I move that, in the Guardian amendment, "Repealing this section of the constitution will require a 66% vote in favour." be changed to "Repeal this section of the constitution will require a 50% vote in favour."
I move that, in a separate amendment, the entire Guardian amendment be repealed.
In light of recent events, I am proposing action to address ongoing disruptive behaviour that is negatively impacting our community. Specifically, this petition concerns the actions of Jordology:
There have been persistent issues with Model-Jordology antagonising others, particularly the canon opposition government.
Model-Jordology has repeatedly blurred the line between meta and canon interactions, causing confusion and frustration.
Excessive focus on the simulation has led to inappropriate behaviour, including unwanted private messages to multiple community members.
These actions are affecting the integrity of the sub and causing several players to consider leaving.
I propose the following constitutional amendment:
Add to section 4:
"u/Model-Jordology and any of their alternative accounts are refused use of the simulation."
This proposal is not made lightly. However, given the history of similar issues and the apparent inability to separate meta and canon interactions, I believe it's necessary for the health of our community.
I invite community discussion on this matter. Would you support this petition to ban Jord?
Let me get this straight off the bat. This is not an apology.
Just minutes ago a vonc was launched in me. For those out of the loop, this was over my decisison to mute a bunch of users for use of the word "tw*nk".
For starters, I am disgusted by the members who rather than attempting to have a good faith discussion about this issue, instead decided to mock it and as such they were muted. Many of these users began swearing at me and chased me onto the MNZP discord and tagged me there using the aforementioned word directed at me. I cannot believe that members would think that is ok. For context, I have made the call to remove this word as it, and I quote a user who agrees that this word should go, "describes a genre of gay porn featuring young skinny hairless gay men". I don't see any reason why this word should be allowed to be used and as such I made the call to remove it.
The Vonc calls out double standards in the moderation team. I cannot deny that there is a large discrepancy between the managers and how we decide. This was made aware to me especially following the last appeal by toby. This issue is currently trying to be fixed but it is slow going. That said, I believe that I have at no point been inconsistent in how I have acted, and that at all times I have acted in line with my rights and duties of the Code of Conduct and Constitution.
I will accept a vonc if it passes but I do not believe that I have done any wrong in this case.
My apologies for being late with this, but it came to my attention that Griffonomics had engaged in provocation, and breached the Discord Community Guidelines that this simulator needs to abide by, due to denying crimes against humanity. As the Discord Community Guidelines say:
These guidelines explain what isn’t allowed on Discord. Everyone on Discord must follow these rules, and they apply to all parts of our platform, including your content, behaviors, servers, and apps.
And, as they further say:
Do not use hate speech or engage in other hateful conduct. This includes the use of hate symbols and claims that deny the history of mass human atrocities.
I will present the evidence for this, as well as the reason why this ban is 14 days.
As a bit of extra context to my dear readers, the subject of the conversation was the 'Dirty War' of Argentina, who's perpretators are being tried for Crimes Against Humanity as well as Genocide. Denial of the gruesome reality of the war, which saw 9,000 to 30,000 killed due to state terrorism. You can read a summary of it here by Wikipedia: Dirty War - Wikipedia
Essentially, this is not at all something to provoke people with by saying a supporter of the actions were 'based', and is reasonably seen as a denial of the history of mass human atrocities.
We have established that Griffonomics has deliberately and egregiously provoked CM, and due to his previous warning about provocation, he should, according to the Code of Conduct get 7 days only.
However, something to consider is that Griffonomics has previously broken that denial of the history of mass human atrocities rules previously. This included a recent 12 hour mute for denying the nature of atrocities committed against indigenous Australians, as shown by this image:
There are also other images that I can release upon request, but I am too tired to right now and I feel my point has been made clear.
The role of the Guardian is not to be an active moderator of the community and to simply be available in cases of emergency, when needed for the health of the simulation. The role of the Guardian is not to be an additional mod. Youmaton has continously been an active moderator of the AustraliaSim community, and is, in my opinion, unfit to be a guardian of the community, unless there is a commitment to take a step back from an active role in managing community behaviour.
The majority of the community want someone who will intervene in an emergency, as well as upon the request of a moderator. Currently, the Head Moderator and the Community Moderator are the only ones can actually ban people, and the Head Moderator is the one who 'makes the final decisions'.
- NGSpy on the results of the meta opinion poll on the role of the guardian
For these reasons, I seek a vote of No Confidence in /u/Youmaton as Guardian.
By their own admission on Discord the mods are breaking the constitution by delaying the double dissolution election till May 20 and Youma as Guardian is enabling it.
Whilst I am sympathetic to the real life reasons behind it, this is still an unacceptable overreach of powers and should be distressing to all members, if a want for a delay is still there, fair enough but put it to a vote at least.
Following an Action by Youma to ban WW yesterday, I am handing down a punishment.
WW will be banned for 5 days (backdated to when the ban was made). This is for a few minor incidents which together warrant a ban. Those incidents are; the incident highlighted here, a post which was part of the events that led to the earlier punishment handed to Max, and other behaviour circa the 20th of june.
Appeals by mod mail. Sentence ends at 7pm on the 4th of july.
New text is bolded, removed text is stricken. I've removed all the examples here because they're unnecessary for the purposes of this post but they'll obviously stay in the meta constitution.
Amendments
Amend Section 7 of the meta constitution to read as follows —
7 - Moderation Team
(1) This Moderation Team is a group of fourthree members (Moderators) that manage key aspects of the community, comprising—
(a) the Head Moderator; and
(b) the Election Moderator; and
(c) the Parliamentary Moderator**.**; and
(d) the Community Moderator.
Eligibility requirements
(2) The Head Moderator and Community Moderator must be 18 years of age or older.
(3) The Election Moderator and Parliament Moderator must be 17 years of age or older.
Powers of the Moderation Team
(4) The Moderation Team may overrule any person acting under this Meta Constitution.
(5) Moderators are members of the Electoral Commission.
Appointment of Moderators
(6) A member of the Moderation Team (a Moderator) is appointed through a Meta Referendum which returns 65% approval.
(7) Moderators must face a Meta Referendum every 6 months which must return 65% approval.
Amend Section 8 of the meta constitution to read as follows —
8 - Head Moderator
(1) The Head Moderator is responsible for all aspects of the community**,** and for the oversight of the operations of the community under this Constitution~~.~~, and for the moderation of the community and its members.
(2) The Head Moderator can—
(a) act as any other Moderator when required; and
(b) overrule anyone acting under a Meta Rule.
(3) However, the Head Moderator cannot overrule the Moderation Team.
(4) The Head Moderator can make a Meta Rule prescribing matters—
(a) required or permitted by this Meta Constitution to be prescribed by a Meta Rule; or
(b) necessary or convenient to be prescribed for carrying out or giving effect to this Constitution; or
(c) if a Meta Referendum approves the Meta Rule.
(5) The Head Moderator may make Meta Rules with respect to—
(a) community management and conduct;
(b) membership, including application, refusal and withdrawal;
(c) permissions, access and roles;
(d) the role, powers, permissions of Community Managers;
(e) alternative accounts and persons;
(f) the Judiciary and the High Court of Australia, in a meta jurisdiction;
(g) any other similar matter.
Repeal Section 11 of the meta constitution.
Replace all mentions of "Community Moderator" in the meta constitution with "Head Moderator".
The way I see it, the role of the Community Moderator is unnecessary, and there is no reason that matters of community moderation cannot be handled by the Head Moderator. If you agree with me, please second this amendment.
I hav had time to think, and today showed that we r very very lucky to hav Youma in aus sim. Youma works hard to make sure the server is safe. Youma is peaceful wen there is a problem, and is always respectful. Youma is not mean to ppl and is full of kindness.
We r lucky to hav Youma here and we should say thank u.
Thank u Youma for being kind to everyone and looking after everyone.
It's not going to be filled again, and was only created because we had Toby, a former head mod who couldn't be trusted. I believe a Toby-style figure is no longer a problem, and as such Head Mods can be trusted with subreddits (considering they're trusted with literally everything else)
All times on each date 6 PM AEST. If the election is posted late, then the close of the election will be pushed back accordingly. Results will be posted ASAP after the close of polling.
Per the Meta Constitution, the list of voters is available here. Eligible voters are those that registered 14 days prior to the announcement of the election, per s 4(2)(b) of the Meta Constitution i.e. 19 October 2021.
Details of Meta Election
One Head Moderator (65%+ approval required)
The Meta Constitution Amendment to Simplify Meta Votes will be going to a vote alongside the Head Moderator election as well
As this is a Moderation Team position, a nominee must:
Be registered as a member of AustraliaSim; and
Be seconded by seven other members of AustraliaSim.
Any nominee not meeting these requirements cannot proceed to the final vote.
Comment below to nominate. Seconders should reply to the top comment. Nominations must, of course, be accepted, except self-nominations.
Ash has, astoundingly, admitted to sitting on evidence because of his "conflict of interest." (Anyone who wants to see the messages in question, which he posted in #a-meta-affair, can either check there or DM me).
This essentially amounts to sitting on his hands and hanging Perekai out to dry, forcing him to work through a thirty page, legalistic appeal document on his own. This has directly resulted in Toby being unbanned far sooner than he should be, because no evidence was presented to Runas.
In excluding himself because of a "conflict of interest," Ash has done To by far more favours than he would've if he was involved in the appeal. He has got to go.
Now apparently some people don't understand how superseding documents works, and believe this handbook (from 2019) was written to clarify a document from 2021. As time travel does not exist, this position is deranged. To ensure such meta wankery cannot happen again, I hereby propose that the entire AustraliaSim Political Party Handbook be repealed.
WW will be permanently banned for repeated high level abuse.
Last night he very strongly abused a member, as well as telling that user and others to kill themselves. When confronted about this behaviour the user doubled down on their actions.
WW has recently served a sentence which itself incorporated a suspended sentence of 100 days. In that post I noted that the user had pledged to act better. This has not occurred and instead the user has acted worse than ever.
Given all this, it is my opinion that WW's attitude and behaviour will not improve, and that any remorse that has been shown or will be shown in the future will either be shortlived or false to begin with.
It is for this reason I have decided to permanently ban Winston.
Due to events that proceeded the banning of /u/nivea_chapstick, we have handed down a 7 day ban to /u/Griffonomics for Vexatious Complaints, impersonating another other Members and giving false information in an investigation. This is an extremely generous ban because I am only handing down a 7 day ban for the first incidence of Vexatious Complaints.
The Code of Conduct on these matters state:
Also in the Discord Community Guidelines, it states:
Do not share false or misleading information (otherwise known as misinformation). Content that is false, misleading, and can lead to significant risk of physical or societal harm may not be shared on Discord. We may remove content if we reasonably believe its spread could result in damage to physical infrastructure, injury of others, obstruction of participation in civic processes, or the endangerment of public health.
Evidence of this is attached here (with commentary on request of community managers and Griffonomics, quite rightly). All this evidence is in chronological order.
Context: This happened at the time where /u/nivea_chapstick was banned permanently, and I requested that all leaders and contacts do indeed get rid of him from the server.
This evidence therefore concludes successfully that Griffonomics committed the three breaches described at the beginning of the post, and thus the 7 Day ban is appropriate.