r/AttachmentParenting • • Mar 11 '22

❤ Sleep ❤ F U to sleep training culture

615 Upvotes

I just wanna give a shout-out and a big fuck you to whatever algorithms and consumerist society have made it so any time you Google anything sleep related, “reasons my 11mo is waking an hour after being put down” etc, the answer is “stop holding them to sleep, you have to teach them to fall asleep independently”. Like seriously. Fuck off. It’s just false. He’s slept amazing before with being rocked to sleep. Stop filling everyone’s head with this BS so you can sell them your sleep training course. Rant over.

Edit: I just want to say I absolutely by no means am meaning to pass judgment or shame onto those who choose sleep training. I have no issue with sleep training that is working for your family, I just have issue with the sleep training culture telling me I can’t approach sleep in a way that is different even though it works for MY family. Sending love and light to everyone who read this 💕


r/AttachmentParenting • • Jun 13 '24

❤ General Discussion ❤ A pacifier is used as a breast. Not the other way around.

555 Upvotes

I’m a FTM to a newborn and can’t believe how many times I keep hearing “he is using you as a pacifier”, including from the labor and delivery nurses at the hospital. This makes no sense!

The pacifier was invented in the 20th century primarily for bottle fed babies. Isn’t it natural that breastfed babies seek comfort (not just food) at their mother’s breast? It’s been that way for centuries before the pacifier was ever invented.

Why is that looked down on and discouraged by claiming the baby is “using mom as a pacifier”? Maybe babies are doing exactly what they’re supposed to and the pacifier fulfills the role of the breast, not the other way around.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Dec 15 '23

❤ Sleep ❤ My mother told me I was left at 6 weeks to cry it out alone in a room

543 Upvotes

She said it was advice she got from her brother. They left me in a room, closed the door and walked away. She started to do this regularly and said I became a really good sleeper.

Well, I have had dissociative anxiety and depression for most of my life. Seeing babies cry triggers me to the point that I have to leave the area they are in and seek refuge.

With my own daughter I have been there for almost every nap and evening. She is nearly 2.5 years old. She has never needed to cry to sleep and we share a bed. I hope that she will never feel the sense of abandonment I have felt my entire life because of my mother’s ignorance and neglect.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Nov 03 '21

❤ Emotions & Feelings ❤ Can I just say, darn Taking Cara Babies for making me feel like nurturing my baby is bad.

515 Upvotes

I shouldn't need permission to cuddle my baby to sleep. I shouldn't wake her with a cold wash cloth if she drifts off while nursing. I shouldn't feel like I have to sit hidden beside her bassinet as she cries for 5-8 minutes hoping she will go back to sleep. I shouldn't push for my baby to have 12 hours of sleep with 0-1 wakes by just 16 weeks old.

She's a baby. She's my baby. I hate that courses like hers have made me feel bad for doing what my girl needs. Also, she's not a sleep doctor, so forget her.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Mar 12 '21

You. Can. Not. Spoil. A. Baby.

480 Upvotes

I realize I am preaching to the choir but omg, I am so tired of this mentality and it breaks my heart.

I work with moms to help them with breastfeeding. The number of people that say their babies are too clingy, or that they don’t want to hold them too much because they’ll “spoil” them, is just wild.

They have been inside your body for nine months, warm and cozy, in the dark and quiet, and literally connected to your body. Now all of a sudden, they’re disconnected from you, in the loud, bright scary world. Their need for physical contact is just that - a NEED - just like their need for food.

Such a bummer.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Apr 04 '26 Heartwarming

❤ General Discussion ❤ My mom did attachment parenting- I’m turning 21 next month and wouldn’t change a thing

467 Upvotes

Just wanted to hop on here and give everyone some encouragement! My mom (who passed when I was 15) was incredibly committed to attachment parenting (+ cosleeping, babywearing, homeschooling, etc.) I am now about to turn 21 and looking forward to having my own kids in a few years! I am a birth doula and on track to become a student homebirth midwife in a bit, and I truly do not think I’d be where I am without attachment parenting.

If anyone has any questions about what it’s like being an adult who grew up with attachment parenting or how that shows up in my everyday life, please don’t hesitate to reach out! You guys are all rockstars and truly making the world a better place ♥️


r/AttachmentParenting • • Mar 06 '26 Regret

❤ General Discussion ❤ Horrified reading some posts

458 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel utter shock reading what some people are posting (not in this sub) about sleep training, cry it out, etc?

The latest post I just read was someone distraught that their 4 month old needed to be rocked to sleep, would sleep 2-3 hour stretches and wake up needing her pacifier. They decided to do the CIO method.

I’ve seen other posts from mothers who cap their baby’s naps at THIRTY (30) minutes during the day so baby sleeps at night. Describing how it’s working so well even though baby cries throughout the day from being exhausted. Stopping breastfeeding at 6 months and moved entirely to solids so they can go to the gym, and then complaining in another post how their child is hungry all day.

I feel like the expectations on how babies should sleep and act is ridiculous!! I think some of these are genuinely harmful (starving a baby, forcing them not to sleep), and I’m not sure how people can see it as “shaming other moms”. Withholding food and sleep is abuse!

I’m sure this will get deleted but wondering if anyone else feels as deeply disturbed by this content as I do.

Edit: I’m not engaging with these posts in any way or shaming these people on their posts. I know several people with children doing things I disagree with, and I’m sure others would disagree with my parenting techniques. I’d never tell them that I disagree as it’s not my place. Just sharing my thoughts here as I think that’s what Reddit is for! The things I’m describing above are things that I genuinely think are going to harm a child. CIO less so but not providing adequate nutrition or allowing sleep is pretty extreme in my eyes.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Jun 22 '23

❤ General Discussion ❤ I genuinely hate how much people normalize traumatizing their children.

447 Upvotes

I understand that sleep training is sometimes necessary for working parents or those who can't be supportive throughout the night for whatever reason. I know that everyone is just doing their best to keep their family safe, sane and happy. But it still shocks me how people willfully ignore the needs of their child. I came across a discussion of one mom asking if it was normal for her toddler to cry for 20 minutes every night when they close the door after putting her to bed, and everyone in the comments was just confirming that I was normal to let your child scream and cry and become hysterical because "they need to learn how to fall asleep independently" or some bullshit.

If any other time of day your child was bawling and screaming for you then you would be there in a heartbeat. Why is it okay to neglect our children's needs just because it's bedtime? Falling asleep is such a vulnerable thing for these little ones and a lot of them express a need for comfort from someone they love in order to feel safe enough to do it.

I know that "studies show cry it out doesn't have long term consequences" but I just can't shake the idea that closing the door and refusing to comfort your lonely, frightened child every night for months? Years? Isn't going to lead to some serious attachment issues down the line. I just couldn't do it.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Sep 21 '25 Heartwarming

❤ Sleep ❤ The sleep industry is tricking parents

436 Upvotes

It really breaks my heart seeing the sleep training industry tricking parents into thinking that their babies and toddlers should magically not need them overnight. I think it makes parents stop trusting their instincts and get overly focused on their own comfort/ease in parenting, instead of focusing on connection and fostering their own resilience as parents. It makes them see their child as abnormal and in need of cold, formulaic "training" instead of just a normal new human who needs their support.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Dec 15 '21

❤ Attachment ❤ Would I want to be treated this way?

436 Upvotes

I was hardcore sleep trained as a child. I didn't even reach 10 pounds until I was 5 months old because my mom believed I needed to cry it out and didn't need to eat at night. She is proud of how "well her children were sleep trained" to this day.

My son is 5 months old. He wakes up at night. He wants cuddles. He doesn't want to be left alone in a room for long "independent play" sessions. He wants to eat a lot and snack when he is cranky. He wants to hold my hand as he falls asleep. But guess what?

So do I.

I wake up at night and snuggle my husband for comfort. I'm extremely social and don't enjoy being alone. I eat a lot and snack when I am sad or cranky, even if it isn't technically "mealtime." I literally hold my husband's hand as I fall asleep because it comforts me.

Why would I expect my son to be stronger and more independent than I am?

I've wrestled with a lot of guilt and stress over not sleep training, and my family mocks me all the time. But if my husband treated me the way those books and boomers keep telling me I must treat my son, I'd be an absolute wreck! I have a host of anxiety and attachment issues that has consumed my adult years. If there is even a slight chance that my experience as a small child contributed to that, why would I do that to my son? I'm glad this community exists. I'm going home for Christmas and afraid to face my parents, but I'm just going to keep asking myself, would I want to be treated that way?


r/AttachmentParenting • • Jul 22 '20 Take My Silver

Anyone else following the Possums sleep approach?

433 Upvotes

Update!:

For those asking about my experience, I’m going to do my best to concisely explain the main points of the approach, and add my personal experience as well.

Possums is a sleep research institute that focuses on maternal well being, breastfeeding, and infant/toddler sleep (and how these factors intersect). They take a science-based approach to sleep, and I’m told it’s the only approach that is 100% based on real sleep science.

Possums approach to infant/toddler sleep is cue-based. Meaning watch your baby, learn your baby’s cues. No one-size-fits-all approach, just some basic understanding of sleep science, and some tweaks you can make based on what you feel is an issue.

(Disclaimer: I think most everyone subscribed to this sub knows infants and toddlers are meant to wake throughout the night, so please keep that in mind. This isn’t going to be a magic approach that allows your kiddo to sleep for 12 hours straight.)

What are the biological factors that control sleep?

  1. The sleep/wake homeostat: As long as you’re awake, sleep pressure is building. Sleeping relieves that sleep pressure. Adults can be awake for longer, and relieve most/all their sleep pressure at night (bedtime) when there’s a big drop-off i.e. We sleep for 7 or 8 hours and wake up rested and ready for another day (not us moms, I know I know lol). Infants and toddlers can’t stay awake as long, so they need to relieve some of that sleep pressure throughout the day (via naps!) This doesn’t mean they need to have these huge drop offs in sleep pressure throughout the day, but simply taking the edge off the sleep pressure (a 20 minute nap can do this, as some of you have undoubtedly witnessed when your kiddo naps for 15 and wakes up with plenty of energy). Infants and toddlers will also see the biggest drop off in sleep pressure at the end of the night for bedtime.

  2. Circadian Rhythm. I’m sure most of you are familiar. We are creatures of this planet! We are awake with the sun, and asleep when it’s dark.

So here are some bits of the Possums approach in random order based on what I can immediately recall

  1. There is no such thing as being over-tied. To make sure your infant is dialed down (not fussy, cranky, fighting sleep) and those 2 biological sleep regulators can do their job, you should ensure your little one has plenty of nourishing stimulation outside the home (damn you, COVID!!) and nursing/feeding is well established. Nourishing stimulation means sunshine, new experiences, new faces, (all the things COVID has robbed us of lol) but basically take your baby with you on your errands. Stop watching the clock. As long as their brains are stimulated, they are getting sunshine, and they’re fed, those sleep regulators will kick in and they. will. nap!

  2. Daytime naps: Because we are not trying to have this huge drop off in sleep pressure (let’s save that for bedtime!) we should encourage little ones to only take the sleep they need during the day. To do that, we let them nap in daylight with regular daytime sounds around them (no blackout curtains, no sound machine). 15 min nap? Fine. 20 minute nap? Fine. 30 min? 1 hour? Fine! If they wake up horribly upset, you can try to get them down for longer, if not, carry on with the day!

  3. Bedtime: This is when we want the sleep pressure to be high, so I’ve heard Possums parents discuss capping naps at a certain hour (lots of experimentation with naps/bedtime based on your specific child.) Then, their sleep pressure is up, the sunlight is gone and they can get that big drop off and sleep longer stretches at night.

  4. Learn the difference between your baby saying “im bored, let’s do something else” and “im sleepy, time for bed.” For us, bored is fussy. Tired is rubbing eyes, staring off into space.

  5. Get in the habit of waking up at the same time every morning (pick a time that works for your family!) This (done consistently over 1 or 2 weeks) will help the body’s circadian rhythm regulate. Possums always recommends this first to address excessive night wakings.

  6. Don’t fear a later bedtime. Possums research suggests a later bedtime works better for many families (7:30-9pm is very common)

  7. Go with the flow! Practice mindfulness, deep breathing. Do not stress about a missed nap, a later bedtime, etc. Focus on spending time with your baby doing new exciting things (I know this sounds woo-woo but this really helped me!!) All babies are different, the range is really wide in what’s “normal” for infant sleep. Trust your baby will take the sleep they need, and the older they get, the less daytime sleep they will need, and the longer those night stretches will get.

How I have implemented this personally (started at 4 months, son is now 11 months)

We try to wake up at 7:30 every morning (this part is hard but if I notice more frequent night wake ups, then I try to kick my ass back into gear on this front lol)

First thing in the morning, we put him in his high chair by a bright window and have breakfast. Hello circadian clock!!

My son takes 2 daytime naps most of the time, these days he can take 1, we just go with what happens each day based on his cues. If he has less daytime sleep than I expect, I consider doing a slightly earlier bath and bedtime. I never force anything, he sleeps when he’s good and ready because fighting him to nap or go to bed is pointless.

Obviously COVID days have been a challenge, but I still try to get him in the yard, water play, sensory play, a new puzzle, playing with the dogs, visiting grandma, even a play date here and there. Drive in the car, walk around the block, we recently took him to the beach and he loved it. Stimulating that growing brain!

Bathtime can be anytime between 6:30 and 7:30, again based on how the day has been. After bath time he goes to bed within the hour on most days. When he’s not teething, leaping, or mastering some other milestone (he just took his first steps) he’ll wake 1 to 3 times from bedtime to 7:30am and that’s just to dream feed (we bed share).

We experimented with how much daytime sleep is ideal for him at this stage. That’s to say, I wake him up from his naps so he doesn’t sleep more than 2 hours total during the day. Again, that is for our little one, every baby has different sleep preferences and needs. Waking a ton during the night? Try implementing some of the Possums suggestions, and if you’re at your wits end, they offer Skype consultations and the parents I know who have done them have been really happy as they tailor their suggestions to your specific situation (they ask you a ton of questions!)

Happy to answer any specific questions. You can buy their sleep video (I think it's $40? and it's a non-profit institute so it's not some money grab) and see Dr. Pamela Douglas give the overview, and even watch some sleep consults with families. In general I love the holistic approach, I love that they focus on maternal health (I do deep breathing as I nurse him to sleep for bedtime, and in general I'm not stressing about his sleep anymore and that has done wonders for my life.)

x

---

I feel so lucky to have stumbled across the Possums Sleep Clinic through various facebook group conversations (specifically The Beyond Sleep Training Project) and it has really done wonders for my stress and my son's sleep (started when he was 4 months, he is now 11 months). I've since deleted my Facebook (for other reasons) and this subreddit has been a great resource, so I thought I'd try to connect with other parents who may be following Possums.

For anyone interested: https://possumsonline.com/


r/AttachmentParenting • • May 24 '25

❤ Sleep ❤ Permanently banned on sleep train Reddit

426 Upvotes

A mother was asking what she was doing wrong because her 6 month old was waking every 3 hours. I was in her shoes once and felt terrible as a mother because I thought my son wasnt getting enough sleep which would negatively impact his development (which I now know is not true).

I replied wanting to provide her with reassurance and said it’s biologically normal for infants to wake in the night and recommended the nurture revolution by Dr.Greer. That book truly changed my relationship with my son and has made motherhood so much more enjoyable and let me tap into what felt natural for the both of us. That comment banned me which makes me feel sad because why cant we share this information that could potentially help this mother? Sleep training is not right for all families. Idk this is more of a vent but I just wish more parents knew about normal infant sleep instead of what’s all over social media/the dominant narrative. It is not normal for babies to be sleeping through the night. I truly feel if parents were more educated on normal infant sleep, most parents would choose not to sleep train and focus on full body rest so they are able to nurture their babies through their development including sleep.

Edit to add: I should have said-it is not common or should be expected for babies to sleep through the night.

I actually learned about the nurture revolution from the sleeptrain Reddit so I truly didn’t know it would ban me. I learned more about wake windows and daytime routines through sleeptrain so I’m not trying to shame any parents who have sleep trained their babies. Families need to do what works best for them.

I’m a FTM and I naively thought I HAD to sleeptrain my baby because everywhere I looked/everyone I talked to said that babies need to be trained and learn how to sleep independently. There’s a whole page on taking Cara babies guide about how your babies cries will pull on your heartstrings but to stay strong. Every bone in my body felt it was wrong but I had to convince myself that it was what was best for him and his development. I wrote down a pros list and affirmations for when the time came to sleep train because I was so anxious about it. I tried to sleeptrain my baby and I obsessed over preparing him for 2 months making sure he had the PERFECT schedule, feeds, and daytime stimulation/bedtime routine. I felt like I was trying to control my baby and motherhood was very hard during that time. When i finally tried to sleep train using the chair/ pick up put down method, it was the worst 4 days of my life and I’m not exaggerating. The look on my son’s face when he woke up looking for one of us and realizing he was alone is a look I’ll never forget as I watched him from the monitor. We decided on night 5 that we couldn’t continue because his progress wasnt linear during those 4 days and I didn’t want to put him through anymore crying (even if we were in the room and comforting him when his cries escalated) I also knew I wouldn’t have it in me if we needed to re train every few months. After that attempt, I started to learn about infant sleep which I wish I did before I attempted to sleep train.

All this to say I’m not shaming any parents who sleep trained. I’m just sharing my experience and information I’ve learned along the way that truly helped me and my family. I now happily sleep on a floor bed next to my son on his floor crib. We still get our own space but he also gets my comfort when he wants it. Bedtime is now my favorite part of the day even though he wakes every 3 hours and wants some comfort or milk. If this resonates with anyone some resources that helped me:

Books: The nurture revolution, the discontented little baby book, Let’s talk about your new families sleep

Hey sleepy baby, resting_in_motherhood, babies and brains, good night moonchild on instagram

Podcast: spoil your baby by Dr Greer, inside the fishbowl: infant sleep with sleep educator Claire Fagin

I also want to add that I’ve worked with children from 0-10 for over 10 years and before I had my son, I knew nothing about infant sleep. It truly took me by surprise and it took me awhile to discover the other side of sleep training and those resources above.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Oct 06 '23

❤ Sleep ❤ CIO posts break my heart

405 Upvotes

There was a post last night about starting to sleep train an 8mo who had been co-sleeping since 3mo using the CIO method. OP commented this morning that baby had scream cried for an hour and 15 minutes, shrieks and screams the mom had never heard previously. She wrote that she was tempted to go it but “stayed committed, and felt better because [she] knew baby was safe.” I read that and just wanted to cry. Just because SHE knew baby was safe does not mean baby knew that. Can you imagine sleeping next to your baby for 5 months and then suddenly putting them in a dark room alone until they “figure it out” ?????? AHHHH I just can’t. I try to be as open-minded and understanding as possible, I know every parent has a unique situation, but it just feels cruel. I’m currently cuddling my napping 6mo and yes, I’m very tired from her 3 wakeups last night, but I cherish every second.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Feb 14 '26

❤ General Discussion ❤ Can I be a little judgy here?

404 Upvotes

Because I would never speak these thoughts aloud to anyone in real life. Most of my mum friends have sleep trained their babies - you gotta do what you gotta do, some people really can’t survive on broken sleep, I get it. But I was recently involved in a group conversation about what to do when your baby is poorly - and all the suggestions about continuing sleep training, propping up the crib to one side to let mucus flow etc all made me really sad. Imagine leaving your sick baby alone in their crib all night 💔

Cuddle their aching little bodies, it’s all they want and it’s the only medicine that really soothes them


r/AttachmentParenting • • Sep 19 '26

❤ Sleep ❤ How to Be Way Less Tired with a Baby, or What I Wish I Would Have Found on Reddit with my First

397 Upvotes

Note: this only applies to you if you are a nursing mom who spends most of her days and nights with her baby. I know that narrows it down quite a bit, but you’re out there. If that’s not you, it doesn’t mean you’re doing it wrong…this advice just doesn’t apply. 

Some background:

  • My first baby was “a terrible sleeper.” He was born 5 weeks early and was 4 lbs, so he had some catching up to do. But even after he caught up, he’s always been a guy who doesn’t need much sleep and does need lots of snuggles. We tried and tried doing everything “right.” None of the sleep training methods worked, and all of it made us so sad. I was so incredibly sleep-deprived and struggling with postpartum rage and depression. I dreaded every nap and every night. 

  • My second baby is not all that much better of a sleeper, but I am so much happier and rarely so dead tired that I can’t go on (like I usually was with my first). I love going to bed at night. That’s cause I scrapped all the “shoulds” of baby sleep and just did what felt right. Here’s what that is:

  1. Nurse to sleep, and stop feeling guilty about it. You’ve got 'em for a reason. Why do we spend so much energy trying to find any other way to get our baby to sleep? 

  2. Look at your baby (and stop googling wake windows). When your baby is showing signs that they are tired, put them in a place where they have a good chance of sleeping and that's convenient for you. A carrier, their bed, the carseat, the stroller, your friend’s lap. If when they wake up, they are happy, they got enough sleep. If when they wake up, they’re sad, try very briefly to put them back down. If they don’t go back down easily, don’t stress and move on with your day. If it’s nearing the end of the day  and their nap is running long and you know that if they sleep past X o’clock, they’ll be up till midnight, then wake them up. It’s an art, not a science. 

    1. There does come a point when it's better for their well-being that their nap is based more on time of day than on what they’re feeling in the moment. I find this is when they switch to one nap. But you’ll know when this starts to happens for your own kid. (See #6)

  3. (Safely) cosleep if you wanna. Know the safe sleep seven. If you need ideas for a sleeping situation, I love having baby sleep on this Japanese futon on top of a Tatami mat next to my bed. Easy to switch from sleeping next to my husband in our bed to sleeping next to baby in the floor bed after their first wakeup. 

  4. Act like you have 12 kids, even if you only have/want one. You might take issue with large families, but I don’t think a common complaint is that the babies didn’t get enough sleep. The babies seem to do just fine in that regard. And suddenly, you feel a lot less pressure to do everything perfectly right with your one.

  5. Consider what I call “Goodnight Moon sleep training." When reading Goodnight Moon one night to my toddler, I noticed the mother bunny knitting in her chair next to the bed. I LOVE to knit. I also love to read. I realized that I could bring the things I love into the room while my toddler fell asleep and we’d both thoroughly enjoy ourselves. He is so comforted by this that he usually falls asleep within minutes, leaving me with a free evening to do whatever I want. (This light is great for nighttime reading.)

  6. If you hate this advice, ignore it. If reading it feels like a relief, try it out. And in general, trust your gut. It’s way more right than your mother-in-law, Cara, or your friend who stopped by unexpectedly during your baby’s 20-minute nap when you finally sat down to eat lunch at 4pm. 

I know this will likely rub some folks the wrong way, but I suspect there is at least one mom out there who might want to hear this, so this one’s for you. Whatever it is that you’re doing, keep on keeping on. You’re doing a good work.


r/AttachmentParenting • • May 21 '22

❤ Sleep ❤ Now that I’m a mom, CIO makes me feel ill.

396 Upvotes

It never seemed like the nicest thing, but I didn’t know much about parenting, and CIO methods (or politely: “self soothing”) seemed de rigeur on parenting blogs and on the infinite ads I see for “sleep training experts.” I know you’re not supposed to be judgy, but now that I’m a mom, I’m definitely not in the “you do you” camp with CIO. It seems so harsh and cruel to not comfort your baby, and the thought of doing so, and of friends I adore having done so with their children, makes my stomach turn. If you don’t bedshare, don’t do EC, whatever, you do you. But leaving a baby to cry itself to exhaustion, on purpose, is terrible. Does anyone else have such a strong visceral reaction like this?

Edit— just have to vent bc I have a lot of well-meaning people saying “you just need to start letting her learn to self-soothe.” Um, I said she wakes up frequently to eat throughout the night, but I didn’t say that it’s problematic. She’s a baby, and is - I must say - babying like a pro! Yes, I’m tired, but the nighttime hours are some of the sweetest and snuggliest.

Edit 2– maybe I’m not using the correct term for all but by “CIO” I mean any kind of just letting little ones cry, whether for timed intervals or outright. Either way, trying to mold a baby’s natural sleep, eating, and comfort needs to fit the convenience of adults is cruel.

Edit 3– Maybe it’ll seem strange to post this well after my original post, but more nuance is needed. I think the practice of leaving a baby to cry is awful. But I also think that with rare exception, all parents are loving parents, and many are put in a terrible situation in which they feel they have no choice, because the amount of time given to care for a newborn (in their natural, frequently eating and waking state) is woefully inadequate especially in the US. I imagine that 1) cultural pressure to have a “good baby” that sleeps through the night, 2) the shame associated with “overly coddled” children, and 3) the necessity to force a baby onto a schedule because of work demands leaves many unsure of how to proceed, and “training” is the current cultural answer. I blame societal and economic factors, not individuals who are mostly trying their best. Doesn’t mean I think it’s okay, but shaming individuals is not the answer— the problem that is “solved” by something like CIO is much bigger.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Feb 02 '25

❤ Sleep ❤ For those who worry your LO will never sleep independently

391 Upvotes

We never sleep trained due to my own anxiety/inability to follow through although I was pushed to do so. My daughter had food allergies that resulted in severe reflux, failure to thrive, and some other medical issues that were not conducive to her sleeping well. When she still didn’t sleep through the night at age 3 and needed my husband or I to lay with her to fall asleep, we were judged pretty harshly and told she’d never sleep independently.

She will be 6 in the spring and is an absolutely wonderful little girl. I can’t believe how lucky we are, even after the sleep struggles when she was little. We are still in the habit of reading to her and laying with her to fall asleep. But tonight she told me she needed some space to calm her body down before she was ready to snuggle. I stepped out to get myself ready for bed. When I checked on her, she had turned out her light, put her Hatch on, and was reading books to her stuffed animals by the nightlight. I asked if she was ready for me to lay with her and she said “I think I can go to sleep by myself.” I assured her I’d come back in to check on her again.

About 20 minutes later she was asleep. All by herself. I know it won’t become every night just yet, but she did it. And a (pretty big) piece of me is already mourning the loss of those shared bedtimes.

Embrace it, and do what’s best for your and your kids. They all sleep independently eventually. And often they’re ready before you are ❤️

ETA I’m touched and honored that this post resonated with so many! I remember vividly the long nights praying she’d fall asleep and wishing she could be one of the “easy” kids who didn’t need me so much. It was hard in the thick of it but I really truly wouldn’t change it. Hugs and love to all of you and your sweet kiddos!


r/AttachmentParenting • • Oct 24 '25

❤ Attachment ❤ It's so worth it.

389 Upvotes

Since day 1 I've had my baby glued to me. Breastfeeding on demand. Contact napping. Co-sleeping. I jump to her as soon as she makes a cry, and I'm a single mom so it's tough. No one to hold her while I shower or cook. Just my own two arms holding her and the household.

We do everything together.

I visit with my mom frequently and she reminds me that it's okay for a baby to cry if she's in a safe environment. I know that. But I still cut my showers short if she starts crying for me. I'm able to do that and I want to be there for her any time she needs me. I'm the only thing she knows.

She's just over 15 months old now, and we've developed some good routines. We play together, sit at the table and eat together, brush our teeth together.

We do everything together.

But she doesn't need me as much as she used to, and that's good. I'm seeing with my two eyes just how secure our attachment is, and I am so happy and in love with the personality that is blooming from my sweet daughter.

Last weekend we were at a wedding, and she tore it up on the dance floor. Running around and spinning in circles. She'd look back to check on me, make sure I'm still there, then go about her business. I'm always here baby.

I took her to the pumpkin patch and they had a playground. I walked her through going up the steps and down the slide one time. And she took off from there. She just wanted me to watch her. I'm always watching baby.

I'm so proud of her.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Sep 20 '24

❤ Social-Emotional Development ❤ Mourning the loss of living in family tribes after a family vacation.

379 Upvotes

I’m someone who normally mostly solo parents. But last month I was on a family vacation sharing a home with both grandparents, aunts, uncles and cousins.

It took a couple of days for baby to warm up to everyone, but the dynamic seemed so healthy and natural once he did. There was always someone to hold him. Always someone to play with him, take him outside on a walk, do naps with him in the day bed, take over meal times, etc… I got so much rest. It felt counterintuitive to attachment parenting because when I’m alone it means I am constantly holding and responding to baby on my own, as opposed to having so many others holding him.

However, it felt like baby and I were both happier and healthier living like this. I felt like this is what it would be like if we lived in tribes. I didn’t necessarily feel like I had to hold or be with baby all day for him to develop a healthy attachment. But he did get upset if I was out of sight for too long (over 3 hours) or not present when he wanted to nurse.

I just wish that it was still this way for us all.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Oct 18 '22

❤ Sleep ❤ Why is bedsharing more taboo than the Ferber method?

378 Upvotes

I feel like I need to vent my frustration in a safe space and this community is most likely to not judge. I am so sick and tired of getting side eyed and even gasps of horror when I tell other parents or pediatricians that I bed share with my 1 year old. There's so so much research out there to support safe bedsharing practices. Also, she doesn't even sleep with us every night, most of the time she sleeps happily in her toddler floor bed in her room through the night. Lately, she has been having a bit of a tough time, so she wakes up around 3, walks into our room and spends the rest of the night with us. I recently revealed this to a childcare worker at the playgroup we go to who asked me how toddler has been sleeping, and she laughed at me, saying my daughter's old enough to cry it out and shame on me for not teaching her how to self soothe back to sleep.

What a crock of shit. I really didn't want to get into it with her, but I said that the concept of children under the age of 5 really being able to self soothe is a very controversial topic. She kind of rolled her eyes at me when I said that, and so did another parent who was listening into the conversation.

It really gets me pissed off. I would never tell a parent outright that what is working for their family is the wrong thing to do, even though honestly, traditional sleep training horrifies me. I read comments on reddit about parents letting their kids cry at night until they throw up, or their voice is hoarse, and other parents just saying "good job for sticking it out" in response. Like how the hell is that more acceptable than letting my kid stay the night with me????


r/AttachmentParenting • • Mar 22 '24

❤ Toddler ❤ “Shall I throw this soup on the floor mummy, or on the wall?” My 3yr old has started giving us ‘choices’ about her bad behaviour.

363 Upvotes

We’ve always loved the approach of giving our kids choices, eg “do you want to brush your teeth upstairs or in the kitchen?”. But this week our toddler has finally clocked and is using our parenting techniques against us. It’s very unnerving, like watching a raptor figure out how to open a door handle.

I’m sort of proud, but we’re so screwed.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Jul 07 '25

🤍 Support Needed 🤍 What do I tell my Son when he asks for Mama?

362 Upvotes

Hi,

I don’t really know what I’m looking for here. Maybe just someone to see me.

My wife died one months ago. She was only 32. We were together for 11 years — she was everything to me. My best friend, my safe place, the one person who really knew me. We have a little boy who just turned one. She adored him. She deserved to be here to watch him grow.

I still can’t believe she’s gone. Every day feels like I’m walking through a bad dream that won’t end. People keep telling me I’m strong, that I’m doing well because I get up every day for our son… but they don’t see the nights. They don’t see how I lie in bed staring at the ceiling, wishing it could all just stop hurting. How I reach for her in the dark and remember she’s not there.

I feel like my whole life is in black and white now. I keep hearing her laugh in my head. Seeing her in little memories — cooking, reading on the couch, humming to our baby. And then reality crashes back, and she’s still gone.

I don’t even know how to describe the pain. It’s like a part of me was ripped away, and what’s left just hurts. And yet I feel guilty when I laugh with our son. I feel guilty when I think about moving forward. It’s like I’m betraying her just by breathing.

I love our little boy more than anything, but even he doesn’t fill the hole she left behind. I’m terrified of raising him without her. And I don’t know how to keep her memory alive for him in a way that won’t hurt him — or me — even more.

Do I show him pictures of her every day? Do I keep talking about her like she’s still here? Or will that just confuse him? He’s so little, and sometimes he looks up at me and says “mama?” and my heart just breaks. What do I even say to him when he asks for her? How do you explain to a baby that his mama isn’t coming back?

I guess I just needed to say all this somewhere. To not feel so alone in this.

If you’ve been through this — especially if you’re a parent who’s lost your partner — I’d really appreciate hearing how you handled it. How did you keep their memory alive for your kids without falling apart yourself? How did you answer when they asked for mama or papa? Please, if you can, share your experience with me.

Thank you for reading.

— Jason


r/AttachmentParenting • • Nov 20 '21

❤ Attachment ❤ I think my bumper group kinda ruined the way I instinctively wanted to parent

350 Upvotes

Hello everyone.

Before falling pregnant, I always envisioned myself as a baby wearing, cosleeping, nursing on demand kinda mom. I’d heard of attachment parenting and gentle parenting, but didn’t really looking into the specifics of them. Just thought I’d do my own thing.

Well, then I found my bumper group on reddit. It was amazing for pregnancy support, but I didn’t realise how much it started to change the way I wanted to mother. I followed “eat play sleep”, every single nap and bedtime. I worked toward putting her down “drowsy but awake.” Well, my 5mo now self settles, but you what? She still catnaps, and I’m up 4+ times a night.

The last couple weeks I started to feel so defeated. I felt house bound in order to catch her at the perfect time for naps. But why?

Well, after an outing this morning where she was extremely overtired, we got home, I snuggled my sleep deprived self in bed with her, and we fed to sleep where she had by far the longest nap she’s had in months. I want to cry. I deprived myself of contact naps/nursing to sleep/etc. for fear of creating bad habits.

So today marks the day that I’m officially done. From this day forward I’m doing exactly what I INSTINCTIVELY want to do, not what the books say I should do.

Thanks for listening to my rant.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Sep 07 '25

🤍 Support Needed 🤍 Update on my baby's grandma neglecting him

336 Upvotes

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/AttachmentParenting/comments/1nb3dp3/my_babys_grandma_was_left_alone_with_him_for_a/

Thank you to everyone who responded with support and advice. I genuinely appreciate it so much, and finding an online community that supports me like this has been amazing.

James and I talked to his dad, and we decided it was best to take him to the ER. The doctor said he was severely dehydrated, to the point where they had to put a tube through his nose because he was refusing the bottle and breast. We're staying overnight with him in the hospital and seeing a social worker in the morning to talk over our options. James's dad called his wife and told her not to be there when we get back tomorrow, and that he wants a divorce, so hopefully we won't be dealing with her anymore.

This whole thing has been really hard for James and I to even see happening. I feel so guilty for asking her to watch him, and I know I shouldn't have been even planning to go to homecoming when I could be staying home with him instead.

love Elliot more than I can even put here and it kills me to see him like this. He's asleep on James's chest right now and I'm sitting in a chair next to his bed crying because I can't believe that woman was evil enough to punish my beautiful little baby by starving him. I didn't plan on getting pregnant, and I certainly didn't plan on my pregnancy and motherhood journey being as hard as it has been, and it's just fucking evil for her to punish my child for a mistake her stepchild made.


r/AttachmentParenting • • Jul 04 '21

Any comments or posts promoting "gentle sleep training" that don't include any further explanation will be removed.

326 Upvotes

Too many comments are promoting "gentle sleep training" and not elaborating on whether the method leaves baby to cry alone. The mods will not engage in arguments about what defines "gentle". If it's not clear what the method entails the comment will be removed to remain inline with the rules of the sub.

Please familiarize yourself with all the rules of the sub and help the mods by reporting anything that breaks the rules.

Thanks caretakers <3