r/AustraliaSimLower • • Nov 06 '17

Concluded 501b - Code of Conduct Bill 2017 - Second Reading Debate

Order, order.

Debate will now commence on the Bill 'Code of Conduct Bill 2017'

Bill details

Bill text

Explanatory Memorandum

Bill history

House First Reading

Time allowed: 48 Hours

Time Ends at 6PM 8/112017


Hon. General Rommel MP
Speaker of the House

1 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

1

u/General_Rommel Nov 06 '17

+/u/ParliamentPageBot here [to debate 2R of Code of Conduct Bill]

1

u/ParliamentPageBot Nov 06 '17

Paging /u/General_Rommel, /u/maiqtheliar42 , and /u/Dicky_Knee to debate 2R of Code of Conduct Bill

1

u/ParliamentPageBot Nov 06 '17

Paging /u/MrUnited12, /u/notkhrushchevsghost , and /u/showstealer1829 to debate 2R of Code of Conduct Bill

1

u/ParliamentPageBot Nov 06 '17

Paging /u/LowKeyUsername, /u/LividMilkTea, and /u/dyljam to debate 2R of Code of Conduct Bill

1

u/ParliamentPageBot Nov 06 '17

Paging /u/LordTrollsworth, /u/BellmanTGM, and /u/Bsharri to debate 2R of Code of Conduct Bill

1

u/ParliamentPageBot Nov 06 '17

Paging /u/BloodyChrome to debate 2R of Code of Conduct Bill

1

u/General_Rommel Nov 07 '17

Mr Speaker,

It has come to my attention that there are some minor flaws within this Bill that needs to be corrected. Therefore I move notice that I intend to move amendments to the following sections to correct certain errors, and any more in which may be noticed between this speech and later:

  • Wording of s 3

  • Use of 'Historical' in s 5(1)

  • Reference to the Constitution in s 4

  • Reference to the 'to be superseded' CoC in s 5(2)

  • Clarifying the title of s 9 to be less ambiguous

  • Clarifying the meaning of alternative account as given in s 9 (definition of 'alternative account')

  • Clarifying the nature of s 9 by delineating dual purpose of s 9

  • Adjusting the wording of s 12 to increase consistency of the section

  • Clarifying that the subsections of s 13 mean to include 'multiple times', and that 'charged' is to also include 'conviction', and that 'charged' is should be 'accused'.

  • Fixing 'prosecution' to 'complainant' in s 14

  • Clarifying s 14 to read 'had the intention to commit the act'

  • Clarifying that the penalty for all offences is to be applied 'per offence'.

  • Clarifying the requirements for the defendant to raise a defence as given in s 27

  • Clarifying the concept of 'exclusion' for defences as per s 28

  • Removing redundant word 'charged' in s 29(3)

  • Fixing 'was' to 'were in s 31

  • Adjusting the way in which s 31 is written

  • Replacing 'outlawed' with 'repealed' in s 32

  • Replacing 'case' with 'claim' where appropriate

  • Clarifying operation of s 35(2) to avoid the use of 'to avoid any doubt' and to make clear that the person making a claim doesn't need to show that they were affected.

  • Replacing 'High Court of Australia' with 'High Court of AustraliaSim'

  • Replace 'should' with 'may' when it comes to Judiciary members and recusals.

  • Ensuring coverage of all offences changed rather than just 'offence' in s 44(1)

  • Removing gendered language in s 47

  • Adjusting s54(3) to also include 'offences' in its coverage

  • Clarifying meaning of s 56(1)

  • Clarifying s 60(1) to mean 'confidential'.

  • Allowing, when banning or muting, to apply it to certain areas of jurisdiction.

And any additional amendments to be made.


Hon. General Rommel MP
Member for Banks (IND)

1

u/General_Rommel Nov 08 '17

Mr Speaker,

I also note the following incoming amendments that need to be made:

  • The word 'crime' should be replaced with 'recidivism' in s 73(2)

  • The language of s 74 is to be clarified

  • Emphasising that the court 'must' consider matters in s 75

  • Fixing an error in s 75(2)(a)

  • Fixing lack of comma in s 75(2)(b)

  • Adding whether defendant has breached ADR or not in considering aggravating or mitigating sentences per s 75(2)-(3)

  • Fixing spelling error in title of s 76

  • Clarifying that the sentence should be imposed for every offence 'for which' the defendant has been found guilty, per s 77

  • Add an ending to s 78 to emphasise that in sentencing person with multiple guilty offences, that it is to be served in addition to any other previous sentences

  • Clarifying s 84 to avoid circular definition of suspended sentence

  • Adjusting s 86(2) to mean 'a court must not order a suspended sentence'

  • Clarifying language used in s 87

  • Removing redundant 'does' in second line of s 88

  • Replacing 'for' with 'of in the first line of s 89

  • Clarifying that breach of offence whilst having suspended sentence means suspended sentence to be added to time served in s 89

  • Adding 'of the defendant' at the end of s 90

  • Clarifying in s 93(2) that the period concerned is the four weeks immediately preceding the claim

  • Removing redundant word 'particular' in s 94

  • Removing unnecessary filler words in s 94

  • Clarifying requirement that Parliament is to approve certain sentence within two days in s 94

  • Clarifying language in s 96

  • Adding semicolons and adjusting full stop in s 97

  • Changing 'penalty' to 'consequences' in relation to s 99

  • Fixing improper word, from 'is' to 'are' in the second line of s 99(1)

  • Fixing improper link to the wrong section as contained in s 100

  • Removing the word 'criminal' in s 101(1)

  • Making minor clarification that sentence is 'handed down' in s 102

  • Allowing appeals even if Full bench of HCA heard the case in first instance in s 103(1)

  • Clarifying it is not possible appeal an appeal in s 103

  • Simplifying language in s 103(2)

  • Remove redundant language in s 104

  • Avoid gendered language in s 104

  • Removing 110(1)(b) and 38(1)(b) as it is inefficient

  • Remove second sentence as is redundant, in s 114

  • Ensuring consistency of referring to 'the Court' in s 117

  • Simplifying language to read 'concerning procedure' in s 119

  • Tightening language in s 126

  • Clarifying language in s 127 and removing redundant second sentence

  • Clarifying language in s 128

  • Adding new section to forbid lawyer representation for any offences heard in this act


Hon. General Rommel MP
Member for Banks (IND)

1

u/BellmanTGM MP for Robertson | Liberal National Party Nov 06 '17 edited Nov 06 '17

Mr Speaker, Justice will be served!!!

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '17

Mr Speaker,

I see no issue with this bill. It has my full support. I believe special recognition is in order to the Member for Banks who contributed significantly to this bill. May the Lord bless him and his family.

Thank you.