Watson Wire
By law, the State Commissioner of Education must intervene in the Austin Independent School District because two middle schools—Burnet and Webb—have received five consecutive accountability ratings of F. The law provides possible actions by the Commissioner, including closing the two schools or replacing the elected school board with a state-appointed board of managers.
I oppose a state takeover of Austin ISD.
Successful schools, successful city.
These children and their families are my constituents, and the success of our public schools is inextricably tied to the success of our city and its future potential.
We want families to stay in Austin. Schools matter.
We want every child to have genuine opportunity. Education is the most powerful opportunity infrastructure a community has.
We want Austin kids to grow up with the skills to participate in the extraordinary economy being built around them. Workforce development begins long before somebody fills out a job application.
We want companies to invest here and create career-sustaining jobs for Austinites. Employers care about the workforce that schools are preparing. They seek a city in which their employees can expect their kids to be well educated.
And I have unambiguously declared that I want Austin to be the best place in America to be a kid.
Accountability and progress
So, what should happen? First, let’s be candid.
We can oppose a state takeover and still ensure accountability.
Five consecutive F ratings at the two schools are unworthy of those children and their parents. They deserve more, and nobody should minimize that.
But accountability isn't just about imposing consequences. It's about producing results. And when those results show improvement, accountability should recognize that, too.
Undeniable improvement is occurring in Austin ISD.
The district has moved up to a B rating. The number of campuses earning an A or B has increased since 2024 by 42%. The number receiving a D or F has declined by 35%. The total number of Title I campuses receiving an A or B increased by 100% since 2024.
AISD Superintendent Matias Segura has implemented significant, systemic reforms since becoming superintendent in 2024 by providing financial incentives for top teachers at high-needs schools, focusing the most intense resources on students needing them, modernizing campuses, and prioritizing schools with historically underserved populations. His actions have been supported by the elected board.
Segura isn't arguing for the status quo. Neither am I.
He believes AISD is on track to have no F-rated campuses within a year. The progress we've already seen from his reform agenda gives me confidence in the direction he's taking.
So, the question leaders should be asking isn't whether there should be accountability. There should. The real question is: What action is most likely to help children?
Parents act. Communities stay together. Progress continues.
There's a path worth pursuing short of the state replacing the elected leadership of an entire school district serving roughly 70,000 children.
And, make no mistake, if the state takes over the district, we can reasonably expect that Webb, Burnet, and other district campuses will be closed.
Texas law gives the parents at Webb and Burnet a powerful voice. If a majority of parents petition for closure, the Commissioner must close the campuses rather than replace AISD's elected board.
That gives this community a path to act instead of simply waiting for something to happen to us. It gives the families most impacted a say in what comes next.
And Austin has an opportunity to do this without breaking these school communities apart.
A brand-new $158 million, state of the art, building is going up right now at Burnet Middle School’s existing site.
Superintendent Segura’s past work gives me confidence that he would develop an ambitious plan that refuses to disperse students from struggling campuses among existing middle schools. I trust him, with the support of the elected board, to create a new school in a brand-new facility that keeps each school community together.
And I believe he will listen to the families and work with the community to fundamentally rethink what surrounds those students and families: academic interventions, exceptional teachers and leadership, mental-health and family support, extended learning opportunities, community partnerships and dedicated support services.
We can expect him to include whatever the evidence tells us these children need to succeed, and we can expect him to listen to the parents most impacted.
Then I think Commissioner Morath should give this plan and the districtwide reforms already underway the time to demonstrate results.
We're not asking the state to suspend accountability. We're asking the state to let results determine what happens next.
Match the intervention to the need.
Good accountability matches the intervention to the need.
The state accountability system has identified a serious problem at two campuses. At the same time, that accountability system and the hard, smart work of the Superintendent, together with board and community support, is showing substantial improvement across the district.
Both facts matter.
Replacing the governance of an entire large school district—a district that has a B rating--is an extraordinary intervention. Before doing that, we ought to ask whether a more targeted intervention can address the campuses that triggered the law while preserving—and accelerating—the strong and steady progress occurring throughout Austin ISD.
That's not lowering the standard. It's asking what action has the best chance of helping kids.
Parents should use the power that Texas law gives them. Superintendent Segura should put forward a bold plan for these children. And Commissioner Morath should give that plan and the successful reforms already underway the opportunity to produce results.
We're not asking the state to look the other way. We're asking it to look at the whole picture.
Hold us accountable.
Measure the results.
Give us the opportunity to prove that local leadership, working with parents and the community, can finish the job.
And let's judge our success by what matters most: how our children are doing.