r/AusLegal • • 7h ago

VIC My landlord entered my rental while I was at work and threw away some of my belongings. What can I do? (VIC)

228 Upvotes

I'm renting a small unit in Melbourne and have been living here for almost two years. Last Thursday I came home from work and noticed a bunch of my stuff was missing from the storage area near the laundry. There were two boxes of old books, some camping gear, a small toolbox and a few personal things I'd kept from my grandfather. At first I thought someone had broken in, but nothing else in the house had been touched. I called my landlord, and he casually told me he'd stopped by with a maintenance guy to check a leaking pipe and decided to clear out some "unnecessary clutter" while they were there. I had no idea anyone was coming, and I definitely hadn't given permission for them to throw anything away

I asked where my stuff was, and he said they'd taken everything to the tip because the storage area needed to be accessible for repairs. When I told him some of those things were important to me, he said I shouldn't have left junk lying around and that he was actually doing me a favour. The really frustrating part is that the boxes were stacked neatly against the wall and weren't blocking the pipe or any access panels. I checked my emails and messages, and there's absolutely nothing about a scheduled inspection or maintenance visit. I do have photos showing how the storage area looked before, plus text messages from him admitting he threw everything away. I've asked him to explain why he entered without notifying me, but he keeps saying it's his property and he's allowed to maintain it.

I'm not trying to stop necessary repairs, and I understand that landlords sometimes need access for emergencies. But this wasn't an emergency as far as I know, and I can't understand how that gives him the right to dispose of my belongings. Some of the items are replaceable, but a few have sentimental value and I can't exactly buy them again. I'm worried about making things worse because my lease is up for renewal in a few months. Would this be something I should take to Consumer Affairs Victoria or VCAT? Should I send a formal written request for compensation first? I've never dealt with a rental dispute before and would really appreciate some guidance on what steps to take and what evidence I should keep


r/AusLegal • • 38m ago

NSW Will my family member go to prison? Any advice truly appreciated

12 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm hoping to get some insight from people familiar with NSW criminal law, particularly sentencing in the Local Court.

Someone I know is due to appear in court esrly next year.. He intends to plead guilty to the following charges:

Negligent driving (no death or grievous bodily harm).

Driving a motor vehicle while disqualified – listed as a first offence.

Failing to give particulars to another driver.

The circumstances are that he drove into another vehicle, causing property damage only. Nobody was injured. After the accident, he refused to provide his details to the other driver because he said he didn't want to deal with police

There are some additional circumstances that concern me:

He has a significant criminal history.

He has served prison sentences for break and enter and GBH in the past few years.

He has previously been caught driving without a licence.

6 months ago, he appeared in court and was found guilty of driving while suspended. He was sentenced for that offence. Despite that previous court appearance, he has now allegedly driven while disqualified. I'm genuinely just trying

Im genuinely just trying to understand how serious this situation is and whether he could realistically be facing prison again.


r/AusLegal • • 21h ago

VIC Incompetent landlord electrocuted me. What do?

381 Upvotes

My landlord insists on doing all of the maintenance at our property themselves even though they're completely incompetent.

They came and installed a door handle next to a light switch. They used 3-inch screws for some reason and naturally drilled them into the wiring, making the door handle live. Of course, I found out when I was electrocuted by the door handle.

I contacted an electrician who came out, repaired the wiring and made it safe again. He's written a short report/certificate explaining what the damage was and that the door handle was live as a result. Another electrician I know personally told me I was lucky to not have been killed. Apparently it could have been that serious.

Consumer Affairs hinted that I should pursue compensation outside of VCAT, so before I lodge at VCAT, just wondering if anyone has any advice.

Thanks in advance.


r/AusLegal • • 10h ago

QLD Brother is schizophrenic, in active psychosis - seeking advice on engaging with mental health tribunal to look into involuntary inpatient care for him

19 Upvotes

My brother is a heroin addict who was diagnosed with schizophrenia about 10 years ago in his early 20s when he was sent to prison for a violent crime.

He served almost 10 years, briefly went back for an unrelated crime, but has been out after the long stint for around 3 years. He's got a long history of criminal activity and has been on and off using.

Overdosed unintentionally and intentionally at least three times in that timeframe. Hospitalised for this at least twice. Burned every bridge now with his immediate family. Has harmed people, and had a restraining order against him from a recent ex.

I tell you this to explain that we feel the history and this most recent episode should be well documented.

We've exhausted the limits of our physical and emotional ability to care for him and he is a very real danger to himself and others, but he will not voluntarily admit himself to a facility.

My sister had to call an Ambulance because he completely trashed her house, was convinced that people were trying to get him and became aggressive towards her boyfriend.

He is currently hospitalised in QLD.

I know that we need to engage the mental health tribunal and that a mental health practitioner needs to provide written support.

Do we just ask the hospital about this when they call about his pending release? Is there a number we should proactively call?

Practical advice on engaging a lawyer and when this is required?

Appreciate any help on how to go about this, thank you in advance.


r/AusLegal • • 6h ago

VIC Want to terminate employment without proper notice for a “valid reason” due to negative workplace culture and practices

6 Upvotes

My contract stipulates that I must serve for a minimum of 2 years in my role & provide at least 2 weeks notice + a week for every year I’ve worked. So far I have worked 1.5 years since the commencement date. Breaching this could result in loss of income & may witthold up to a week of pay.

The place I work at has regularly forced me to work while sick due to lack of shift cover, harrassed with repeated phone calls during days off to cover a shift, and forced to practice my role in ways that are unfaithful & make me complicit i.e. manipulate employee clock times to avoid mandatory break breaches, regularly expected to arrive early and work while not clocked on, regularly expected to clock off and continue working unpaid.

There are likely more things but these are the main issues and happens so often at work to others in the same role, I don’t even know what other inappropriate things they do that cross the line

I was wondering what I can do to leave before the notice period in the contract so I can resign since I’m fed up with my current employment, or what I can do to protect myself legally. There are others in my role that go through the same thing and also want to quit before the notice period.

Please feel free to ask questions


r/AusLegal • • 12h ago

NSW [SYD-AUS]Warning to cleaners – Scrubadubadoo Cleaning https://scrubadubadoo.com.au/ What is the best possible way to tackle this ?

10 Upvotes

Warning to cleaners – Scrubadubadoo Cleaning (Australia)

I want to warn other cleaners and subcontractors about my experience with Scrubadubadoo Cleaning.

They advertise cleaning jobs on platforms such as Facebook and Gumtree, offering what appear to be legitimate cleaning contracts and promising weekly payments.

However, in my experience, after completing the assigned cleaning work and submitting invoices, I have not received payment.

I am also aware of other cleaners who say they have experienced similar payment issues. Despite these complaints, the company continues advertising for cleaners and offering new jobs.

My advice:

\- Be extremely cautious before accepting any jobs.

\- Get payment terms confirmed in writing.

\- Keep copies of all communications, job details and invoices.

\- Do not assume that completing the work guarantees you will be paid.

It is incredibly frustrating to spend your own time, effort and money completing cleaning jobs, only to chase payments for work already delivered.

I am sharing this so other cleaners can do their own research and make an informed decision before getting involved. Please don't let other cleaners end up in the same situation.


r/AusLegal • • 18h ago

NSW What to do when board members steal money from the organisation/club they run?

31 Upvotes

I’m a member of a small community club that is run by a voted board of directors. Several years ago, the club sold its old property and purchased a new one. For argument’s sake, let’s say the old property sold for $5 million, the new property cost $1 million, and a further $4 million was spent renovating the new premises. At the time, the club apparently had no debt. However, after just a couple of years of trading, the club is now reportedly $8 million in debt.

It has since come to light that there are allegations of serious financial misconduct by members of the board, including embezzlement and falsifying financial records. Much of the alleged misconduct appears to have occurred during the renovations, with the expenditure accounting for a significant portion of the club’s current debt.
There are several concerning examples. One board member, for instance, travelled to India to source windows for the renovations at a lower cost. He reportedly returned with more than 100 additional double-glazed window systems that were never used in the project and has refused to explain what happened to them. His argument was that the savings on the reno’s belong to him and don’t count as stealing. This is just one of many alleged irregularities.
The board has since been stood down following an emergency meeting, but the club's members are unsure what steps to take next.
What legal options do we have? Ideally, those responsible should face criminal charges, but the club also wants to recover as much of the misappropriated money and assets as possible, although I appreciate that may be difficult.

There are also concerns that one of the former board members was allegedly overheard saying he intended to have his accountant prepare false documents to make himself appear innocent.

How can we prevent former board members from creating or introducing false records, destroying existing documents or deleting electronic records? What immediate steps can we take to protect the evidence and preserve the club's ability to pursue legal action?

We are a relatively small community with little experience dealing with matters of this scale. Most members have no idea where to begin, what legal or criminal proceedings would involve, or which authorities we should be contacting?


r/AusLegal • • 8h ago

SA SA Work threatening to fire me

5 Upvotes

Location: South Australia

Hey all,

I'm in South Australia and have been off work for almost a year due to illness and injury. I work in local government. My workplace sent me an email stating frustration with the work contract due to my extended absence. That is all well and good as the timing lined up perfectly with my clearance to return to work.

Now, I submit my clearance and they would like me to take another medical. I am happy to attend and complete this but they have scheduled it for a time I'm not available for with 24 hours notice.

I let them know it will have to be later this week as I have a lot to sort out before returning to work (homeless and a lot to sort out due to months in hospital). They have threatened to fire me if I dont attend the short notice appt.

Can they do that? I have provided them with the dates for Thursday and Friday and let them know I am happy to attend, but they are being difficult.

I am in the union so I will speak to them tomorrow morning before the appt time but just looking for other opinions.

Thanks!


r/AusLegal • • 16h ago

NSW Divorce without solicitors?

19 Upvotes

I’ll try to keep it brief. Wife and I have decided to split. We are completely on the same page regarding splitting finances, 50/50 custody of our kids etc. but there’s a few things that we cannot figure out ourselves ie. value of furniture and appliances, how much of my super will need to go to her, how much I’ll need to pay her in child support, how we work out school fees, just stuff like that. We don’t see the point in paying thousands in solicitor fees when we are both happy to be amicable about it all. But yeah, there’s just a few finer details we won’t be able to sort out between us. Is there a way to do any of this without solicitors? If not can we just see the 1 solicitor and work it out together or would we both need separate solicitors?


r/AusLegal • • 59m ago

NSW De facto property settlement in New South Wales – looking for real-life experiences

1 Upvotes

I'm hoping to hear from people in NSW who have been through a de facto separation and property settlement, particularly anyone who has been in a similar situation.

My partner and I have been together for over 7 years and living together for 4 years. During our relationship, we bought a house with the intention of it being our shared home. However, the property is only in his name.

He took care of the purchase payments and didn't want me contributing towards the purchase price. I have, however, contributed financially in other ways and taken on much of the responsibility for running and maintaining our home, including managing the bills, household responsibilities, housework, gardening and general upkeep.

I've also been actively involved in managing his investment properties for around 6½ years. This has included helping with renovations, cleaning and preparing properties, furnishing and setting up Airbnbs and rental properties, and dealing with decision making.

We both owned properties before getting together and have retained those properties separately. Neither was sold or used to fund the purchase of our current home.

I'm now considering separating and trying to understand what the property settlement process might look like in a situation like ours.

For anyone who has been through something similar, were you able to reach an agreement between yourselves, or did you need lawyers or mediation? Did your contributions to the household and the relationship form part of the settlement discussions?

I'd really appreciate hearing about your experiences and how things worked out. I'm not looking for judgement, just genuine insight from people who have been through it.

Thank you.


r/AusLegal • • 12h ago

VIC Help please

7 Upvotes

Posting anonymously as I'm hoping someone might have some advice or experience with something similar.

My husband and I have been separated for around a year, although we've quietly been working on rebuilding our marriage for approximately 11 months.

During our separation, I've had no contact with his children from a previous relationship due to the cirscumstances of our seperation. Since we seperated, their mother has repeatedly made allegations about me to my husband, accusing me of having abused her children, which I strongly deny. She has never contacted me directly. All of her accusations and threats have been directed towards my husband, but they are about me.

To my knowledge, there have been no formal investigations, court proceedings or findings against me, and I've never been contacted by police or Child Protection regarding these allegations.

What makes this particularly difficult is that the allegations seem to be repeatedly brought up whenever my husband makes decisions about his personal life that his ex disagrees with. There have been ongoing threats of legal action against me, communicated to him, and it feels as though these accusations are being used to pressure and control him and interfere with our relationship.

We've kept our reconciliation private because of the ongoing conflict and threats. Recently, his ex became aware that we may be working things out and began demanding information about our relationship, claiming she has a legal right to know.

My husband explained that she would be informed of anything that directly affects their children, but that his private relationship is otherwise his business.

This resulted in further accusations, references to domestic abuse and renewed threats of legal action against me. She has also involved other family members in these threats.

For context, I haven't seen or spoken to his children throughout our separation, we aren't living together, and there are currently no plans to change that. However, it does break my heart to be accused of such things.

I completely understand that allegations involving children need to be taken seriously. However, I'm finding it incredibly difficult to live with repeated accusations and threats, particularly when they seem to escalate whenever my husband tries to establish boundaries or make decisions about our relationship.

My question is, what can I actually do to protect myself legally?

Can someone repeatedly make these allegations and threaten legal action without ever formally pursuing anything? At what point could repeated threats and accusations potentially constitute harassment? Is there anything I can do proactively, rather than constantly waiting for the next threat?

Has anyone in Victoria dealt with a similar situation involving an ex-partner, allegations about stepchildren or threats of intervention orders?

I'm considering seeking legal advice, but I'd really appreciate hearing from anyone who has experienced something similar or has knowledge of how these situations are handled.

I don't want to start a legal battle. I just want to be able to move forward with my life and marriage without constantly feeling like another threat is hanging over my head.

Please be kind. This situation has taken an enormous emotional toll, and I'm simply looking for some guidance.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

Off topic/Discussion Are they obliged in this situation to exempt cancellation fee

28 Upvotes

A Patient booked an appointment with the GP online on Monday for an appointment on Friday. However, the website does not mention anything about AI scribe in the booking terms/privacy policy. But when he got to the GP clinic, there was a noticeboard note that said some doctors are using AI. Once the GP asked "Would you like to consent to AI scribe", the Patient declined it but the GP refused service unless the Patient pays extra money to the GP.

Because it is on the GPs side, are they obliged in this situation to exempt cancellation fees or any fees.

Edit: I can only imagine a GP that adopts new technology for medical devices (defined as the legal regulation, AI scribes not included) the fastest but does not use AI scribes. This is because humans doing scribing are proven and reliable, just like how the US military still uses Windows XP in the late 2010s. This probably is good at avoiding lawsuits while having the latest technology.


r/AusLegal • • 13h ago

WA Micromanaged and critisism in meetings

3 Upvotes

This one isn't for me but a friend of mine. Recently work has been coming down harder on them after a small snaffoo, basically telling manager that they were getting pissed off. Micromanaging has increased 10 fold if not more. And near weekly meetings between them, their line manager and the line manager's manager. It's always presented as a professional conversation but more often than not it flat out criticism, even though the friend is still completing the necessary work, to standards or more. Meetings are always about "supporting them however needed and ensuring everyone is meeting the professional standards and following procedures", however whenever the friend has started to say something or defend themselves, they are literally shouted at.

So, legal question is, if it is a workplace meeting about standards/behavoiur/professional responsibilities, which will more than likely be documented from both the managers sides, is the friend allowed to record the meeting without giving a heads up? Or would all parties need to consent to the recording of each possibly future meetings.

Basicslly they are fed up and feel the manager has dropped the ball with something else going on in the department, so they have become the scapegoat, as they speak their mind.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

VIC My friend was attacked at a bar

89 Upvotes

I am just beside myself upset and angry. A close friend was at an establishment in a smokers area with cameras and security. An old friend approached who is a nasty aggressive person that the group has had to cut off for repeated drunken belligerent behaviour. It was a back and forth about needing to move on. My friend said no I don't want anything to do with you. Then the other girl just swung as hard as she could. The blood was streaming out of her head. Swelling to her face twice the size and left in an ambulance to the hospital for brain scans and to see a plastic surgeon next week. She has a beaten black face with her teeth through her lips too. Surely this other girl will go to prison? Do people that do this sort of violent crimes get off? She wouldn't pay for a lawyer she couldn't afford it. What are people's opinions? Police report made.


r/AusLegal • • 11h ago

NSW Warning to Australian Accor customers – check your currency settings! Misleading pricing in ALL Accor app

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/AusLegal • • 12h ago

VIC Third party car insurance does the assessor check both cars?

1 Upvotes

Hey guys, just wondering if anyone has made a third party property damage claim before.

If you're at fault in an accident, does the insurance assessor check your car as well or just the other person's car?

For example, if your car already had some minor scratches and dents before the accident, would the assessor inspect those as well? But it didnt contribute the accident

Do they normally just ask for photos or actually come out to inspect both cars?

What's the process like from start to finish? Anyone been through this before?


r/AusLegal • • 12h ago

NSW first year law

1 Upvotes

ok this is ambitious to aim for but I'm aiming for a D/HD average in my first year of Law. I was thinking of trying to get ahead. for reference im doing foundations of law, criminal law and contract law for my first semester. how do u do well in these units? I keep hearing IRAC and knowing ur case law examples. after reading someone's notes now im terrified.


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

AUS Posting pictures of students online?

8 Upvotes

Does a school need to capture consent to post pictures of their students on social media platforms?


r/AusLegal • • 1d ago

QLD QLD: Asked for a trade mark quote, received a $605 invoice. Should I reply to the final reminder?

65 Upvotes

I’m a sole trader in Queensland looking to register a trade mark for a startup. After a phone call, I emailed a practitioner saying I would like to engage him to prepare and lodge the application. In that same email, I asked for “an indication of your fees and likely total costs”, specifically including the initial review. I don’t recall him quoting a fee on the call. I wanted to know the price before deciding whether to go ahead.

He acknowledged my email and said he’d look at it. I thanked him. Three minutes later, he sent his comments and fee schedule. At the end of that email, he said that if I chose not to proceed, he would invoice me $550 plus GST for his time to date. That was the first time I saw a price. I gave no further instructions.

He later invoiced me $605. The invoice refers to a costs agreement, but I never agreed to pay for the review and he hasn’t provided the agreement he refers to. He’s now sent a final reminder saying he’ll take recovery action. I haven’t received a QCAT application.

I want to use someone else for the trade mark. Has anyone in Queensland dealt with this? Is there a practical downside to leaving the reminder unanswered, or would it be better to reply once, dispute the invoice and ask him to identify when and how he says I agreed to the charge?


r/AusLegal • • 20h ago

VIC VGSO - IVOs

2 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

I posted over the weekend about an IVO from an ex-boyfriend and I called Geelong station who let me know that the VGSO are taking over the IVO. I cannot find any information on this - does anyone know the reasoning!

Thnx for any help


r/AusLegal • • 16h ago

NSW NRMA charging excess after NAF total loss.

1 Upvotes

Gday guys. Wondering if anyone knows or has experience with this.

A couple of weeks ago driving back from Sydney. An old bloke pulled a u turn in front of my partner's MX5. Her car. I was driving. I am not listed as a driver.

Plugged in all the info. Excess waived. Car has been deemed a total loss.

Received a text from NRMA stating the other party hasn't provided our address and as such we need to pay excess to continue the process.

Is that a thing? We need to cover excess because the other party didn't fully supply our information? We've tried contacting the other party with no luck.


r/AusLegal • • 7h ago

WA Can a retailer be legally required to honour an online order confirmed at $0?

0 Upvotes

I’m looking for some informed opinions on a consumer dispute involving a computer store in Western Australia, and whether I potentially have grounds to pursue the matter legally.

On 13 February 2023, I placed an online order through the computers website for an Austin A40 v4 Gaming Radiant gaming PC.
The specifications included:
Intel Core i7-12700KF
NVIDIA RTX 3080
16GB RAM
1TB NVMe SSD
2TB HDD

The product was listed at $0.00.

I completed the checkout process and received an email titled “Order #83518 confirmed”, which explicitly stated “Thank you for your purchase!” The email included the full product description, order number and a total of $0.00 AUD.

The order was subsequently cancelled the following morning. I never received the computer and no payment was made.

I have retained three screenshots showing:
The original order confirmation email.
The complete product specifications and $0.00 total.
My Austin Computers account displaying the order and the status “All products have been sent”.

Some additional context:
I was approximately 12 years old when I placed the order.
The original Austin Computers Cannington store has since permanently closed.

I contacted the current Rockingham store, but they could not locate my historical order and said the two stores were not connected.

Historical ABN records associate Panlyn Australia Pty Ltd with Austin Computers Cannington.
I also found Panlyn Australia Pty Ltd v Austin Computers Pty Ltd [2023] WADC 80, which discusses a historical franchise relationship between the businesses.
I have since lodged a formal complaint with WA Consumer Protection.
I’m particularly interested in the legal position under Australian law.

My questions are:
Could an email explicitly stating “Order confirmed” and “Thank you for your purchase” constitute acceptance of an offer and formation of a contract?

Does the fact that the transaction was recorded at $0.00 mean there was insufficient consideration for an enforceable contract?

If the retailer’s website accepted the order and generated a confirmation, can it subsequently cancel it on the basis of a pricing error?

If cancellation terms were not clearly presented or accepted during checkout, could the retailer still rely on them?

Does my age at the time (12 years old) affect my ability to enforce an agreement against the retailer?

Could sections 18 and 29 of the Australian Consumer Law provide an alternative avenue, even if a contractual claim is unsuccessful?

If the original store has closed, how would I establish which legal entity is responsible for the transaction?

I’m not claiming that a retailer should automatically have to provide a $3,000+ computer because of a website error. However, I am interested in whether the actual checkout and confirmation process created any enforceable obligations.

I would particularly appreciate opinions from anyone familiar with Australian contract law, consumer law or similar online pricing disputes.

Thanks!!


r/AusLegal • • 21h ago

QLD Obtaining deceased family member's medical records?

2 Upvotes

Has anyone here personally had to go through the process of applying for access to a dead family members medical records? My mum passed when I was a kid and I'm trying to be vigilant about my own health , see if there is some family history of disease or disorder that I should be aware of (that I don't already know of)

She had an unexpected ruptured brain aneurysm in her 40s, but I dont know if she had pre-existing conditions which may have contributed.

I dont actually own a copy of her death certificate, so should I start there first? Are there some bumps that I might encounter during the application process? It's just a lot of information, and Im not sure where to start.

Thanks for anyone who takes the time to respond/share their experience

Edit: Potentially important information: She passed in 2019


r/AusLegal • • 18h ago

NSW Has anyone actually won??

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes