r/AustraliaSimLower • u/General_Rommel • Nov 06 '17
Concluded 501b - Code of Conduct Bill 2017 - Second Reading Debate
Order, order.
Debate will now commence on the Bill 'Code of Conduct Bill 2017'
Bill details
Bill history
Time allowed: 48 Hours
Time Ends at 6PM 8/112017
Hon. General Rommel MP
Speaker of the House
1
u/General_Rommel Nov 07 '17
Mr Speaker,
It has come to my attention that there are some minor flaws within this Bill that needs to be corrected. Therefore I move notice that I intend to move amendments to the following sections to correct certain errors, and any more in which may be noticed between this speech and later:
Wording of s 3
Use of 'Historical' in s 5(1)
Reference to the Constitution in s 4
Reference to the 'to be superseded' CoC in s 5(2)
Clarifying the title of s 9 to be less ambiguous
Clarifying the meaning of alternative account as given in s 9 (definition of 'alternative account')
Clarifying the nature of s 9 by delineating dual purpose of s 9
Adjusting the wording of s 12 to increase consistency of the section
Clarifying that the subsections of s 13 mean to include 'multiple times', and that 'charged' is to also include 'conviction', and that 'charged' is should be 'accused'.
Fixing 'prosecution' to 'complainant' in s 14
Clarifying s 14 to read 'had the intention to commit the act'
Clarifying that the penalty for all offences is to be applied 'per offence'.
Clarifying the requirements for the defendant to raise a defence as given in s 27
Clarifying the concept of 'exclusion' for defences as per s 28
Removing redundant word 'charged' in s 29(3)
Fixing 'was' to 'were in s 31
Adjusting the way in which s 31 is written
Replacing 'outlawed' with 'repealed' in s 32
Replacing 'case' with 'claim' where appropriate
Clarifying operation of s 35(2) to avoid the use of 'to avoid any doubt' and to make clear that the person making a claim doesn't need to show that they were affected.
Replacing 'High Court of Australia' with 'High Court of AustraliaSim'
Replace 'should' with 'may' when it comes to Judiciary members and recusals.
Ensuring coverage of all offences changed rather than just 'offence' in s 44(1)
Removing gendered language in s 47
Adjusting s54(3) to also include 'offences' in its coverage
Clarifying meaning of s 56(1)
Clarifying s 60(1) to mean 'confidential'.
Allowing, when banning or muting, to apply it to certain areas of jurisdiction.
And any additional amendments to be made.
Hon. General Rommel MP
Member for Banks (IND)
1
u/General_Rommel Nov 08 '17
Mr Speaker,
I also note the following incoming amendments that need to be made:
The word 'crime' should be replaced with 'recidivism' in s 73(2)
The language of s 74 is to be clarified
Emphasising that the court 'must' consider matters in s 75
Fixing an error in s 75(2)(a)
Fixing lack of comma in s 75(2)(b)
Adding whether defendant has breached ADR or not in considering aggravating or mitigating sentences per s 75(2)-(3)
Fixing spelling error in title of s 76
Clarifying that the sentence should be imposed for every offence 'for which' the defendant has been found guilty, per s 77
Add an ending to s 78 to emphasise that in sentencing person with multiple guilty offences, that it is to be served in addition to any other previous sentences
Clarifying s 84 to avoid circular definition of suspended sentence
Adjusting s 86(2) to mean 'a court must not order a suspended sentence'
Clarifying language used in s 87
Removing redundant 'does' in second line of s 88
Replacing 'for' with 'of in the first line of s 89
Clarifying that breach of offence whilst having suspended sentence means suspended sentence to be added to time served in s 89
Adding 'of the defendant' at the end of s 90
Clarifying in s 93(2) that the period concerned is the four weeks immediately preceding the claim
Removing redundant word 'particular' in s 94
Removing unnecessary filler words in s 94
Clarifying requirement that Parliament is to approve certain sentence within two days in s 94
Clarifying language in s 96
Adding semicolons and adjusting full stop in s 97
Changing 'penalty' to 'consequences' in relation to s 99
Fixing improper word, from 'is' to 'are' in the second line of s 99(1)
Fixing improper link to the wrong section as contained in s 100
Removing the word 'criminal' in s 101(1)
Making minor clarification that sentence is 'handed down' in s 102
Allowing appeals even if Full bench of HCA heard the case in first instance in s 103(1)
Clarifying it is not possible appeal an appeal in s 103
Simplifying language in s 103(2)
Remove redundant language in s 104
Avoid gendered language in s 104
Removing 110(1)(b) and 38(1)(b) as it is inefficient
Remove second sentence as is redundant, in s 114
Ensuring consistency of referring to 'the Court' in s 117
Simplifying language to read 'concerning procedure' in s 119
Tightening language in s 126
Clarifying language in s 127 and removing redundant second sentence
Clarifying language in s 128
Adding new section to forbid lawyer representation for any offences heard in this act
Hon. General Rommel MP
Member for Banks (IND)
1
u/BellmanTGM MP for Robertson | Liberal National Party Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17
Mr Speaker, Justice will be served!!!
1
Nov 06 '17
Mr Speaker,
I see no issue with this bill. It has my full support. I believe special recognition is in order to the Member for Banks who contributed significantly to this bill. May the Lord bless him and his family.
Thank you.
1
u/General_Rommel Nov 06 '17
+/u/ParliamentPageBot here [to debate 2R of Code of Conduct Bill]