The 2026-27 Budget's CGT reform is being sold as closing a generous loophole. The numbers say the opposite.
Top effective CGT rates across 43 developed economies:
0% (often conditional): Singapore, Hong Kong, UAE, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Georgia, Greece, Luxembourg, Malta, Slovakia, Slovenia, Switzerland, Turkey, NZ
Romania 1%, Moldova 6%, Belgium 10%, Bulgaria 10%, Croatia 12%, Hungary 15%, Poland 19%, Ukraine 19.5%, Portugal 19.6%, Lithuania 20%, Japan 20.3%, Estonia 22%, Iceland 22%
Australia (current, 50% discount) 23.5%, rank 28 of 43
UK 24%, Italy 26%, Germany 26.4%, Austria 27.5%, Latvia 28.5%, US (fed + avg state + NIIT) 28.7%, Spain 30%, Sweden 30%, Ireland 33%, Finland 34%, France 34%, Netherlands 36%, Norway 37.8%, Denmark 42%
Before the reform: Australia is rank 28 of 43. Middle of the pack. Below the UK, Germany, the US, and most of Europe.
Under the new rules, indexation with a 30% floor, no discount, a top-bracket investor pays 47% on a real gain.
After the reform: Australia is rank 42 of 43. Second only to Denmark. Harsher than the US, UK, Germany, Japan, and almost all of Europe.
That's a 14-place jump...
You can argue about these numbers in plenty of ways, OECD vs developed nations, indexed vs nominal gains, top marginal vs effective rates, whether to include state level taxes, how to treat the zero rate jurisdictions. Run any reasonable methodology you like. The picture stays the same, Australia moves from the middle of the developed-world distribution to the harsh end. The reform pairs indexation with a 30% floor and no discount, a combination no comparable economy uses at this rate.
However, people abusing the discount to reduce income tax is a real problem, This policy can be made more intelligent. Just one example:
The abuse the bill supposedly targets, CEOs and fund managers converting their salaries into discounted capital gains through vested shares, can be tackled directly.
Treat any shares received as employment compensation as ordinary income, taxed at the marginal rate. Leave the 50% discount in place for ordinary shares, ETFs, and managed funds bought with after-tax savings. That targets the CEOs without punishing the middle income savers who are already locked out of the property market.
If this matters to you, email your senators. They're the ones who actually decide whether this passes.