates for workplace emails? Ways to get your writing assessed? I use dictation a lot — any suggestions?
Explanations: If anyone understands why workplaces communicate like this, I'd genuinely love to hear it. What cues did I miss? My coworkers offered their theory (accountability avoidance?) but it still doesn't compute — is that actually the logic people operate on? I love hearing explanations for the unspoken workplace rules I seem to miss.
Impact: I feel like I am in a different reality entering into "Workplace Mode" and I need a map. I got fired instead of quitting this time. I had my accmodations approved. I used my coping skills. I really felt good about this one. Documented everything. So it feels like it is getting worse, and has a larger significant functional impact to my ability to live my life. I have never been fired, I have just quit before it got too bad, or shortly after hospitalization. I did need hopsitalization again the time, around, but they fired me before I could find another job. Now I have been fired and that will be a mark on my employment history. How do I navigate this without disclosing anything that could make geting a job even harder than it already is? I am trying to frame it as a learning experiance to ward off the existential and self-loathing demons.
Thanks for reading my novel. Most appreciated. 🙂